Tag Archives: management

Motiwala Capital Q4 2014 Letter

Summary 2014 Q4 Letter to investors. Winners and mistakes. Portfolio activity (buys, sells). Fourth Quarter 2014 Letter The year 2014 ended on a strong note with the US equity market as reflected by S&P 500 up ~14% The US markets are in an amazing six year bull market with the S&P 500 having tripled from the lows of March 2009. Motiwala Capital had a below average year with consolidated net return (after all fees and expenses) of ~4%. The consolidated number means some accounts performed below this number and some above it. See important notes at the end of the letter for more information. The performance information is shown in the table below: Year S&P 500 Motiwala Capital 2011* -1.7% 4.9% 2012 16.0% 20.3% 2013 31.9% 33.2% 2014 13.7% 3.9% 2014 Performance Overall our performance in 2014 was poor both on absolute and relative basis. There were more winners than losers but two large positions suffered large declines hurting overall performance. Positions detracting from performance included North Atlantic Drilling (NYSE: NADL ) (-80%), Prosafe ( OTCPK:PRSEY ) (-57%), CTC Media (NASDAQ: CTCM ) (-33%), Blucora (NASDAQ: BCOR ) (-27%) and International Housewares (-22%). Our biggest winners were Microcap H (+90%), Microcap L (+48%), Apple (NASDAQ: AAPL ) (+42%), Visteon (NYSE: VC ) (+40%), Microsoft (NASDAQ: MSFT ) (+25%) and Oracle (NYSE: ORCL ) (+20%). In addition, 14 of the 17 special situation investments during 2014 were profitable (or breakeven) and positively impacted our portfolio returns. We will continue to invest in this area and believe it distinguishes our management style. Discussion on winners Microcaps H and L were purchased at low valuations. Both exhibited strong earnings growth and were rewarded with higher valuations resulting in superb gains. Apple had a fantastic year, releasing exciting new products and continuing to return capital to shareholders via share buybacks and dividends. Investors were more optimistic and the share price headed higher. Visteon continued to divest non-core businesses and investors were happy. Recently, the company announced the sale of its majority stake in publicly traded Halla-Visteon for $3.6 billion. Visteon will be left with only one business segment and could be potentially acquired. Microsoft and Oracle reported business as usual generating solid free cash flow and continued buybacks and dividends. Discussion on mistakes High leverage, capex and high dividend payout The positions in North Atlantic Drilling and Prosafe hurt the portfolio returns by 6%. These were the biggest mistakes since 2011. Both companies are in the energy service industry, cyclical in nature and dependent on capital spending by large oil producers, which in turn depends on crude oil pricing. NADL and PRSEY had significant capital expenditures and high levels of debt. To add fuel to the fire, they had a high (75-100%) dividend payout policy. The combination of these three factors in a cyclical business is too risky. I will guard against this in the future. Prosafe warned about weakening demand and potential dividend cuts in its Q2 earnings. The stock price fell and I felt that the bad news was priced in. In the case of NADL, its agreement with Rosneft ( OTC:RNFTF ) did not close due to sanctions against Russian entities. NADL suspended its dividend given the weak outlook. From mid September, crude oil prices started declining and there was a meltdown in late November. Most energy related stocks including NADL and PRSEY declined sharply as result. When the situation changes I purchased shares of Russian media company CTCM Media in March 2014. My argument then was “CTCM has a solid balance sheet and produces attractive free cash flows. CTCM was purchased for 10%+ FCF yield. When Russia moves out of the front-page news, I hope the stock would be higher.” After purchase, the stock appreciated by 25% despite Russia continuing to be in the headlines. The stock was still cheap and I continued to hold. However, in late September Russia passed a law restricting ownership of Russian media companies to 20% from the prior 50%. This was unexpected and the stock price took a 20% hit. Later the stock was also hurt by the rapid depreciation of the Rubble, which was caused by the rapid decline in crude oil prices. CTCM indirectly became linked to energy prices. My mistake here was not selling immediately after the media law change, which would have reduced our losses. Portfolio Composition Our portfolios are divided into two sections. The ‘Generals’ are generally undervalued equity investments that fit the value