Tag Archives: management

NRG Yield – Well Hedged Yield Co With Great Growth Prospects Going Into 2015

NRG Yield is well hedged between renewable and conventional assets. Coal fired plants is being phased out – conventional gas and renewables will pick up the slack. NRG Yield´s total power capacity will increase 25% in 2015. NRG Yield (NYSE: NYLD ) operates a portfolio of thermal infrastructure and both conventional and renewable generation assets in mostly Northeast, Southwest and California regions of United States. The company focuses on returning cash flow back to shareholders and has established a goal to reach a 15% dividend growth per year for the foreseeable future. Currently roughly half of the power generation is contributed by conventional, mostly gas fired, power plants while the other half is primarily wind. The company has long term agreements to sell the generated power with an average contract duration of 18 years, providing certainty, although ultimately market prices determine the profitability of the operations. The management is actively seeking to expand the company’s portfolio by looking to acquire projects from NRG Energy and other energy companies that look promising from the cash flow perspective. Currently NRG Yield and NRG have entered an agreement for the acquisition of the following NRG facilities – Walnut Creek gas fired power plant with a capacity of 500MW and three wind farms with total capacity of 285MW. The deal will be financed by cash and revolving credit facility and is to close during this quarter. It will bring the NRG Yield´s total power capacity to 3769MW which represents a more than 25% increase from the current levels. Revenue increase by the same order of magnitude is to be expected. NRG stands out from the rest of the Yield Co-s, because its portfolio is well diversified between conventional and renewable assets (around 50% conventional gas fired plants and 50% solar and wind) offering more flexibility to fit the constantly changing regulatory landscape. The company´s conventional assets comprise of gas fired power plants, which are suitable to meet the requirements of peak generation. This is especially important in the light of aggressive renewable takeover induced by both new technology and regulatory incentives, because renewables are bringing about more instability when it comes to consumption and production equilibrium. The crux of the matter here is that it pays to be diversified between relatively green gas fired assets and renewables as the older coal fired plants are quite aggressively phased out by political moves . The energy sector, especially companies in the renewable energy business, have unfairly sold off along with the oil prices, although oil has very little to do with electricity markets – generating only roughly 4% of power globally. Going forward, NRG Yield is a well hedged play in the energy sector and will gain from the coming regulatory moves to support renewables and greener technologies. After all, the old power capacity has to be replaced with something. Renewables and more economical gas fired power plants are likely to pick up the slack – both of which are in the core asset portfolio of NRG Yield. The company offers a dividend of 3.4% and great growth prospects for 2015 and beyond considering its total production capacity will increase by 25% next year. Now that you’ve read this, are you Bullish or Bearish on ? Bullish Bearish Sentiment on ( ) Thanks for sharing your thoughts. Why are you ? Submit & View Results Skip to results » Share this article with a colleague

Applying Graham’s Stock Selection Criteria To Dow Jones Utilities

Summary Ben Graham’s stock selection criteria are tried and true for the defensive investor. Public utilities, represented by the Dow Jones Utility Average (DJUA), are no longer sound investments for the defensive investor today. Great variations are found among the 15 DJUA components, allowing an enterprising investor to select stocks higher in both quality and quantity than the average. In a previous article , we revisited Benjamin Graham’s stock selection criteria, applied them to the thirty issues in the Dow Jones Industrial Average (DJIA), and found the DJIA unsatisfactory, mostly failing the valuation criteria. Below are Graham’s 7 stock selection criteria for the defensive investor: Quality 1. Adequate Size of the Enterprise . Graham suggested at least $100 million of annual sales for an industrial company, and at least $50 million of assets for a public utility. These 1973 figures can be adjusted for inflation to roughly $500 million of annual sales and $250 million of assets today (2014). Market capitalization, used by many as a proxy for size, confuses market valuation with business fundamentals. While the two are very much correlated, they may widely diverge at times, and paying exorbitant price for a small business is the exact opposite of defensive investing. 