Tag Archives: ideas

The iShares Core Conservative Allocation ETF: AOK Is A-OK

An atypical fund of funds. An unusual construct containing non-traditional ETF sectors. Surprisingly good capital appreciation and consistent monthly dividends. Any individual investor who might catch equity and bond market news in bits and pieces during the course of the day is most likely feeling a bit of angst. Analyst and economist have seemed to become ‘polarized’ in their thinking. Some argue that impending inflation looms on the horizon; other that a fathomless deflation has already begun. Some argue that the global economy is still growing at an above average pace while others claim we’re on the verge of a deep global recession. Who has time to study markets and also go about the daily routine? Then again, what investor can ignore the change in sentiment over the past year? Well, there’s a way to continue with a well-disciplined, consistent investment strategy without taking undo risks and still do quite well. BlackRock’s iShares Core Conservative Allocation ETF (NYSEARCA: AOK ) ma y be the exact right place to stick with a long term disciplined investment plan and protect those hard earned retirement or future college fund savings until the time is again right to diversify. There are advantages in choosing this ‘fund of funds’ over traditional conservative investments. First, investment dollars are not being locked in as they would be if one had purchased U.S. Treasuries or a major financial institution’s certificate of deposit. Further, its Treasury holdings diversify across the span of all maturities. It’s not exclusively fixed income U.S. Treasuries, but also allocates among equities via other iShares “Core” funds including S&P 500 large, mid and small caps, European and Asia-Pacific core holdings as well as a small emerging market allocations. However, the greatest portion of all of the fund’s asset classes are U.S. focused, or global companies whose business is mostly in U.S. markets. (Data from BlackRock) In order to grasp this fund as a good safe haven play in uncertain times, a closer examination of the allocations, individual components and returns need to be examined in greater detail. For example, a large portion of the fund is classified as ‘ Other ‘ and as ‘ Supranational’ . That’s an unusual name for a sector to say the least! (Data from BlackRock) According to Investopedia, Supranational is: … an international organization, or union, whereby member states transcend national boundaries or interests to share in the decision-making and vote on issues pertaining to the wider grouping … As examples, the European Union, the International Monetary Fund, and World Trade Organization are ‘Supranational organizations’. Indeed, scrolling through iShares comprehensive asset listings, there is indeed a ‘Supranational’ sector. The breakdown is summed up in the following table, and well worth noting. Supranational Organization Fund Symbol Fund Weighting Brief Description African Development Bank Medium Term Notes AFDB 0.06% NGO for economic development in Africa Asian Development Bank Medium Term Notes ASIA 0.13% NGO for economic development in Asia Development Bank of Latin America CAF 0.01% NGO Financing and Technical Assistance Council of Europe Development Bank COE 0.06% NGO Social Investment Projects European Bank for Reconstruction Medium Term Notes EBRD 0.07% NGO for Entrepreneurship European Investment Bank EIB 0.43% Bank of the European Union for EU Member States Inter-American Development Bank IADB 0.17% NGO Financial and Technical Support Latin America and Caribbean International Bank for Reconstruction Medium Term Notes IBRD 0.24% WTO Sponsored for Developing Countries International Finance Corporation IFC 0.10% NGO Private Sector Development in Emerging Markets Nordic Investment Bank NIB 0.03 NGO Financial Development for Nordic and Baltic Countries Total 1.3% (Data from BlackRock) Most, if not all of the above mentioned Non-Government Organization (NGO) Banks do receive support from governments, or other supranational organizations but operate mostly independent of governments for the social and economic betterment in developing regions. The point of the matter is that the ‘medium term notes’ or other NGO investments seem reasonably secure since they are ‘backed’ by larger ‘parent’ organizations or part of a government’s foreign aid budget. The second undefined label, ‘ Other ,’ is a bit more complicated, to say the very least. Scrolling through the holdings, it seems that ‘Other’ includes a wide ranging, globally diversified collection of assets. The number of global holdings was quite surprising. There are small holdings of equities, bonds and agency notes allocated in over 52 countries. They are summarized in the Bar chart below. The sum total of ‘other’ holdings