framework. The rest of the portfolio is invested in special situations (short term investments with a specific event that unlocks value) or cash. Average cash balance at the end of 2013 was 45%. The top 5 positions add up to 25% of the portfolio. We have 16 regular positions (Generals) in our portfolio. This makes up ~45% of the portfolio. The rest of the portfolio is currently in special situations (10%) and cash (45%). Cash is 30% higher over last quarter end due to heavy selling as explained later. Portfolio Characteristics Weighted average P/E = 12 (P/E is based on 12-month trailing earnings) Portfolio dividend yield = 2.4% Weighted average Market Cap = $55 billion Price to Value (P/V) For every stock we purchase, we estimate a range of fair values. We compute a ratio of current market price (price) to estimated value (value). Price to value on the invested portfolio was 0.83. Lower P/V means better upside and limited downside. A higher P/V points to lower future upside potential for the portfolio. We will continue to look for attractive investments that will help to lower the P/V at the portfolio level. Top 7 Positions (some clients will not have all the positions and in the same weights) Company name (Ticker) % of portfolio B/S Div FCF ROIC Val Visteon (Equity and Warrants) 7.5% Y Y Microcap H 5.6% Y Y Y Y Y Outerwall (NASDAQ: OUTR ) 5.4% Y Y Y Oracle 3.6% Y Y Y Y Y Blucora 3.3% Y Y Y Y Qualcomm (NASDAQ: QCOM ) 3.1% Y Y Y Y Y Conrad Industries ( OTCPK:CNRD ) 3.1% Y Y Y Y Y For the above stocks, we have provided information about which characteristics they satisfy B/S = strong balance sheet Div = pays a dividend FCF = solid free cash flow ROIC = solid Return on Invested Capital (NASDAQ: ROIC ) Val = low/reasonable valuation Portfolio by Market Cap Micro cap 18% less than $250m Small Cap 15% $250m to $2billion Mid Cap 9% $2 billion to $10 billion Large Cap 8% $10 billion to $200 billion Mega Cap 5% $200 billion + We have invested across the market cap spectrum and are market cap agnostic. Portfolio by Sector Sector Weight Technology 12% Consumer Discretionary 12% Financials 7% Energy 6% Telecom 3% Consumer Staples 3% Industrials 1% Special Situations 11% Cash 45% We do not seek investments by sector. We make our investments one stock at a time. However, as part of risk management, we want to make sure that our investments are across multiple sectors. Portfolio Activity Special Situations: Share tenders We participated in two special situations in the quarter that were profitable. Generals: Portfolio exits: We sold out of seven positions in the quarter. Some positions were sold as they hit our price targets, while some were sold when I was concerned about the business or the situation had changed. Microsoft ( MSFT ): We purchased shares of Microsoft in early 2011 around $26. During our 3+ years holding period, Microsoft has continued to be very profitable, generate lot of free cash flow, paid dividends and buyback shares. A new CEO has come in and the market perception has improved. We sold our shares around $46 as the stock price appreciated to our price target. Vodafone (NASDAQ: VOD ): Vodafone shares were also purchased in early 2011. It owned 45% of Verizon wireless back then. After the sale of its stake in Verizon wireless, VOD made some acquisitions in Europe and decided to invest heavily in its network. The major part of its business is in Europe and has been struggling for several years. The negatives from Europe are greater than the positives from the rest of its business in Asia and Africa. Finally, VOD has gone from net cash to net debt on its balance sheet to finance the dividend and capex. These combined factors swayed us to sell the position. Amcon Distributing (NYSEMKT: DIT ): DIT was purchased in the second quarter of 2013. DIT is a wholesale distributor of consumer products to convenience stores. Since our purchase, business results have been soft with declining earnings and ROE on increasing competition. Despite this, the stock price appreciated, seemed fairly valued and we sold. Hess Corp (NYSE: HES ): We sold our remaining shares of HES. HES was purchased as a special situation when it was selling assets, paying down debt and buying back shares. HES has now become a pure play E&P company. I had no interest to own HES beyond the asset sales. I was holding on for the announced spinoff of an MLP. However, with declining crude oil prices, it made sense to close the position. National Oilwell Varco (NYSE: NOV ): NOV was another energy services company in the portfolio. It is a high quality albeit cyclical business with a solid balance sheet and generates