2. A Sufficiently Strong Financial Condition . Current ratio should be at least 2:1 for industrial companies; debt to equity should be no more than 2:1 for public utilities. 3. Earnings Stability . Some earnings in each of past ten years. 4. Dividend Record . Uninterrupted payments for at least the past 20 years. 5. Earnings Growth . A minimum of at least one-third in per-share earnings in the past ten years using three year averages at the beginning and the end. Multi-year average earnings smooth out cyclical earning variations and better reflect a company’s true earning potential. This corresponds to 2.9% compound annual growth, a relatively low hurdle. Quantity 6. Moderate Price/Earnings Ratio . Current price should be no more than 15 times average earnings of the past three years. Again, ignore single year earnings. P/E calculated using trailing twelve month earnings or predicted earnings for the next 12 months are unreliable. 7. Moderate Ratio of Price to Assets . Current price should be no more than 1.5 times the book value last reported. Alternatively, the product of P/E and P/B should not exceed 22.5. A stock meeting this alternative criteria may be considered as fulfilling both quantity criteria and admitted for investment. Application of Graham’s Criteria to the DJUA in 2014 We will now turn our attention to the public utilities, specifically the 15 prominent issues in the Dow Jones Utility Average (DJUA), to see how many, if any, meet these stringent criteria for the defensive investor. As a frame of reference, when Graham did his analysis for the DJUA in 1971, he found all fifteen issues meeting the criteria. In his own words: In comparison with prominent industrial companies as represented by the DJIA, [the DJUA] offered almost as good a record of past growth, plus smaller fluctuations in the annual figures–both at a lower price in relation to earnings and assets. Can the same be said regarding the DJUA today? The table below lists the 15 DJUA stocks with the Graham criteria (red means it failed; green means it passed). These data are obtainable from SEC filings here . Stock Ticker Price Assets Debt/equity Earnings stability? Yrs of Uninterrupted Dividends 2002-2004 Avg Earnings 2011-2013 Avg Earnings Earnings Growth Price to Earnings Book value Price to Book (P/E)*(P/B) # Criteria Met Duke Energy DUK 80.62 119656 1.00 Yes 29 0.43 3.55 725.58% 22.71 58.57 1.38 31.26 6 Exelon EXC 35.48 85264 0.95 Yes 34 2.13 2.39 12.21% 14.85 27.45 1.29 19.19 6 Southern SO 47.76 67654 1.19 Yes 32 1.98 2.36 19.19% 20.24 22.07 2.16 43.79 4 American Electric Power AEP 57.83 57925 1.15 Yes 44 0.49 3.22 557.14% 17.96 34.48 1.68 30.12 5 PG&E PCG 51.94 57884 0.93 Yes 10 3.11 1.95 -37.30% 26.64 33.25 1.56 41.61 3 NextEra Energy NEE 101.08 53383 1.54 Yes 31 0.05 4.54 8980.00% 22.26 43.10 2.35 52.22 5 Dominion Resources D 71.79 52279 2.15 Yes 30 3.20 2.69 -15.94% 26.69 19.82 3.62 96.67 3 FirstEnergy FE 37.19 51224 1.70 Yes 16 1.98 1.66 -16.16% 22.40 30.19 1.23 27.60 4 Edison International EIX 63.18 49475 1.14 No 11 2.85 0.70 -75.44% 90.26 32.95 1.92 173.06 2 Consolidated Edison ED 64.14 40667 0.99 Yes 44 2.59 3.68 42.08% 17.43 43.39 1.48 25.76 6 AES AES 12.79 38983 2.76 No 2 (2.23) (0.33) NM NM 6.14 2.08 NM 1 Public Service Enterprise PEG 40.46 34147 0.74 Yes 107 1.09 2.62 140.37% 15.44 23.89 1.69 26.15 5 NiSource NI 39.10 23710 1.62 Yes 28 1.24 1.37 10.48% 28.54 19.04 2.05 58.61 4 CenterPoint Energy CNP 21.71 22048 1.92 No 44 (4.70) 1.62 NM 13.40 10.41 2.09 27.95 4 Amertican Water Works AWK 51.42 15716 1.20 No 6 1.10 1.94 76.36% 26.51 27.44 1.87 49.67 3 DJUA 51334 1.40 Yes 31 19.19% 26.09 1.90 50.26 4 Unfortunately, the DJUA has changed for the worse since 1971. Not even one of the 15 issues meet all 7 criteria today. It is poorer in both quality and quantity compared to 1971, when utility stocks were inviting to the defensive investor. Salient Aspects of the DJUA Today 1. Size is adequate , with all fifteen issues easily surpassing the minimum $250 million of assets stipulated. 2. Financial condition is adequate in the aggregate, with an average debt to equity ratio of 1.4 for the DJUA, and 13 out of 15 issues meeting the criteria of debt to equity less than 2:1. 3. Earning stability is satisfactory in the aggregate , but 4 out of these 15 issues failed this criteria, a worse showing compared to the DJIA, where only 1 out of 30 issues failed. This is both surprising and alarming, suggesting that utilities are no longer as stable or defensive as they once were. 4. Most of the issues have at least 20 year history of uninterrupted dividends , with an average of 31 for the DJUA. Although satisfactory, the dividend history for the DJUA pales compared to the DJIA, which boasts an average of 67 years of uninterrupted dividends. 