Tag Archives: management

A Stock Picker Establishing An ETF Portfolio: My Plans For A Roth IRA

Summary Building a global portfolio with ETFs within a Roth IRA. A “set it and forget it” portfolio to supplement individual stock picks in a taxable account. Diversification amongst sectors, market caps, geographical regions, and asset classes. With tax season around the corner, and as one of the lucky souls who will likely receive a refund this year, I’ve decided it’s time to consider funding a Roth IRA with the proceeds. My current idea is to build a “worry free” global equity portfolio with low-cost exchange-traded funds, coupled with a core bond holding to help smooth out volatility and build a source of income. Pruning the portfolio of individual stocks I consider myself a value investor at heart, with a soft-spot for dividend growth investing. My individual account is filled primarily with dividend-paying, large-cap blue chips. I’ve recently liquidated some positions (Kraft (NASDAQ: KRFT ), General Mills (NYSE: GIS ), Chevron (NYSE: CVX ), Exxon Mobil (NYSE: XOM ), and ConocoPhillips (NYSE: COP ), to be exact) in my portfolio since my last update , and I’m now holding 23 companies. I decided to limit my exposure to some overvalued, highly-leveraged staples, due to my previously overweighted exposure to the sector. I’m also primarily “ex-oil” at this point, with the exception of BP (NYSE: BP ), which I still think has some value left. I decided to limit my exposure to oil despite considering Chevron as a “top pick” in the beginning of the year, because I’m not convinced oil will double to rebound near $100/barrel anytime soon, and despite much lower earnings prospects, the companies I once owned still trade near where they did when oil was much, much higher. I believe a time will come when I will be able to buy them back at much better prices. Most of the proceeds were rolled into Disney (NYSE: DIS ) and Gilead (NASDAQ: GILD ) pre-earnings, with the rest used to re-establish a position in Cisco (NASDAQ: CSCO ) and add to an existing position in Microsoft (NASDAQ: MSFT ), after a large, earnings-related sell-off. MetLife (NYSE: MET ) was also added, and I plan to continue to gobble up shares of cheap financial companies as the Fed prepares to raise rates. A paradigm shift After “cutting the fat” and changing my view on oil so suddenly, I decided that maybe I should “hedge my bets” a little by dedicating some capital to more passive investments. Sure, I’m doing fine so far with my picks while building a nice stream of dividends, but what if I’m not always so lucky? I also noticed that I was invested mostly, if not only, in large to mega caps within the U.S. as well, which may not necessarily be a bad thing. In today’s market environment, these types of companies tend to outperform, but this may not always be the case if rates normalize and bonds start paying respectable yields again. Then small caps may see their time in the sun again as well. So the first ETF I am considering will include smaller companies. The U.S. equity portion For the domestic portion of my ETF portfolio, I am currently considering the Vanguard Total Stock Market ETF (NYSEARCA: VTI ). This fund has a rock-bottom expense ratio of just 0.05% and covers a wide spectrum of U.S. stocks, including a 6.5% exposure to small caps and a 19% weighting assigned to mid caps. To complement VTI, I plan to add an allocation to real estate with the Vanguard REIT ETF (NYSEARCA: VNQ ). This will add another layer of diversification to my Roth IRA, as well as a higher yield of about 3.37% to offset the miniscule yield of roughly 1.88% offered by VTI. I plan to equally weight these two ETFs, and together they will compose about 36% of the overall portfolio and half of the overall equity portion of the portfolio. Moving overseas To gain exposure to international equity markets, I plan to equally weight the Vanguard FTSE Developed Markets ETF (NYSEARCA: VEA ) and the Vanguard FTSE Emerging Markets ETF (NYSEARCA: VWO ). These two funds will fill the other half of my equity allocation within my Roth. VEA carries a low expense ratio of 0.09% and VWO’s expense ratio sits at 0.15%. VEA gives me exposure to Europe, with core holdings such as Nestle ( OTCPK:NSRGY ) and Novartis (NYSE: NVS ), as well as Japanese markets with companies like Toyota (NYSE: TM ). Japan, the United Kingdom, and Switzerland make up half the geographical allocation of the fund, with countries like Germany, Australia, and other developed markets making up the rest. To offset slower-growing foreign markets, VWO offers more risk and potentially more reward, with over 20% of the weighting placed in China and almost 12% exposure to India. These markets should continue to grow at a rapid pace, and this fund gives me lower-risk exposure to this growth without the headaches of selecting individual companies in these countries. Holding my nose and buying bonds The last ETF I plan on adding to my Roth to round out the overall portfolio is the Vanguard Total Bond Market ETF (NYSEARCA: BND ). This will be my first foray into bonds, and I think this fund is a good anchor to begin the process of establishing an allocation to fixed income. The fund tracks the performance of the Barclays U.S. Aggregate Float Adjusted Index. The reason I selected this fund is due to its lower expense ratio of just 0.08%, as