Author Archives: Scalper1

XLE: Diversified Exposure For An Oil Rally

Summary For those who believe the oil market is going to rally, an Energy Sector ETF can provide diversified exposure. I will compare to XLE to two viable alternatives. Broad energy market ETFs reduce single stock and sub-sector risk by providing up, down, and mid stream energy exposure. Introduction I am an ETF believer. I think ETFs reduce cognitive bias and risk. I believe they provide adequate exposure and diversification when utilized properly. Each ETF comes with different equity weightings, expense, volume, yield, correlation, etc., so I have spent time recently comparing key metrics to narrow down the vast number of ETFs on the market. Crude Oil has recently tanked into the mid to low 40s, and some investors believe now is the time to capitalize on a cheap energy market. For those interested in buying into oil and gas, I recommend you avoid risky ETNs like UWTI and UGAZ . Instead, I recommend buying a less risky long-term position in a broad market energy ETF. ETNs and Unnecessary Risk Certain leveraged ETNs provide direct exposure to the oil market; however, I believe some are unnecessarily risky. In this case, a largely traded ETN like the VelocityShares 3X Long Crude Oil ETN (NYSEARCA: UWTI ) would provide an attractive amount of liquidity based on its high trading volume. However, this type of fund is associated with a veritable laundry list of risks including tracking error, compounding risk, and expensive fees. These funds perform sub optimally in flat or declining environments, and they generally decline significantly over time. For more information on the risks of multiplied leverage and daily tracking risk see my article here . To help visualize the sharp decline, I’ll include a relevant graph. Other more conservative options include 1X ETNs that don’t suffer from the same long-term tracking error as a 3X ETN. (2X and 3X ETNs in particular are meant to be used by professionals to accomplish short term objectives.) An example of a direct investment in the oil market includes the United States Oil Fund ETF (NYSEARCA: USO ). In theory, USO would provide a much stronger correlation to the underlying oil market. However, I believe strongly that an ETF designed towards broad market exposure will outperform the underlying oil market. While the 1X ETN has a better correlation, and ETF is not limited strictly by the change in the underlying index (oil price). A well-crafted, highly liquid energy ETF, provides additional incentives such as dividends, and it achieves returns based on the weighted performance of its portfolio holdings. An ETN designed to track an index is limited to the fluctuations of the price of the underlying commodity. A sector ETF on the other hand is based on the growth capabilities and stock performance of its energy holdings. It is clear that XLE is more capable of mitigating its downside in a weak environment whilst maximizing returns in a bull market. I believe companies are able to develop strategies that allow for protection from fluctuations in price. An Oil Rally With Brent at 49.15 and WTI at 42.50, some believe the oil market has been dramatically oversold. The argument for an oil rally is essentially this: overly negative sentiment towards a supply gut and geopolitical events (like the Iran deal) has led to an unprecedented market sell off that has driven oil prices to six year lows. Now is the time to capitalize on cheap oil. We are currently in an environment similar to early March, and oil will return to prices closer to 55-60 dollars a barrel (WTI). If you hold to this belief, I recommend choosing an energy ETF that will perform optimally in a variety of environments. The integrated broad market exposure will allow the investor to reduce the risk of betting solely on the performance of the underlying commodity ((oil)). XLE & Two Alternatives Currently I am invested in the Energy Select Sector SPDR ETF (NYSEARCA: XLE ), and I will make the case for XLE in this article. In an effort to provide you with additional high quality options, I will also analyze the Vanguard Energy ETF (NYSEARCA: VDE ) and the iShares U.S. Energy ETF (NYSEARCA: IYE ). There are other energy plays. Some ETFs focus specifically on the E&P side while others have more exposure to global performance. I liked XLE, VDE, and IYE because they are more focused on North American Companies (Exxon (NYSE: XOM ), Chevron (NYSE: CVX ), Etc.) with a global presence in all aspects of the energy market. These ETFs are also have the largest amount of net assets and provide desirable liquidity. Correlation I always mention correlation because you want the ETF to closely track (if not outperform) the underlying index. If it does not do this, then the ETF is likely inefficiently weighted. With long plays, short term correlation is less important, but I will include a graph to show how each ETF performs relative to its index. ^SS1J data by YCharts I compared each ETF to the S&P 500 Equal Weighted Energy Sector Level % change. it is not a perfect correlation, but it does express the close relative grouping of each. Really all I’m looking for here is that each ETF does what it says it will do. Looking closer into 5-year returns, you’ll notice XLE outperformed both VDE and IYE by about 3.5%. Brief Portfolio Composition Look Each ETF is weighted towards each subsector of the broad energy market differently. For this reason, there is variety of tracking error and diversification differentiation. I made an excel sheet to express each sub-sector weighting. Portfolio Composition XLE VDE IYE Integrated Oil and Gas 32% 32% 34% E&P 29% 30% 31% Equipment & Service 17% 16% 17% Pipelines 10% 11% 7% Refiners 10% 8% 7% Drillers, Coal, Etc. 1% 2% 3% Key ETF Metrics I included some key metrics to make a valid comparison. While it does not necessarily dive into weighting or historical returns, it does help narrow down specific areas to think about. XLE VDE IYE Total Assets 11.28 Bil 3.68 Bil 1.19 Bil Avg. Volume 19.9 Mil 456,395 1.1 Mil Expense 0.15% 0.12% 0.45% SEC Yield 2.93% 3.01% 2.28% Turnover Ratio 5.25% 4.00% 7.00% Recommendation All three ETFs are tactical plays that offer exposure to the U.S. energy sector without taking on too much single equity risk. Historically XLE has performed the strongest in most market conditions. I attribute this to XLE’s large net assets and broad exposure (particularly downstream: refiners, pipelines etc.) Storage and Pipelines are not as hurt by excess supply because price reductions are mitigated by increased service demand. XLE has desirable liquidity, and it is extremely cheap (15 Basis points) with a near 3% yield. I believe XLE is the best energy ETF on the market. Disclosure: I am/we are long XLE. (More…) I wrote this article myself, and it expresses my own opinions. I am not receiving compensation for it (other than from Seeking Alpha). I have no business relationship with any company whose stock is mentioned in this article.

