Tag Archives: ideas

A Case For Active Investment Management

Summary Investing in fundamentally strong companies. Active Management vs. Benchmarking. Potential for reduced exposure to declining markets. “The most successful investment managers generally possess three qualities: independent thought, discipline, and consistency of application” – John Train in his book The Money Masters. “It is impossible to produce superior performance unless you do something different from the majority.” – Sir John Templeton. Screening for Fundamentally Strong Companies For over 15 years I have been a multi-asset class investor, advisor and analyst. My teams over the years have managed a variety of active strategies. While different in focus, every equity based strategy incorporates fundamental investment principles. Regardless of the fad of the day or the hot company everyone is talking about, consistent performance and risk management depends on these principles. I have recently collaborated with a group of CFA charterholders to form an all-cap equity strategy from our most successful strategies with the sole purpose of generating exceptional risk adjusted returns. Below is a summary of the parameters we use. All Alpha Strategy Parameters Price to Book < 1.5 7 years of positive operating margin 3 years roe > 15% Lowest 20% of growth adjusted free cash flow multiple Companies with above average operating and net margin within their respective industry Below average debt to equity Positive cash flow ROA growing D/E declining Current ratio, gross margin, asset turnover growing Cash flow > net income Consistent earnings growth Momentum parameters Thanks to Henry Crutcher and Equities Lab for creating a great quantitative tool that enables us to generate and successfully back test the performance of our fundamental and technical based strategies for the periods we don’t have actual trading history. See the output since 1997 from the program below. Here is a list of every trade for the past 15 years. Recently passing companies: (click to enlarge) The results from the model were strong. Upon verifying the data, 13.12% annualized is accurate. I then combined it with a proprietary risk management model that helps us anticipate significant market declines and the results were even more encouraging. I nvesting in fundamentally strong companies Investing “is pursued most successfully in a simple, straightforward way.” – Brad Perry, Winning the Investment Marathon. Buy stocks of high-quality companies at good prices and continue holding them as long as the companies’ performance merits doing so. Do this consistently and the probability an investor will enjoy above average returns substantially increases. Below are brief descriptions of the investment parameters. 1. Price to Book < 1.5 As a primary measure of value, the price to book ratio is an initial screen that seeks to pass securities that have moved away from their true value due to neglect and are typically out of favor. These securities over time have proven to be successful investments. 2. 7 years of positive operating margin Consistent operating margins are a positive sign a company's underlying business is successful and seemingly sustainable. 3. 3 years roe > 15% Strong and consistent return on equity is essential. 4. Lowest 20% of growth adjusted free cash flow multiple Using price/free cash flow multiplied by 5 year growth of free cash flow is a valuation measure. 5. Companies with above average operating and net margin within their respective industry This measure helps us choose the leaders in each investment’s respective industry. 6. Below average debt to equity Because overleveraged companies are not attractive. 7. ROA growing We prefer the companies we invest in to get better at what they do over time. Additionally, we look for companies that invest internally and that return produces consistently growing ROA. Otherwise, our money is better invested elsewhere. This is a year over year measure. 8. D/E declining Efficient use of debt is important, as well as consistent retirement of debt. 9. Current ratio, gross margin, asset turnover growing Measures of liquidity, profitability and business activity. 10. Cash flow from Operations > net income This is a simple accrual accounting check to avoid companies that may be attempting to manage earnings. 11. Consistent earnings growth Earnings growth attracts attention. We again use year over year measures that help us identify companies that are poised to move. 12. Momentum parameters in the form of relative strength play an important role in our growth oriented screen. It helps identify companies with attractive price movement but remain appropriately valued. In addition, we tend to focus our attention to price movers that are within 15% of recent highs. Active Management vs. Benchmarking So I guess you now have me pegged as an active investor. I personally don’t consider myself active or passive, I consider myself a fundamentally based technical investor, meaning I buy when it makes sense and sell when things start looking uncertain. My current domestic exposure, managed with a beta weighted futures overlay on a long portfolio, is 100% hedged due to current volatile economic conditions. The exposure metric was derived by analyzing market valuations