Author Archives: Scalper1

How To Limit Your Market Risk

Summary As the bull market has continued, so have predictions about its demise. We note the latest one, and the problem presented by such predictions. We discuss ways to limit market risk and describe one method. We show an example of that method using an automated approach. The Latest Bearish Prediction As the current bull market has powered on, there has been no shortage of predictions of its eventual end. The latest such prediction appeared in an article by James Fontanella-Khan and Abash Massoudi in Saturday’s Financial Times (“Value of megadeals this year beats dotcom-boom record to reach $1.2tn”). The authors detailed this year’s record volume of mergers and acquisitions and then warned, But if history is anything to go by, activity might well be at a peak. Data from Dealogic show that sustained deal-making cycles from 1997 to 2000 and from 2005 to 2008 were followed by sharp stock market falls The Problem Presented by Bear Market Predictions The problem presented by bear market predictions such as the one above is what to do with the information, particularly when we’re not given a time frame when we can expect the bear market to begin. If you got out of the market at the first one of these predictions, you would have missed most of the current bull market. On the other hand, if you do nothing to protect yourself, and the prediction comes to pass soon, you may regret your inaction. A solution to this problem is to stay invested, but take steps to limit your market risk. First, we should clarify the difference between market risk and idiosyncratic risk. Market Risk versus Idiosyncratic Risk Idiosyncratic risk , in a portfolio comprised of common stocks, can also be thought of as stock-specific risk: it’s the risk of something bad happening to one of your stocks. The chance that one of the companies you own shares of may become the subject of a criminal probe, as Volkswagen (OTCQX: VLKAY ) recently did , is an example of idiosyncratic risk. Idiosyncratic risk can be limited via diversification. Market risk , or systemic risk, is the risk of a decline in the market as a whole, as happens during crashes and bear markets. Since most stocks decline in those cases, market risk can’t be limited via diversification. In order to limit market risk, you need things in your portfolio that will go up in value when everything else is going down. Ways to Limit Market Risk Adding short positions. If you are short some stocks, most likely those will decline in value during a market decline (ideally, you’d want to be short stocks that will decline even if the market doesn’t decline). Seeking Alpha contributor Chris DeMuth, Jr. offered some specific short ideas in an article earlier this month (“Preparing for a Market Collapse, Part II”). One challenge with this is that you may need to allocate a significant percentage of your portfolio to short positions to significantly limit your market risk. If you allocate half of your portfolio to short positions, for example, by investing exclusively in pairs trades, you can eliminate all market risk, and make your portfolio market neutral. This requires some facility with short selling though. Buying inverse ETFs. These include unleveraged inverse ETFs such as ProShares Short S&P 500 (NYSEARCA: SH ), ProShares Short Russell 2000 (NYSEARCA: RWM ), and ProShares Short Dow 30 (NYSEARCA: DOG ), which seek daily returns equal to -1x the returns of the indexes in their names, and leveraged inverse ETFs, such as ProShares Ultra Short S&P 500 (NYSEARCA: SDS ), and ProShares Ultra Pro Short S&P 500 (NYSEARCA: SPXU ), which seek daily returns equal to -2x and -3x, respectively, the daily returns of their indexes. There are two problems with using inverse ETFs to limit market risk. The first is that, because these ETFs react to their underlying indexes in a linear fashion, as in the case with adding short positions to your portfolio, you would need to allocate a significant percentage of your portfolio to them to significantly limit your market risk. The second problem is that, unlike short positions in individual equities, which can potentially produce positive returns in a bull market, inverse ETFs will produce negative returns. So, they will act as a drag on your performance in up markets. For those two reasons, inverse ETFs are not a good way to limit market risk in a typical portfolio (they can be useful tools for market timers, or for those