Tag Archives: management

A Dim Light Shines Out Of The Deep Value Investing Cave

One tea leaf indicator that is used to get a sense of the future direction of the overall stock market is the number of stocks moving down in price. More stocks are now trading below their 200-day moving average than above it. Some investors might view this negatively, but an increasing number of stocks falling in price is a telling sign that brighter days lie ahead for deep value investors. Falling stock prices are a necessary but insufficient condition for deep value stocks to bubble up to the surface. This may seem counter-intuitive to investors who desire an ever-rising stock market, but for value investors, the opportunity to find true bargains increases following a significant market decline. One of Benjamin Graham’s more aggressive value investing strategies was to purchase stocks trading below their net current asset value . If a stock was beaten down in price so far to where it traded below what a private owner would value it upon liquidation, investors could take advantage of the anomaly and scoop up the bargain. Holding a deep value stock until the market price exceeds its net current asset value has historically produced excellent returns over the long term. An ever greater number of stocks trending below their long-term moving average is consistent with a future environment conducive to deep value investing. Some percentage of stocks trading below their moving average will eventually reach a valuation level consistent with Graham’s original concept of a true bargain. The chart below shows the percentage of net current asset value stocks that experienced a significant price decline before making their way into a deep value portfolio. (click to enlarge) Source: V. Wendl, The Net Current Asset Value Approach To Stock Investing , (2013): p. 184 . As indicated in the chart, nearly 80% of all stocks lost money over the previous five-year period before entering the net current asset value portfolio. This holds true in both bull and bear market years over the 50-year-plus study period. As more stocks join the growing herd trading below their 200-day moving average, a certain percentage of them will fall to such an irrationally low price point that deep value investors might take an interest in them. Waiting for stocks to reach a true bargain basement price level requires patience. It is a process that unfolds gradually over time. If most stocks are in a general decline , as they are currently, the evidence shows that some will continue to fall in price to a price point below net current asset value. The chart below shows the performance of a typical net current asset value stock over the five -year period of 1955-2008 before it entered the deep value portfolio. The chart is restricted to rolling five-year time periods when the overall stock market was in decline. There existed 10 overlapping five-year periods over the past 50-plus years when the stock market dropped in value. (click to enlarge) As indicated in the chart, more than half of the stocks declined in price by more than 60% before entering the net current asset value portfolio. Over a typical five-year losing period in stocks, the ones trading below liquidation value experience close to seven times the price drop in comparison with the overall market. This unfolds over years, not months. Mr. Market is at times tenacious, forcing deep value investors to wait a long time before labeling certain stocks a true bargain. Remaining on the lookout for a crack of light peering through the financial engineering monstrosity blocking our view of true bargains is the hallmark of a true disciple of Graham’s teachings. Share this article with a colleague

Understanding XLE: Looking Back And Going Forward

XLE has outperformed oil thus far this year. This does not mean it will outperform oil in a bull market. Diversification is a strength to prevent weakness, but also limits potential investment upside. With oil prices nearing the $40 a barrel mark there are many enterprising investors hypothesizing that now is the time to hop into an Energy sector ETF and enjoy the ride if oil prices recover. Surely it makes sense that the Energy Select Sector SPDR ETF (NYSEARCA: XLE ) would increase along with oil prices; conventional wisdom would have an investor believe that with oil prices so low energy sector ETFs have massive upside. However, examining a few charts tells a far different story, that the very same diversification that limits its downside also restricts the fund’s upside. It has been noted elsewhere on the site that the diversification of the ETF (as it sets out to track the Energy industry as a whole) allows it to outperform the The United States Oil ETF (NYSEARCA: USO ). While this may be true over the past five years, in which XLE has gained 30% despite USO dropping over 58% (all figures at time of writing), it is a fundamentally misguided belief to assume this would occur in an oil recovery. Because, as the chart below shows, the 5 year comparison began at a high-point in the commodity cycle, meaning USO could only really remain flat and then fall drastically in