and economic indicators. It is updated monthly, which may also be considered an actively managed strategy. Regardless of my bias, active management has taken a beating over the past few years and rightfully so, in many instances, such as the “active” managers that are more concerned about underperforming than actually providing value to their clients. In other cases, active management can provide an investor peace of mind and tremendous value if the strategy is fundamentally sound and is implemented consistently. William Sharpe stated in the Arithmetic of Active Management (The Financial Analysts’ Journal Vol. 47, No. 1, January/February 1991. pp. 7-9): If “active” and “passive” management styles are defined in sensible ways, i t must be the case that 1. before costs, the return on the average actively managed dollar will equal the return on the average passively managed dollar and 2. after costs, the return on the average actively managed dollar will be less than the return on the average passively managed dollar The problem with this statement from William Sharpe is that it assumes the active manager seeks to benchmark a specific market such as large cap, small cap, etc. As a business, active managers live and die on performance against their respective benchmarks. Knowing this, many use enhanced benchmarking. Enhanced benchmarking involves an active manager investing in an essentially passive portfolio of securities that mimic a benchmark. However in addition to this passive allocation, these active managers will use derivatives or some other portable alpha to “enhance” portfolio performance in an attempt to reduce the risk of underperforming the benchmark and providing the possibility of outperforming at any random time. Additionally, active managers may also stray from their benchmark allocations by adding smaller cap and potentially higher returning securities. This is known as style drift and measured by tracking error. Oftentimes, these additional measures do not add sufficient alpha to offset higher risk and fees. These are reasons a high percentage of active managers perform poorly after fees compared to passive index investing. Potential for reduced exposure to declining markets As seen in the Business Cycle Overlay data, the potential for reduced exposure to declining markets can be substantial if executed properly. The model effectively reduces equity risk when valuations become rich and economic conditions warrant more caution. Returns from effectively managing downturns is termed the buy-and-hold equalizer. The buy-and-hold equalizer (Why Market Timing Works, Journal of Portfolio Management, Summer 1997), represents the increased leverage an active investment strategy gains by preserving capital during a market drop. The more money an investor has to invest when the market turns up, the greater the performance leverage. The following passage is from NAAIM . When properly implemented, active management strategies should lessen an investor’s exposure to declining markets, blunting the impact of bear markets and preserving capital and the majority of prior gains. Moving out of the market prior to the majority of a decline means you have more money to invest when the market heads upward. Active investment management is most effective over a full market cycle (3 to 5 years). The reality of down markets provides the rational for active management. Down markets hurt investors in a number of ways. First, the more investors lose money in a down market, the more they lose valuable time and opportunity. Over the past 70 years, the major indices spent nearly 60% of the time sitting out bear markets and then returning to earlier highs. Only about 40% of the time were real gains being made. Through the use of active management strategies, money managers seek investment approaches that moderate the volatility of the market, helping investors stay the course and benefit from the long-term gains of the market and improve risk adjusted returns. Additionally, active management offers potential benefits beyond performance. Unlike with passive approaches, active managers are not required to invest cash inflows at the time of receipt when market conditions or prices may not be conducive. They can screen for quality and use buy/ sell triggers as a means of reducing risk. While a passive manager must own everything in an index, an active managers have the freedom to look for attractive stocks across the targeted universe. Summary Active management is an effective tool if used properly. It can not only lead to larger gains, but also reduce risk. However, it is very important for investors to understand the underlying investment strategy of a particular investment regardless of whether it is active or passive. Moreover, an investor should compare the statistics of an active strategy (Total Return, Standard Deviation, Calmar Ratio, Sharpe Ratio, Information Ratio, and Tracking Error) to that of a similar passive to determine if the higher fees are producing sufficient additional gains to warrant an investment. I will follow up this article with regular investment and economic analysis specific to these strategies, highlighting passing companies and providing economic rationale for managing an investment portfolio. Follow me to stay informed.