5. Earnings growth is very poor . The median earnings for the DJUA is only 19% over the past decade, or 1.77% compounded annually, which does not even keep up with inflation. Only 6, or fewer than half, out of 15 issues met the threshold of at least one-third of per-share earnings over ten years. 6. Ratio of price to three-year average earnings was 26.31 for the DJUA today, which is 75% greater than the maximum 15 required. The DJUA today is not only significantly more amply valued compared to its past, but even more overvalued than the DJIA today, which has a ratio of price to three-year average earnings around 20. 7. Ratio of price to net asset value was 1.91 for the DJUA today, which is 27% greater than the maximum 1.5 required. This is significantly more expensive compared to a ratio of 1.21 for the DJUA in 1971, but more favorable compared to the corresponding figure of 4.38 for the DJIA today. That DJIA commands a higher price relative to asset than the DJUA is by no means surprising, since the industrials tend to have more intangible assets such as brand name, patents, franchises, and trade secrets, which we generally do not find in public utilities. Not all 15 DJUA Issues Are Created Equal It is important to note that although none of the 15 DJUA issues met criteria, significant variations in quality and quantity are detected among the issues. Duke Energy, American Electric Power, NextEra Energy, Consolidated Edison, and Public Service Enterprise Group are five high quality issues meeting all five quality criteria, but failing one or both of the quantity criteria. These would be good stocks to buy after a correction. Stock Ticker Price D/E P/E Book value P/B (P/E)*(P/B) ROE Yield Duke Energy DUK 80.62 1.00 22.71 58.57 1.38 31.26 6.06% 3.94% American Electric Power AEP 57.83 1.15 14.96 34.48 1.68 25.09 11.21% 3.67% NextEra Energy NEE 101.08 1.54 22.26 43.10 2.35 52.21 10.54% 2.87% Consolidated Edison ED 64.14 0.99 17.43 43.39 1.48 25.77 8.48% 3.93% Public Service Enterprise PEG 40.46 0.74 15.44 23.89 1.69 26.15 10.97% 3.66% Average 1.08 18.56 40.69 1.71 32.09 9.45% 3.61% Interestingly, despite these five issues possessing better quality than the composite DJUA, they sell at lower prices relative to earnings and assets compared to the DJUA, with P/E only 71% and P/B only 90% of the composite index. Debt to equity is only 1.08, which is only 77% of the DJUA. Enterprising investors do not have to “pay up” for quality in this peculiar case, and can obtain higher quality utility stocks with lower risk at better prices relative to earnings and assets. Return on equity for this group is 9.45%, not bad given the regulatory environment of public utilities. Exelon also stands out, meeting both quantity criteria and 4 out of 5 quality criteria, failing only the earning growth criterion. The enterprising investor may considering buying if he deems the recent low earnings temporary and trusts the company to turn around eventually, while getting paid a 3.5% dividend to wait it out. On the other hand, AES is demonstrably an inferior issue compared to the average DJUA stock. It has significantly higher debt, multiple years of earnings deficits within the past decade, but nevertheless selling at higher price in relation to its net asset value. Edison International and American Water Works are also inferior issues to be avoided for similar reasons. Conclusion As we have seen, utility stocks, as represented by the DJUA, are unattractive investment options for the defensive investor today. Compared to 1971, utility companies have become somewhat more aggressive, but in vain, evidenced by poorer ten year earnings growth. The moat once enjoyed by regulated public utilities appears to have eroded. Despite the poor showing, the market amply values utility stocks today, much more so compared to 1971, and, in terms of price in relation to earnings. even more so than the DJIA today. This overvaluation is likely the result of the multi-decade low interest rate environment we are in today, since public utilities, with their higher dividend yields and generally higher debt on the balance sheet, are more bond-like compared to industrial issues. At the current extremely low levels, interest rate have nowhere to go but up, which will not hurt bonds, as I wrote in a previous article , but also bond-like investments like public utilities. The defensive investor is well advised to avoid the DJUA for now and wait for a more favorable entry point when interest rates revert to the mean.

