Tag Archives: ideas

NRG Energy – Adding Value With A Business Restructuring

Summary NRG Energy’s dream of building one of the first integrated fossil fuel and clean energy businesses will go unfulfilled. NRG Energy plans to spit off its clean energy business in a few months time, forming what will be known as “GreenCo.”. While the fossil fuel and clean energy business have many synergies, a separation of these two businesses is likely more viable in the current investment atmosphere. NRG Energy’s clean energy business will have to compete with ultra-competitive solar companies as a standalone company, which could prove to be a large obstacle. Over the past few years, NRG Energy (NYSE: NRG ) has stood out in its attempt to become the first major integrated fossil fuel and renewable energy company. While the company has successfully integrated these two businesses to some extent, there have been many obstacles that have limited NRG Energy’s overall success in this endeavor. There are many aspects of the distributed solar business, in particular, that do not mix well with the traditional fossil fuel power business. While these two businesses are not at odds in theory, the relatively unproven distributed solar business has made investors wary. As such, the company decided to split off its clean energy business into what will be known as “GreenCo.” Here is a chart explaining why NRG Energy is planning to split off its clean energy business. (click to enlarge) Source: NRG Energy Integration Problems NRG Energy’s plan to integrate a large clean energy business was not flawed in theory. NRG Energy could use the comparatively vast resources from its fossil fuel business to help catalyze its burgeoning clean energy business. This would put the company at a financial advantage against pure play clean energy companies like Vivint Solar (NYSE: VSLR ). However, the downsides associated with such integration seem to be outweighing the benefits. One of the main problems with this strategy is that fossil fuel and clean energy investors are generally of different mindsets. Fossil fuel investors are usually more interested in more stable businesses, whereas clean energy investors are more interested in growth. While NRG Energy’s clean energy business has enormous growth potential, many fossil fuel investors are likely off-put by the segment’s more risky nature. On the flip side, many clean energy investors are likely put-off by NRG Energy’s relatively low growth fossil fuel business. While there are indeed many investors that find the combination of businesses attractive, it seems as if separating these two businesses would attract more investors on balance. In addition, both the fossil fuel and clean energy businesses require a huge amount of attention. Pure-play distributed solar companies like SolarCity (NASDAQ: SCTY ) already have their hands full just managing their specific businesses. In NRG Energy’s case, distributed solar is just one segment in a larger business portfolio. It is unlikely that the company would be able to invest the optimal amount of time and energy into all of its businesses. While many synergies certainly do exist in NRG Energy’s fossil fuel and clean energy businesses, it seems as though separating the businesses would unlock more value due to the combination of current investor sentiment and limited attention/resources. Pure-Play Approach NRG Energy’s pure-play approach will likely attract more investors over the long-run. However, this also means that its renewable spin-off will be competing against the likes of SolarCity, Vivint Solar, etc, with much less assistance. The big financial advantage of NRG Energy’s clean energy businesses will mostly disappear once the company is spun-off from its fossil fuels business(NRG Energy is planning to give the GreenCo a financial limit of $125M in 2016). With that being said, NRG Energy’s clean energy business is still doing relatively well, and will likely succeed even without the help of the company’s main business. NRG Energy believes that there is ~$1B that can be unlocked by spinning off its clean energy business, which could very well be true given the benefits of separation. As investors will likely favor this strategy, as was mentioned before, NRG Energy is likely going down the correct path. Shareholders should benefit from the company’s planned pure-play approach, especially given the increasing complexities of the clean energy business. While CEO David Crane’s integrated energy plan was sound in principle, it may have been too early to implement this as investors have not fully committed to the idea. Obstacles While there are definitely many positives associated with a clean energy spin-off, the company could find it difficult to adjust as a pure play. Also, the company may have more trouble financing its operations as was mentioned before. Whereas the NRG Energy’s clean energy business currently has an advantage in financing due to its relationship with NRG Energy’s fossil fuel business, this will no longer be the case after the spin-off occurs. Competing against well-established companies like SolarCity and Vivint Solar could prove to be more difficult than expected. Regardless, the distributed solar market in particular is still incredibly underpenetrated, which means that NRG Energy’s GreenCo has great growth opportunities. Conclusion While NRG Energy’s grand plan to integrate massive fossil fuel and clean energy businesses has been derailed, the company is still undervalued at a market capitalization of $5.1B . Given that most of the company’s growth potential lies in its clean energy segment, NRG Energy may no longer be undervalued after it splits off its clean energy business. In theory, the synergies of NRG Energy’s fossil fuel and clean energy business should have outweighed the negatives of such integration. With that being said, investors are still largely uncomfortable with this idea, thus making the planned spin-off a smart decision for shareholders.

