Tag Archives: investing ideas

How To End Index Gaming

There was an article at Bloomberg on gaming additions to and deletions from indexes , and at least two comments on it ( one , two ). You can read them at your convenience; in this short post I would like to point out two ways to stop the gaming. Define your index to include all securities in the class (say, all U.S.-based stocks with over $10 million in market cap), or Control your index so that additions and deletions are done at your leisure, and not in any predictable way. The gaming problem occurs because index funds find that they have to buy or sell stocks when indexes change, and more flexible investors act more quickly, causing the index funds to transact at less favorable prices. You never want to be in the position of being forced to make a trade. The first solution means using an index like the Wilshire 5000 , which in principle covers almost all stocks that you would care about. Index additions would happen at things like IPOs and spinoffs, and deletions at things like takeovers — both of which are natural liquidity events. Solution one would be relatively easy to manage, but not everyone wants to own a broad market fund. The second solution remedies the situation more generally, at a cost that index fund buyers would not exactly know what the index was in the short-run. Solution two destroys comparability, but the funds would change the target percentages when they felt it was advantageous to do so whether it was: Make the change immediately, like the flexible investors do, or Phase it in over time. And to do this, you might ask for reporting waivers from the SEC for up to x% of the total fund, whatever is currently in transition. The main idea is this: you aren’t forced to trade on anyone else’s schedule. The only thing leading you would be what is best for your investors, because if you don’t do well for them, they will leave you. Now, that implies that if you were to say that your intent is to mimic the S&P 500 index, but with some flexibility, that would invite easy comparisons, such that you would be less free to deviate too far. But if you said your intent was more akin to the Russell 1000 or 3000, there would be more room to maneuver. That said, choosing an index is a marketing decision, and more people want the S&P 500 than the Wilshire 5000, much less the US Largecap Index. So, maybe with solution two the gaming problem isn’t so easy to escape, or better, you can choose which problem you want. Perhaps the one bit of practical advice here then is to investors — choose a broad market index like the Wilshire 5000. At least your index fund won’t get so easily gamed, and given the small cap effect over time, you’ll probably do better than the S&P 500, even excluding the effects of gaming. There, a simple bit of advice. Till next time. Disclosure: None

Sometimes One Mutual Fund Is More Than Enough

When it comes to investing, simple is sometimes beautiful. If you don’t actually like investing, doing as little as possible is definitely beautiful. And that can make the often misunderstood balanced fund beautiful. Investing isn’t easy. In fact, for some people it’s a daunting, even painful, task that quickly overwhelms. And, in the end, that can lead people to do the worst possible thing-nothing. For such people, and for those just starting their investing journey, the best option may be the misunderstood balanced fund. A beautiful breed of creatures that even experienced investors can learn to love if only you take the time to get to know them. What is a balanced fund? At the core, a balanced fund is meant to be a complete portfolio in one investment. In other words, it is quite possible that you could buy a single balanced fund and never make another investment decision again. At that point, all you ever need worry about is saving money. That is beautiful. But there are really three different kinds of funds that can be found in this broad category. There are balanced funds, asset allocation funds, and flexible funds. The differences can be pretty minor, but they are worth knowing. A balanced fund generally has a target allocation for stocks and bonds. However, it can usually make minor adjustments around those bands. For example, a fund might say that it will have between 40% and 80% of assets in equities at all time, with the remainder in bonds. In function the goal might be to have a 60%/40% split between stocks and bonds. However, the bands give the management team the ability to become more or less aggressive based on prevailing market conditions. An asset allocation fund, meanwhile, tends to be far more rigid in its approach. These funds are usually based off of modern portfolio theory and so called efficient frontiers. Essentially management figures out an allocation between different asset classes based on achieving the highest possible return for a desired amount of risk. Of course that’s based on past performance, so it doesn’t always work as planned. The key difference here is that this approach usually goes well beyond the simple stock/bond portfolio, taking into account slivers of the market such as large-cap growth, large-cap value, small-cap growth, small-cap value, precious metals, emerging markets, developed foreign markets, bonds, foreign bonds, emerging market bonds, high-yield