Tag Archives: management

2014 Diversified ETF Portfolio: Annual Performance, Replacing BOND With TLT And 2015 Estimates

Summary The S&P 500 had another great year with 14% annual return (including dividends). The diversified portfolio only returned 3.6%, held back by Business Development Company ETF. Portfolio yield exceeded the S&P 500 by 118 basis points. Pimco’s BOND ETF was replaced by TLT. TLT chosen based on correlation. S&P 500 Fundamentals need to continue to grow to have a positive 2015 year. Here are the fourth quarter and full-year results of a diversified ETF portfolio. The holding in BOND was replaced with TLT because of a change in my thesis. BOND was included to cover the bond portion of the portfolio because my thesis was that the expertise of Bill Gross would help BOND perform during calendar year 2014. Once Bill Gross quit Pimco, it was time for a change. Q1 Update: Link Q2 Update: Link Q3 Update: Link MARKET PERFORMANCE The S&P 500, as measured by the Vanguard S&P 500 ETF (NYSEARCA: VOO ), was up 13.97% (including dividends) for CY2014. Not too shabby. (click to enlarge) Eight of the nine sectors were positive for the year. Energy was the one sector that was negative. Technology, health, and utilities all outperformed the S&P 500. The utilities sector was the best performer, up 24.4%, which is usually considered a safe harbor investment. According to my calculations, a portfolio equal weighted in each sector would have returned 11% for the year. Throughout CY2014, bond yields fell. Yields closed the year at 2.2%. There was a significant drop during Q4, which is reflected in the performance of TLT. A drop in yields results in a price increase for the bonds. PORTFOLIO PERFORMANCE For Q4, the portfolio was up 2% while the S&P 500 was up 4.89%. For the year, the portfolio was up 3.62% while the S&P 500 was up 13.97%. PowerShares Buyback Achievers (NYSEARCA: PKW ), PowerShares Fundamental Pure Small Value (NYSEARCA: PXSV ), and the iShares 20+ Year Treasury Bond ETF (NYSEARCA: TLT ) all outperformed the S&P 500 for the quarter. Market Vectors BDC Income ETF (NYSEARCA: BIZD ), Vanguard FTSE Emerging Markets ETF (NYSEARCA: VWO ), and SPDR Barclays High Yield Bond (NYSEARCA: JNK ) all posted negative returns for the quarter. (click to enlarge) For the year, only the Market Vectors BDC Income ETF was down; even with its high dividend yield, it was not able to generate a positive return. No one fund outperformed the S&P 500 for the year. The Buyback Achievers came close and the Small Value fund posted a decent rally at year’s end, along with the Bond ETF. (click to enlarge) Here is the performance of the portfolio for the year: BOND FUND REPLACEMENT Why did I replace PIMCO Total Return ETF with iShares 20+ Year Treasury Bond ETF? The purpose of the bond fund is to give some negative correlation to the portfolio and help smooth out some returns over a long time frame (I know, I am monitoring the portfolio on a quarterly basis). As soon as it was announced that Bill Gross was leaving Pimco, I ran a correlation matrix on several possible bond funds. I used the following funds: iShares TIPS Bond (NYSEARCA: TIP ) Vanguard Short-Term Infl-Prot Secs ETF (NASDAQ: VTIP ) iShares Core Total U.S. Bond Market ETF (NYSEARCA: AGG ) Vanguard Intermediate-Term Corp Bd ETF (NASDAQ: VCIT ) SPDR Barclays Capital Convertible Bond ETF (NYSEARCA: CWB ) iShares 20+ Year Treasury Bond Vanguard Short-Term Corporate Bond ETF (NASDAQ: VCSH ) Vanguard Long-Term Corporate Bond ETF (NASDAQ: VCLT ) Here are the results of the correlation matrix (as of 3-Oct-2014): (click to enlarge) TLT has the largest negative correlation to the three equity funds (PKW, BIZD, and PXSV) and therefore, I choose it as the replacement for BOND. Note: The ETF share price used for the correlation matrix was sourced from Yahoo! Finance. TIP came in a very close second. As an exercise, I took the 10 worst days for PXSV (01-Jan-2014 through 03-Oct-2014) and compared that with TLT and TIP. TIP actually had the least correlation over this time frame. LOOKING FORWARD Last year at this time, I estimated a 10% return for the S&P 500. The S&P 500 outpaced that estimate. I estimated a 4.5% increase in sales per share with an 8.5% EPS margin. The actual sales per share increase was only 3.5%, but the EPS margin was 9.18%, which resulted in an actual EPS of $105.96, as compared with my $99.07 EPS estimate. I estimated a 20.5 multiple but the multiple (for the trailing twelve months) came in at 19.4, still allowing a greater than 10% return for the S&P 500. How about for 2015? I looked at three scenarios below. With the continuing improving employment numbers and the recent