who wish to bet against a particular country or sector, but neither of those scenarios is the subject of this article). Hedging. An advantage of hedging over the previous two methods of limiting market risk is that, because options react to their underlying securities in a non-linear fashion, a small dollar amount allocated to them can protect a much larger underlying security or portfolio. We showed an example of that, with a particular put option on the S&P 500 ETF (NYSEARCA: SPY ), in an article about the August 24th market meltdown. On that day, SPY dropped 4%, the triple-levered inverse ETF SH rose 13%, and that particular put option on SPY (pictured nearby) was up nearly 80%. Hedging can be used to limit market risk in a diversified portfolio, or to limit both market risk and idiosyncratic risk in a concentrated portfolio. We offered an example of the second kind of hedging in a previous article (“Keeping a small nest egg from cracking”). In this one, we’ll look at hedging market risk in a diversified portfolio. Hedging Market Risk If your portfolio is diversified enough so that your idiosyncratic, or stock-specific risk has been ameliorated, you can hedge market risk by buying optimal put options on ETFs that track a relevant index. Puts (short for put options) are contracts that give you the right to sell a security for a specified price (the strike price) before a specified date (the expiration date). Optimal puts are the ones that will give you the level of protection you are looking for at the lowest cost. Step One: Choose A Proxy Exchange-Traded Fund Although mutual funds and some stocks can’t be hedged directly, you can still hedge a diverse portfolio of mutual funds and non-hedgeable stocks against market risk by buying puts on a suitable exchange-traded fund, or ETF. The first consideration is that the ETF will need to have options traded on it, but most of the most widely-traded ETFs do. The second consideration is that the ETF be invested in same asset class as your portfolio. Let’s assume your portfolio consists of large cap U.S. stocks, or mutual funds that invest in them. An ETF you could use as a proxy would be the SPDR S&P 500 Index , which, as its name suggests, tracks the S&P 500 Index. Step 2: Pick A Number Of Shares In order to hedge an equity portfolio against market risk, you would want to hedge an equivalent dollar amount of your proxy ETF. By dividing the dollar amount of your portfolio by the current share price of your proxy ETF, you can get a number of shares of the ETF that you need to hedge. Bear in mind that options contracts cover round lots of shares (generally, a round lot = 100 shares), so if your number of shares includes an odd lot, you can either hedge the next highest round lot of shares, or slightly over-hedge the next lowest round lot of shares. Step 3: Pick a Threshold Threshold, in this context, means the maximum decline in the value of your position that you are willing to risk. Generally, the larger the decline, the less expensive the hedge, and vice-versa. In some cases, a threshold that’s too small can be so expensive to hedge that the cost of doing so is greater than the loss you are trying to hedge. I sometimes use a 20% decline thresholds when hedging equities, an idea borrowed from a comment by fund manager Dr. John Hussman: An intolerable loss, in my view, is one that requires a heroic recovery simply to break even … a short-term loss of 20%, particularly after the market has become severely depressed, should not be at all intolerable to long-term investors because such losses are generally reversed in the first few months of an advance (or even a powerful bear market rally). Step 4: Find the Optimal Puts Given the time frame over which you are looking to hedge, you’d want to find the put options that would protect you against a greater-than-X% decline (where X is your threshold) at the lowest cost. When doing so, you’d want to keep in mind the cost of the hedge: for example, if you can only tolerate a 20% decline, and there’s a put option with a strike price 20% below the current market price, but it would cost 5% of your portfolio to buy it, then you are actually risking a 25% decline in that case. In most cases, the optimal puts will be out-of-the money, but on occasion they may be in-the-money. An Automated Approach Here we’ll use a hedging app to facilitate finding the optimal puts for an investor with a $787,000 portfolio invested in large cap U.S. stocks, who’s