Tag Archives: management

Not All Asset Managers Are Enthused By Vanguard Index Changes

Summary Vanguard is making changes to its emerging market ETF as the FTSE makes index changes. China A-shares will have a greater role in the FTSE Emerging Market Index. Potential risks in changing up the current make-up of the widely observed index. By Todd Shriber & Tom Lydon Last month, Vanguard, the second-largest U.S. issuer of exchange traded funds, said it is making changes to four of its popular international ETFs, including the Vanguard FTSE Emerging Markets ETF (NYSEARCA: VWO ) . VWO is the largest emerging markets ETF by assets. Pennsylvania-based Vanguard said VWO will transition to the FTSE Emerging Markets All-Cap China Inclusion Index from the FTSE Emerging Index, meaning the ETF will eventually hold Chinese A-shares, becoming the second diversified emerging markets ETF to do so. The Vanguard FTSE Developed Markets ETF (NYSEARCA: VEA ) , the Vanguard FTSE Europe ETF (NYSEARCA: VGK ) and the Vanguard FTSE Pacific ETF (NYSEARCA: VPL ) , funds with nearly $80 billion in combined assets under management, are also undergoing index changes , including significantly increased exposure to small caps. Not all money managers are fussed on those index changes. In a blog post posted dated July 17 , New Frontier, a Boston-based institutional research and investment advisory firm, said it is dropping the aforementioned Vanguard ETFs in favor of competing products from BlackRock’s (NYSE: BLK ) iShares unit, the world’s largest ETF issuer. New Frontier said it is replacing positions in the Vanguard ETFs with the iShares Core MSCI Europe ETF (NYSEARCA: IEUR ) , the iShares Core MSCI Emerging Markets ETF (NYSEARCA: IEMG ) and the iShares Core MSCI Pacific ETF (NYSEARCA: IPAC ) . “These are institutional quality ETFs with known exposures to known indexes with stable histories and differentiated risk premiums. Our patented rebalance test, which signals when portfolios are meaningfully different from optimal, provided rigorous quantitative justification for the trades,” said New Frontier. Part of the iShares core lineup targeted at cost-conscious advisors and investors, IEUR, IEMG and IPAC have nearly $10 billion in combined assets under management, with IEMG controlling over $7.4 billion of that total. IEMG continues to be a popular alternative for investors – professional and retail – looking for a cost-efficient alternative to the iShares MSCI Emerging Markets ETF (NYSEARCA: EEM ) . IEMG’s annual fee is 0.18% compared to 0.69% on EEM . “Vanguard’s reconstituted ETFs represent an expanded level of one-stop diversification for investors. However, the upshot is that they will homogenize important global risk premiums, limiting the benefit of sophisticated global ETF asset management. Other concerns include the difficulty of controlling risk during the transition period as well as possible front-running by various market entities,” adds New Frontier. VEA, VGK, VPL and VWO will all see significantly increased small-cap exposure as a result of the index transitions. Under the funds’ new benchmarks, small-cap stocks will account for approximately 9-11% of each fund, according to Vanguard. VEA will also add Canadian stocks for the first time, and it is expected the ETF will eventually hold a weight of up to 8.2% in Canadian equities. iShares Core MSCI Europe ETF (click to enlarge) Disclosure: I/we have no positions in any stocks mentioned, and no plans to initiate any positions within the next 72 hours. (More…) I wrote this article myself, and it expresses my own opinions. I am not receiving compensation for it. I have no business relationship with any company whose stock is mentioned in this article.

