Tag Archives: investing ideas

Commodity Returns: So Much For The ‘Reversion To The Mean’ Trade

In 2014, I managed to avoid the energy sector for clients, almost entirely, owning no energy (crude oil or natural gas) companies and selling Halliburton (NYSE: HAL ) near $70 during the summer of 2014. Unfortunately, like a golfer that eagles one hole, and then takes a 9 on a par 3, the basic materials holdings for clients coming into and out of the summer of 2014 were: a) Alcoa (NYSE: AA ) (aluminum) b) US Steel (NYSE: X ) (steel) c) Freeport Copper (Copper and Energy) d) Peabody Energy (NYSE: BTU ) (and for the granddaddy of all disasters, coal) Here is what piqued my interest in the group and kept me long the names for so long. Although I haven’t owned gold for clients since late 2011, commodities and gold have been at the bottom of the “asset class return” table for three years running, i.e. 2012 through 2014, and managed to move up one slot through the first 6 months of 2015. Today, gold is getting killed again. When I think of the “reversion to the mean” trade today, the old saying “timing is everything” still matters too. 1) The dollar is stronger once again, the last few weeks, breaking the downtrend line in place since mid-March ’15, which is a negative for gold and commodities. 2) China is a mess both producing a LOT of its commodities and given the supposed slower growth, likely consuming less too. 3) I’ve always felt that the commodity complex and the emerging markets, given their commodity-based economies, seemed to be closely correlated, and the EEM (emerging markets ETF) looks ready to roll over again and trade down to $35. We were long for clients some of the base metals companies waiting for a “return-to-global-growth” theme, and the trade didn’t work. Looking at the past 35 years, from 1980 through 2015, the only time these stocks worked for a decent period of time was the early 2000s through 2007, when China was growing 15% per year. US Steel traded up to $180 by mid-2008 and promptly came right back down. Peabody Energy traded up to $82 and is now $1.50 per share. Freeport Copper traded as high as $62 in mid-2008. Basic materials, of which chemicals is the largest weighting at 70%-75% of the sector, is just 3% of the S&P 500 by market cap and earnings weight, so these base metals companies are a pretty small component of the overall index. Next time, I do think we will eliminate the operating risk of commodity companies, and stick with pure-play commodity ETFs, like we did with GLD. In the early 2000s, when gold bottomed right when the tech and growth stock bubble peaked, the only way investors could get exposure to gold was to buy Newmont Mining (NYSE: NEM ) or other gold miners. The GLD, when the ETF was launched in late 2005, was a much better way (in my opinion) to play gold than the operating companies. If readers have a favorite commodity ETF that you think is worth mentioning, send a note and I’ll give it a look please. Given the asset class returns table, “relative” investors can’t ignore the commodity complex.

Benjamin Graham’s Defensive Versus Enterprising Investor Performance Over The Dismal Decade Of 2000-2009

