Tag Archives: management

Quarterly Financial Reporting Is Needed, Productive, And Good

The following may be controversial. It also may be dull to the point that you might not care. Here’s why you should care: quarterly reporting is a useful and productive use of corporate resources, and it would be a shame to lose it because some people with a patina of intelligence think it is harmful. Who knows? Losing it might even make you poorer. The cause for this article is a piece from the Wall Street Journal, Time to End Quarterly Reports, Law Firm Says . Here’s the first two sentences: Influential law firm Wachtell, Lipton, Rosen & Katz has an idea that may be music to the ears of its big corporate clients and a nightmare for some investors and analysts: end quarterly earnings reports. Wachtell on Tuesday called on the Securities and Exchange Commission to consider allowing U.S. companies to do away with the obligatory updates, one of the most important rituals on Wall Street and in corporate America, suggesting that they distract executives from long-term goals. The basic case is that quarterly earnings lead companies to behave in a short-term manner, and underinvest for longer-term growth, thus hurting the US economy. I disagree. There are at least four things that are false in the arguments made in the article, and in books like Saving Capitalism from Short-Termism : Quarterly earnings don’t produce value in and of themselves Quarterly earnings cause most corporations to ignore the long-term. Ending quarterly earnings will end activism, buybacks, and dividends. Buybacks and dividends are bad uses of capital, and more capital investment, especially for long-dated projects, is necessarily a good thing. Why Quarterly Earnings are Valuable I’ve written a number of articles about quarterly earnings and estimates of those earnings: Earnings Estimates as a Control Mechanism, Flawed as they are , and Earnings Estimates as a Control Mechanism, Flawed as they are, Redux . The basic idea is this: quarterly earnings results give investors an idea as to whether the companies remain on their long-term growth path or not. As I wrote: Most of the value of a Corporation on a going concern basis stems from the future earnings of the company. Investors want to have an estimate of forward earnings so that they can gauge whether the company is growing at an appropriate rate. Now, it wouldn’t matter if the system were set up by third-party sell side analysts, by buyside analysts, by companies themselves, or by a combination thereof. The thing is investors are forward-looking, and they want a forward-looking estimate to allow them to estimate whether the companies are doing well with their current earnings or not. Don’t think of the quarterly earnings in isolation. A good or bad quarterly earnings number conveys information not about the current period only, but about all future periods. A bad earnings number lowers the estimates of all future earnings, telling market players that the long-term efforts of the company are not going to be so great. Vice-versa for a good number. Now, in some cases, that might not be true, and the management team will say, “But we still expect our future earnings to reach the levels that we expected before this quarter.” That still leaves the problem of getting to the high future earnings, which if missed will lead the market to reprice the stock down. They might also use a non-GAAP measure of earnings to explain that earnings are not as bad as they might seem. In the short-run the market may accept that, but if you do that often enough, eventually the markets factor in the many “one-time” adjustments, and lower the earnings multiple on the stock to reflect the reduced quality of earnings. In addition, having shorter-term targets causes corporations to not get lazy in managing expenses and capital. When the measurement periods get too long, discipline can be lost. Quarterly Earnings Don’t Cause Most Firms to Neglect the Long-Term Firms aren’t interested in only the current period’s earnings, but about the entire future path of earnings. Even if the current period’s earnings meet the estimates, the job is not done. If there aren’t plans to grow earnings for the next 3-5 years, eventually earnings won’t meet the expectations of investors, and the price of the stock will fall. The short-term is just the beginning of the long-term. It is not either/or but both/and. A company has to try to explain to investors how it is growing the value of the firm – if present targets aren’t being met, why should there be any confidence that the future will be good? Think of corporate earnings like a long-term project which has a variety of things that have to be done en route to a significant goal. The quarterly earnings measure whether the progress toward completing the goal is adequate or not. Now, the measure is not perfect, but who can think of a better one? Ending Quarterly Earnings Would Not End Activism, Buybacks, and Dividends I can think of an area in business where earnings estimates don’t play a role – private equity. Are the owners long-term oriented? Yes. Are they short-term oriented? Yes. Is capital managed tightly? Very tightly. All excess capital is dividended back – it as if activists run the firms permanently. If there were no quarterly earnings in the public equity markets, firms would still be under pressure to return excess capital to shareholders. Activists would still analyze companies to see if they are badly managed, and in need of change. If anything, when companies would release their earnings less frequently, the adjustments to the market price of the stock would be more severe. Companies that disappoint would find the activists arriving regardless of the periodicity of the release of earnings. On the Use of Excess Capital Investing, particularly for the long-term, is not risk-free. In an environment where there is rapid technological change, like there is today, it is difficult to tell what investments will not be made obsolete. In such an environment, it can make a lot of sense to focus on shorter-term investments that are more certain as to the success of the project. It is also a reason why dividends and buybacks are done, as capital returned to shareholders is associated with higher stock prices, because the capital is used more efficiently. Companies that shrink their balance sheets tend