Tag Archives: management

Choosing The ‘Best’ REIT CEF

Summary Over the past 8 years, only RNP has consistently outperformed VNQ on a risk-adjusted basis. REIT CEFs help diversify an S&P 500 focused portfolio. Domestic REIT funds outperformed international REIT funds over most of the timeframes analyzed. In November, 2014, I wrote an article expounding the benefits of Real Estate Investment Trusts (REITs). Unfortunately, in late January of this year, REITs hit a speed bump, many dropping by 15% or more. The likely reason was the fear that REIT prices would fall when the Fed raised interest rates. However, since the Fed will likely not raise rates unless the economy is thriving, increased rates may not be all bad for REITs. A robust economy typically bodes well for real estate and according to REIT.com , during the 16 periods since 1995 where interest rates rose significantly, equity REITs generated positive returns in 12 of the periods. As a retiree looking for income, I am a fan of REITs. I own some individual REITs but I tend to gravitate to REIT funds, especially Closed-End Funds (CEFs) because of their high distributions. As prices have decreased, the discounts associated with REIT CEFs have widened and the distribution percentages have increased. If you believe the weakness is temporary, now may be a good time to consider adding REITs to your portfolio. There are currently 12 CEFs focused on REITs, so the question is, which funds are “best.” There are many ways to define “best.” Some investors may use total return as a metric, but as a retiree, risk is as important to me as return. Therefore, I define “best” as the fund that provides the most reward for a given level of risk and I measure risk by the volatility. Please note that I am not advocating that this is the way everyone should define “best”; I am just saying that this is the definition that works for me. This article will analyze the REIT CEFs to assess relative risk-adjusted performance since the bear market of 2008. Along the way, I will also compare the REIT CEFs to Exchange Traded Funds (ETFs). However, before jumping into the analysis, it will be useful to review some of the characteristics of this asset class. In 1960, Congress created a new type of security called REITs that allowed real estate investments to be traded as a stock. The objective of this landmark legislation was to provide a way for small investors to participate in the income from large scale real estate projects. A REIT is a company that specializes in real estate, either through properties or mortgages. There are two major types of REITs: Equity REITs purchase and operate real estate properties. Income usually comes through the collection of rents. About 90% of REITs are equity REITs. Mortgage REITs invest in mortgages or mortgage-backed securities. Income is generated primarily from the interest that is earned on mortgage loans. The risks and rewards associated with mortgage REITs are very different than those associated with equity REITs. This article will only consider equity REITs. One of the reasons REITs are so popular is that they receive special tax treatment, and as a result, are required to distribute at least 90% of their taxable income each year. This usually translates into relatively large yields. But because REITs must pay out 90% of their income, they rely on debt for growth. This means that REITs are sensitive to interest rates. If the interest rates rise, the cost of debt increases and the REITs have less money for business investment. However, as we have discussed, rising rates usually imply increased economic activity, and as the economy expands, there is a higher demand for real estate, which is positive for REITs. To narrow the analysis space, I used the following selection criteria: A history that goes back to 2007 (to see how the fund reacted during the 2008 bear market). Generally, REITs were devastated in 2008, but, like other equities, they have recovered strongly since 2009. A market cap of at least $100M An average daily trading volume of at least 50,000 shares The 7 CEFs that passed the screen are summarized below. Nuveen Real Estate Income ( JRS ). This CEF sells for a discount of 7.6%, which is unusual since over the past 5 years the fund has sold at an average premium of 3.3%. The fund has 93 holdings with 57% invested in REITs and the rest in preferred stock. The REIT’s holdings are spread over all types of properties (retail, office, residential, healthcare, hotels). As with most REITs, the