In a previous blog (see Benjamin Graham’s Value Investing versus the Robo-advisor ), I illustrated included a chart outlining the performance of the United States stock market over the course of every decade covering during the past 100 years. Stock performance over the past decade (2000-2009) was not only a net loser, including the paltry dividend income received, but it even underperformed the 1930’s depression era. If the typical investor had known this information at the start of the year 2000, I’m confident he or she would have remained on the sidelines in cash. Let’s assume that Mr. Market held a gun to your head, forcing you to buy and hold stocks over the coming decade. Further assume that you knew the performance in stocks would be terrible. Given few good options against the wrong end of Mr. Market’s gun, one might find some solace by turning to the value investing teachings of Benjamin Graham. How did value stocks perform over the dismal decade from 2000-2009? In Graham’s first edition of The Intelligent Investor , he outlined several approaches to stock selection. One approach was designed for the defensive investor, involving the selection of only stocks that met a conservative set of buying criteria with safety of principal as the primary concern. Another stock selection approach was designed for the more enterprising investor, one willing to assume more risk with the hope of gaining a larger profit. The defensive investor approach to stock selection recommends the following buying criteria: Benjamin Graham’s Stock Selection Rules for the Defensive Investor 1) Diversify your portfolio across at least 10 different securitie s, with a maximum of about 30. Over the decade from 2000-2009, we’ll review the range of portfolio returns for both a “10” and a “30” stock portfolio that met all of Graham’s criteria for the defensive investor. 2) Each company should be large, prominen t, and conservatively financed. We’ll put a company on the defensive investor list only if it had a market cap of at least $350 million. That’s about the size of a larger company in 1949 on an inflation-adjusted basis when Graham published The Intelligent Investor. Graham defined a company as “prominent” if it ranked in the upper-quarter to upper-third in size within a particular industry. We’ll give as many companies the benefit of the doubt as being “prominent” provided they were in the upper-third in size within a particular industry. A “conservatively financed” company according to Graham had total debt under half of its total market capitalization. We’ll screen out all stocks that are leveraged beyond this defensive-investor threshold. 3) Each company should have a long record of continuous dividend payments. The first edition of The Intelligent Investor was published in 1949. Graham was reluctant to exclude companies on the defensive list that discontinued their dividend payments during the 1931-1933 period. After all, that time period occurred shortly after the Dow Jones Industrial Average declined 85% in value, including the dividend income received. Graham must have felt that keeping stocks off of a defensive list simply because the dividend payments were temporarily discontinued during that awful time period was a bit restrictive. As a compromise, Graham allowed all companies to be on the defensive stock list provided that a continuous dividend payment took place on every stock back to the year 1936. That’s a historical 13-year dividend-paying history from the date of Graham’s book publication. We’ll follow a similar approach and require all stocks on our defensive list to have paid an uninterrupted dividend over the previous 13-year period. 4) The price paid for a stock should be reasonable in relation to its average earnings. Graham recommended purchasing only stocks that had a price-to-average-earnings ratio below 20. Average earnings was calculated using the previous five years of data from the income statement of each public company. We’ll follow the same approach and keep off of the defensive list any expensive stocks with a price-to-average-earnings ratio greater than 20. The charts below shows the performance of the best-and worst-performing stocks meeting Graham’s defensive stock criteria covering the worst-performing decade over the past century. The number of stocks at the start of the year 2000 that met all of Graham’s defensive selection criteria totaled 111. Ten Best – and Worst – Performing Defensive Stocks, Including Dividend Income… (click to enlarge) Thirty Best – and Worst – Performing Defensive Stocks, Including Dividend Income… (click to enlarge) As already mentioned, Graham recommended holding between 10 and 30 stocks that met the rigorous defensive stock criteria. As shown in the two charts above, quite a bit of variation in performance existed depending on what stocks were chosen from the defensive list. Diversifying across 30 defensive stocks instead of only 10 improved your worst-case portfolio return over the dismal decade, but it also reduced your potential best-case return. In general, following Graham’s value investing instruction of purchasing a number of defensive stocks stood a good chance of outperforming the broad stock market average over the course of the worst decade in history. Benjamin Graham’s Stock Selection Rules for the Enterprising Investor Graham outlined four broad categories available for the enterprising investor. 1) Buying in low markets and selling in high markets. 2) Buying carefully chosen “growth stocks” 3) Buying bargain issues of various types 4) Buying into “special situations” Choices one and two from the list are highly problematic to implement in real time. Many analysts on Wall Street have attempted to forecast the overall movement of the stock market or the future earnings of a particular company, with mixed results. Option four is a technical branch of investment, and according to Graham, “…only a small percentage of our enterprising investors are likely to engage in it.” We’ll put the microscope over choice number three on the list and look at the performance of buying only bargain issues over the past decade when stock returns scraped the bottom of the barrel. Graham’s bargain approach to stock selection involved either purchasing a stock that traded at a price below some multiple of estimated earnings or selecting securities priced below net current asset value . In a previous blog, we showed how difficult it was to estimate future earnings (see ” Does Earnings Growth Matter When it Comes to Stocks Trading below Liquidation Value? “). Given the challenges of forecasting company earnings, we’ll limit ourselves to only selecting stocks for the enterprising investor list that traded below net current asset value. Stocks that made it on to the enterprising investor list were purchased at a market price below 75% of net current asset value. No more than a 5% weighting was allocated to any one stock. If few stocks could be found meeting our rigorous value criterion, the balance of cash remained in U.S. Treasury Bills. The chart below compares the performance results of Graham’s enterprising investor approach to stock selection with the defensive approach over the dismal decade (2000-2009). Annual rebalancing took place once at the beginning of every yea r, and the capital gains taxes was assumed to be zero. Armed with the knowledge that equity performance over the previous decade (2000-2009) was horrible, you might think a defensive investor had the upper hand over an enterprising investor. In an environment hostile towards stock investing, one might assume that being as conservative as possible would be the better route to take. As illustrated in the chart below, the results are counterintuitive. (click to enlarge) Over the course of the dismal decade, bargain issues using the enterprising approach toward stock selection outperformed defensive stocks by a wide margin. Even if an investor managed to select the top-performing 10-30 stocks that met Graham’s defensive criteria, the portfolio still wouldn’t have outperformed a portfolio of stocks purchased below net current asset value. Negative-return years were more prevalent for the enterprising value investor, but not by much. Aggressive investors endured two negative-return years over the course of the dismal decade, while defensive investors endured only one. A chapter in the book, The Net Current Asset Value Approach to Stock Investing , reviewed the performance over the course of the dismal decade (2000-2009) using a maximum 10% portfolio weighting in any one net current asset value stock rather than the 5% weighting shown in the chart from above. Either way, the average annual return results are about the same and clobber the defensive approach to stock investing. Assuming an investor is willing to stomach greater monthly volatility, it pays to be aggressive even if the overall market provides few value investing opportunities as it did over the course of the period from 2000- 2009 .