good free cash flow. NOV was sold in response to the sharp decline in crude oil prices. A major part of NOV business is providing equipment and parts for rig systems. I do not know how this business will perform 2016 onwards given the excess supply of deep-water rigs. CTC Media : We sold our shares as explained earlier. Generals: New Positions: GameStop (NYSE: GME ) makes a second appearance to our portfolio. GME is the largest video game retailer in the world and sells new and used video game software, hardware, accessories for video game systems from Sony (NYSE: SNE ), Nintendo ( OTCPK:NTDOY ) and Microsoft. Recently, GME has diversified into other concepts such as Cricket wireless stores and Simply Mac stores. GME has generated annual free cash flow of $450 million. The capital allocation policy is impressive and allows for the distribution of up to 100% of free cash flow to share holders. We purchased shares at a dividend yield of 4% and 10x P/E. Last time we purchased shares of GME, the video game console cycle was long in its tooth. The new consoles from Sony and Microsoft were released in 2013. Sales of games for the older consoles have declined faster than the increase in sales for new consoles. This is weighing on recent results. Once software sales for newer consoles pick up, I feel the shares should get re-rated higher. Generals: Reduced positions: We reduced our large position in Conrad Industries as we grew concerned about the demand for new barges that CNRD builds. The stock appears cheap on a trailing basis but this is a cyclical business and we wanted to be a bit cautious after a superb multiyear run. We sold half of our remaining position in Apple) after the stock doubled since our investment in Q2 2013. We sold half of our position in Franklin Resources (NYSE: BEN ) as it traded close to our conservative price target. My initial assessment on the valuation was higher due to the large net cash of $8 billion (25% of market cap). However, this cash is held overseas and is unlikely to be returned to shareholders. Also, recent asset flows have stagnated at this asset management firm. Generals: Increased positions During the quarter we increased our positions in Visteon warrants (VSTOW) and International Housewares (1373) as they were attractively priced. High Cash levels Cash in the portfolio grew to an all time high of 45%. The reason for this is simply because we sold (33%) a lot more than what we bought (5%) in this quarter. It has become increasingly difficult to find attractive investments as markets overall have run up. However, I continue to look for investments to deploy some of the cash. Often investors question when there are high cash levels as it can detract from performance in a period of rising markets. The value of cash is twofold: it acts as a buffer in declining markets and the optionality it provides to make purchases. Special dividends : Once again Conrad gave us a Christmas gift and declared a special dividend of $1/share. On our original purchase price of $15, we have already received $5/share in dividends. Conrad also instituted a regular quarter dividend of $0.25/share. Asset manager Franklin resources declared a $0.5/share special dividend and raised its dividend. Other news : I am happy to report that I have moved into my new office. At year-end, our AUM was $5.4 million. We wish everyone a prosperous and happy new year 2015. Please contact me if you are interested in our managed account services. This commentary candidly discusses a number of individual companies. These opinions are current as of the date of this commentary but are subject to change. All information provided is for information purposes only and should not be considered as investment advice or a recommendation to purchase or sell any specific security. While the information presented herein is believed to be reliable, no representations or warranty is made concerning the accuracy of any data presented. This communication may not be reproduced without prior written permission from us. Past performance is no guarantee of future results. Motiwala Capital performance is computed on a before-tax time weighted return (TWR) basis and is net of all paid management fees and brokerage costs. Performance figures are unaudited. Performance of individual accounts may vary depending on the timing of their investment, the effects of additions, and the impact of withdrawals from their account. Editor’s Note: This article covers one or more stocks trading at less than $1 per share and/or with less than a $100 million market cap. Please be aware of the risks associated with these stocks.

