Tag Archives: ideas

Retirement Portfolios – Volatility, Taxes, And Risk

Summary This article refines a previously-presented method for qualifying investment portfolios as suitable for retirement. It uses simple formulas for the effect of taxes on returns and volatilities, which leads to a surprising result: an investor in a higher tax bracket can accept a lower volatility. The method also extends the previous analysis to cover more volatile portfolios, such as those trading XIV and VXX. Introduction A previous article introduced a method for comparing investment portfolios based on back-test results. It considered a recently-retired person who: – Invests an initial amount at the start of retirement, – withdraws a percentage of the initial amount each year, adjusted for inflation, and – holds a portfolio with an expected volatility and return for the duration of their retirement. The previous article showed how to make a go/no-go decision about investing in a portfolio, based on its expected after-tax annualized return, after-tax annualized volatility of returns, and historical inflation. However, back-tests provide pre-tax returns and volatilities, not after-tax figures, and the current level of inflation remains below the mean historical level. To improve the usefulness of the method, this new article shows how to decide whether to invest in a portfolio based on its expected pre-tax returns and volatilities, and based on other-than-historical inflation rates. As before, this article defines risk as a number with direct impact on the retiree, the chance of running out of money during retirement; rather than as a more abstract number, the annualized volatility of returns. A prudent retiree would first seek to reduce risk, the chance of running out of money, to a negligible level. That ensured, the retiree would next seek to increase the portfolio’s balance at the end of retirement to leave a legacy. Simulation method As in the previous article, this analysis uses a Monte Carlo simulation tool at portfoliovisualizer.com to test the risk of a portfolio with a given volatility and return. Table 1 shows the input parameters for the simulation. For each volatility shown in the table, the analysis tried various values of expected return until the simulation output showed a 99% probability of success. This means that at the preset annual withdrawal and volatility settings, 99% of Monte Carlo trials showed a positive balance at the end of retirement. In other words, the retiree did not go broke. The expected return setting that yields 99% probability of success represents the average annualized return necessary throughout retirement to reduce risk to a negligible level at the given settings for annual withdrawal and volatility. Defining negligible risk as 99% probability of success (1% risk) seems appropriate considering the severity of the consequences of running out of money. The simulation tool also provides a median end balance, the retiree’s legacy at the end of retirement in 50% of Monte Carlo trials at the given withdrawal rate and volatility settings, and at the expected return necessary for 99% probability of success at those settings. The simulator shows median end balance discounted for inflation, and therefore expressed in the same dollars as the initial invested amount at the start of retirement. This procedure yielded (volatility, return) pairs at 1% risk of going broke for withdrawing an inflation-adjusted fixed amount annually, equal to 3% of the initial amount. It also provided the median end balance at this volatility, return, and withdrawal rate. Simulation results The simulation tool provided the results in Table 2, where: “Median annual return” = (Median end balance / Initial amount)^(1/30)-1. This gives the median annual rate of return during retirement after inflation and withdrawals at the selected withdrawal rate, the selected volatility, and the rate of return required to reduce risk to 1%. Consider, for example, a portfolio with 15% volatility – similar to the historical volatility of the S&P 500 index. Suppose inflation remains near zero. Table 2 shows that a retiree would need an average annual return of 12% in this portfolio for an acceptable risk of going broke. If the portfolio in fact delivers this 12% return, year after year, then the investor will benefit from a median return after withdrawals of 9%, and the original investment of $1M will rise to a median legacy of $13M at the end of retirement. While this median performance seems more than adequate, remember that there remains a 1% chance of leaving