robust GDP numbers, I would expect the S&P to return between 2.5% and about 14% for the year. Large range, I know. Looking at the three scenarios below, it does not take much degradation in the fundamentals to get a negative return for the year. I was surprised how easy it would be to get a -11% annual return, using what I would still consider to be some decent fundamental performance. (click to enlarge) Disclosure: The author is long VOO, VWO. (More…) The author wrote this article themselves, and it expresses their own opinions. The author is not receiving compensation for it (other than from Seeking Alpha). The author has no business relationship with any company whose stock is mentioned in this article.

Betting Against Japan: The Straddle Of The Century

Japan has accumulated an enormous and growing debt load. The Japanese Central Bank’s bond buying may prevent a crisis. The yen is likely to continue weakening. Investors can profit from the JCB’s moves. Japan emerged from the ashes of World War II to becoming one of the largest economic powers in the world by the 1980s. By creating high quality products and making highly publicized corporate purchases, Japan was both respected and feared by competing economic powers. Japan’s economic advancement came to an abrupt end when the Japanese market crashed in the late 1980s and never truly recovered. The once mighty power is now heavily indebted and dealing with a declining population and a declining economy. A crisis is possible, but like with crises of the past, a major Japanese economic event can become a great opportunity, particularly with the right investments. The debt load of the Japanese government stands at just under 1.2 quadrillion yen ($10.1 trillion), greatly exceeding their 484 trillion yen ($4.07 trillion) economy and the 96 trillion yen budget ($812 billion), with projected revenue at only 54.5 trillion yen. This is a precarious financial position, and at a 4.5% interest rate, the projected revenues would only cover debt service. But because the Japanese Central Bank (JCB) is such a large buyer of Japanese government bonds, the interest rate for a 10-year bond stands at under 0.5% as of the time of this writing. Given that this 1.2 quadrillion yen is a debt level unlikely to be paid off, hyperinflation or default would appear to be the only realistic options for addressing the debt. To counter a possible collapse, the JCB started buying larger amounts of bonds than the Japanese government was creating. It’s likely the JCB plans to buy up a large percentage of the outstanding bonds ( it owns about 16% now ) and simply write off the bonds, and hence, that portion of Japanese government debt. If this were to work without destroying the economy, the Japanese government strengthens its financial position by returning to sustainable debt levels. If it fails and Japanese bonds rise to double or even triple digit interest rates, default becomes a possibility. Another possible scenario involves weakening the yen. This has been seen in earnest since 2012 and born of the JCB’s larger levels of aggressive stimulus. The JCB created more yen and pumped the currency into the economy, sending the Nikkei to highs not seen since the 1990s. The price of this stimulus has been a greatly devalued yen falling from 76 to the dollar in early 2012 to the low 120s in early 2015 . Experts such as Kyle Bass predict the yen will fall beyond 140 to the dollar by year-end and further beyond this year. The potential danger of this approach is that more yen chasing the same amount of goods will devalue the yen to the point that investors lose confidence in the currency. In addition to making Japanese consumers poorer, the devalued currency could also lead to higher interest rates that also make the government debt load untenable. Investors can protect themselves from this horrifying yet plausible scenario with a different take on the straddle bet, one based on different vehicles instead of up or down bets on the same investment. In this case, it would be a position betting against Japanese government bonds (the JGBS ETF is the easiest way to accomplish this) coupled with a second bet against the value of the Japanese yen (versus a precious metal or a currency such as the US Dollar). If the JCB can successfully write off a large amount of government debt, investors can still profit from what’s likely to be substantial yen devaluation. If the worst case bond crash occurs, investors can profit or at least protect themselves from what would be a devastating economic event. The once-mighty Japanese economy now finds itself in a situation where the JCB struggles to maintain economic strength. An