price of the fund dropped over 60% in 2008, but rebounded strongly in 2009, gaining 89%. The fund utilizes 29% leverage and has an expense ratio of 1.8%, including interest payments. This distribution is 9%, funded from income and capital gains, with no return of capital (NYSE: ROC ) over the past year. Neuberger Berman Real Estate Securities Income Fund ( NRO ). This CEF sells for a discount of 16.3%, which is larger than its 5-year average discount of 12.8%. The fund consists of 70 holdings with 66% in diversified REITs and 33% in preferred shares. The price of the fund fell a whopping 78% in 2008, but rebounded over 100% in 2009. The fund uses leverage of 27% and has an expense ratio of 1.7%, including interest payments. The yield is 7.4% funded primarily from income with no ROC. Cohen and Steers Quality Income Realty Fund ( RQI ). This CEF sells for a 13% discount, which is larger than its 5-year average discount of 8.4%. The fund has 126 holdings consisting of REITs (82%) and preferred stock (16%). The price of this fund fell 68% in 2008 and gained 80% in 2009. The fund utilizes 24% leverage and has an expense ratio of 1.9%, including interest payments. The distribution is 8.5%, consisting primarily of income and long-term gains with no ROC. Cohen and Steers Total Return Reality (NYSE: RFI ). This CEF sells for a discount 9%, which is larger than the 5 year average discount of 0.9%. The portfolio consists of 143 securities with 80% in diversified REITs and 19% in preferred stocks. This fund does not use leverage and has an expense ratio of 0.9%. The distribution is 7.7% with no ROC. Cohen and Steers REIT and Preferred Income Fund ( RNP ). This CEF sells for a discount of 15.6%, which is larger than its 5-year average discount of 9.9%. The portfolio consists of 206 holdings with 50% in REITs and 48% in preferred shares. The fund lost 60% in 2008 and rebounded strongly in 2009, gaining over 90%. The fund uses 25% leverage and has an expense ratio of 1.7%, including interest payments. The distribution is 8.3%, consisting primarily of income with about 40% ROC over the past 6 months. The undistributed net investment income (UNII) is positive so I would consider the ROC to be non-destructive. CBRE Clarion Global Real Estate Income ( IGR ). This CEF sells for a discount of 15.1%, which is larger than its 5-year average discount of 9.7%. The portfolio consists of 57 securities with 90% in REITs and the rest in preferred shares. About 50% of the holdings are from the United States with the rest spread over Asia, Europe, Australia, and Canada. The fund dropped 67% in 2008 and gained 79% in 2009. This fund uses only a small amount of leverage (9.6%) and has an expense ratio of 1.1%. The distribution is 7.4%, consisting of income and ROC in roughly equal parts. Some of the distribution appears to be destructive since UNII is negative and is large when compared to the distribution. Alpine Global Premier Properties Fund ( AWP ). This CEF sells for a discount of 13.8%, which is larger than its 5-year average discount of 11.4%. The portfolio consists of 105 holdings with almost all (99%) in REITs. Only 30% of the holdings are domiciled in the United States. The next largest geographical weightings are Japan at 15% followed by the UK at 10% and China at 8%. The fund lost 63% in 2008 and rebounded 79% in 2009. The fund uses only a small amount (2%) of leverage and has an expense ratio of 1.3%, including interest payments. The distribution is 9.2% consisting primarily of income and about 40% ROC. Some of the distribution appears to be destructive since UNII is negative and is large when compared to the distribution. For comparison, I used the following Exchange Traded Funds (ETFs). Vanguard REIT Index ETF ( VNQ ). This ETF was launched in 2004 and tracks the MSCI US REIT Index, which is a pure equity REIT index. The index is diversified across real estate sectors with retail being the largest constituent at 27% followed by Office (15%), residential (15%), and health care (15%). The fund lost a relatively low 37% in 2008 and recovered 30% in 2009. The fund charges a miniscule 0.12%, which is substantially less than most of its competitors. The fund yields 4.1%. SPDR Dow Jones International Real Estate (NYSEARCA: RWX ). This ETF offers exposure to foreign real estate REITs. It holds 120 securities with 54% domiciled in the Pacific region (21% from Japan and 12% from Australia) and 36% domiciled in Europe. This fund lost 50% in 2008 and recovered 36% in 2009. The fund has