is 7.7%. Other Holdings: All less than 1.00%; Total: 7.7% of all holdings. (Data from BlackRock) Hence, there’s a bit more risk in that sector; however to be fair, these other holdings are extremely diverse, and very lightly weighted. What remains to be examined then, are the actual funds in the fund. A little care must be taken here, too. First, when the number of holdings is considered in each of the funds, all part of iShares “Core” ETFs theme, there is bound to be ‘overlaps’. So the fund does lack efficiency. However, with most of the Fund in U.S. Treasuries and S&P large cap equities, it should serve its purpose as a defensive holding in the current global economic environment. The investor should keep in mind, though, that the steady capital appreciation may have much the do with the extraordinary advanced economy bond purchasing programs and flight to quality trade into sovereign bonds. That being said, the fund has, in fact, performed rather well and has consistently paid monthly dividends since inception, November of 2005. (click to enlarge) As noted, the fund is composed mostly of fixed income; about 69%. Investors should also take note that it has become a common practice for corporations or governments to issue bonds denominated in stronger foreign currencies, for example, in Euros, Pound Sterling, Yen or U.S. Dollars. There are many good reasons for this strategy. It might be that two nations share a special trade relationship, for example the U.S. and Mexico. Another is to attract foreign fixed capital investments by having a large foreign currency reserve of the foreign investor. Also, it is a means to make bonds with weak domestic economies more attractive to investors seeking an added measure of security. However, the strategy could backfire if the issuer’s native currency weakens sharply against the stronger currency, thus making it more expensive to service the debt. Bond ETF Funds Symbol Number of Holdings Type of Holdings Distribution Yield Weighted Average Coupon Weighted Average Maturity Premium / Discount Expense Fee Weight in AOK Fund iShares Core U.S. Treasury Bond ETF GOVT 120 1 to 30 year U.S. Treasuries 1.36% 2.24% 7.05 years Premium 0.02% 0.15% 16.18% iShares Core Total USD Bond Market ETF IUSB 1547 Global U.S. Dollar Denominated Bonds 1.68% 3.26% 7.11 Years Premium 0.18% 0.15% after 0.01% waiver 41.93% iShares Core U.S. Credit Bond ETF CRED 2542 U.S. Dollar denominated, sovereign, supranational, corporate, local authority notes and bonds 3.35% 4.17% 10.18 years Premium 0.16% 0.15% 11.49% (Data from BlackRock) Next, the fund extends globally with comprehensive U.S., European and Pacific index equity holdings. It’s also important to keep in mind, as described above, that the “Supranational” and the “Other” holdings have a “theme” all their own as well as a structure just like a sector with merely a skeleton of weightings. However, in total, the ‘Other’ and ‘Supranational’ sectors carry a rather heavy allocation weight: Supranational ranks between Switzerland and China, and the “Other” is the fund’s second largest ‘geographic allocation’. Equity ETF Fund Symbol Number of Holdings Type of Holding Distribution Yield Price / Earnings Price / Book Equity Beta Premium / Discount Weight in AOK Fund iShares Core S&P 500 ETF IVV 505 S&P 500 2.20% 19.13 2.75 1.20 Discount -0.04% 13.83% iShares Core MSCI Europe ETF IEUR 991 Large, Mid and Small Cap Europe 4.02% 17.65 1.83 0.99 Premium 0.49% 7.31% iShares Core MSCI Pacific ETF IPAC 861 Large, Mid and Small Cap Pacific 2.45% 14.31 1.37 0.82 Premium 0.19% 4.62% iShares Core MSCI Emerging Markets ETF IEMG 1787 Large, Mid, Small Cap emerging Market 1.93% 19.21 3.13 0.72 Premium 1.10% 2.81% iShares Core S&P MidCap ETF IJH 401 Mid Cap S&P 500 1.51% 20.08 2.29 1.09 At NAV Par 0.00% 1.21% iShares Core S&P SmallCap ETF IJR 602 Small Cap U.S. Equities 1.30% 20.57 1.96 0.97 Premium 0.02% 0.51% (Data from BlackRock) Lastly, just a few quick facts about the fund in the table below. iShares AOK Symbol Number of Holdings Type of Holding Distribution Yield 12 Month Trailing Yield Expense Ratio Equity Beta Premium / Discount Average Volume iShares Core Conservative AOK 9 ETFs plus Supranational and Diversified Global Assets Mostly Equities plus Government, Agency, Corporate Fixed Income 1.46% 2.10% 0.39% 0.25% Discount -0.08% Appx 6000 daily; Recent 11,000 Appx (Data from BlackRock) All said and done, on the surface the fund seems rather simple: nine ETF holdings mostly in U.S. assets. However, when the details are examined, there’s nothing small nor simple about this fund, at all. Although a core conservative fund of funds, it’s quite diversified, global, comprehensive and complex! The main point being that either for short term safety or in terms of long term performance, the fund is, without a doubt, A-OK!