no legacy at all. Each row in Table 2 represents a hypothetical portfolio. Each portfolio has the same 1% risk of going broke, but the portfolios with higher volatility require higher annual returns to reduce risk to that level, and as a consequence, investors benefit from higher median annual returns, and their heirs should benefit from greater legacies. An investor who chooses a higher-volatility portfolio at the same level of risk should expect to experience a jumpier account balance and to leave a greater legacy. Effect of inflation Chart 1, graphed from Table 2, shows how annual return required for 99% success probability increases with volatility. A portfolio with annual return on or above the line has acceptable risk. The lines in Chart 1 can be considered “lines of equal risk,” or in this case, “lines of 1% risk.” The difference between the two lines in Chart 1 is close to the mean historical inflation rate (4.18%). Over the range studied here, the annual return required for 99% success probability can reasonably be estimated as the zero-inflation annual return (lower line in Chart 1), plus the expected inflation rate. For simplicity, the remainder of this article assumes zero inflation, which is close to the situation today. Chart 2, also graphed from Table 2, shows how median annual return (and therefore the investor’s legacy) also increases with volatility. As explained above, each row in Table 2 gives returns for a different volatility, but all rows have the same 1% risk. Similarly, all points on the same line in Chart 2 have the same 1% risk. For these curves, annual return was selected to reduce the worst-case risk to 1% at a given volatility and withdrawal rate. Chart 2 shows that for two portfolios with equal risk, an investor leaves a larger legacy by selecting the portfolio with higher volatility, provided that it delivers the required higher return. Chart 2 also shows, like Chart 1, that the difference between the two curves is close to the mean historical inflation rate (4.18%). Over the range studied here, the median annual return with inflation can reasonably be estimated as the zero-inflation median annual return (lower line in Chart 2), plus the expected inflation rate. Required pre-tax return Until now, the analysis has not considered the effect of taxes. The required return as a function of volatility in Chart 1 must apply to after-tax returns and volatilities, because those are what affect the balance in the retiree’s account. This begs a question, what are the corresponding pre-tax volatilities and returns? Define “Rtn” as the required annual after-tax return for a given after-tax volatility (“Vol”), that is, the annual return required for 99% probability for reaching the end of a 30-year retirement, making 3% annual withdrawals, and assuming zero inflation. At a marginal tax rate “Tax,” the after-tax return: Rtn = (1-Tax)*PreRtn, where PreRtn is the pre-tax return (Equation 1). The after-tax volatility is reduced by the same ratio: Vol = (1-Tax)*PreVol, where PreVol is the pre-tax volatility (Equation 2). Equation 2 holds true for volatility because volatility is a standard deviation (“σ”), and for a random variable X and a constant m: σ(m*X) = m*σ(X). For example, at a tax rate of Tax = 50%, for a portfolio to provide an after-tax volatility of Vol = 15% and an after-tax return of Rtn = 12%, it must have a pre-tax return of PreRtn = Rtn/(1-Tax) = 24%, but it can have a pre-tax volatility as high as PreVol = Vol/(1-Tax) = 30%. Table 3 and Chart 3 show after-tax and pre-tax (volatility, return) pairs for 1% risk. The after-tax volatilities and returns come from Table 2, and the pre-tax volatilities and returns come from applying the simple equations in the preceding paragraph to the after-tax figures. Table 3 and Chart 3 provide pre-tax figures for 50% and 25% marginal tax rates: For example, in Chart 3, portfolio “K” has 45% after-tax volatility, which, from Chart 1, requires 67% after-tax return for 1% risk. With 25% tax, this corresponds to pre-tax volatility of 60% and pre-tax return of 89%. With 50% tax, this corresponds to pre-tax volatility of 90% and pre-tax return of 133%. Back-test results are pre-tax. By the way, these stratospheric volatilities and back-test returns are included here for exceptional strategies, such as those trading derivatives of derivatives (XIV and VXX). Charts 3b and 3c show an expanded view of more usual volatilities and returns. Consequently, Charts 3, 3b, and 3c provide an investor with a way to qualify a portfolio for retirement – it must fall above the line in