economic collapse would be the most devastating occurrence to hit Japan since their loss in World War II, and a catastrophic blow to a world economy where Japan exerts wide influence. However, this situation also presents a great opportunity for the prepared investor. Whether the high debt resolves itself through a dramatic collapse or by the JCB engineering a large-scale debt write off, bets on a weaker yen and higher interest rates will likely bring investors outsized returns and possibly protection in a crisis. Disclosure: The author is long JGBS, GYEN. (More…) The author wrote this article themselves, and it expresses their own opinions. The author is not receiving compensation for it (other than from Seeking Alpha). The author has no business relationship with any company whose stock is mentioned in this article.

Intelligent Investing Is (Literally) Child’s Play!

Summary In any large group of investors, some are bound to have outperformed simply by pure chance – it does not prove that they are skilled. The fact that even children and pets can outperform professional fund managers proves that luck is what mainly drives investment results. Even buying stocks you understand, as advocated by Warren Buffett, does not lead to superior investment performance. Stocks selected at random perform just as well – and often times even better – than stocks carefully selected by the so-called “experts.”. The common wisdom is that the more time one spends researching stocks, the better one’s investment results will be. But if this was true, then why do actively managed funds consistently underperform the market? Many of these funds spend enormous resources on research in an attempt to uncover the best stocks, and yet their performance is often surpassed by blindfolded monkeys throwing darts at a stock board. How can this be? How much of a role does luck play in investment success? This article will attempt to answer these important questions. Everyone is Above Average in their Own Minds Overconfidence refers to the human tendency to overestimate one’s own abilities and knowledge relative to others. This is sometimes called the “Lake Wobegon Effect” – a fictional town where all the women are strong, all the men are good looking, and all the children are above average. In the real world, for instance, 84% of Frenchmen feel that their lovemaking abilities put them in the top half of French lovers. And in the U.S., 93% of people believe their driving skills put them in the top 50% of U.S. drivers (although it does make me curious about how bad the last 7% of drivers are – they are probably dead by now). To see how prevalent the Lake Wobegon Effect (i.e., overconfidence) was in the financial markets, I once conducted a survey asking professional traders at a large, proprietary trading firm to rank their trading skills as either “below” or “above” average compared to their peers at the firm. Out of the 87 participants, 84 rated themselves as above average. This, of course, is a mathematical impossibility since only half of them, not 97%, can be better than average. Curiously enough, though, many of these “above average” traders ended up blowing up during the 2008 financial crisis. Their overconfidence led to massive risk-taking, which caused their eventual downfall. But in addition to irrational risk taking, overconfidence also leads to excessive trading. There are two major problems with overtrading: the first, and the most obvious problem, is that it increases taxes and trading fees; and second, the shares that individual traders sell, on average, do better than those they buy, by a very substantial margin. Essentially, this means that less really is more when it comes to trading. This is why the best predictor of future performance is the level of turnover, not pursuit of specific investment styles/philosophies. Perhaps Winnie-the-Pooh put it best when he said “Never underestimate the value of doing nothing.” More people should heed this advice. Luck is More Important than Skill (in Investing) Not only does overconfidence led to excessive trading and risk taking, it also makes people blind to the fact that investing – like casino gambling – is largely a game of luck. This is why past investment track records are less relevant than what most people think. Since there are literally tens of millions of investors in the world, it is a statistical certainty that a very tiny percentage of them will become a Warren Buffett or a George Soros. Likewise, if there were an equal number of coin-flippers, a few would, by pure chance alone, flip heads 20 or more times in a row – it does not prove that they are skilled coin-flippers. Because luck is