unwilling to risk a decline of more than 20% over the next six months. Steps 1-3: Since our investor is in large cap U.S. stocks, we’ll use SPY as a proxy ETF. So we enter “SPY” in the Ticker Symbol field in the screen capture below. As of Monday’s close, SPY traded at $196.46 per share, so to get our number of shares, we’ll divide 787,000 by 196.46, and enter the result, rounded to the nearest share (“4006”) in the Shares Owned field. In the Threshold field, we enter the largest decline our investor is willing to risk over the next six months, in percentage terms (“20”). Step 4: We tap “Done”, and a few moments later, are presented with the optimal puts: As you can see at the bottom of the screen capture above, the cost of this hedge was $9,960, or 1.27% of our investor’s portfolio value. Note that, to be conservative, the app calculated the cost using the ask price of the puts. In practice, you can often by puts for less (i.e., at some price between the bid and ask), so the actual cost of this hedge would likely have been less. How This Hedge Would Protect Your Portfolio Remember, the reason we picked SPY in this case is because our hypothetical investor’s funds were invested in blue chip US stocks. If those funds drop in value due to a market decline, most likely, the S&P 500 Index will have dropped as well. And if the S&P has dropped, the ETF tracking it, SPY, will have dropped too. If the S&P 500 drops more than 20% — if it drops 20.5%, 30%, 40%, or even more — the put options above will rise in price by at least enough so that the total value of a $787,000 position in SPY + the puts – the initial cost of the puts will have only dropped by 20%, in a worst-case scenario. Hedging A Portfolio Of Stocks And Bonds The example above is simplified in that we’ve assumed our hypothetical investor’s portfolio is entirely invested in equity funds. But what if he had some bonds or bond mutual funds? In that case, we could use a similar process to hedge his portfolio against market risk, except instead of using just one proxy ETF, we’d use one per each asset class. So, for example, if 60% of the investor’s assets were in blue chip US stocks, and 40% in investment grade corporate bonds, we might scan for optimal puts on a number of shares of SPY equal to 60% of the portfolio, and then scan for optimal puts on a number of shares of the iShares iBoxx $ Investment Grade Corporate Bond ETF (NYSEARCA: LQD ) equal to 40% of the portfolio. Editor’s Note: This article discusses one or more securities that do not trade on a major U.S. exchange. Please be aware of the risks associated with these stocks. Disclosure: I/we have no positions in any stocks mentioned, and no plans to initiate any positions within the next 72 hours. (More…) I wrote this article myself, and it expresses my own opinions. I am not receiving compensation for it (other than from Seeking Alpha). I have no business relationship with any company whose stock is mentioned in this article.

You Can Buy This 11.2% Yielding, Unleveraged Equity CEF Without Paying A Premium

STK pays a distribution yield of 11.2%. The fund is an unleveraged, option-income CEF in the technology sector. There are only five unleveraged, domestic-equity CEFS with positive returns TTM. STK has the highest yield and largest discount of that set. Let’s start with a tale. There’s a domestic-equity closed-end fund that is paying an 11.2% distribution from a quarterly payout that has been stable since the fund’s inception over five years ago. It is one of only five unleveraged, domestic-equity CEFs that is in positive territory TTM; the other four are well-covered CEFs with lesser distribution yields. Its investing strategy is conservative, focused on covered-calls to generate income. At least here on Seeking Alpha, it stays well under the radar with essentially no attention from the site’s contributors. Impossible, you say? Well take a look at Columbia Seligman Premium Tech (NYSE: STK ). I’ve been writing about this fund for two years . If any other Seeking Alpha contributor has paid any attention to it, it’s not obvious. Put STK in the search box and the only thing you get is a few articles by Left Banker. Readers are no more interested than Seeking Alpha’s authors: those articles are solidly among my least. Despite its impressive numbers, STK remains about as unnoticed as a fund can be on this site. STK has $254M in AUM, which places it as a mid-size equity CEF. Trading volume is modest but