bonds, real estate, etc. You can slice and dice a lot in the financial world. But in the end, the fund will have a fairly rigid percentage guideline for each asset class they include and stick close to it. Flexible funds can be similar to both asset allocation and balanced funds except that the managers can really do whatever they want allocation wise. In other words, they can go 100% stock or 100% bond or 100% cash or any combination they want. There are a lot fewer funds that follow this approach nowadays since modern portfolio theory and efficient frontiers have come into prominence. That said, there are some funds that act like the other two that might better be placed here. For example, the Vanguard Managed Payout Fund (MUTF: VPGDX ) decided to completely remove real estate funds from its portfolio in late 2013. A true asset allocation fund wouldn’t have done that. What’s the best option? Honestly, at some level the differences are minor enough to be meaningless. Yes, it would be a good idea to know what your fund does. But for an investor who hates investing, it’s far more important that you save money and invest than that you pick the perfect balanced fund variant. In the end, your efforts at saving money will be more important to your end results than the fund you pick. So don’t get bogged down in selecting a fund. That said, the simplest approach is probably a fund like the Vanguard Balanced Index Fund (MUTF: VBINX ). It has a 60%/40% split between the entire U.S. stock market (via an index fund that tracks the entire U.S. stock market) and the entire U.S. bond market (via an index fund that tracks the entire U.S. bond market). You can’t get more basic than that. And that split is rigidly maintained, so this is a true balanced fund and would work well for just about anyone. But if you like a little more zest, you might prefer something like Dodge & Cox Balanced Fund (MUTF: DODBX ). Dodge & Cox is a relatively small, though well respected, value focused shop. The fund is a balanced fund, too, but it has an allocation band for stocks of between 25% and 75%. The rest goes into bonds and cash. This fund would provide you the comfort of knowing that it can shift with the market and, for those of you who like to buy on the cheap, it uses a value approach to investing. This, too, would be a great option for most investors-except, perhaps, for those who prefer growth stocks. On the asset allocation front a simple example is Fidelity Four-In-One Index Fund (MUTF: FFNOX ). Although many funds get into far more detail, this one gives a reasonable view of the difference between a balanced fund, like Vanguard Balanced Index which owns all U.S. stocks and all U.S. bonds, and asset allocation, which engages a broader list of asset classes. In Fidelity Four-in-One’s case, those asset classes are large-cap U.S. stocks (48% of assets), small-cap U.S. stocks (12%), foreign stocks (25%), and U.S. bonds (15%). The fund tries to adhere to these allocations fairly closely and each is represented with an index fund. Flexible funds are often harder to find. However, they can hide in plain sight, too. My earlier example of Vanguard Managed Distribution Fund shows this. The fund has a model allocation to follow, but it doesn’t have to do so rigidly and can change. The shift out of real estate investment trusts is a good example. And several of the investment approaches it uses can’t be easily categorized into an asset class. For example, it invests in a market neutral strategy and a “minimum volatility” fund. What those two funds actually do is beyond the discussion here, but what’s important is that they don’t fit in a box and allow the fund to shift around a lot more than either a true balanced or asset allocation fund. That’s neither good nor bad, but it is something to understand. OK, now what? For people who really hate investing, but know they have to do it, my recommendation is usually Vanguard Index Balanced Fund. It’s fine, not great, not bad-just fine. And that’s enough for most people. For those who want to get into investing a little more, I’d say look at the other funds I mentioned and expand from there. But try to stick with a major fund company and try to keep expenses low. Your deciding factor should be finding a fund that feels like it fits with your personality. The goal is to pick something that you’ll be able to stick to for a long, long time. For new investors, this is a great way to start putting money to work while you start to learn about investing. For example, you might put the bulk of your money in a balanced, asset allocation, or flexible fund and keep say 20% on the side for you to start buying individual stocks. That way the bulk of your money is in what you might consider a foundation fund while you experiment with the rest of the house. As you get more experienced you can start shifting that balance more toward you managing your own money. Or not. For a more experienced investor, you might place a chunk of change into a balanced fund as the core of your portfolio and then use the rest to focus in on asset classes you know well. For example, buying Dodge & Cox Balanced Fund as a core holding (say 60% of your portfolio), and then buying large cap growth stocks. This would allow you to focus on an area in which you are most comfortable without undue overlap