accordance with the WTI collapse; conversely, during a generally flat market with high oil prices the Energy ETF had room to grow along with the Earnings of the companies it tracked. (click to enlarge) What is worth noting, however, is that XLE has not seen nearly as severely a sell off as Crude Oil or the ETFs that track it. Could this mean XLE is the perfect instrument for every portfolio ? Just looking at the five-year chart and other analysis on the fund would have you believe it is, but it makes the crucial mistake of not recognizing how the companies composing XLE will perform in the future, and how its composition limits returns the same way it limits downside. Before proceeding, I highly recommend an investor read Jonathan Prather’s article on XLE, as it does a fantastic job of depicting the fund’s correlation with the index it tracks and why it is a better investment than its peers. There is one issue to be noted with the article, however, and that is with the assertion that “It is clear that XLE is more capable of mitigating its downside in a weak environment whilst maximizing returns in a bull market. I believe companies are able to develop strategies that allow for protection from fluctuations in price.” From March 15 to May 28 USO drastically outperformed XLE in a bull market; it is in a rising commodity price environment that USO will dominate XLE, thus any investor interested in an ETF to play the recovery could see higher returns in USO, not XLE. As Prather noted, though, XLE offers more downside protection, or at least has thus far. Now, to understand why XLE has managed the downturn without tumbling nearly as far as oil itself we need to examine its holdings and analyze what they might mean for the future — in both a low oil pricing environment and in a rising one, before judging whether or not to invest. How XLE Has Thus Far Outperformed Oil In the case of a severe downturn it is the diversification of the fund that gives it its strength, as noted above. The mechanics behind this result from the companies in the downstream performing exceptionally well and benefiting from lower oil prices, thus the share price gain from the refining stocks — which comprise about 12% of the overall fund — has mitigated the more drastic falls in some of the Exploration and Production companies. The chart below depicts just how well refiners have performed, demonstrating that their appreciation has helped keep XLE from sinking to the same depths as USO: (click to enlarge) But because of this paradigm the idea that the refiners will grow XLE is slightly misguided; that is, because they are only a portion of the pie they will not propel the entire fund in the green if other components continue to falter. Overall, refiners may be loss limiting in a low-oil price environment, but they are not gain-leading. An investor operating under the belief that oil prices are to remain lower for longer best not seek XLE for its refiners, a pure refiner-play would, of course, be the better bet. Moreover, while some of the fund’s Offshore Drillers and Shale Producers have particularly felt the pain of oil’s fall, many producers have had their costs reduced or managed the commodities market well enough to outperform the general oil market (in the case of Cabot Oil and Gas and EOG Resources , for example). The below chart depicts how some of the E&Ps have performed over the past six months, with USO in bold: (click to enlarge) Clearly many of the fund’s E&Ps, which account for around 32% of total fund investments, have exceeded oil’s own performance, as — for many — reduced costs, focuses on core acreage, and advances in technology have led to higher returns for this resilient group. Of course, an investor would have been far worse handpicking an E&P over XLE, as some such as Chesapeake Energy (NYSE: CHK ) — now down 63% over the past six months — have underperformed even oil itself. The same paradigm holds true for the fund’s other groups, with ExxonMobil (NYSE: XOM ) down just 15% over the past six months (versus 25% for USO); moreover, Williams Companies (NYSE: WMB ) is 6% in the green over the same time period due partially to their large natural gas exposure. Many of the services companies, such as Schlumberger (NYSE: SLB ) and Halliburton (NYSE: HAL ), have shed less than 10% of their value since January as their businesses are not nearly as oil-dependent as the E&Ps. Due to its diversification across sectors that have varying degrees of oil dependency — and across companies within these sectors — XLE’s downside has been limited enough to prevent severe losses. However, before making any investment decision we must understand how this knowledge will manifest itself in future price movements. Going Forward What happens if oil truly remains lower for longer? For USO, that means the downside is likely limited to another 5 to 10% if we see $35 a barrel oil, and if oil stagnates around $40 a barrel USO is unlikely to lose more than 4% of its value. Conversely, XLE has far more room to trend lower in a stagnating low price environment, just as it could outperform a flat, high price oil market for years. That is, as oil prices remain