what mostly determines success, the type of investment style/philosophy employed (e.g., value, growth, momentum, etc.) is of little importance. Buffett’s approach, for instance, is to buy undervalued stocks and wait for them to appreciate to fair value; conversely, Soros does not pay too much attention to valuation – he is famous for making some of his largest trading decisions based on nothing more than how much his back is hurting that day. Although using completely opposite investment approaches, both Buffett and Soros were still able to amass huge fortunes. This shows that, with luck on one’s side, literally any investment strategy can work. In fact, even random stock selection – like a blindfolded monkey throwing darts at a stock board – gives one as good a chance at beating the market as any other strategy. Interestingly enough, most of the time the monkeys actually perform better than the so-called “professionals,” probably because they have lower turnover and charge lower fees (bananas are pretty cheap). A few years ago, I began conducting a random stock picking experiment. I enlisted the help of my trusty five-year old sidekick Jimmy (or Jim as he prefers to be called). Jim was tasked with pulling 10 slips of paper at random out of a hat. Every slip of paper in the hat had a ticker symbol on it – there were 500 slips in total (each representing one company in the S&P 500 index). I then created a portfolio that is equally invested in those 10 companies, and tracked their performance over the course of a year. This experiment was conducted for three consecutive years (2012-2014), with the results show below. Exhibit 1: Random Stock Selection Outperforms Most Hedge Funds Note: (1) Jim picked a new set of stocks at the start of every year, which means his portfolio was completely rebalanced once per year. (2) The performance returns exclude dividends paid. Source: A North Investments, State Street Global Advisors, Barclay Hedge Fund Index The performance was impressive to say the least. Jim’s random stock picks significantly outperformed both the SPDR S&P 500 ETF (NYSEARCA: SPY ) as well as the average hedge fund for three consecutive years. But Jim’s outperformance is not surprising or unique – even non-humans can do it! Back in 2012, a ginger cat named Orlando had managed to outperform many fund managers. The cat simply selected stocks by throwing his favorite toy mouse on a grid of numbers allocated to different companies. In another funny example, a Russian circus chimpanzee named Lusha picked stocks that tripled in value over a year’s time. Lusha was presented with cubes representing 30 different stocks and selected eight to invest money in by picking the cubes. Her chosen portfolio outperformed 94% of Russian investment funds! The undeniable fact that children and pets can outperform professional fund managers proves beyond a shadow of a doubt that luck is what mainly drives investment results. If investing truly did involve skill, then the professionals would consistently outperform – just like we can expect a world-class chess grandmaster to consistently beat even the luckiest amateur chess player. Rather than seeking expert advice, then, most people are better off investing their savings by selecting stocks at random or by buying into an index fund or ETF which tracks a reputable selection of securities. Not only does this reduce long term risk, it also saves paying fees to fund managers with seven-figure salaries and hefty bonuses. For those who are interested (or perhaps have no children or pets to help them pick stocks), below I have provided a list of Jim’s random stock picks for 2015. I am willing to bet that little Jim’s portfolio will once again outperform the average high-fee-charging hedge fund! Exhibit 2: Jim’s Random Stock Picks for 2015 Source: A North Investments The Futility of Equity Research One of Buffett’s personal investing rules (right after “never lose money”) is to only buy companies you understand. This sounds like a very reasonable rule in theory. But as Yogi Berra once said, “In theory there is no difference between theory and practice; in practice there is.” In a way, Buffett seems to believe that having more knowledge about a company makes it easier to predict how much its intrinsic value (and its stock price) will change over time. This simply does not appear to be the case. Take, for instance, Google (NASDAQ: GOOG ) (NASDAQ: GOOGL ) founders Larry Page and Sergey Brin. Several years before Google’s massive IPO that made them both billionaires, they attempted to sell the whole company for a paltry $1.6 million. Luckily for them, no one in Silicon Valley was interested in buying the