TransCanada: Sandell Asset Thinks It Can Unlock Value With A Split

Summary Sandell Asset Management has moved up from activist campaigns in the restaurant space to the oil & gas pipeline space. Founder Thomas Sandell is pushing TRP to break itself up and utilize its MLP more. TRP is pushing back, given it might not benefit its Canadian shareholders. But with a below-average dividend yield and the Keystone XL overhang, something needs to be done. Sandell Asset Management is known for its heated battle with Bob Evans (NASDAQ: BOBE ), with its founder, Thomas Sandell, pushing for a split of Bob Evans’ restaurant and processed food business. “One of Sandell’s keys is to get Bob Evans to sell or spin-off the segment that produces products, such as sausages and mashed potatoes for sale in supermarkets. That’s because there are little synergies between that business and the restaurants it operates.” – Marshall Hargrave Well, he’s pushing the “split-up” thesis at another company, one that is quite the opposite. Sandell wants TransCanada (NYSE: TRP ) to spin off its power generation business, while also transferring its U.S. assets into an MLP. Known for the Keystone XL pipeline, TransCanada is much more than that; however, the stalling of the Keystone yet again puts in focus the fact that the company only offers a 3.7% dividend yield, well below its oil/gas infrastructure peers. It needs to generate more value for shareholders – with shares up 37% over the last five years, while the S&P 500 is up 80%. Sandell is just a small TransCanada shareholder. But that hasn’t stopped it from waging a proxy battle in an effort to get the company to reorganize its corporate structure. Sandell puts TransCanada’s fair value at C$75 a share, which is over 40% upside. Sandell Asset Pro Forma Portfolio (Q3’14) (click to enlarge) (Source: stockpucker.com) The Sandell Basics Sandell wants TransCanada to split off its nuclear, coal and other power generation businesses; granted, without those it would likely be afforded a higher multiple, where it would also be a more stable business and not as dependent on commodity prices. Sandell also wants more asset dropdowns to TC Pipelines (NYSE: TCP ) – a U.S. pipeline MLP that TransCanada has a stake in. It already has plans to drop down stakes in natural gas pipelines to TC, but Sandell wants more. TransCanada plans to drop down $1 billion in assets to TC over the interim; Sandell thinks that number should be north of $10 billion. Selling all its U.S. pipelines to the MLP would reduce costs, given the MLP pays no taxes. This isn’t Sandell’s first rodeo with this type of deal; last year, it pushed Spectra Energy (NYSE: SE ) to drop down its U.S. assets to Spectra Energy Partners (NYSE: SEP ). Using MLPs is a way to pass profits to shareholders without having to pay taxes. Many of the other major oil/gas infrastructure companies turned to MLPs years ago; think Williams Companies (NYSE: WMB ). Yet, the big counter-argument from some of TransCanada’s top shareholders, which are Canadian institutions, is that they would not benefit as much from the U.S. MLP tax benefits. Our Thoughts TransCanada’s dividend leaves something to be desired when stacked up against its oil/gas infrastructure peers. However, the pipeline industry is heavily regulated and has some pretty high barriers to entry, and as a result, is fairly stable. The counter-argument to Sandell is that the pipeline projects are highly capital-intensive. Canadian pipeline companies are self-funding most of their large projects, and don’t need equity funding. With that, its cash distribution payouts are subpar to American counterparts. However, by TransCanada dropping more of its assets to the MLP, it would be able to boost its distribution payout to shareholders. That means a higher yield and higher stock price for the company. So there would be initial upside in dropping the assets down, but it wouldn’t be a long-term positive. TransCanada would be forced to undergo equity issuances to fund future pipeline projects. Where We Stand Sandell sees two key catalysts: one being the spin-off, two being MLP dropdowns. The spin-off seems the least likely of the two, but it also creates the least value. If TransCanada does show signs of utilizing its MLP more, it would seem to be a buying opportunity for investors. However, we would caution the move for investors with a long-term horizon, and question the suggested benefits to dropping down more assets to its MLP.