an expense ratio of 0.59% and yields 3%. For the funds that met my criteria, I plotted the annualized rate of return in excess of the risk-free rate (called Excess Mu on the charts) versus the volatility for each fund. This data is shown in Figure 1. The risk-free rate was assumed to be 1%. The Smartfolio 3 program was used to generate this chart. (click to enlarge) Figure 1. Risk versus reward over bear-bull cycle Figure 1 illustrates that REIT funds have had a large range of returns and volatilities. To better assess the relative performance of these funds, I calculated the Sharpe Ratio. The Sharpe Ratio is a metric, developed by Nobel laureate William Sharpe that measures risk-adjusted performance. It is calculated as the ratio of the excess return over the volatility. This reward-to-risk ratio (assuming that risk is measured by volatility) is a good way to compare peers to assess if higher returns are due to superior investment performance or from taking additional risk. In Figure 1, I plotted a red line that represents the Sharpe Ratio associated with VNQ. If an asset is above the line, it has a higher Sharpe Ratio than VNQ. Conversely, if an asset is below the line, the reward-to-risk is worse than SPY. Some interesting observations are evident from the figure. With the exception of RWX, REIT funds had similar volatilities but significantly different returns. Somewhat surprisingly, RWX was by far the least volatile fund but it also had the least return. RQI and NRO were the most volatile. Over the bear-bull cycle, three funds (RFI, VNQ, and RNP) outperformed the other funds on a risk-adjusted basis with RNP eking out the best performance by a small margin. The international REIT funds (RWX, AWP, and IGR) substantially lagged the domestic REIT funds. RQI had relative good absolute performance but, when coupled with the high volatility, had the fourth best risk-adjusted performance. One of the reasons often touted for owning REITs is the diversification they provide. To be “diversified,” you want to choose assets such that when some assets are down, others are up. In mathematical terms, you want to select assets that are uncorrelated (or at least not highly correlated) with each other. To assess the degree of diversification, I calculated the pair-wise correlations associated with the REIT funds. To round out the analysis, I also included SPDR S&P 500 (NYSEARCA: SPY ) to represent the overall stock market. The results are provided as a correlation matrix in Figure 2. (click to enlarge) Figure 2. Correlation matrix over bear-bull cycle As is apparent from the matrix, REITs did provide a reasonable amount of portfolio diversification. The REIT CEFs were about 70% correlated with SPY. The CEFs were also not highly correlated with each other or with the REIT ETFs (with correlations ranging from 60% to 80%). As you might expect, the Cohen and Steers REIT funds were more correlated with each other than with others funds, but they still offered relatively good diversification. Next, I looked at the past 5-year period to see if the REIT performance had significantly changed. The results are shown in Figure 3. The performances were tightly bunched, but RNP was still the best performer with NRO and RQI both beating VNQ. The international funds improved but still lagged. (click to enlarge) Figure 3. Risk versus reward over past 5 years As a final test, I re-ran the analysis over the past 3 years and the results are shown in Figure 4. What a difference a couple of years made! Over this period, the two ETFs (RWX and VNQ) plus RNP have generated the best risk-adjusted performance. AWP and NRO also had relatively good performance with RQI, RFI, JRS, and IGR lagging. IGR had the worst performance among all the funds. (click to enlarge) Figure 4. Risk versus reward over past 3 years Bottom Line REITs have had good performance in the past but have recently fallen on hard times. If you believe that REITs currently offer a buying opportunity, I recommend either VNQ or RNP, depending on whether you prefer ETFs or CEFs. I would steer clear of international funds since their performance has not be consistent over the years. Disclosure: I/we have no positions in any stocks mentioned, but may initiate a long position in VNQ,RNP over the next 72 hours. (More…) I wrote this article myself, and it expresses my own opinions. I am not receiving compensation for it (other than from Seeking Alpha). I have no business relationship with any company whose stock is mentioned in this article.