ETRACS Adds A New Leveraged MLP ETN To Its Lineup

UBS ETRACS has a new leveraged ETN tracking the S&P MLP index. The ETN holds the top eight weighted MLPs from the index. This is a speculative choice for income and it will likely be very volatile. On July 14th, ETRACS newest ETN started trading on the NYSE Arca. The fund is the ETRACS 2xMonthly Leveraged S&P MLP Index ETN (NYSEARCA: MLPV ). UBS (NYSE: UBS ) has a fair selection of MLP ETNs already, and MLPV will be the ninth addition to their list in the MLP category of ETNs. This security is an unsecured debt note that tracks the S&P MLP index with 2x leverage. The S&P MLP index tracks the leading partnerships trading on the NYSE and Nasdaq, which includes both MLPs and LLCs. The index tracks 79 companies in total. The leverage in this fund is reset on a monthly basis instead of daily. Distributions are made quarterly and linked 2x to the index. Here are some features of MLPV. Market Cap-19.2 million Expense Ratio-0.95% 2x Index Yield-12.49% Maturity Date-7/14/2045 Here are the holdings of the ETN and the percentage weighted. MLPV only holds the top eight out of the 79 total constituents that the index tracks. Enterprise Products Partners LP EPD 14.78 Energy Transfer Equity LP ETE 11.25 Energy Transfer Partners LP ETP 8.08 Magellan Midstream Partners LP MMP 6.43 Plains All American Pipeline LP PAA 6.19 Williams Partners LP WPZ 4.54 Buckeye Partners LP BPL 3.61 MarkWest Energy Partners LP MWE 3.61 Here is how MLPV compares to some similar funds. Ticker Symbol Yield Expense Ratio MLPV 12.49% 0.95% ETRACS 2xMonthly Leveraged Long Alerian MLP Infrastructure Index ETN MLPL 15.02% 0.85% iPath S&P MLP ETN IMLP 5.55% 0.80% This ETN might appease people who are chasing yield at the expense of high volatility and risk. It is definitely not the kind of fund you should use if you are seeking stable and conservative income. The downturn in the oil price last year has pummeled many MLPs, including IMLP which tracks the same index as MLPV. The one year chart below shows the four highest yielding MLP ETFs. (click to enlarge) The expense ratio of .95% is much too high for my liking, but the lowest ratio for any available MLP ETF is only .45% and some even have fees as high as 5-8%, which is extremely high for any ETF. The fund that has the .45% ER is the Global X MLP & Energy Infrastructure ETF (NYSEARCA: MLPX ), but it has a drastically lower yield of 2.66% when compared to most other MLP funds. The MLP ETF I like most for finding a balance between high yield and a decent expense ratio is the Direxion Zacks MLP High Income Shares ETF ( ZMLP) which currently yields 11.33% with an net expense ratio of .65%. With that said, one should only invest in this or any MLP with the expectation of volatility. With oil prices currently depressed, this might be a relatively safer time to initiate a position in these high yielding securities. This fund is structured as an ETN rather than an ETF, and there is good reason for this. The nature of MLPs gives them the advantage of legally escaping corporate taxes, but if the partnerships are in an ETF, then the corporate tax applies to the ETF itself and thus cancels out the tax advantage of MLPs. The drawback to the ETN however, is that the distributions are considered taxable income, which is not the case when an MLP is held individually. The tax consequences of owning MLPs can be very tricky, so it is always best to consult a tax professional before investing in any MLP or MLP fund and make sure you know exactly how you will be taxed. Due to the leverage used in this ETN, I consider it speculative income and potential investors should be aware of the risks. In addition to the leverage, MLPs present volatility due to being exposed to the energy sector. In the short time that MLPV has been trading, the underlying index has seen a bit of a sell-off which resulted in a price decline in the ETN. This dip might make for a good buying opportunity, but the volatility and risk should not be underestimated. Disclosure: I/we have no positions in any stocks mentioned, and no plans to initiate any positions within the next 72 hours. (More…) I wrote this article myself, and it expresses my own opinions. I am not receiving compensation for it (other than from Seeking Alpha). I have no business relationship with any company whose stock is mentioned in this article.