New Janus Mutual Fund Uses Tail Risk Analysis

Summary JAGDX is a global allocation fund (70/30) which uses tail risk analysis to mitigate risk. The Fund inception was in June 2015, and it has gotten off to a rocky start. But it may be worthwhile to track this fund to see how they manage a full market cycle. Overall Objective and Strategy The primary objective of the Janus Adaptive Global Allocation Fund (MUTF: JAGDX ) is to provide investors total return by dynamically allocating its assets across a portfolio of global equity and fixed income investments, including the use of derivatives. The fund attempts to actively adapt to market conditions based on forward looking views on extreme market conditions (both positive or negative) with the goal of minimizing the risk of significant loss in a major downturn while still participating in the growth potential of capital markets. On average, the fund provides 70% exposure to global equities and 30% exposure to global bonds (70/30 allocation). But the fund has the flexibility to shift this allocation and may invest up to 100% of its assets in either asset class depending on market conditions. Because of this, JAGDX will likely have above average portfolio turnover compared to other funds. The portfolio managers use two complimentary processes: a “top down” macro analysis and a “bottom-up” risk reward analysis. These processes use proprietary models which seek to identify indicators of market stress or potential upside. These models include an options-implied analysis that monitors day-to-day movements in options prices for indicators of risk and reward between asset classes, sectors and regions. Top-Down Macro Analysis: Focuses on how the Fund assets will be distributed between global equity and fixed income. They use a proprietary options implied information model, among other tools, to monitor expected tail gains and losses across the equity and fixed income sectors and adjust as necessary to mitigate downside risk exposure. Bottom-Up Risk Reward Analysis: Designed to identify underlying security exposures in order to maximize exposure to securities which will realize tail gains while minimizing exposure to securities expected to provide tail losses. Within the Fund’s equity positions, the managers will adjust sector, currency and regional exposures away from market cap weightings based on their evaluation of expected tail loss and gain. Within the Fund’s fixed income positions, they will adjust the credit, duration and regional exposures using the same analysis. The fund managers measure both extreme positive and negative movements known as expected tail gain (ETG) and expected tail loss (ETL). Portfolio construction is driven by the ratio of ETG to ETL, while targeting a desired level of portfolio risk with the goal of maximizing future total return. For more information on expected tail loss, take a look at this Wikipedia page on Expected shortfall . (click to enlarge) Source: rieti.go.jp Fund Expenses The Fund offers several classes of shares. JAGDX is available without a 12b-1 charge, but only if you buy the fund directly from Janus. The expense ratios for some of the share classes are listed below: JAGDX (Class D Shares): 1.01% JVGIX (Class I Shares- Institutional): 0.82% ($1 million minimum) JVGTX (Class T Shares): 1.13% (available on brokerage platforms) JAGAX (Class A): 1.07% (front-end load 5.75%) JAVCX (Class C Shares): 1.82% (deferred load 1%) Minimum Investment JAGDX has a minimum initial investment of $2,500. Past Performance JAGDX is classified by Morningstar in the “World Allocation” or IH category. The fund had unfortunate timing when it was first issued on June 23, 2015. As of the end of the third quarter it had dropped by 9%, although it has recovered a bit since then. It is still very early, but so far the Fund is lagging its peers. 1-Month 3-Month JAGDX +1.18% -4.16% Category(IH) +1.37% -3.89% Percentile Rank 61% 66% Source: Morningstar Mutual Fund Ratings The fund is too new to have a Lipper or Morningstar rating. Fund Management The fund is managed by two individuals: Enrique Chang: Chief Investment Officer, Equities and Asset Allocation. Joined Janus in September 2013, and has previously worked for American Century and Munder Capital Management. Holds a BS in Mathematics from Fairleigh Dickinson and a master’s degree in finance/quantitative analysis and statistics and operations research from NYU. Ashwin Alankar, PhD: Global Head of Asset Allocation & Risk Management. Joined Janus in August, 2014 and has previously worked for AllianceBernstein and Platinum Grove Asset management. Holds a BS in chemical engineering and mathematics and a master of science degree in chemical engineering from MIT. He also holds a PhD in finance from the University of California at Berkley Haas School of Business. Comments Tail risk hedging is designed to enhance return potential by: Helping to mitigate losses when a market storm hits. Provide liquidity in a crisis, allowing you to buy assets at distressed prices when others are forced to sell. Allow investors to take greater risks elsewhere in their portfolios. But as with any market timing strategy, there is always the possibility of market “whipsaws,” where markets trade up and down in a sideways pattern for extended periods and tail risk hedging may become an extra expense instead of a benefit. JAGDX has gotten off to a rocky start, but they have an interesting approach to risk management, and I will be tracking the fund to see how they do over a full market cycle. So far, they have attracted about $50 million in assets, so it is still uncertain whether the fund will be a long term success.