lower for longer the Integrated Companies and E&Ps will shed more and more value, as oil remains flat (and, by extension, USO minus fees). Although XLE may still be better than an individual E&P play in this scenario, the fund’s large dependency on these two segments will send it lower than the 4% maximum loss USO will experience with oil stagnating in the $39-42 range. One of the best shale producers, EOG Resources (representing approximately 4% of XLE’s total investments), even noted that they will not take steps to grow production until oil fully recovers. Thus at this point in time the downside of XLE may exceed the downside of oil itself, in spite of the refiners, pipeline companies, and service companies that partially make up the fund. An investor may be thinking “that’s great, but earlier the idea was that XLE could outperform in a bull market, isn’t that at least true?” Not quite, as the same varying degrees of oil dependence and uniqueness of companies within the fund limit returns the same way they limited weakness. This manifested itself between March 14, 2015 and May 28, 2015 as USO gained 20% and XLE climbed less than 4% over the same period. (click to enlarge) If oil recovers to $50 a barrel then USO would appreciate almost 25%, that same type of performance seems highly unlikely out of XLE as many of the E&Ps need oil prices above $50 over the long-term. While the rally in E&Ps and in the Integrated companies would propel XLE modestly, its diversification would likely again limit returns as depicted in the chart above. Overall, XLE still limits its downside with diversification, but a current investment in it seems akin to catching the proverbial falling knife: the longer oil stays low, the longer its compositions (with exceptions in the downstream, of course) struggle. For a very conservative investor XLE may be the right choice for long-term buy and hold exposure to oil; however, for a trader looking to profit off of an uptick in oil prices XLE is hardly the vehicle to do it with. Disclosure: I am/we are long BP. (More…) I wrote this article myself, and it expresses my own opinions. I am not receiving compensation for it (other than from Seeking Alpha). I have no business relationship with any company whose stock is mentioned in this article.

Recent Buy – Brookfield Infrastructure Partners L.P.

Summary I initiated a position in Brookfield Infrastructure Partners LP, a utilities and infrastructure company. The diverse sectors of operations and geography, coupled with regulated and contractual cash flow, makes it a very stable and attractive investment. A starting yield of 5.2% and a 5-year dividend growth rate of 12.6% make it very attractive for income-focused investors. The market jitters continue as the world turns its eyes to the US Fed – will they or wont they raise the interest rates? There are a plethora of dangerous financial situations facing the world which could possibly send the stock and bond markets into a turmoil. I continue to purchase looking for good opportunities trying to tune out the noise as a majority of these occurrences are out of control. Whenever I make a purchase, I like to share my buys to document and illustrate how I am building my income stream over the course of months/years. My main goal is simply to keep investing at regular intervals and build my passive income over the course of time. In staying true to tradition, here’s another purchase in my portfolio, this time adding a new company to my portfolio. I initiated a position in Brookfield Infrastructure Partners LP (NYSE: BIP ) (note: it also trades as BIP.UN.TO on TSX, and since I am a Canadian resident, I bought the TSX-listed shares) with 35 shares @ C$53.20. The stock yields 5.18%, adding US$74.20 (~C$96.50) to my forward annual passive income. Brookfield Infrastructure Partners, even though headquartered and based in Canada & trades on the TSX exchange, maintains its financials (and declares dividends) in USD. Company Overview Brookfield Infrastructure Partners L.P. owns and operates utility, transport, and energy businesses. The company’s Utilities segment operates a port facility that exports metallurgical and thermal coal mined in the central Bowen Basin region of Queensland, Australia; approximately 10,800 kilometers of transmission lines in North and South America; and approximately 2.4 million electricity and natural gas connections in the United Kingdom and Colombia. Its Transport segment provides transportation, storage, and handling services for freight, bulk commodities, and passengers through a network of 5,100 kilometers of track in Southwestern Western Australia; approximately 4,800 kilometers of rail in South America; approximately 3,200 kilometers of motorways in Brazil and Chile; and 30 port terminals in North America, the United Kingdom, and Europe. The company’s Energy segment offers energy transportation, distribution, and storage services through 14,800 kilometers of transmission pipelines; and 370 billion cubic feet of natural gas storage in the United States and Canada, as well as serves approximately 40,000 gas distribution customers in the United Kingdom. Brookfield