to outperform those that grow them. As an example, large acquisitions tend not to benefit shareholders, while small acquisitions that lead to greater organic growth do tend to benefit investors. The same is true of large versus small investments for organic growth away from M&A. Most management teams can adequately estimate and plan for the growth that stems from incremental action. Large revolutionary investments are another thing. There is usually no way to estimate how those will work out, and whether the prospects are reasonable or not. In one sense, it’s best to leave those kinds of investment projects to highly focused firms that do only that. That’s how biotech firms work, and it is why so many of them fail. The few winners are astounding. Or, think about how progressive Japanese firms were viewed to be in the 1980s, as they pursued long-term projects that had very low returns on equity. All of that failed, to a first approximation, while the derided American model of shareholder capitalism prospered, as capital was used efficiently on projects with high risk-adjusted returns, and not wasted on speculative projects with uncertain returns. The same will prove true of China over the next 20 years as they choke on all of their bad investments that yield low returns, if indeed the returns are positive. Remember, bad investments are just expenses in fancy garb – it just takes the accounting longer to recognize the losses. Think of Enron if you need an example, which brings up one more point: good investing focuses on accounting quality. Accrual items on the asset side of the balance sheets of corporations get higher valuations the shorter the accrual is, and the more likely it is to produce cash. Most long term projects tend to be speculative, and as such, drag down the valuation of the stock, because in most cases, it lowers the long-term earnings of the company. Conclusion If quarterly earnings are abolished, intelligent corporations won’t change much. Investment won’t go up much, and the time horizon of most management teams will not rise much. If you need any proof of that, look at how private equity and large mutual insurers manage their firms – they still analyze quarterly results, and are conservative in how they deploy capital. The only great change of eliminating quarterly earnings will be a loss of quality information for equity investors. Bond investors and banks will still require more frequent financial updates, and equity investors may try to find ways to get that data, perhaps through the rating agencies. Disclosure: None

The One Factor To Explain Them All

Yesterday’s post on hedge funds got me thinking again about how vague “risk factors” are. CAPM uses a one factor model showing that risk explained why certain assets performed better than others.¹ Basically, take more risk and you’ll generate a better return. That didn’t exactly explain things fully though. In fact, higher risk often correlates with worse returns.² Over the course of the last 25 years the idea of “factor investing” has really boomed. And investment companies loved this because they could market specific stylized facts that explained why the markets do certain things and why you should pay them high fees so they can take advantage of those things for you. Heck, even hardcore passive investors, who are notorious fee avoiders, will trip over themselves buying higher fee funds trying to guess the best factors to own at certain times. As a result, we got the small cap factor and the value factor and the momentum factor and all sorts of other factors. I think we’re up to 1,000+ factors now. There are so many I could just start making them up. And I will. Right now. For instance, companies whose founders are dog owners might outperform companies whose founders are cat owners. This is a perfectly logical assumption because dogs are better than cats so company founders who own dogs must be smarter than company founders who own cats. So, we now have the dog vs cat factor. If I tweak some data and find it’s statistically meaningful over long periods of time then I might even start a high fee fund to sell you. No cat owners allowed, obviously. Okay, okay. I am being stupid. I know. But you see my point, right? A lot of these “factors” could be nothing more than slick data mining by someone who found a pattern that doesn’t really exist. We want to understand and be able to predict things so badly that we often find stylized facts where they don’t even exist. But maybe we just can’t know. That doesn’t mean it’s not worth trying to find out or to try guessing about future outcomes. But we should start from one general factor: The We-Know-A-Lot-Less-Than-We-Think-We-Know Factor This doesn’t require some law of the financial markets that says anything has to outperform anything else over the long-term. Yes, we know that stocks will generally beat bonds because they’re a contract that gives the equity owner greater claim to profits than the bonds, but that doesn’t mean stocks have to outperform bonds or even that they’re more risky (whatever “risk” means in the context of this discussion to begin with, but that’s a whole other matter). The point is, you don’t necessarily earn a “risk premia” in stocks. You earn a contractual premia assuming the firm earns enough profit to pay it out (good luck predicting which firms will generate the highest profits in the future) and a bunch of apes with keyboards try to guess what the future value of those profits will be. Importantly, no one needs the efficient market hypothesis to understand why markets are really hard to beat. You just need the basic arithmetic of global asset allocation to understand that . This whole monetary system is something humans created from thin air. And we have, at best, an imprecise understanding of what financial assets are really worth at certain times and so the best we can do is try to understand the world for what it is, slap together some sound assumptions about the future, reduce our frictions, manage the known risks as best as possible and hope it doesn’t all fall apart at some point. Is it really much more complex than that? ¹ – Here’s the Three Factor Model. Here’s the Five Factor Model. Here’s a 100+ Factor model paper. Here’s a real model. 2 – See this paper titled ” High idiosyncratic volatility and low returns: International and further U.S. evidence “.