MBG: A Comps Leader With Stable Returns

Summary Fed backed mortgage securities are very safe and provide high interest payments. Of the 4 major mortgage security ETFs, MBG offers the most potential for the highest yields. MBG is well valued and backed by strong underlying assets. Introduction Fed backed mortgage securities are safe and reliable investments that provide high interest payments. Most mortgage backed securities, however, are too expensive for the average investor. Minimum investments generally reach as high as 25,000, for a mortgage pass-through. Additionally, MBS funds generally require a 1 million dollar minimum investment. MBS ETFs allow average investors to buy some exposure to a valuable fixed income security. There are 4 main players on the market, but the SPDR Barclays Capital Mortgage Backed Bond ETF (NYSEARCA: MBG ) offers the most potential for high yields. MBG Analysis There are many MBS ETFs on the market, but of those ETFs there are really four primary ETFs that offer attractive returns with minimal risk. The other MBS ETF options have too few AUM, poor liquidity, high expenses, inadequate exposure, poor returns, or risky underlying assets. For the sake of time, trust me when I say the proceeding four MBS ETFs are the best (and safest) choices, I included others in the link above. MBG is a strong MBS ETF. It holds over 151 million in total assets and it has a net asset value of 26.88. What sets MBG apart is its 12-month returns. Average yields fall between 1.4% – 2%, while MBG has 12 month returns in excess of 3.5%. It has a miniscule expense fee of 0.20%. MBG also exclusively holds AAA bonds and cash. MBG attains comparably optimal returns while maintaining an incredibly safe portfolio. All of MBG’s assets are also agency backed, which means they come with agency guarantee (or for Ginnie Mae’s the full faith and credit of the United States government). Comps Analysis What MBG lacks in total assets, exposure, and volume, It makes up with in asset strength and 12 month yields. Mortgage Securities Analysis Mortgage securities are inversely correlated to interest rates. With the possibility of an interest rate hike , one may want to wait for prices to decrease or adapt a long term-investing horizon. Capital appreciation, while possible, is a secondary objective when investing in mortgage securities. The stable distribution of fixed income payments ( in excess of treasury yields ), as well as portfolio diversification ought to be the primary objectives of MBS investing. In the long term, MBG’s volatility is negligible. To visually express this, I included a chart of the Vanguard Total Stock Market ETF ( VTI) (total market returns) and the ten year treasury rate. Conclusion Mortgage securities offer a valuable source of fixed income. They can be used by retirees as a stable form of income, or they can be used as a tool for portfolio risk diversification. There are four investable MBS ETFs on the markets. MBG, while the smallest, historically has offered the highest comparable yields whilst maintaining a 100% AAA rated portfolio. For this reason, I consider MBG to be an attractive buy. Disclosure: I/we have no positions in any stocks mentioned, and no plans to initiate any positions within the next 72 hours. (More…) I wrote this article myself, and it expresses my own opinions. I am not receiving compensation for it (other than from Seeking Alpha). I have no business relationship with any company whose stock is mentioned in this article.