not so low as to present exceptional liquidity problems. The fund invests in the technology sector. Management looks for capital appreciation from the portfolio holdings, and generated income from a covered call option-writing strategy. Calls are written on the Nasdaq 100 or its ETF equivalent on a month-to-month basis. The aggregate notional amount of the call options will typically range from 25% to 90% of the underlying value of the fund’s holdings on common stock. The fund has a managed distribution policy. It pays $0.4625 quarterly and has done so since its inception date. There had been considerable return of capital earlier, but in the last two years RoC has totaled only $0.37. At its current price, that is an 11.15% yield, just about its midpoint for the past two years. (click to enlarge) The fund has faltered along with the tech sector since mid-year, but even so it has a 1-year total return of 4.15% which places it 18th of 192 general equity funds indexed by cefanlayzer . Of those 192, only 40 are positive for this stat. Return on NAV TTM is 3.08%, which places 25 of 192 funds. STK is unleveraged. Some 60% of the 192 funds in the general equity category use leverage greater than 5% to enhance their yields. Leverage comes with risk, of course, an important risk factor that STK avoids. The fund had been priced at a premium as high as 10%. Since mid-summer, that has fallen to a discount reaching -6% early in September. The discount is climbing again and stood at -0.72% at Friday’s close. (click to enlarge) Annual portfolio turnover is 60%. As of the end of July, the top 10 holdings were: (click to enlarge ) It is the highest yielding of the 12 equity CEF that are both unleveraged and have a positive return for the last 12 months. Only five domestic equity funds pass those filters; the other seven are single-country funds. Three of these are in healthcare and one is a general equity, option-income fund. None has a distribution yield that approaches STK’s, and all but one sells at a premium. They have all turned in better TTM returns than STK, the two Tekla funds having done so by a large margin. Fund Distribution Yield TR 1yr Prem/Disc Columbia Seligman Premium Technology Growth Fund ( STK ) 11.15% 4.15% -0.72% Tekla Life Sciences Investors (NYSE: HQL ) 8.19% 35.08% 0.93% BlackRock Health Sciences Trust (NYSE: BME ) 5.36% 8.19% 4.64% Tekla Healthcare Investors (NYSE: HQH ) 8.30% 27.35% -0.32% Eaton Vance Tax-Managed Buy-Write Income Fund (NYSE: ETB ) 7.99% 7.80% 4.83% I should add here that HQL, HQH and ETB are long-time favorites of mine. If I were making recommendations in specialty equity CEFs, ETB or one or more of its sibling option-income funds from Eaton Vance would be at the top of that list. Right up there would be either HQL or HQH, which I consider must-own funds for the CEF investor. But for someone already invested in those funds and looking for opportunities for diversification in other sectors, STK is, in my view, among the strongest candidates. In conclusion, I think it’s clear that STK remains one of the most attractive options among high-income equity CEFs. Its 11.2% yield is near the top of the category. The income comes primarily from option premiums, which tends to position a fund somewhat more defensively in uncertain markets. Income is stable and, with the managed distribution policy, is likely to remain so, albeit with some risk of erosive return of capital in edgy times. On the negative side, while the fund has performed well over the past two years, its performance was erratic prior to 2013. It has also faltered since mid-2015 as its sector and the overall market started to turn sour. This may call into question the ability of management to handle less positive market environments. Disclosure: I am/we are long STK, HQH, HQL, ETB. (More…) I wrote this article myself, and it expresses my own opinions. I am not receiving compensation for it (other than from Seeking Alpha). I have no business relationship with any company whose stock is mentioned in this article. Additional disclosure: I remind readers that this article does not constitute investment advice. I am passing along the results of my research on the subject. Any investor who finds these results intriguing will certainly want to do all due diligence to determine if any fund mentioned here is suitable for his or her portfolio. As always I welcome your comments and critiques, particularly from those readers who have contrary opinions.