these charts that corresponds to investors’ marginal tax bracket. If an investor used the lines in the previous article (which were after-tax lines) to qualify a portfolio based on back-tested volatility and return (which are pre-tax figures), this would have been too stringent a qualification test. In effect, the investor would have required a return above the green line in Chart 3, when a return above the yellow or red line would have sufficed. To take inflation into account, the investor needs to shift the curves in Chart 3, 3b, or 3c upward by the expected inflation rate. Chart 3b shows an expanded view of the low-volatility part of Chart 3: Chart 3c shows an expanded view of the midrange of Chart 3: Charts 3, 3b, and 3c show that at a given back-test volatility – which is a pre-tax volatility – the required back-test return – which is a pre-tax return – is lower for a higher tax rate. This non-intuitive result occurs because taxes not only reduce returns, but also reduce volatility. When an investor does poorly, so does the tax collector. Effectively, the tax collector shares the investor’s risk along with the investor’s returns. This analysis has other interesting (and perhaps non-intuitive) consequences: Consider a strategy with back-tested (pre-tax) average annual return of 25% and volatility of 40%. Row F in Table 3 shows that this has acceptable risk for an investor in the 50% tax bracket, but row H in Table 3 shows that it is too risky for an investor in the 25% tax bracket. This investor needs the tax collector to share more of the risk. Now, consider a strategy with a back-tested (pre-tax) average annual return of 20% and volatility of 40%. Rows F and H in Table 3 show that this is too risky for an investor in either tax bracket. However, if that investor keeps 25% of the retirement account in that portfolio and 75% in cash at zero return and zero volatility, the account would have a pre-tax return of 25% * 20% = 5% and a pre-tax volatility of 25% * 40% = 10%. Rows B and C in Table 3 show that this is enough return at this volatility to reduce risk to an acceptable value for an investor in either tax bracket. Discussion and conclusion Investors could use this method to qualify portfolios for retirement investments, based on back-tested returns and volatilities, and taking taxes and inflation into account. The method extends to cover unusually volatile portfolios: even those with 50% volatility can provide acceptable risk after taxes and inflation, provided they maintain acceptable returns. This opens a door toward including non-traditional portfolios – such as those trading VXX and XIV – in a prudent retiree’s account. This method is subject to the classical limitation of back-tests: they do not consistently predict future results. Most investors will want to maintain a mix of qualified portfolios, including a traditional core. Acknowledgement: The author thanks Dr. Toma Hentea for reviewing and clarifying the article. Appendix: Alternative calculations with a pseudo-Sharpe ratio Although Charts 3, 3b, and 3c provide enough information to make a go/no-go decision about investing in a portfolio, there is another method for looking at the data. Both methods reach the same decision in the same situation. For the second method, portfolio back-tests provide not only (volatility, return) pairs, but they also provide a ratio of annualized return to annualized volatility. This is similar to a Sharpe ratio, except it assumes a risk-free return of zero (close to the situation today). Table 4 and Chart 4 show the required return/volatility for 1% risk, using the data from Table 3. Chart 4 shows that the required return/volatility ratio (“pseudo-Sharpe ratio”) for 1% risk increases with volatility over the range studied. It also shows that the pseudo-Sharpe ratio required for a given portfolio (“A” through “L”) does not change with the investor’s tax situation. This follows directly from equations 1 and 2, because volatility and required return change by the same proportion when changing tax situations. Like Chart 3, Chart 4 provides an investor with a method to qualify a portfolio – its pseudo-Sharpe ratio must fall above the curve in Chart 4 for that investor’s marginal tax bracket. Chart 4b provides an expanded view of the lower-volatility part of Chart 4: Charts 4 and 4b show that at a given back-test volatility, the required back-test pseudo-Sharpe ratio for 1% risk is lower for a higher tax rate. As in Charts 3, 3b, and 3c, this occurs because the tax collector shares the investor’s risk along with the investor’s returns.