with your core. I normally call this a core and explore type approach. You could also substitute in real estate investment trusts, closed-end funds, and limited partners for growth, if you wanted. The general idea being the same in that you rely on the fund for broader diversification while you do the things that you do best (or the things you enjoy). The biggest impact you’ll have There are a wide variety of ways to use balanced, asset allocation, and flexible funds. However, what they really do is provide simplification. And that’s more important than you may think. Investing can be very, very complicated if you let it. This can distract from what will be your most important contribution to your future financial success-the amount of money you save. And, in the end, saving is really the hard part of this because we humans are notoriously bad at delaying gratification. So, if you are new to investing or hate the idea of investing, find a decent one-and-you’re-done fund and focus on saving money. As you get more comfortable you can change how you do things. But start by, well, starting simple. And if you are more experienced, don’t overlook the value of a sound, and diversified, foundation around which you can build a core and explore portfolio. In the end, sometimes, all you really need is one single solitary fund. Disclosure: I/we have no positions in any stocks mentioned, and no plans to initiate any positions within the next 72 hours. (More…) I wrote this article myself, and it expresses my own opinions. I am not receiving compensation for it (other than from Seeking Alpha). I have no business relationship with any company whose stock is mentioned in this article.

Decoding The Myths Of Managed Futures 2015

This paper examines seven very popular myths and misconceptions held by both retail and institutional investors regarding managed futures. These myths have persisted for several years. Knowing if the myths are true or false is critical for an investor’s understanding and appreciation of managed futures. From presenting at more panel events, instructing workshops on alternative investments and teaching my managed futures/ global macro course at DePaul University in the last several years, I found it was time to update the original paper written in 2011 with additional myths added to the list. The demand for alternative investments continues to grow as investors are seeking more ways to decrease their correlation risk and tail risk of their portfolio. After the dot com bubble and the recession in the early 2000s more investors realized the need for wider diversification beyond stocks and bonds. More recently since the financial crisis the demand to reduce correlation risk and tail risk continues to grow. Managed futures (AKA Commodity Trading Advisors), a subset of alternative investments and sometimes categorized under global macro hedge funds continues to grow in popularity. However, many old myths still persist about the investment product, the managers and the due diligence of the managers. As of the end of 2014, assets under management have grown by 736% since 2000 and by 53% since 2008, according to BarclayHedge . 2011, 2012 and 2013 were challenging years for the returns of managed futures and the product found itself out of favor. But no one has a crystal ball to know when markets change and the 2nd half 2014 gave CTAs a positive year while equities were experiencing greater volatility in the latter part of 2014. As of March 2015, CTAs continue to profit. A fair amount of the recent growth in managed futures has been driven by the increasing interest for both commodity related investments as well greater non-correlation of portfolio allocations. Below are some of the myths and misconceptions of managed futures: Mysterious “black box” trading systems Managed futures are a hedge or insurance against equities Only commodities are traded Managed futures are risky and volatile All Commodity Trading Advisors are the same CTA indices contain survivorship bias All CTAs are large firms The discussions below are tendencies of the managed futures industry. Results may vary with individual managers. 1: Mysterious “Black Box” Trading Systems Over the years I’ve often heard investors or allocators state “we don’t understand or can’t get comfortable with the systematic trading models” and “they are black boxes, so we stay away from them.” Systematic trading models are quantitative computerized trading models. In earlier years, many CTAs were cautious of fully explaining their models due to replication risk. However, in more recent years there is a trend towards CTAs explaining their models. But the transparency by the CTA is not enough. It also involves the investors and allocators to do their research in understanding the concepts and terminology of the asset as they do their due diligence, just as they would for any other investment. 