A Fork In The Road For XIV

Summary Investors are currently torn between fear mongering pundits and semi-positive economics. An update on the contango and backwardation strategy. The longest period of backwardation in over four years has ended, for now. It has been a very interesting couple of weeks in regards to contango and backwardation. Unlike most of my readers, I don’t get the real time view of the market since I am in the classroom all day. I get a few minutes to check at lunch and that sums up my daily view of the market until around 8pm. My preferred strategy here to profit from the increased volatility has been the contango and backwardation strategy. You can find a detailed description of that strategy, with back testing, here . I always find it fun to go back and read my past writings. When I first started writing for Seeking Alpha, I really wasn’t that great. I believe I had to edit my first article around five times before they agreed to publish it. That is life. Pick yourself up and try again. When I first introduced this strategy on Seeking Alpha, I pointed out that it would not win 100% of the time. Because we are using contango and backwardation as entry and exit points, the strategy becomes difficult when you have futures that consistently bouncing into and out of backwardation. There are two basic options to overcome this problem: Continue on with the strategy. Remember that this strategy will historically protect you from severe losses. Move away from the strategy by holding your position. If you have a long-term positive view for the market and the economy, then you may want to buy and hold a short position in volatility rather than continuing to trade into and out of positions. Before entering these trades you should be fully aware of your potential risks verses the reward. Moving Forward I have stated this previously and it is now being confirmed in the markets. The VIX Index and VIX Futures have moved away from their historically low range. In the short-term I would expect futures to begin trading more towards the historical mean. Take a look at the chart below: (click to enlarge) The VIX will move through cycles of higher and lower ranges of volatility. Historically when the VIX trades in the 10-13 range for an extended period of time, it is followed by a prolonged period where the median VIX will move to a 17-25 range. In periods of economic distress or turmoil that range can be much higher. Let’s look at the VelocityShares Daily Inverse VIX Short-Term ETN (NASDAQ: XIV ) as a basis for discussion here. We know that XIV is driven by the first and second month’s contract within the VIX futures. If the front month’s contract were to fall to 13 from here, that would represent a theoretical gain of around 30% considering all factors. However, if the front month contract were to fall to 17 than XIV would experience a theoretical gain of around 12%. In both cases you would have the added benefit of contango to compound your gains over time. This would make your actual gain larger than what I am reporting for illustration purposes. Over the long-term XIV needs healthy levels of contango to build value and cannot just depend on falling futures contracts. When assessing risk and reward you need to factor in a potential sea change in the median level of the VIX futures. As you can see below XIV is only off about 17% from six months ago despite experiencing a severe haircut. All of this is can be attributed to the wealth built from contango. See below: We have just experienced the longest period of backwardation in over four years: (click to enlarge) Other events that could affect XIV and volatility The Senate and House are currently debating the next potential government shutdown which is scheduled for the end of this month. This would provide a healthy dose of volatility and negatively impact XIV. The larger question here is, is this now how the United States government operates now? I have written past articles, which have been mainly brushed to the side, on government debt levels. I believe our debt is unsustainable with current levels of economic growth. Ultra low rates have helped our interest payments. I would be more optimistic about our government debt if we had respectable politicians who could put their personal agendas aside and come together to actually solve problems. Much of what I see is theater and kicking the can down the road. For example, the current solution to the government shutdown is to pass a measure to get us to December. Slow growth is now the new normal. This has been confirmed by The Fed and recently several CEOs have come on record as stating the same. The concern with slow economic growth and low inflation is that it doesn’t take much to turn the tide the other way. These are larger economic problems that require us to come together and create solutions that last longer than two months. Conclusion For now, the days of ultra-low volatility are gone but not forgotten. Like the business cycle it will always come back around. Whether that will be in a couple months or several years remains to be seen. I remain optimistic on the U.S. economy and hope that Washington has the will power to create long-term optimism through compromise. We need to help foster genuine sustainable growth. Bubbles create great opportunities for us volatility traders, but hurt real people. We may get into a longer period of contango this week that would again align your trading with the contango and backwardation strategy. However, if the market remains choppy we could be moving between the two often. You will have to make a personal decision on how you want to proceed with your investments. Follow me here on Seeking Alpha for regular volatility updates and news you can use. As always, feel free to leave your professional comments below. We always create some great discussions. Disclosure: I/we have no positions in any stocks mentioned, but may initiate a long position in XIV over the next 72 hours. (More…) I wrote this article myself, and it expresses my own opinions. I am not receiving compensation for it (other than from Seeking Alpha). I have no business relationship with any company whose stock is mentioned in this article. Additional disclosure: The author reserves the right to trade into and out of any products mentioned here and generally will not post exact positions or trades in real time. The author does not give individual buy/sell advice.