3 Top REIT ETFs Battle It Out, With Some Surprising Results

Summary REITs can enhance your core portfolio by helping you diversify into an added asset class. In this article, we will examine three worthy competitors, examining both their similarities and differences. Along the way, the author will have a preconceived notion disturbed, and discover some surprises with respect to recent performance. Now that I have spent a little time covering some basic core ETFs with which to build a simple, though well-diversified, portfolio , I thought I would branch out into an asset class that you may wish to consider as an added component. That asset class is REITS. For a little background on REITS, as well as a link to further reading if desired, feel free to check out this article on my personal blog. Presenting The Competitors In doing some research in preparation for this article, I consistently encountered information featuring three ETFs as preeminent contenders in this space; the Vanguard REIT Index ETF (NYSEARCA: VNQ ), the SPDR Dow Jones REIT ETF (NYSEARCA: RWR ), and the Schwab U.S. REIT ETF (NYSEARCA: SCHH ). I listed them in the order I did based on some commonalities I encountered in my research. VNQ is often described as sort of the pre-eminent player in the field, the “big daddy” if you will. With an inception date of 9/23/04, 145 REITs in the portfolio, $23.7 billion in Assets Under Management (AUM) , a low .12% expense ratio, and great daily trading volume leading to a wonderful average price spread of .01%, there are many reasons this ETF has been described using terms such as “the king” and “top of the charts.” RWR , in contrast, might be termed the “grand old man.” This venerable ETF is the oldest of the three, with an inception date of 4/23/01. RWR features 94 REITs in its portfolio. It has approximately $3.1 billion in AUM , an expense ratio of .25% and an average price spread of .03%. SCHH might be thought of as the “new, but competitive, kid on the block.” With an inception date of 1/13/11, it has only been around a little over 4 years. It features 95 REITs in its portfolio. It is also the smallest of the three, with $1.3 billion in AUM . Due to its smaller size and lower daily volume, it has a price spread of .05%. But here’s the kicker. Though it tracks the same index as RWR, it does so with an incredibly low .07% expense ratio. That’s right, not only does it handily beat out RWR in this area, but it also beats the much larger VNQ! Similarities and Differences As you might quickly gather, VNQ is the obvious winner in terms of greatest diversification. VNQ tracks the MCSI US Reit Index , which contains 144 constituents, whereas both RWR and SCHH track the Dow Jones U.S. Select REIT Index , which contains 92 constituents. One similarity is that the Top-10 holdings are almost exactly the same in all 3 ETFs; with General Growth Properties (NYSE: GGP ) just slipping out of the 10th spot in VNQ, replaced by Vornado Realty (NYSE: VNO ). However, here are two data points that highlight VNQ’s greater diversification. Simon Property Group (NYSE: SPG ) is the top-weighted holding in each ETF. However, while it comprises 9.83% of both RWR and SCHH, it only comprises 8.39% of VNQ. Clearly, how SPG performs will have a greater effect on RWR and SCHH. As of the latest published data, the total weight of the Top-10 holdings in RWR and SCHH is 44.63% and 44.61%, respectively. In contrast the total weight of the Top-10 holdings in VNQ is a lower 36.4%. In terms of sectors, all three track fairly closely, with a slightly higher percentage of residential REITs being featured in RWR and SCHH; approximately 20.2% vs. 17.3% in VNQ. This is offset by a slightly higher weighting in specialized REITs in the index tracked by VNQ. Recent Performance – And A Few Surprises To be honest, I came into this evaluation with somewhat of a preconceived notion. Perhaps you are already sensing it, from what you read above? I sort of felt like VNQ was going to be the runaway winner. I mean, its size, better diversification (including smaller REITs), great expense ratio, what could be better? The fact that I own VNQ in my own portfolio perhaps contributed to my viewpoint (bias?) as well. But then I started to dig into some numbers over the past year. I looked at the dividend distributions for each fund and compared them against the respective share prices. Something interesting leaped out at me right off the bat. Have a look at the picture below: (click to enlarge) First of all, you might note that VNQ (highlighted in green) is the winner as far as dividend distributions over the past year, at 4.08%. “Yep, pretty much confirms that VNQ is the king,” I proudly thought to myself. But then something caught my attention with respect to RWR (in blue) and SCHH (in brown). Both ETFs track the same index, yet RWR returned almost a full percentage point more in dividend distributions! How could that be? I next started wondering how the comparative share prices had performed over that period? In other words, was there a greater increase in the share price of SCHH that would offset the higher dividend paid by RWR? And that’s when the surprises started. Have a look at this 1-year chart: RWR data by YCharts The first item that jumped out at me was that SCHH’s share price had appreciated by 2.69% over that year, compared to 1.66% for RWR. Not only did that offset the larger dividend, in terms of total return it meant that SCHH outperformed RWR, 5.09% to 5.00% (you can see that back on the spreadsheet). That didn’t necessarily surprise me so much, as SCHH carries a lower expense ratio. You’re probably already noticing the second surprise, aren’t you? VNQ’s share price performance substantially trailed the other two; losing .20% over the period. Surely the greater dividend compensated for this? Sorry, it didn’t. To my great surprise, VNQ came in dead last in terms of total return. “Perhaps,” I thought, “this was just an aberration, something about the timing.” So I ran the same chart, but YTD through June 30. Here it is: RWR data by YCharts The first thing you will likely note is that the entire REIT sector took a pretty big hit between approximately February and June. The second thing you might note, though, is that the order of performance is the same. SCHH actually performed the best (in this case, losing the least), followed by RWR, with VNQ once again bringing up the rear. Have another look back at the spreadsheet. Even with its larger Q1 and Q2 distributions, VNQ still trails the pack in total YTD return. OK, last picture, I promise. The REIT sector has actually staged a nice comeback in July, so I thought I would see how this has played out for our 3 competitors: RWR data by YCharts Interestingly, this time the order is precisely reversed. VNQ is the strongest, with RWR in the middle and SCHH bringing up the rear. Summary & Conclusion Along the way, this became quite the interesting exercise for me, and reminded me to take nothing for granted, but instead to dig into the numbers, ask questions about details that did not appear to make sense, and follow the trail wherever it lead. At the end of the day, I’m going to call this one a tie between VNQ and SCHH. Ironically, during this latest downturn, it would appear that the smaller REITs in VNQ’s portfolio actually hurt its performance. Still, I like VNQ’s extra diversification, size and tradeability, low .12% expense ratio, and lengthy track record. At the same time, SCHH is a worthy competitor. Though not having as extensive a track record, it sure appears that Charles Schwab has succeeded in offering a quality, competitive ETF in the REIT space. That low .07% expense ratio is not to be ignored, particularly if one is a long-term investor and the slightly higher price spread is not a concern for you. And, with 95 REITs in the portfolio, it certainly offers solid diversification. RWR comes in last in my view simply because it appears clear that SCHH’s lower expense ratio is giving it a slight edge in performance. Still, if one currently holds RWR, I don’t see any particular need to sell it in favor of either VNQ or SCHH, particularly if this would create a tax impact due to unrealized gains. One last thing, if at all possible it is preferable to hold REITs in tax-deferred accounts. Since REITs receive preferred tax status as entities, their dividends are deemed non-qualified to the investor, meaning they do not benefit from the lower “qualified” dividend tax rate granted to firms that are double-taxed. As an investor, this means that you would pay tax at your highest marginal tax rate . Disclosure: I am/we are long VNQ. (More…) I wrote this article myself, and it expresses my own opinions. I am not receiving compensation for it (other than from Seeking Alpha). I have no business relationship with any company whose stock is mentioned in this article. Additional disclosure: I am not a registered investment advisor or broker/dealer. Readers are advised that the material contained herein should be used solely for informational purposes, and to consult with their personal tax or financial advisors as to its applicability to their circumstances. Investing involves risk, including the loss of principal.