Surf’s Up With Hawaiian Electric Industries

Summary Hawaii Electric Industries has 95% of Hawaiian electricity market. Hawaii population and building projects are trending up. Hawaiian Electric is poised to expand into this growing market while aligning with other macro trends. Hawaii has been known as one of the most coveted tourism destinations in the United States, but has recently started to become a hot area for residency and permanent living. As mainlanders flock to the beautiful beaches and island lifestyle offered by the most recently inducted U.S. State, opportunity for investors becomes more and more apparent in a variety of different ways. A company that is fully equipped and already capitalizing on Hawaii’s growth is Hawaiian Electric Industries (NYSE: HE ). A leading electricity provider for the Hawaiian Islands, Hawaiian Electric is a strong pick in an expanding economy, especially where residencies and buildings are being built and filled at a high rate. The Opportunity Hawaiian Electric Industries is the leading electricity provider, supplying almost 95%, roughly 450,000 customers, of the Hawaiian population with electricity through its various subsidiaries, including Hawaiian Electric Light Co., and Maui Electric Co. With obvious domination of the market, HE is poised to grow with the economic and population growth of Hawaii. As population trends towards higher numbers, more projects and residencies will continue to be built, and power will need to be supplied to these new homes. Hawaiian Electric can expect to get that call based off of their dominant market share and well known reliability. A steady flow of new customers in the foreseeable future as migration to Hawaii grows, coupled with a company that already has a strong grip on the market could lead to attractive profits and growth. (click to enlarge) As one can see from the chart, after soaring housing numbers pre-recession there was an obvious lull in authorized projects. Since, there has been growth, that, while not at pre-recession numbers, is trending up. This opens the door of opportunity for a company that provides electricity to almost all new housing projects in Hawaii. If this growth continues, look to see HE increase customers and ultimately profit from the construction of new housing. Expansion is looking to be a promising opportunity in the near future as a merger between HE and NextEra Energy, Inc. (NYSE: NEE ) is in the works, currently clearing obstacles in the process of joining forces. NextEra is a clean energy company stationed in Juno Beach, Florida, with almost $17 billion in latest reported annual revenues. As one of the top ten in Fortune’s 2015 list of “World’s Most Admired Companies,” NEE will offer a variety of services and assistance for HE to reach it’s goal of an entirely renewable energy portfolio by 2045, matching Hawaiian Electric Ind. with a leading trend in the utilities macroenvironment. The Company HE is a mid-cap stock with a strong financial base. Revenues have remained steady over the past 3 years, leading many to believe a stall of sorts has occurred, but as macro conditions improve and the company expands its portfolio these numbers could see growth. Forward thinking management strategies such as the renewable energy plan set forth by HE President Connie Lau will propel the company into the future of energy, aligning with not only consumer trends, but natural trends as well. Recognition of the fruits of these plans may not be seen for a number of years, but strong strategy and pursuit of that strategy is paramount in any business, but vital to the energy and utilities sectors in particular. Dividends have remained strong at $1.24 (4.37%) per common share, a respectable number for a mid-cap stock. One thing to consider when analyzing HE as a company is the strong growth in operating income this company has experienced over the past few years, from $284 million in 2012 to $329 million in their most recent 2014 annual report. This shows internal strength in its ability to generate larger profit margins while revenues remain steady, a competency necessary to success in an industry where squeezing higher profits from sales is so integral to growth and financial health. Share prices have seen a recent decline, from around $34 in January, down to about $28 in the recent days. Expect to see a rebound in these prices if the eminent merger with NextEra is completed, as this would lead to expansion and increased internal company strength in the market. Analysts predict company growth of 19% next quarter, along with 6% for the next year. Conclusion All investment decisions should warrant caution, and HE is no different. That said, a strong company with a large market share in a growing market are good finds. HE is exactly that, a strong, financially healthy, company that owns 95% of a market that expects steady growth in the coming years. Couple that with strong expansion strategy to meet changing macro trends towards cleaner, renewable energy and HE could be a strong investment.