ENFR Is An Energy Sector ETF That Might Fit Very Well Under Modern Portfolio Theory

Summary I’m taking a look at ENFR as a candidate for inclusion in my ETF portfolio. The correlation to SPY is incredibly low but poor liquidity is reducing the reliability of statistics. The expense ratio is high and the holdings within the ETF could use more diversification. I wasn’t planning on using energy ETF, but the low correlation is too appealing. I’m not assessing any tax impacts. Investors should check their own situation for tax exposure. Investors should be seeking to improve their risk adjusted returns. I’m a big fan of using ETFs to achieve the risk adjusted returns relative to the portfolios that a normal investor can generate for themselves after trading costs. I’m working on building a new portfolio and I’m going to be analyzing several of the ETFs that I am considering for my personal portfolio. One of the funds that I’m considering is the Alerian Energy Infrastructure ETF (NYSEARCA: ENFR ). I’ll be performing a substantial portion of my analysis along the lines of modern portfolio theory, so my goal is to find ways to minimize costs while achieving diversification to reduce my risk level. What does ENFR do? ENFR attempts to track the total return (before fees and expenses) of the Alerian Energy Infrastructure Index. At least 90% of the assets are invested in funds included in this index. There are only 30 equity securities included in the index, so I’m expecting some diversification and volatility issues. ENFR falls under the category of “Energy Limited Partnership”. Does ENFR provide diversification benefits to a portfolio? Each investor may hold a different portfolio, but I use (NYSEARCA: SPY ) as the basis for my analysis. I believe SPY, or another large cap U.S. fund with similar properties, represents the reasonable first step for many investors designing an ETF portfolio. Therefore, I start my diversification analysis by seeing how it works with SPY. I start with an ANOVA table: (click to enlarge) The correlation appears incredible at 51%. I want to see low correlations on my investments. Extremely low levels of correlation are wonderful for establishing a more stable portfolio. I consider anything under 50% to be extremely low. However, for equity securities an extremely low correlation is frequently only found when there are substantial issues with trading volumes that may distort the statistics. The statistics appear too good to be true, which usually indicates that they are. I’ll keep an eye out for things that could distort the numbers. Standard deviation of daily returns (dividend adjusted, measured since November 2013) The standard deviation is very high for the relative calm sample period. For ENFR it is .9802%. For SPY, it is 0.6748% for the same period. While I’ve covered quite a few ETFs where the standard deviation was greater than 1%, those scores usually came from periods where SPY would have a standard deviation higher than .7200%. However, if the correlation really is 51%, I could work with the high deviations. Liquidity is a problem Average trading volume is running around 10,000 shares per day. It’s not completely illiquid, but it is pretty bad. In that time period, slightly under 280 trading days, the ETF reported a change from one closing value to the next (dividend adjusted) of 0.00% on 12 occasions. That might indicate days in which no shares changed hands, or the ending price might just have been the same as the prior day because of coincidence. For SPY, it happened 0 times during that period. However, SPY also trades at a much higher share price which reduces the chance of randomly having the same closing price since a one cent change in share price represents a smaller percentage of the price. The presence of 12 days in a sample of 280 is enough that it could have a meaningful influence on the calculated standard deviation and correlation of returns. I don’t think the poor liquidity is enough to explain away the correlation only being 51%, but it does reduce the reliability of the statistics. Mixing it with SPY I also run comparisons on the standard deviation of daily returns for the portfolio assuming that the portfolio is combined with the S&P 500. For research, I assume daily rebalancing because it dramatically simplifies the math. With a 50/50 weighting in a portfolio holding only SPY and ENFR, the standard deviation of daily returns across the entire portfolio is 0.7227%. With 80% in SPY and 20% in ENFR, the standard deviation of the portfolio would have been .6615%. If an investor wanted to use ENFR as a supplement to their portfolio, the standard deviation across the portfolio with 95% in SPY and 5% in ENFR would have been .6673%. Why I use standard deviation of daily returns I don’t believe historical returns have predictive power for future returns, but I do believe historical values for standard deviations of returns relative to other ETFs have some predictive power on future risks and correlations. Yield & Taxes The distribution yield is 1.97%. I like to see strong yields for retiring portfolios because I don’t want to touch the principal. By investing in ETFs I’m removing some of the human emotions, such as panic. Higher yields imply lower growth rates (without reinvestment) over the long term, but that is an acceptable trade off in my opinion. The poor liquidity would still concern me for any investor that needed even a moderate level of liquidity in the portfolio. I’m not a CPA or CFP, so I’m not assessing any tax impacts. Expense Ratio The ETF is posting an expense ratio of .65%. I want diversification, I want stability, and I don’t