The Real Cost Of Hedging With Leveraged ETFs

Summary Scaled hedging has some advantages over usual market-timing. Leveraged ETFs are convenient hedging tools, but they suffer from a decay. This article calculates the additional cost of hedging a stock portfolio with leveraged ETFs. A timed, scalable hedging tactic has at least 3 advantages over usual market-timing consisting in going out of the market: adaptability to the risk level, lower transaction costs, and cashing all dividends. This previous article shows how to use a systemic risk indicator to scale a hedging position and protect my premium portfolio with SPXU . ETFs are not necessarily the best hedging tools, but they are available and understandable for all investors. SPXU has the advantage to allow hedging in an account where only long positions in stocks and ETFs are possible, and without margin. Like all leveraged ETFs, it has the drawback of suffering from a decay called beta-slippage. This article calculates the real additional hedging cost incurred by this decay in 2015 for SPXU, and for another leveraged inverse S&P 500 ETF: SDS . It also shows the decay of long leveraged ETFs. What is beta-slippage? If a volatile asset goes up 25% one day and down 20% the day after, a perfect double leveraged ETF goes up 50% the first day and down 40% the second day. On the close of the second day, the underlying asset is back to its initial price. At the same time, the perfect leveraged ETF has lost 10%: (1 + 0.5) x (1 – 0.4) = 0.9 This decay is called beta-slippage. It is a mathematical property of a leveraged and frequently rebalanced portfolio (leveraged ETFs may hold futures, options and/or swap contracts). In a trending market, beta-slippage can be positive. If an asset goes up 10% two days in a row, on the second day, the asset has gone up 21%. The perfect 2x leveraged ETF is up 44%: (1 + 0.2) x (1 + 0.2) = 1.44 It is 2% better than holding the underlying leveraged 2x on margin. Beta-slippage is path-dependent. If the underlying gains 50% on day 1 and loses 33.33% on day 2, it is back to its initial value, exactly like in the first example. This time, the perfect leveraged ETF loses one third of its value, which is much worse than the 10% of the first case: (1 + 1) x (1 – 0.6667) = 0.6667 Without a formal demonstration, it shows that the higher the volatility, the higher the decay. Hence the name of beta-slippage: “beta” is the best known statistical parameter of volatility. Of course, it is uncommon to have such price variations on an ETF’s underlying asset. These numbers are here to give an amplified vision of what happens with more realistic daily returns, day after day and month after month. (click to enlarge) SPXU in red, SPY in blue. Chart and data: portfolio123 Decay of S&P 500 ETFs in 2015 The next table gives the decay of leveraged ETFs on the S&P 500 index from 1/1/2015 to 10/15/2015 (9.5 months). It was a sideways and quite volatile market, with a worse than usual beta-slippage. The decay includes beta-slippage, and also tracking errors and management fees. Ticker Return Return of SPY x leveraging factor Decay (difference) Drag on portfolio SPY -0.52% SH (1xshort) -1.84% 0.52% -2.36% -1.18% SSO (2xlong) -3.92% -1.04% -2.88% -0.96% UPRO (3xlong) -8.69% -1.56% -7.13% -1.78% SDS(2xshort) -4.84% 1.04% -5.88% -1.96% SPXU(2xshort) -9.45% 1.56% -11.01% -2.75% When using SDS or SPXU for hedging, the hedging position represents 1/3 of the total portfolio (stocks + hedge) in the first case, and 1/4 in the second one. So the real drag on the portfolio was respectively 1.96% and 2.75% compared with shorting SPY. This is the additional cost of hedging the whole portfolio during the whole period (setting it in market neutral mode), which is not the best tactic proposed in my previous article (and service ). The cost of using leveraged ETFs with any of the proposed variable hedging tactics was much lower. Rebalancing the hedge weekly also lowers the decay due to beta-slippage (but not tracking errors). Finally, the cost is lower than losing all dividends when going out of the market in a classic market-timing approach, and it is likely to provide a better long-term risk-adjusted performance. SSO and UPRO also look like decent alternatives: SSO had the lowest portfolio drag. But short selling always incurs additional risks and borrowing costs. SDS and SPXU allow to hedge without borrowing cost and with less or no margin cost. These costs depend on the broker, so the best choice for hedging with an ETF may depend on your broker. If you have the skills and possibility to manage other instruments like futures, options, CFDs, they may be more cost-effective. Keep also in mind that the hedge and the stock portfolio can be in different accounts. If you like this article, you might be interested in the next ones. Click the “Follow” tab at the top if you want to stay informed of my free-access publications on Seeking Alpha. You can even choose the “real-time” option if you want to be instantly notified.