The Health Care Sector’s Weakness Could Be The Investor’s Best Friend

Summary The health care sector went through a significant meltdown during the recent weeks. A long term investor might consider it as an opportunity to invest in great companies. Here is a list of 4 non-expensive ETFs that are focused on the Health Care sector. Three weeks ago a good friend of mine bought shares of Mylan Inc (NASDAQ: MYL ). His goal was to invest in a defensive stock in order to mitigate the volatile market. Since the day he made the purchase the stock was hammered down and closed is currently at a total of ~20% lower. Mylan is a global generic and specialty pharmaceuticals company that is registered in the Netherlands. In 2007, following a big acquisition Mylan became the second-largest generic and pharmaceuticals’ company in the United States. It was a wise decision at the time. Here is Mylan’s forecast P/E growth rates in the coming years based on Nasdaq.com. A P/E of 8x for a double digit growth company is not too bad at all. MYL’s stock price free fall was no different compared to other Health care companies’ stocks. If looking at the behavior of the S&P 500 Health Care Sector the graph tells us that there was about 20% drop in the sector since the recent highs. On Wednesday, September 30th, there seemed to be some recovery after several bloody weeks. (click to enlarge) The drop is explained by Hillary Clinton’s ” price gouging ” tweet which led to concerns within the investors’ community regarding higher regulations on drug pricing. Is this massive drop justified or is it an out-of-panic oversell and therefore a great opportunity? Why do I think it is an oversell? Several reasons lead me to believe it is an extreme reaction over nothing and it is a temporary meltdown: The market is very volatile in the recent weeks and it seems that the focus is only on the bad news that are being a catalyst towards a dipper correction. Back in August it was the less-than-expected growth in China’s economy, than it was the Volkswagen ( OTCQX:VLKAY ) scandal and now it is this tweet. Any regulation would need to pass Congress where the Republicans still have the major votes. It would be at least couple of years until something would really change. Not all companies are taking outrages profits on their developed drugs. The amount of Research and Development the companies are investing is huge and therefore the economy of the business will eventually dictate the prices. It will not be the politicians. The sector is composed from different types of companies. Some develop an original medicine or drug and there are generic drug companies. Some are focused on specific niches and others have huge diversification. Even if there will be new regulations not all will suffer equally. Some would even benefit from it. For those, like me, who think that it is the later here are some ETFs that invest in this sector and should be profoundly examined by the long term investor. Why an ETF and not specific stock picking? While both the uncertainty and the volatility are high an investment in a specific sector can be better managed through an ETF. In cases where an investor would like to build a position that is composed by wide list of holdings, sometimes in several steps, an ETF would be a better way to do it. Buying into a sector’s ETF allows to build a position in a by-step model. Another reason to prefer an ETF is the level of familiarity with the list of companies in the sector. Though all the sector’s companies were hurt by the recent selloff most of the investors will not know which of the companies are best to recover and which could be impacted by new regulations (in case it is not just a hot balloon towards election). An ETF allows to have a wide exposure and by that increase the probability to ride the right companies towards recovery. When looking at the list of Health care ETFs I found a list of 38 ETFs. The full list can be found here . Some of the ETFs are focused on the traditional big health care companies like Johnson & Johnson (NYSE: JNJ ), Gilead (NASDAQ: GILD ) and Pfizer (NYSE: PFE ). Others are focused on biotechnology companies like BioMarin Pharmaceutical Inc. (NASDAQ: BMRN ) and Biogen Inc. (NASDAQ: BIIB ). Some are focused on health care equipment companies and some in small biotech small startups. An investor can decide based on his or her risk profile the best ETF that suits his or her needs based on its mix and focus. Filtering the list As I like to start a list filtering by eliminating ETF that charge high management fees I have sorted out all ETFs that charge more that 0.3% per year. Surprisingly I was left with only four ETFs. (click to enlarge) The last four are: The Health Care Select Sect SPDR ETF (NYSEARCA: XLV ), which replicates Health Care Select Sector Index. The Vanguard Health Care ETF (NYSEARCA: VHT ), which replicates MSCI US Investable Market Health Care 25/50 Index. The Fidelity MSCI Health Care Index ETF (NYSEARCA: FHLC ) that replicates MSCI USA IMI Health Care Index. The PowerShares S&P SmallCap Health Care Portfolio ETF (NASDAQ: PSCH ) which replicate S&P SmallCap 600 Health Care Index. This list allows an investor to pick an inexpensive ETF based on his or her own risk tolerance. A quick comparison between the four: In term of performance, PSCH delivered the highest return in the last five years due to its more risky nature. Surprisingly it wasn’t harmed harder than the others during the recent month drop. Both XLV and VHT are tending towards the large cap health care companies. XLV seems to be more conservative as it shown by its average 18x P/E ratio versus the average of 32x. VHT has a significantly higher amount of holdings which are mostly small and medium cap companies that are trading at higher P/Es compared to the JNJs and PFEs. Conclusions: The list of four non-expensive ETFs can be examined by a long term investor who believes that the Health Care sector’s meltdown is only a temporary one. In term of the potential of long term gains, some would prefer the small cap ETF, PSCH. If looking for high diversification, VHT seems to be the best one. I picked XLV in term of risk/return tradeoff. I prefer an exposure to the big and strong companies of the sector. In any case, I suggest to plan a strategy of building a position in multiple steps. The volatility is still here and the correction can be dipper than anyone anticipates. Happy investing.