want to pay for them. I’m not attracted to the high expense ratio, but I won’t eliminate the ETF on the grounds of a high expense ratio because I’m still intrigued by the very low correlation. Market to NAV The ETF is at a .07% premium to NAV currently. Premiums or discounts to NAV can change very quickly so investors should check prior to putting in an order. I wouldn’t consider .07% to be meaningful, but investors should still watch out for the bid-ask spread. Poor liquidity is frequently connected with larger spreads. Largest Holdings The diversification within the ETF is fairly bland. I expected that because the underlying index had a fairly limited number of securities as well. In my opinion, the most reasonable way to use this ETF would be as a fairly small position within a large portfolio in which the investor was willing to sink in a little time watching for the right times to enter. Specifically, they would need to be watching the spread and the premium or discount to NAV. Additionally, the investor would need to be aware of their risk tolerances and liquidity needs. For an investor that meets all those criteria, this ETF might work. (click to enlarge) Conclusion I’m currently screening a large volume of ETFs for my own portfolio. The portfolio I’m building is through Schwab, so I’m able to trade ENFR with no commissions. I have a strong preference for researching ETFs that are free to trade in my account, so most of my research will be on ETFs that fall under the “ETF OneSource” program. I’m going to keep ENFR on my list as a potential candidate despite the fairly poor liquidity and high expense ratio. I don’t have a portion of the portfolio set aside for energy stocks, so the odds may be stacked against ENFR. If ENFR is selected, it would probably be used as 3% to 5% of the portfolio value. The major incentive for me is the low correlation, so I would want to run more statistical testing on the correlation over different time periods to reduce the risk of poor liquidity creating a misleading picture. Additional disclosure: Information in this article represents the opinion of the analyst. All statements are represented as opinions, rather than facts, and should not be construed as advice to buy or sell a security. Ratings of “outperform” and “underperform” reflect the analyst’s estimation of a divergence between the market value for a security and the price that would be appropriate given the potential for risks and returns relative to other securities. The analyst does not know your particular objectives for returns or constraints upon investing. All investors are encouraged to do their own research before making any investment decision. Information is regularly obtained from Yahoo Finance, Google Finance, and SEC Database. If Yahoo, Google, or the SEC database contained faulty or old information it could be incorporated into my analysis. The analyst holds a diversified portfolio including mutual funds or index funds which may include a small long exposure to the stock.

China Watch: Bull Market Ahead?

Summary Chinese equities have traded sideways for the past five years while sales and earnings have improved. In late November, the PBOC cut interest rates for the first time since 2012. China is the world’s only major economy with ample room to cut policy rates. Falling energy costs should depress consumer prices in coming months, bolstering the case for monetary stimulus. If our interest-rate thesis is correct, FXI, the most liquid equity ETF, might soon break out from a three-year-old ascending-triangle formation, generating an initial price objective of $56/share. Something interesting is happening in China. Financial stocks are surging relative to the broad market. The “hockey stick” liftoff began in late November when the People’s Bank of China (PBOC) cut policy rates for the first time since 2012. China is the world’s only large economy with room to pursue conventional monetary policy. Further rate cuts are likely as falling energy costs put downward pressure on consumer prices. Investors should keep close watch on FXI which holds about 50% financials. This bellwether index could potentially break out from a three-year-old ascending triangle, generating an initial price objective of $56/share. The conditions for a new bull market — attractive valuations plus monetary stimulus — seem to be falling into place. A technical breakout, however, is needed to confirm it. The following seven charts outline the potentially bullish case. Figure 1. Financial stocks are on the move Figure 2. Consumer Prices are headed lower (click to enlarge) Figure 3. China is the world’s only major economy with room to cut policy rates (click to enlarge) Figure 4. Valuations are attractive (click to enlarge) Figures 5 & 6. Sales and earnings are both attractive (click to enlarge) (click to enlarge) Figure 7. After years of sideways action, a technical breakout is needed to confirm a new bull market Note: FXI is similar in structure to the MSCI China Index referenced in figures 4-6. Conclusion Every investor dreams of identifying cheap or reasonably-priced securities in the early stages of a bull market. Chinese equities may soon meet both criteria. Valuations are historically attractive, but a technical breakout has yet to confirm a new bull market. Asset allocators should prepare their mindsets for such an event. The prospect of further rate cuts from the PBOC is a likely catalyst. Now that you’ve read this, are you Bullish or Bearish on ? Bullish Bearish Sentiment on ( ) Thanks for sharing your thoughts. Why are you ? Submit & View Results Skip to results » Share this article with a colleague