Global Macro – Generate Superior Returns With Less Risk

Summary Global macro not only generates higher returns but does it with far lower risk than equities. Long-only equities have been profitable, but has had some very long and deep periods of negative returns. Not only are stocks usually in a drawdown, but over the past 20+ years, we have had two massive drawdowns that took years to make up. We at The Macro Trader are obviously fans of Global Macro as an investment strategy and even philosophy. Fortunately, the data backs us up showing that global macro not only generates higher returns but does it with far lower risk than equities. The chart below shows how you would have done if you had invested $1,000 into the Credit Suisse Macro Hedge Fund Index, SP500, and Barclays Aggregate Bond Index since 1994. As you can see, the CS Macro Hedge Fund Index did drastically better than either stocks or bonds. To be more specific, the CS Macro Index beat the SP500 by 2.11 times and the AGG Index by 2.75 times. So, that shows the returns, but what about the risk taken to achieve these returns? (click to enlarge) Global Macro vs SP500 vs Lehman AGG Bond Index We have a few different charts to display the risks taken to generate the returns in each index. First, we will show the historical drawdown charts. A drawdown is simply anytime you are not at new highs in your account. If you have $100 and lose $5 you are in a -5% drawdown. The deeper the drawdown the higher the return needed to get back to breakeven and the math, while simple, can be tricky. For instance, if you lose -50% many think you need to make 50% to get to breakeven. The reality is that you need 100% to get to breakeven. In our case of being down -5%, you only need a 5.26% return to get to breakeven, but it gets harder the deeper you get. Looking at a drawdown chart of the SP500, you can see that not only are stocks usually in a drawdown, but over the past 20+ years, we have had two massive drawdowns that took years to make up. We know them as the dotcom crash and the GFC (Global Financial Crisis). It took the SP500 57 months to recover from the dotcom crash and 50 months to recover from the GFC. (click to enlarge) SP500 – Drawdowns At the opposite end of the spectrum, we have the drawdowns of the Barclays AGG Fixed Income Index. As you can see, the AGG Index has frequent but small drawdowns with the worst one barely dropping below -5%. It only took nine months for the AGG index to fully recover from the worst drawdown and three months to recover from the second deepest drawdown. (click to enlarge) Lehman/Barclays AGG Fixed Income Index Drawdowns Finally we have the CS Global Macro Index drawdowns. As you can see, its worst drawdown was a -26.79% and its second worst was -14.94%. It took 19 months to recover from the -26% drawdown and 19 months to recover from the -14.94% drawdown. (click to enlarge) Credit Suisse Global Macro Index Drawdowns Another way to show the depth and length of the drawdowns is to plot both the equity line as well as the new-highs line. In each of the next three charts, the green line equals the highest equity line got; notice that it never dips down, and the red line is the equity curve which goes both up and down. Here is the SP500. As you can see, while it hit a new high in 2007, it then went back down. In essence it took about 12 years before investors were really making new money. While this is a worse-than-“normal” period, it is also not the first or the second time that the stock market has had a rough decade. (click to enlarge) SP500 DD and NH Looking at the AGG Fixed Income Index, we see that the drawdowns are both shallow and short. If you were in the AGG Index, you would not make the most money but you also took very little risk. (click to enlarge) Lehman-Barclays AGG Fixed Income Index DD and NH Finally, we have the CS Global Macro Index. As you can see, the drawdowns, while larger than that of the AGG index, are far smaller than the SP500 index. It kind of takes the middle route in regards to risk but it drastically outperforms both in regards to return. (click to enlarge) Credit Suisse Global Macro Index DD and NH Another way to look at the risk and return is to look at the 12-Month Rolling Returns. At any point in the chart, you are looking at the returns you would have gotten if you had invested 12-Months ago. As you can see, the SP500-red line has the highest 12-Month returns, but also the lowest 12-Month returns. The AGG Index (green line) almost always shows positive returns, but it never has a really big year. Finally, the CS Macro Index (blue line) again comes somewhere in the middle. It is positive almost as often as the bond index but the 12-Month period to 12-Month period returns are less than stocks. (click to enlarge) Global Macro-SP500-AGG 12-Month Rolling Returns Basically global macro has lower volatility and more consistent returns than the stock market and almost as consistent returns and far more gains than the bond market. The main reason that this is possible is that as opposed to either the stock or bond index a global macro fund can go long and short anything and trade derivatives on anything. Most macro managers stick to liquid instruments but that still means you have hundreds if not thousands of tradeable instruments. The flexibility inherent in global macro allows you to always find a bull market somewhere whether that is being long stocks, short stocks, long the Australian Dollar, or short the Australian Dollar. You can bet on U.S. Treasuries against German Bunds or across almost any other market relationship you can think of. Not only is global macro flexible but macro managers are famous for stringent risk management practices. It is almost cliche, but in the end risk management is one of the keys to success in any trading approach and one of the most important things that separate macro from long-only buy and hold. What about claims in the press that “hedge funds have underperformed the SP500 since the GFC?” Well that is true but if you are picking only half a cycle, then it is probably not a fair comparison. In the chart below, you can see what happened to the CS Macro Index and the SP500 from the end of 2008 until the end of August 2015. As you can see the stock market is ahead. (click to enlarge) 2009-Now Of course that was just in a bull move when everything was headed up. If instead of the end of 2008 or the end of February 2009 we use 2007 as our starting point we get a drastically different result. In this case the flexibility and risk reduction inherent in the global macro approach shines as the CS Macro Index outperforms the SP500 with both higher returns and far lower risk. (click to enlarge) 2007-Now As far back as we have data global macro has outperformed both stocks and bonds across full market cycle. On the other hand, long-only equities have been profitable, but has had some very long and deep periods of negative returns. We are obviously biased towards global macro. We have a site and run a research service dedicated to it. You could say we drank the kool-aid and live and breathe this stuff. At the same time, however, many of the most successful money managers in history have been macro managers and the data shows that when done right, it can lead to both higher absolute and risk-adjusted returns. So, while we are indeed biased, we think that the case is fairly strong in our favor.