Alliant Energy: Management Strategy Looks Solid

Summary Alliant is investing in its future by building new, state-of-the-art power plants. New power-plant buildup has been costly, but debt is manageable and financed at low rates. With a history of stable earnings growth and dividend increases, shares look poised to outperform peers. Alliant Energy (NYSE: LNT ) is a regulated public utility with both electric and natural gas businesses. The company has a substantial presence in the Midwest, with the vast majority of Alliant operations taking place in Iowa and Wisconsin. A long-time outperformer, shares rebounded nicely off 2009 lows, trouncing the total returns of most other utilities. However, the last two years have seen shares just track along with the broader index. Can Alliant Energy return to its strong return profile? Shifting Energy Mix and Future CapEx Plans To comply with federal and state mandates, Alliant has made a big push over the past ten years to move from a coal-dominated power generation mix to one more focused on natural gas and wind. While coal still holds the largest piece of Alliant generation capacity, company management forecasts a major shift by 2024, where coal only constitutes roughly one-third of production. This change will primarily be driven by upcoming company investments in natural gas through its Marshalltown Generating Station (650MW combined cycle natural gas) and an expansion of its Riverside facility (another 650MW combined cycle natural gas facility). (click to enlarge) * Alliant Energy Investor Presentation Once these facilities are built, this will allow the company to shift its capital expenditure away from environmental upgrades and new power plant builds, instead allocating resources towards taking advantage of higher allowed returns through upgrading ATC electric transmission infrastructure (12.8% allowed return on equity). I’m a big fan of Alliant management’s capital expenditure plans and believe this is the way to go for enhancing shareholder returns, while ensuring compliance with possible future enhanced emissions regulations. This strategy is distinctly different from the plans we’ve seen from other Midwestern utilities like Great Plains Energy (NYSE: GXP ) and large nation-wide behemoths like Duke Energy (NYSE: DUK ). Operating Results Regulated electric revenues have stalled, primarily due to falling residential customer sales due to lower overall energy demand. Customer count has remained mostly flat. The big driver has actually been industrial demand, but these larger customers have the advantage of negotiating cheaper electricity from utilities directly, yielding lower margins. On the plus side, Alliant’s industrial customers are primarily in the food manufacturing and chemical businesses, businesses which are traditionally fairly resilient to economic downturns. Gas operations revenues are also down, but not due to falling sales. Like most gas utilities, Alliant has riders that pass along the cost of natural gas to customers, for better or worse. Falling natural gas prices means falling revenue but the company maintains its fixed profit per sale. While revenue has been flat, cash flow generation has been exceptionally strong for Alliant. The company has been spending this cash quicker than it comes in though, with heavy investments in new generation ($300M+ annual for Marshalltown/Riverside expected in 2015-2017) and electric transmission. (click to enlarge) * Alliant Energy Investor Presentation Alliant has made the decision to take advantage of its credit ratings and low interest rates and make these upgrades and investments now. Long-term debt has grown $1B from 2011 to the present, now standing at $3.7B. However, net debt/EBITDA is still 3.6x, in line with utility averages. There shouldn’t be much risk here, especially as operating income rises and capital expenditures fall over the next five-ten years. Conclusion Alliant is investing in its future, committed to shifting its power-generation mix and investing its operating cash flow in high-margin businesses. With a current dividend yield of 3.70% and a history of healthy annual dividend increases, shareholders seem set to be rewarded handsomely. 5-6% annual dividend increases over the next three-five years seem likely. With expected 2016 earnings per share of approximately $3.85, shares trade at just 15.6x 2016 earnings. There looks to be substantial value here with a fair margin of safety compared to most alternatives in the utility sector. Primary risk for shares are standard to most utilities: interest rate risk, risks related to allowed regulated returns or customer loss in the company’s service area, and a general revaluation within the utility sector that brings earnings multiples down across the board.

3 Southeast Asian Country ETFs Surging In October

The economic slowdown in China may be appalling for the Southeast Asian economies, but there is a flip side to it that actually spells opportunity. Years ago, leading manufacturing companies across the world had turned to China as a production base in order to take advantage of low-cost facilities and inexpensive labor. However, the trend seems to be changing at a fast pace due to the economic turmoil in the world’s second largest economy (read: Asia-Pacific ETFs to Watch on a Surprise Rebound ). Due to the massive growth that China has experienced in the past, its wages and manufacturing costs have grown sharply. Further, the country’s huge population base and rising disposable income of middle class have slowly turned the economy from production-based to consumer-based. It is for these reasons that international companies are becoming more inclined toward taking their labor-intensive manufacturing