2 ETFs To Hold For The Next 25 Years

The Dow Jones Industrial Average ETF may be a better way to invest in the American economy than the S&P 500. The Dow Jones Industrial Average typically outperforms the S&P 500 over longer periods of time, especially when dividends are factored in. The Russian stock market is one that investors typically fear, but there is reason to believe that this may be one of the best assets to own going forward. Russia currently has one of the cheapest stock markets in the world and trades at the low-end of its historical valuation range. The Russian market is projected to outperform all major markets in the world going forward, once commodity prices recover. For many investors, investing in exchange-traded funds (also known as ETFs) makes much more sense than purchasing individual stocks. This is because the ETF includes many different stocks that allow one to effectively diversify away company-specific risks while still allowing that investor to profit off of a given theme. In this article, we will examine two ETFs that could easily deserve a position in any investor’s portfolio and that will likely prove to be very profitable holdings over the next 25 years. SPDR Dow Jones Industrial Average ETF (NYSEARCA: DIA ) The Dow Jones Industrial Average has been one of the most widely followed indicators of overall stock market activity for more than a century. The index is composed of thirty stocks that the publishers of the index, currently S&P Dow Jones Indices, believe best represent the composition of the United States economy. Unlike most of the other major stock market indices, the Dow Jones Industrial Average is a price-weighted index. This means that companies with higher stock prices such as Apple (NASDAQ: AAPL ), Goldman Sachs (NYSE: GS ), and International Business Machines (NYSE: IBM ) make up a larger portion of the index than companies with lower stock prices such as Coca-Cola (NYSE: KO ) or General Electric (NYSE: GE ). Unfortunately, this also results in these companies’ stock performance having an outsized impact on the performance of the index that may be completely disconnected from their respective market caps. For example, the stock price performance of Goldman Sachs has a 75% greater influence over the index’s performance as Apple’s stock price performance, despite Apple having a market cap more than six times greater. Given these problems with price-weighted indices, one may wonder why I am suggesting an investment in the Dow Jones Industrial Average instead of a broader, market capitalization-weighted index such as the S&P 500. Well, the reason is that the Dow Jones Industrial Average has historically outperformed the S&P 500. This is immediately apparent when we compare the performance of the SPDR Dow Jones Industrial Average ETF to that of the largest ETF tracking the broader Standard & Poors 500 Index, the SPDR S&P 500 ETF (NYSEARCA: SPY ). Here is how the two ETFs have performed over the past ten years: SPY data by YCharts As this chart shows, the S&P 500 ETF outperformed the Dow Jones Industrial Average over the past ten years (although for much of that time, the Dow Jones Industrial Average was outperforming the S&P 500). But, this comparison excludes one very critical factor. The Dow Jones Industrial Average is by and large composed of mature, slow-growing companies that pay out a portion of their earnings to investors in the form of dividends. While the S&P 500 Index does include companies like this, it also includes a number of younger, high-growth companies as well as other firms that for whatever reason choose not to pay dividends. As a result, the Dow Jones Industrial Average typically boasts a higher dividend yield than the S&P 500. This needs to be factored in when determining relative performance. Here is the same chart, this time showing the total return produced by each of the two ETFs over the trailing ten-year period: SPY Total Return Price data by YCharts As this chart shows, the Dow Jones Industrial Average has outperformed the S&P 500 over the past ten years when dividends are factored in (although yesterday’s decline in the Dow brought the two into parity). This outperformance becomes even more pronounced over longer time periods. Here is the same chart showing the total return of both ETFs since the beginning of 1998 (when the Dow Jones Industrial Average ETF was first made available for purchase). SPY Total Return Price data by YCharts As this chart shows, the Dow Jones Industrial Average has significantly outperformed the S&P 500 over longer time periods. It is for this reason that this ETF, and not the one tracking the S&P 500, is my choice for investors interested in making a broad-based bet on the future of the American economy. The SPDR Dow Jones Industrial Average ETF does a respectable