Vanguard Wellington Fund: Can One Fund Do It All?

VWELX is one of the oldest balanced funds around. It has a great track record of success and is dirt cheap to own. This could be the cornerstone on which you built a portfolio, or even your entire portfolio. Vanguard Wellington Fund (MUTF: VWELX ) dates back to 1929, that puts it among an elite group of funds in the pooled investment world. And, unlike many of Vanguard’s funds, it isn’t an index fund. If you are looking for a single fund to be your portfolio or to be your portfolio’s backstop, this fund should be on your short list. What’s it do? Vanguard Wellington Fund is a balanced fund, placing roughly two-thirds of its assets in stocks and the rest in bonds. Its primary goal is long-term capital appreciation with a moderate amount of income. When selecting securities Wellington Management uses a value approach. In practice that means buying “established large companies” in which earnings, or earnings potential, is not fully reflected in share prices. On the bond side, Wellington Management, “…selects investment-grade bonds that it believes will generate a moderate level of current income.” That’s not very exciting, but the true value of the bond assets is diversification. So boring is good here. How’s that working out? So far, Vanguard Wellington’s done a great job for investors. Over the trailing 15-year period through June, the fund has an annualized total return of roughly 8%, including reinvested distributions. That may not sound all that exciting, but that’s pretty much the point of a balanced fund. Solid, but boring. That 8%, by the way, puts the fund in the top 4% of all similar funds tracked by Morningstar. But the risk/reward trade off deserves more examination than this. For example, over that trailing 15-year period Vanguard Wellington’s standard deviation, a measure of volatility, was roughly 9.5. Compare that to the S&P 500 500 Index’s 15 and you start to see the benefit. Oh, and the S&P returned roughly 4.5% a year annualized over that 15 year span… Now that makes Vanguard Wellington start to look pretty good. And, perhaps the best part, the fund is dirt cheap to own with an expense ratio of just 0.26%. That’s active management for a price that’s not much higher than an index fund. Not a bad deal at all. So what? That brings us back to what you might want to do with this fund. For starters, it’s a fund that’s appropriate for just about any investor to own, aggressive or not. For those who don’t want to bother with the work of investing it could easily be the only fund you every need to buy. A true one and you’re done offering. However, there’s a small problem here if you are looking for income. Vanguard Wellington’s trailing yield is just 2.4%. Unless you have a lot of money, that’s not going to be enough to live on. That leaves two options. First is to set up an automatic withdrawal program so that you get regular checks from the fund. In good times Vanguard Wellington’s gains will more than make up for a modest withdrawal program (say the old rule of thumb 4%). However, in bad years, you’ll be drawing down capital. Despite the fact that past performance is no guarantee of future returns, historically speaking the fund would have more than made up for its lean years. The other option, and perhaps the better choice for more active investors, is to use Vanguard Wellington as your core holding. That means you don’t have to worry too much about the base of your portfolio, allowing you to spend more time finding other investments that can provide you with more income. A core and explore type portfolio structure. And one that would allow you to take on more risk with the explore portion because of the relatively low risk of the core. For example you might pair higher distribution closed-end funds with Vanguard Wellington. In the end, Vanguard Wellington is a great fund. It isn’t right for everyone, but it could have a place in almost any portfolio. That includes being the only holding all the way to being a cornerstone of a more diverse portfolio. If you are trying to simplify, take a moment to look at Vanguard Wellington Fund. Disclosure: I/we have no positions in any stocks mentioned, and no plans to initiate any positions within the next 72 hours. (More…) I wrote this article myself, and it expresses my own opinions. I am not receiving compensation for it (other than from Seeking Alpha). I have no business relationship with any company whose stock is mentioned in this article.

