Tag Archives: ideas

Why Investor Sentiment May Not Be A Contrarian Indicator Anymore

Investor sentiment indices such as the AAII have been extremely bearish since this summer, before the August downturn. Many analysts have pointed to this bearish sentiment as a contrarian, and therefore bullish, indicator. However, the bearish investors this summer were proven right in August, and they may well be proven right again in October. Sentiment surveys may no longer reflect the opinion of as substantial a portion of the market as they used to. Also, the spreading knowledge of technical analysis in recent years may have made average investors — lo and behold — smarter than they were in 2007-2008. Since this summer, well before the August downturn, a variety of measures of investor sentiment have given extremely bearish readings. Headlines appeared in July that investors are the most bearish that they’ve been in 15 years, and similar headlines still appear in September. And it is now typical for the articles about these bearish sentiment measures to point out that historically such sentiment readings have been a contrarian indicator: Extreme bullish sentiment has tended to indicate that a bull market has peaked and is about to decline, while extreme bearish sentiment has tended to indicate that a bear market has bottomed and is about to rally. Strangely, though, this year bearish sentiment exploded before the bull market even entered a correction. Some analysts still point to the sentiment now and use it as an argument that we are only in a correction, not a bear market, and that the bull market will soon resume its march higher. I doubt this very much. Rather, I argue, this year — for once — investor sentiment was and is on the money about the direction of the market. Investors were and are right to be bearish. So why is investor sentiment no longer a contrarian indicator in 2015? This is a very good question, so allow me to offer a couple plausible explanations. First, the individual investors whose sentiment is being measured in the surveys may not represent as substantial a portion of the market as they used to. Large institutional investors make up an even more dominant share of the market than they did 7 years ago or 15 years ago. Trading driven by computer algorithms is certainly a much bigger factor in the market than it ever was before. This summer, individual investors felt the fear before the technical indicators alerted the computer algorithms that something was wrong. Another factor in recent years is the flood of money from overseas that has been seeking out relative safety in the U.S. stock markets. Most of the sentiment indicators probably do not incorporate the opinions of overseas investors as much as those of American investors, so the surveys are likely overlooking relatively more bullish sentiment from overseas investors, who have been happy to buy U.S. stocks rather than Asian, European, or other stocks. Second, the spread of technical analysis itself may be a factor in the sentiment readings since August (most technical indicators turned negative slightly before the market downturn). Individual investors have far more access to the basic principles of technical analysis than they did 15 years ago or even 7 years ago. The technicals were flashing danger signs almost an entire year before the 2008 crash, but most investors were not aware of them or ignored them. Today there is far less ignorance or lack of awareness of such information among investors. Many more people now know how to read a simple chart of the price, the 50-day moving indicator, and the 200-day moving indicator of a stock or index. And even such simple charts give an accurate enough indication to tell individual investors to be bearish before the market has bottomed, rather than waiting until after the market has bottomed to suddenly panic. Moreover, the type of knowledgeable investor who understands technical analysis is precisely the type of investor who is also likely to be a member of the American Association of Individual Investors and reply to their sentiment survey. The investment newsletter advisors whose sentiments are measured in the Investors Intelligence survey are also more likely to follow the technical charts. I strongly suspect that newsletter advisors too have increased their knowledge of basic technical analysis a great deal in the past 7 years. On the other hand, the more passive “buy and hold” investors, and the people who simply put part of their 401k money in an S&P 500 index fund and never make any adjustments to it, are less likely to pay enough attention to turn bearish before the market completely crashes and they panic. Their sentiments are also less likely to be captured in investor sentiment surveys. In summary: The type of active investors whose opinions tend to be measured in sentiment surveys may well have gotten a lot smarter now than they were 7 years ago or 15 years ago! I dare say websites such as Seeking Alpha may have contributed to this increase in investor education. There is still a lot of dumb money out there, but at least there’s hopefully less of it, especially among investors such as those who read Seeking Alpha.