job of tracking its underlying index due to the fact that the ETF itself is composed of the same stocks that comprise the index and in relatively similar weightings. Here are all of the ETF’s holdings, sorted by weight: (click to enlarge) Source: State Street Global Advisors As the chart clearly shows, the ETF simply consists of an identical number of shares of each of the companies in the Dow Jones Industrial Average with the relative weightings being determined by the stock price of each company. This is exactly the same way that the index itself is constructed. With that said however, the weighting of each company owned by the ETF is slightly lower than in the index itself due to the fact that the ETF holds a cash position and the index itself does not contain cash. However, the SPDR Dow Jones Industrial Average ETF is still an excellent way for investors to track the index itself. Market Vectors Russia ETF (NYSEARCA: RSX ) At first glance, this may seem to be an unlikely choice for a long-term ETF holding. After all, Russia is a nation that is widely considered to have a high degree of corruption in its business environment, has been economically sanctioned by several Western nations due to recent events in the Ukraine, and is not generally considered to be an investor-friendly place to invest. However, there is much to like here. One of the ratios that can be used to measure the relative stock market valuations present in a nation is the total market cap to GNP ratio. Investing legend Warren Buffett once described this ratio is “probably the best single measure of where valuations stand at any given moment. Using this measure, the Russian stock market is one of the most undervalued in the world. Unfortunately, it can be difficult to obtain accurate GNP information on many countries, but we can calculate the ratio using GDP instead to illustrate this fact. At the time of writing, Russia had a GDP of $2.12 trillion compared to the United States’ $17.7 trillion. Meanwhile, the Russian stock market had a total market capitalization of $380 billion compared to the United States’ $21.88 trillion. Thus, Russia has a total market cap to GDP of 17.9% compared to 123.6% for the United States (lower values indicate a cheaper market). Here is how this compares to other major markets around the world: Source: GuruFocus As this chart shows, the Russian market is only rivaled by Italy in terms of relative valuation. This is very close to the lowest valuation that the Russian market has traded at since it became accessible to investors. Meanwhile, many other markets around the world are near the midpoints or upper ends of their historical valuations: (click to enlarge) Source: GuruFocus This valuation would seem to imply that the Russian market has some of the greatest potential for outperformance going forward. Investment research site GuruFocus performed a complete analysis of the forward return potential present in each country given the historical GDP growth of each of these countries, the dividend payments from each country’s corresponding ETF, and an assumption that each country’s market will revert to its mean valuation. Here are their projections on the returns of each of these markets going forward: Source: GuruFocus As this chart shows, analysts expect the Russian stock market to outperform all other major national markets going forward. However, there are some caveats here. First and foremost, the Russian economy is highly dependent on commodity prices, both energy and metals. As such, the Market Vectors Russia ETF contains significant exposure to energy and commodities companies. As many of you reading this are no doubt aware, commodity and energy prices have fallen significantly over the past year and many analysts expect that prices will be suppressed for quite some time. This has significantly weakened the Russian economy as well as pressured the cash flows and profits at the companies that make up the majority of the ETF’s assets. It is unlikely that either the nation’s economy or corporate profits will recover until commodity prices do and thus it is likely that the ETF will underperform until that occurs. However, I find it unlikely that commodity prices will be depressed over the 25-year period over which this article refers and thus the Market Vectors Russia ETF looks like an appealing investment. Disclosure: I/we have no positions in any stocks mentioned, but may initiate a long position in RSX over the next 72 hours. (More…) I wrote this article myself, and it expresses my own opinions. I am not receiving compensation for it (other than from Seeking Alpha). I have no business relationship with any company whose stock is mentioned in this article. Additional disclosure: I have long positions in S&P 500 tracking index funds, but not in SPY specifically.