well as its lower duration of roughly 5.6 years. The low expenses are extremely important for a bond fund, and the low duration is important to limit risks related to rising interest rates. The fund also holds only high-quality bonds credit-wise with about 42% of the fund in investment-grade government bonds, roughly 23% in investment-grade corporates, and 20% in agencies. BND will be the anchor of my fixed income allocation for now, and when rates do begin to normalize, I may consider extending the duration and increasing the yield of my overall bond portfolio. I’ll accomplish this by adding shares of the iShares 7-10 Year Treasury Bond ETF (NYSEARCA: IEF ), and then even longer-dated treasuries with the iShares 20+ Year Treasury Bond ETF (NYSEARCA: TLT ). BND will account for about 27% of the overall portfolio, equal to my age of 27 years old. Conclusion Once funded, I plan to add these 5 ETFs to my newly established Roth to offset some of the risk of the individual stocks in my taxable account. As a retirement account, I want a globally diversified equity portfolio, anchored with investment grade bonds with only moderate exposure to rising rates. I believe the above-mentioned funds can achieve this goal in a simple, cost-effective way, and also in a way that allows me to easily rebalance if need be. While this ETF portfolio may be far from perfect, and now may not be the optimal time to be buying into these funds, I have a 30+ year timeline to let them marinate. I plan to rebalance at least annually as well. I also plan to shift more towards bonds the older I get, essentially creating my own “target date” fund. I decided to write up this portfolio concept to share it with the Seeking Alpha community, hopefully receiving some constructive criticism along the way. What do you think? Please let me know in the comments section below. Disclosure: The author is long BP, DIS, GILD, CSCO, MSFT, MET. (More…) The author wrote this article themselves, and it expresses their own opinions. The author is not receiving compensation for it (other than from Seeking Alpha). The author has no business relationship with any company whose stock is mentioned in this article. Additional disclosure: Articles I write for Seeking Alpha represent my own personal opinion and should not be taken as professional investment advice. I am not a registered financial adviser. Due diligence and/or consultation with your investment adviser should be undertaken before making any financial decisions, as these decisions are an individual’s personal responsibility.

Is There A Holy Grail To Investment Success?

It is possible to beat the market averages, otherwise managers like Warren Buffett and George Soros would not have done so consistently for many years. Investors should maximize the geometric mean of their outcomes instead of the arithmetic mean. Leverage destroys the geometric mean of returns over time, which is why it should never be used. The efficient market hypothesis only applies to equity exclusive investors and equity fund managers. Investors who manage concentrated stock portfolios and multiple asset classes can beat the averages. As Dr. Edward Thorp discovered the secret to beating the game of blackjack, investors can use probability to beat the stock market by skewing the odds in their favor. The Holy Grail is described in mythology as the cup that Christ drank from during the Last Supper, and is described as having mystical and miraculous powers. It is the stuff of medieval and Arthurian legend. It is also metaphorically described as something magical and elusive that may or may not exist. For investment professionals, the Holy Grail would be a formula for trading the financial markets that generates superior results. But to determine whether the Holy Grail exists or not we first have to define our terms. What results would classify a trading or investment formula as the Holy Grail? Would it be a strategy that simply beats the stock market averages or beats it by a lot? Some theorists believe there is no investment Holy Grail, just as some believe there is no secret to financial success. But throughout human history there have always been people who succeeded financially and those who did not. Is there a key that separates the successful from the unsuccessful? There must be otherwise it would not be happening, the same way it has happened for thousands of years. The proponents of the Efficient Market Hypothesis (EMH) and Modern Portfolio Theory (MPT) would have you believe that it is not possible to beat the market averages and that everyone should just buy an index fund and be done with it. But if that were true there wouldn’t be managers such as Warren Buffett and George Soros and numerous others who have beaten the averages consistently for many years. If the odds were against them, then they would have lost money or their results would have mirrored the averages. It is obvious they are doing something different from the norm. The question is, what is it? Proponents of EMH argue the averages cannot be bested because they take the performance results of the equity mutual fund industry as a whole and compare it to the market averages. The problem with this reasoning is they fail to make the connection that equity mutual funds as a whole are the market. Of course, their results will not significantly differ from the averages. That