projects to Southeast Asian nations due to lower labor costs and their ability to handle sophisticated production on a large scale. With this, the companies will be able to cater to an increasing consumer base in China as well as to conventional markets such as Europe and the U.S. The industrial relocation is expected to result in huge foreign direct investment (“FDI”) inflow into these emerging economies. Asian Development Bank expects Southeast Asia to record a GDP growth of 4.6% in 2015 and 5.1% in 2016. This compares with a GDP growth of 2.7% in 2015 and 2.8% in 2016 for the U.S., and 1.5% in 2015 and 1.8% in 2016 for the Eurozone, per forecast of World Bank . Based on these strong economic fundamentals and recent developments, we turn our focus to three Southeast Asian country ETFs that have experienced double-digit gains since the beginning of this month (read: 4 Safe Ways to Invest in Emerging Market ETFs ). iShares MSCI Indonesia ETF (NYSEARCA: EIDO ) Indonesia is struggling with weakening demand from China and low prices of commodities such as palm oil and coal. However, a set of stimulus packages announced by its President Joko Widodo recently is expected to spur growth in this largest Southeast Asian economy. The stimulus measures range from cutting energy prices for companies and giving insurance to farmers against crop failures to giving access to subsidized loans to salaried workers for small business enterprises. Before this, the government has already tried to revive the economy by easing permit processing and stabilizing a weak rupiah. The government aims to achieve a GDP growth of 7% in 2017 through enhanced infrastructure spending and accelerated FDI inflow compared to its six-year low GDP growth of 4.7% for the first quarter of the year. EIDO tracks the MSCI Indonesia Investable Market Index, measuring the performance of Indonesian-listed equity securities in the top 99% by market capitalization. The fund is heavily biased towards financials, accounting for nearly 40% of its assets. It has gathered about $298 million in assets and trades in an average volume of 687,000 shares. The ETF charges 62 bps in investor fees per year and was up more than 25% since the beginning of this month (till October 13, 2015). It carries a Zacks ETF Rank #3 (Hold) with a High risk outlook. Notably, two other Indonesian ETFs also recorded double-digit gains (more than 20%) in the same time frame. They include the Market Vectors Indonesia Index ETF (NYSEARCA: IDX ) and the Market Vectors Indonesia Small Cap ETF (NYSEARCA: IDXJ ) . iShares MSCI Malaysia ETF (NYSEARCA: EWM ) Malaysia is another Southeast Asian economy falling prey to the commodity rout and slowdown in China (its largest trading partner). However, the recent trading data from the country spurred investors’ interest. According to data released by the Ministry of International Trade and Industry, the country’s trade surplus increased to 10.2 billion ringgit ($2.4 billion) in August from 2.4 billion ringgit ($0.6 billion) a month earlier. Exports rose 4.1% year over year while imports fell 6.1% from the year-ago level. Despite the China slowdown, exports to the country soared 32.4% year over year. Meanwhile, exports to the U.S. and the European Union escalated 12% and 13.5% year over year, respectively. The surge in exports can be attributed to its weakening currency. According to Datuk Seri Abdul Wahid Omar , Minister in the Prime Minister’s Department, Malaysia has compensated the loss in oil and gas revenues from the slumping crude oil prices to some extent by implementing the Good and Services Tax in April. Further, its debt level (currently 54% of GDP) is expected to decline given the rising investments from the private sector. EWM follows the MSCI Malaysia Index, which is highly focused on the country’s financials, industrials and consumer staples sectors. The fund has garnered roughly $320 million in assets and trades in a hefty volume of 1.7 million shares per day. It charges 49 bps in annual fees and was up 19.1% so far this month. The fund carries a Zacks ETF Rank #3 with a Medium risk outlook Market Vectors Vietnam ETF (NYSEARCA: VNM ) Vietnam’s economy has been benefiting from low energy costs and very low inflation. Last month, inflation dipped to zero for the first time ever, as per General Statistics Office. Inexpensive labor and devaluation of the Vietnamese dong for the third time in a year by the country’s central bank have also been boosting the country’s exports and attracting foreign investments. The recently enacted Trans-Pacific Partnership (TPP) deal is further expected to boost export demand for Vietnamese goods. Bloomberg data showed that the country’s exports went up 9.6% year over year to $120.7 billion in the first nine months of the year. In the same period, pledged foreign investment soared 53.4% while disbursed foreign investment rose 8.4% from the year-ago levels. According to Asian Development Bank, Vietnam is likely to record the fastest growth in 2015 among the five major Southeast Asian countries tracked by the bank. The growth would be driven by burgeoning private spending, rising exports and increasing flow of FDI. VNM tracks the Market Vectors Vietnam Index, measuring the performance of stocks listed in the Vietnamese stock index, which generates at least 50% of its revenues from within the local economy. The ETF’s holdings are mostly from the financial sector (44%). The fund has amassed nearly $467 million in assets and trades in a volume of 457,000 shares per day. It charges 76 bps in fees and has returned about 13.3% since the beginning of October. The fund carries a Zacks ETF Rank #4 (Sell) with a High risk outlook. Link to the original post on Zacks.com