young company with its unique search technology. It can easily be said that nobody in the world possessed more knowledge about Google than its two founders, and even they could not predict the Google phenomenon (as the attempt to sell proves). It would then be foolish to believe that it is possible to make any better predictions about companies’ futures just by reading their old SEC filings. This explains why actively managed funds, even after spending millions of dollars and thousands of man-hours every year conducting detailed research in a futile attempt to find the best stocks, consistently underperform passive index funds and dart-throwing monkeys. As it is so often said, the definition of insanity is doing the same thing over and over and over again and expecting different results. That pretty well describes the actively managed fund industry. But what about small individual investors? There is a long-held belief that smaller investors have an advantage over the Wall Street crowd, since they are not subject to institutional constraints. Chief among these is the freedom to invest in small, thinly traded stocks, which research has shown tend to have higher returns than their larger counterparts. Still, I would argue that the future price behavior of each individual stock, regardless of size, always remains completely random and unpredictable – essentially making it impossible to consistently pick the best ones. In other words, smaller investors possess no advantage at all. To prove this empirically, I simply tracked the performance of every Seeking Alpha “Pro Top Idea” published during January 2014 (only the “long” recommendations). Not only are all of these relatively small companies, but they were specifically picked by the experts as the best stock ideas with the most near-term upside potential. These stock recommendations, 40 in total, were combined into an equally weighted portfolio, and the portfolio’s overall performance was tracked over the course of the year. The end results were even worse than expected. As shown below, the Pro Top Ideas even underperformed hedge funds, generating a negative return of 1.8% in 2014. Every single one of these 40 recommendations is extensively researched, well-written, and sounds very convincing, and yet these expert stock picks were easily outperformed by a child picking stocks at random out of a hat. To be fair, a small number of Pro Top Ideas did generate impressive 30%+ returns; however, any set of 40 randomly selected stocks will also contain a few that will provide similar returns, there is no need to waste time conducting research on them. Exhibit 3: Professional Stock Pickers Underperform Note: (1) Performance tracked from January 2, 2014 (the first trading day) to December 31, 2014 (the last trading day). (2) Only the “long” Pro Top Ideas were included; companies that were acquired during the year were excluded. Source: A North Investments, State Street Global Advisors, Barclay Hedge Fund Index, Seeking Alpha The main point is that no amount of research will make someone a better stock picker. It might sound counterintuitive, but the empirical evidence is overwhelmingly in support of this conclusion. This is because the price behavior of stocks is influenced by an infinite number of variables (most of them unknown), so attempting to predict which stocks will perform the best at any given time is impossible. It should also be noted that high subjective confidence (e.g., “high conviction stock picks” made by some suit-and-tie-wearing investment guru) is not to be trusted as an indicator of accuracy; if anything, low confidence could be more informative. Summary and Conclusion In any large group of investors, some are bound to have outperformed by pure chance alone – it does not prove that they possess skill. In other words, luck is what separates good investors from bad ones. But since luck has a tendency to revert to the mean in the long run, investing with a hotshot fund manager could be hazardous to one’s wealth. For this reason, most people are far better off investing their savings by selecting stock at random or by buying into a low-cost index fund or ETF which tracks a reputable selection of securities. This reduces risk and over time will produce higher after-tax returns. Disclosure: The author has no positions in any stocks mentioned, and no plans to initiate any positions within the next 72 hours. (More…) The author wrote this article themselves, and it expresses their own opinions. The author is not receiving compensation for it (other than from Seeking Alpha). The author has no business relationship with any company whose stock is mentioned in this article.