Middlesex Water Is A Dividend Aristocrat

Middlesex Water Company has a remarkably safe, growing dividend, with a current yield of over 3%. Using a constant dividend growth model, investors will find that the current stock price is slightly below the fair value. Investors looking for a safe utility company with a steady dividend should take a look at Middlesex Water Company. Middlesex Water Company (NASDAQ: MSEX ) could be one of the safest dividend stocks in the market. This is a water utility company operating in central and southern New Jersey, as well as Delaware and northeastern Pennsylvania, which include some of the highest-income areas in the nation. As a water utility company and a company whose customers are overwhelmingly wealthy, Middlesex Water Company is able to provide a remarkably safe dividend, with the current 3%+ yield representing a payout ratio of under 70%. Furthermore, recent developments in New Jersey (where Middlesex Water Company operates most of its business) should allow the company to grow earnings and maintain its healthy dividend. Governor Chris Christie recently signed into law the Water Infrastructure Protection Act , which allows municipalities to sell their water systems to water companies. So while utility companies have typically been seen as safe investments, in New Jersey they can be considered safe and also have the potential for growth. These developments show that the Middlesex Water Company’s dividend should be safe, and that earnings growth opportunities in the future could potentially provide an additional incentive to invest. If the under 70% payout ratio is not impressive as it is, the company has made a cash dividend payment every year for 102 years, even in the midst of the financial crises. Furthermore, Middlesex Water Company has raised its dividend every year for 42 years. (click to enlarge) This is a perfect case of a dividend stock, and a stock that many investors will only purchase for the safety of its dividend. Thus, we can safely use the dividend growth model to find its value. Excluding that one quarter blip, Middlesex Water Company has raised its dividend every four quarters by .25 cents, for an annual increase in its dividend of 1 cent. While this nominal growth rate is constant, in order to use the dividend growth model, we must come up with a percentage rate. The percentage rate will be declining year after year, even as the dividend growth remains at a steady 1 cent increase. For next year, the dividend growth rate is represented by .01/.77 = 1.3%. In about 25 years, we know this rate will decline to just under 1%, so we can split the different and use a rate of 1.15%. This assumes the investor will be holding the stock for a period of 25 years. For our required return rate, we will use the Weighted Average Cost of Capital for Middlesex Water Company. This can be calculated by finding the weighted average cost of equity, which we will find using the Capital Asset Pricing Model (CAPM), and the cost of debt multiplied by 1 minus the tax rate). The weights will be 71% equity and 29% debt, using market cap of equity and the book value of debt. The Cost of Equity = Risk-Free Rate of Return + Beta of Asset * (Expected Return of the Market – Risk-Free Rate of Return). The risk-free rate we will use is the 10-year Treasury, currently yielding about 2.05%. The beta we will use is .62, as calculated by YCharts, which uses data from BATS Exchange. The expected return of the market – the risk-free rate, otherwise known as market premium – is left up to much more interpretation. I will use a rate of 5%, which is slightly less than the average S&P performance minus the current risk free 10-year Treasury rate. I am using a slightly less-than-average S&P average because evidence suggests the market will not do as well as it has done the past few years, as news is coming out that people are pulling money out of the market and into other investments. For example, the return on cash now exceeds returns on stocks and bonds for the first time in 25 years . This model will assume that investors putting money in the market will receive a historically lower return than average. Plugging all these values in, we get a cost of equity of 5.15%. The cost of debt can be easily calculated as interest expense divided by book value of debt. In this case, using year-end data from 2014, we get $5.067 million divided by $162.2915, which equals 3.45%. Middlesex Water Company’s average tax rate for the past two years has been 34.57%, so we will multiply 3.45%*(1-.3457) to get 2.26%. Now, to weight them, it will come out to (.71)*(.0515) + (.29)*(.0226) = 4.31% Using the next annual dividend payout of $0.78 as well as all these values, we can use the dividend growth model to estimate the stock is worth approximately $24.69. At a current price of $23.75, it appears MSEX is undervalued by approximately 4%. For investors looking for a safe, growing dividend, Middlesex Water Company is worth a look.

Tactical Asset Allocation – October 2015 Update

There was a lot of volatility in September in the equity markets. So far it looks like the portfolio signals to go to cash have been valid. Of course, that’s only half the battle. We’ll see what October brings, a historically positive month for equities. Here are the tactical asset allocation updates for October 2015. All portfolio updates are online as part of Paul’s GTAA 13 Portfolio New sheet. First, for the basic portfolios – the GTAA5 and the Permanent Portfolio. GTAA5 is now 20% invested, with IEF going to “invested” this month. For the timing version of the Permanent Portfolio there were no changes this month. (click to enlarge) Now for the more aggressive GTAA AGG3 and AGG6 portfolios. This month I’ve decided to show all 13 asset classes so you can really see where they all stand and what kind of year it had been so far. (click to enlarge) No changes this month for AGG3. For AGG6, VCIT went to “invested” this month. Both portfolios are still in full risk management mode. Performance for the portfolios so far this year is in the table below. Numbers are for each month. The figures are estimates taken from a variety of sources. I don’t do detailed performance tracking until the end of the year. (click to enlarge) If you’re a fan of the Antonacci dual momentum GEM and GBM portfolios, no changes from last month. I’ve also made my Antonacci tracking sheet shareable so you can see the portfolio details for yourself. That’s it for this month. These portfolios signals are valid for the whole month of October. As always, post any questions you have in the comments. Full Disclaimer: Nothing in this article should ever be considered advice, research or the invitation to buy or sell securities. These are my personal opinions only. Share this article with a colleague