is like saying someone who bets on every horse in a race cannot lose. Of course they can’t. After years of experience and extensive research, I’ve come to the conclusion that the Efficient Market Hypothesis, while valid, only applies to equity exclusive investors with broadly diversified stock portfolios. In other words, it applies to individual investors who only buy stocks, as well as equity fund managers. For example, if you are a stock fund manager with a required minimum of 100 stocks in your portfolio, then you will be at a disadvantage. Over time, your results will not significantly differ from the averages, and transaction costs will leave your results below that of the averages. Mathematically speaking, there are two ways to beat the stock market averages: Have a concentrated equity portfolio Own multiple asset classes Leveraging a portfolio will not beat the market averages, as I will explain later. For example, let’s say we have a DeLorean and went back in time to the year 1990. For argument’s sake, let’s say you wanted to invest in equities, but could only buy 5 stocks. You decided to buy Microsoft (NASDAQ: MSFT ), Intel (NASDAQ: INTC ), Apple (NASDAQ: AAPL ), Starbucks (NASDAQ: SBUX ), and Wal-Mart (NYSE: WMT ). How would your portfolio have fared? We all know the answer to that. A portfolio of these winners would have left the market averages in the dust. Of course, hindsight is always 20/20, but this example demonstrates the power of a concentrated portfolio with superior performers. The trouble is, no one could have predicted that result let alone had the wherewithal to stay with those positions. The other way to beat the averages is to own multiple asset classes. Different asset classes, such as bonds, precious metals, real estate, and cash, can not only reduce the overall risk of your portfolio, but also make it more profitable. By holding different asset classes and rebalancing them regularly, investors will be profiting from market fluctuations. This differs from the margin speculator who is betting on the direction of the market. He will always lose in the long run to the balanced investor. The purely mathematical reason for this is because big losses hurt you more than big gains help you. Let’s say you start with $1000 and enter an investment that combines a 9 percent gain with a 9 percent loss. You would end up with $992. In contrast, let’s say a speculator entered the same position, but instead used 10 times the leverage. He would end up with $190 at the end. Roughly an 80 percent net loss! This is astonishing when you think about it, especially given the number of traders out there who are holding naked margin positions. When you ask most speculators about the potential risks of their trading systems, they think simplistically that a 90 percent gain combined with a 90 percent loss will be a wash with no net gain. This is incorrect because they aren’t grasping the concept of the arithmetic versus the geometric mean. With the arithmetic mean or simple average, you add up all the outcomes and divide by the number of outcomes. Whereas, the geometric mean multiplies the outcomes and takes the root of the number of outcomes. For example, let’s take 3 numbers: 1, 7, and 13. The arithmetic mean or simple average would be 7, whereas the geometric mean would be 4.5. (1 + 7 + 13) / 3 = 7 Simple Average ³√ (1 * 7 * 13) = 4.5 Geometric Average The geometric mean is calculated by multiplying the three numbers and taking the cube root of the product. Compound return is geometric average, not simple average. Leverage always lowers the geometric mean of outcomes over time because once again, big losses hurt you more than big gains help you. Every consistently winning manager emphasizes and follows this rule. Large losses destroy a portfolio, and reducing or eliminating leverage is the first step to increasing absolute return. Investors should always choose the game with the highest geometric mean of returns. This is the Holy Grail. However, if you define the Holy Grail as an investment system with all gains and zero losses, not even in the short term, then I would agree there is no Holy Grail. But a system that significantly beats the market averages over time could be classified as such. In 1962, a mathematician by the name of Edward O. Thorp published the book, Beat The Dealer, which presented the first popular mathematical system for beating the game of blackjack. The card counter was born. Contrary to popular opinion, the card counter was not immune to losses. He could lose half his bankroll during a losing streak. But if the counter kept playing, he would beat the casino significantly. It was just a matter of time. The odds were on his side. Dr. Thorp discovered the Holy Grail of beating the game of blackjack. It was a probability puzzle and he figured out how to skew the odds in his favor. The financial markets are nothing more than one giant probability puzzle. If others have beaten it, it is entirely possible that you can too. Disclosure: The author has no positions in any stocks mentioned, and no plans to initiate any positions within the next 72 hours. (More…) The author wrote this article themselves, and it expresses their own opinions. The author is not receiving compensation for it. The author has no business relationship with any company whose stock is mentioned in this article.