Infrastructure Partners Limited serves as a general partner of Brookfield Infrastructure Partners L.P. The company was founded in 2007 and is based in Toronto, Canada. Corporate Structure The Brookfield companies have a complicated corporate structure, with each entity intricately weaved with other entities to form a set of public and private companies. The companies include Brookfield Asset Management, Brookfield Property Partners, Brookfield Renewable Energy Partners, and Brookfield Infrastructure Partners. The simple view of where Brookfield Infrastructure Partners fits in under the Brookfield Asset Management umbrella is summarized below. (click to enlarge) Recent Buy Decision I sold my Utilities ETF in June 2015 and have been looking into buying individual companies that can give me dividend growth and better equity ownership. In July 2015, I initiated a small position in Algonquin Power & Utilities Corp (AQN.TO) , and earlier this month I initiated a position in Canadian Utilities (CU.TO) . This adds a third company in the utilities sector. While the classification is under the Utilities sector, Brookfield Infrastructure is, as the name suggests, truly a complete infrastructure company. BIP holds interests in Utilities (39% of revenue), Transport (43% of revenue), Energy (10% of revenue) and Communication Infrastructure (8% of revenue). BIP has a great geographical diversification with operations in North America (8% of revenue), South America (27% of revenue), Europe (34% of revenue), and Australia (31% of revenue). The utilities segment operates: Coal terminals (handles 20% of global seaborne metallurgical coal exports from Australia) 10,800 Kms of electricity transmission lines in North & South America; Regulated distribution of electricity & natural gas connections. The transport segment operates: Railroads: ~5,100 km of track, sole freight rail network in Southwestern Western Australia ~4,800 km rail network in South America Toll Roads ~3,300 km of motorways in Brazil and Chile Combination of urban and interurban roads that benefit from traffic growth and inflation Ports 30 terminals in North America, UK and across Europe One of the UK’s largest port services providers The energy segment operates: Energy Transmission, Distribution and Storage 14,800 km of natural gas transmission pipelines, located primarily in the U.S. Over 40,000 gas distribution customers in the UK 370 billion cubic feet of natural gas storage in the U.S. and Canada District Energy Delivers heating and cooling to customers from centralized systems including heating plants capable of delivering ~2.8 million pounds per hour of steam heating capacity and 251,000 tons of cooling capacity and distributed water and sewage services The communication infrastructure operates: Telecommunications Infrastructure ~7,000 multi-purpose towers and active rooftop sites 5,000 km of fibre backbone located in France Generate stable, inflation-linked cash flows underpinned by long-term contracts with large, prominent customers The diverse sectors of operations and geography, coupled with regulated and contractual cash flow makes it a very stable and attractive investment. A wide economic moat Funds from operations (FFO) have risen at 23% CAGR and distribution has risen 12% CAGR since 2009. BIP is a Dividend Challenger having raised dividends for 7 consecutive years. The current yield is 5.18% and has 1-, 3-, and 5-year dividend growth rates of 11.6%, 13.3%, and 12.6%. BIP has a BBB+ (stable) S&P credit rating and the debt/equity 1.86, and the company holds enough cash to service the debt. Debt repayment schedule has a well laddered maturity profile. BIP just announced earlier this week that it will acquire Australian port operator Asciano for US$6.6B – which will expand the company’s footprint in Australia and help better compete in the space giving BIP better recognition and visibility. The management has made it clear that this is only the beginning this transaction is a ‘stepping stone’ for more expansions in the future. While some share dilution is occurring as part of the deal, AFFO from the deal is expected to increase 7% immediately. Brookfield Infrastructure Partners LP Diversification (click to enlarge) (click to enlarge) Risks As with any investment, there are risks involved. Being in the utilities sector, the risks in the regulated industry is slightly lower. But the non-regulated industry, where most of the growth comes from – can see possible new regulations that could put future growth prospects in doubt. Rise in interest rates can cause the stock prices to tumble in the utilities sector. With international operations, currency fluctuations can cause an unknown movement in revenue, especially since the financials are reported in US$, the international earnings can seem depressed. Further Reading Disclosure: I am long AQN.TO, BIP.UN.TO, and CU.TO. My full list of holdings is available here . Disclosure: I am/we are long BIP, AQUNF, CDUAF. (More…) I wrote this article myself, and it expresses my own opinions. I am not receiving compensation for it. I have no business relationship with any company whose stock is mentioned in this article.