2: Hedge or Insurance against Equities Many believe that managed futures are a hedge or insurance against equities. This is not true. CTAs tend to be non-correlated to equities. This means their returns are independent of equity returns. The independent returns are primarily due to CTAs trading various commodity and financial markets and they can be long, short, neutral or spreading in those markets. In the last 20 years managed futures have shown moments of having a positive correlation to equities when equities rally and in other moments a negative correlation to equities when equities decline. Over time the correlation cycles between positive and negative. But they tend to show positive performance when there are “shocks” to the various markets or the economy such as in the early 2000’s and in 2008. A CTA does not care about the direction of the market they trade, but only that there is enough of a move to create a profit. 3: Only Commodities Are Traded Because the managers who trade futures are called Commodity Trading Advisors, there is a myth that only commodities are traded. Some CTAs do trade only commodities or only trade one market or sector such as corn or the grain sector. But many trade only financial futures such as stock index futures, bond futures or currency futures or forwards. Diversified CTAs may trade both financial and commodity futures. 4: Managed Futures Are Volatile Some CTAs can be volatile, just as any other investment has the potential to be volatile or risky. However, if you look at volatility in terms of the Sharpe ratio and or standard deviation, then you are also assuming the return distributions are a normal (bell-curve) distribution. CTAs may have low Sharpe ratios, high standard deviations, thus one would believe they are very risky and volatile. However, the low Sharpe ratio and high standard deviation are often derived from positive skewness of the return distribution due to risk management policies. One must understand the source of volatility returns. Volatility is similar to cholesterol; there is good volatility and bad volatility. Good volatility is derived from positive returns and the bad volatility derived from negative returns. The Sortino ratio and S-ratio are probably more informative in understanding risk-adjusted returns for a non-normal distribution than the Sharpe ratio or standard deviation. It may sound counter-intuitive, but adding an investment with a high standard deviation may actually reduce the portfolio’s volatility due to the positive skewness. In doing so to analyze the investment not as a standalone investment, but how does it compliment the portfolio. 5: Managed Futures Funds Are All the Same Some investors will ask “why do I need to invest in more than one CTA? Aren’t all CTAs the same?” The answer to that is NO! This topic can be detailed in a separate discussion, but they are not all the same for some basic reasons: 1) Some CTAs may trade different markets or varying number of markets. 2) Their time horizons or average trade duration may vary. 3) How they get into or out of positions may vary. 4) How they manage risk, one of the most important components of the trading system may vary among the CTAs. As I tell my students at DePaul University, the risk management of the positions may make or break a manager. 6: CTA Indices Contain Survivorship Bias Some investors will refrain from investing in managed futures because the indices include survivorship bias. They are correct, the indices usually do contain survivorship bias. This bias relates to managers being taken out of the index because they no longer meet a certain requirement to be in the index or they are no longer in business. Managers may also be taken out of an index because they stop reporting to the databases. One common reason for a manager to stop reporting their returns is if they reach a certain asset size and are no longer seeking to raise funds. What is often missed is that most investment indices do include survivorship bias. For example, General Electric was one of the original components in the Dow Jones index. They are now the only remaining original constituent. Over the decades DJ and S&P have added and removed companies from their respective indices. If survivorship bias is a reason for an investor to avoid investing in managed futures then why isn’t the same logic applied to equities? 7: All CTAs are Large Firms Often new investors in the managed futures space may know of a few large CTAs and think all CTAs are large firms with hundreds of millions if not billions of dollars under management, millions spent on technology, a large research staff and a deep infrastructure. However, it is more common for a CTA to be a small business. They will often have from 2 to 10 employees. Using easily accessible technology and many back office functions outsourced to third party firms. This should not take away from investing in the smaller “emerging” managers, but to understand and appreciate the makeup of the industry. In summary, we have discussed some of the myths or misconceptions that have persisted over the years regarding managed futures. As the industry has become more transparent of their research and demand for non-correlated assets have increased, there is a need for investors to do their research, understand the product, as they would with any other asset class they explore to invest in and understand the profile of the managers they investigate. Disclosure: I/we have no positions in any stocks mentioned, and no plans to initiate any positions within the next 72 hours. (More…) I wrote this article myself, and it expresses my own opinions. I am not receiving compensation for it. I have no business relationship with any company whose stock is mentioned in this article.