Senior Loan Funds: Buy Inexpensive Defense Against Rising Interest Rates

Instability in Greece and China further emphasizes the ‘asynchronous recovery’ where the US might decouple from the reset of the world. In this scenario, investors would want to prepare for mild to moderate increase in US interest rates, and diversify towards rising interest rate assets. Blackstone Strategic Credit (BGB) is one such opportunistic play with a total yield value proposition worth considering. Investing is a confusing thing these days. There’s a pundit for every theory. There’s Jeff Gundlach and Bill Gross talking about the Bond ‘freight train’ and how interest rates are going to rise. There are pundits talking about how Greece and China are going to fall off the cliff (so interest rates fall further), or how secular stagnation is going to be a long-term malaise on the world economy. You can prepare for the two extremes by investing in bonds and commodities, but what about the muddle in the middle? How do you deal with the Asynchronous Global Recovery where the US trends gently higher while the rest of the world grapples with issues that are behind us? This muddle – slow(er) growth than past recoveries but higher interest rates than we have today, is something your portfolio should have an allocation to. This is where Bank Loan (or Senior Loan) funds come in. Bank Loans do better as the economy does better, but in ways that are unique to their asset class. Since they are an out-of-favor asset, buying a closed end fund or CEF gives you the additional pop of a NAV discount that will turn into a NAV premium at a future point. The right CEF thus gives you asset exposure at a discount, and therefore protection on the downside and returns on the upside. US is in (Gentle) Recovery Mode. We could argue endlessly for any of many sides (deflation, recession to be, recovery) based on the indicators we pick, but the hiring and compensation market (see Figure) suggests a gentle recovery to be the most likely possibility. Indirect data suggest that end market conditions that are interpreted as recessionary (e.g. housing starts) are a sign of labor shortage, not low demand. Asset Class Div ersification. The adjoining figure from Credit Suisse shows you the correlations between Bank Loan funds and a number of other common asset classes over the last 20 years. While Bank Loans have had a moderate correlations to High Yield over that period, they provide Asset Class diversification against most of the other traditional asset classes. High Yield has some unique near-term concerns including withdrawal risk (a matter Carl Icahn took a megaphone to in the recent past) and duration exposure, so I believe the current correlation to be notably below the 20 year correlation. Many Choices, Some Better than Others. The adjoining figure provides you a list of options within the Senior Loan CEF category. If you eyeball their charts – you will notice their performance to be highly correlated, and uniformly uninspiring over the last 2 years. But the future isn’t the past. The future is a Wall Street expectation of at least a gentle recovery, global unrest notwithstanding. You would probably do reasonably picking any one of these earning a 6-7% interest while you wait. A number of these funds are trading at a NAV discount of 10-12%, having traded at premiums to NAV in times past. So there is another shared element of the upside. But I favor Blackstone Global Credit (NYSE: BGB ) within the category for a couple of reasons. First, Senior Loans are at the ‘spicy’ end of fixed income, with a risk (and return) that is greater than stodgier asset categories such as Treasuries. I prefer to go with fund managers who have a Private Equity background and do ‘spicy’ as a matter of routine. If there are liquidity issues as Mr. Icahn raises as an issue, Blackstone has successfully navigated rockier waters than most. Second, hedge fund manager SABA Capital (which has a long history of outperforming the indices) took a 5% stake in BGB . BGB is the only Senior Loan Fund on SABA’s portfolio, and is perhaps their testament to the veteran management team in a specialized space. It is worth mentioning that Senior Loan funds are tied to what’s called the LIBOR floor . With rates below the LIBOR floor, interest might not trend upward until interest rates go up 50 to 75 basis points. But with a 6-7% interest and 10% NAV discount, there is a total return thesis that gives you income, NAV return and inflation protection. Disclosure: I am/we are long BGB. (More…) I wrote this article myself, and it expresses my own opinions. I am not receiving compensation for it (other than from Seeking Alpha). I have no business relationship with any company whose stock is mentioned in this article.