Market Beginners Portfolio – July Update

Summary The Market Beginners Portfolio has had a difficult time over the past few months. The portfolio has significant potential for future growth. I chose to invest in Frontier Communication Corporation because of the future opportunity it provides. Introduction As many of my subscribers know, I have written a large number of portfolios talking for a variety of different goals. However, the original Market Beginners Portfolio represented my first attempt at creating a portfolio designed for someone incorporating multiple different points of view. The overall goal of this portfolio is to create a sample portfolio for someone with $100,000 to invest. The portfolio will be composed of both ETFs and Individual Stocks designed to maximize both safety and income for the portfolio. However, rather than focusing on just income for the portfolio, I will also be focusing on overall stock growth. This portfolio is centered towards overall growth and that involves growth both in the form of income and portfolio value. Rules Discipline is the backbone of any major portfolio. As a result, any good portfolio requires at least a few rules to help keep things in balance. This portfolio has two. The first rule is no new money may be added to the portfolio. While this is not a restriction most people generally face, it is helpful for managing a portfolio and as a result is a rule I include in most of my portfolios. The second rule is that no stock or ETF may make up more than 20% of the portfolio. While having different ETFs or secure stocks may help with the portfolio’s safety, minimizing your positions in different stocks helps to maintain your portfolio’s security. Portfolio Stock Name (Ticker) Number of Shares Purchase Price Current Price Johnson & Johnson (NYSE: JNJ ) 100 $100.55 $100.09 Chevron (NYSE: CVX ) 100 $107.70 $93.14 Pimco Strategic Income Fund (NYSE: RCS ) 1000 $9.19 $8.49 Bank of America (NYSE: BAC ) 1000 $16.47 $18.10 Monsanto Company (NYSE: MON ) 100 $118.25 $107.07 Vanguard Total Stock Market ETF (NYSEARCA: VTI ) 100 $108.73 $109.96 Vanguard Dividend Appreciation ETF (NYSEARCA: VIG ) 200 $81.18 $80.77 Original Portfolio Value: $85,430 Total Cash: $14,570 Current Portfolio Value: $83,770 Current Cash: $14,570 Change In Portfolio Value: -1.94% Portfolio Discussion The portfolio has had a relatively difficult time – it has lost 1.94% over the past few months. Much of this loss is due to a decrease in the prices of Chevron, Pimco Strategic Income Fund, and Monsanto Company. However, the portfolio has done an impressive job in Bank of America seeing that position increase by almost $2000. This helped offset some of the other more significant losses for the portfolio. As for decisions, I am choosing to keep the portfolio relatively simple. However, at this time I am making a 1000 share purchase in Frontier Communications Corporation (NASDAQ: FTR ) at $5.14 per share. That takes the cash position of the portfolio down to $9430. Frontier Communications Corporation is a solid company that has had a difficult time dropping from $8.42 earlier in the year. However, management at the company is solid and the company offers a 8.17% dividend at current prices. Cash I continue to hold a significant cash stake in the portfolio amounting to almost 10% of its assets. Future dividends should help to increase the portfolio’s cash position. The market is currently near all time highs and I am hoping to be able to let the portfolio’s cash position grow until better opportunities can be identified. Conclusion The portfolio has had a difficult time recently losing almost 2% of its value. Despite significant losses in other regions, the portfolio managed to make some of the losses back due to a significant increase in the value of Bank of America. I also chose to invest in Frontier Communications Corporation this month. The company has had a difficult time in recent months and as a result now offers a significant dividend amounting to over 8%. I hope to see this portfolio recover and continue growing in future months. Disclosure: I/we have no positions in any stocks mentioned, and no plans to initiate any positions within the next 72 hours. (More…) I wrote this article myself, and it expresses my own opinions. I am not receiving compensation for it (other than from Seeking Alpha). I have no business relationship with any company whose stock is mentioned in this article.