Atmos Energy – Great Company, But Overvalued

Summary Atmos Energy operates in highly favorable operating and regulatory environment. The company is a Dividend Aristocrat, having raised its dividend for over 31 years now. However, the company is overvalued. The yield is too low compared to historical averages and the company’s overspending of its cash is worrisome. Atmos Energy Corporation (NYSE: ATO ) operates primarily as a regulated natural gas distributor, in fact it is one of the largest pure play natural gas operations in the United States. Based out of Texas, he company has operations stretching across eight states serving over three million customers. Given its location, Atmos Energy has access to cheap natural gas sourced from the Val Verde and Barnett shale plays. Further bolstering the company is a favorable regulatory environment. Both Texas and neighboring Louisiana have company-friendly utility policies in the form of annual rate filing mechanisms. These allow Atmos Energy to put in requests to modify its rates on an annual basis without filing a formal rate request. What this means is that the company can recover a majority of capital expenditures and commodity prices from customers quickly. These two factors have created a prime situation for Atmos Energy’s utility operations. Overall, Atmos has been a consistently profitable business that has rewarded shareholders greatly over the years. The company is a member of the oft-observed Dividend Aristocrats index (companies with 25 or more years of consecutive dividend increases), which has led to Atmos Energy finding itself in many retail investor portfolios due to its strong yield and proven track record. But is the future for Atmos Energy as bright as the past? Company Track Record (click to enlarge) Total revenue has grown at a 3.74% pace since 2011. In reality, this understates growth as the company sold some of its natural gas distribution operations in four states as part of a streamlining initiative (Missouri, Illinois, Iowa, Georgia). Investors can see that this divestiture was wise as it likely contributed to improved operating margins from fiscal 2013 forward. Like I do with most utilities, I like to see how cash flow is used by the company. Dividend-paying companies have two main uses of cash outside of operational activities; capital expenditures and dividend payments. At worst, I like to see cash flow from operations = capital expenditures + dividend payments. As you can see, Atmos Energy has traditionally run a deficit on this metric. What this means is that the company has to raise cash to meet all of its obligations, either through debt or a dilutive stock offering. As should have been expected, Atmos Energy raised $386M net cash in 2014 from a stock issuance (9.2 million shares), the announcement of which sent shares plunging (shares have since recovered). Atlas has no plans to slow down capital expenditures, which the company has said is needed primarily to maintain pipeline integrity and general system improvements. In fact, capital expenditures may reach $1.1B annually by 2018 according to company estimates. I would expect Atmos to raise some funds in the debt markets in 2016 or 2017, possibly in the range of $500M, given its solid credit ratings. Application of the Dividend Discount Model As I highlighted in a prior article , the dividend discount model is a great way for conservatively valuing dividend companies, especially those with stable and proven track records. We can generate a valuation of Atmos Energy with the following assumptions: $1.65 expected dividend next year, an 8% discount rate, and 2.5% average annual dividend increases going forward (below the current three year average of 2.9% but below the ten year average of 2.0% increases). P = 1.65 / (.08 – .025) P = 1.65 / 0.055 P = $30/share This gives us a fair value of $30.00/share, indicating that shares might be overvalued based on the expected future cash flows to be generated from our investment. Further support of this relative overvaluation can be found in the five year dividend yield average for Atmos, which has historically averaged 3.80%, which would put fair value of shares at the $44-45/share range. Given the yield currently stands at 2.81%, I believe that shares may have appreciated in value too much compared to recent company earnings. Conclusion Atmos has a strong set of operations in a highly desirable area. Management history of rewarding shareholders is healthy. However, this status has made the company’s stock a bit crowded, especially given the risks related to the expected continued leveraging given the operational cash flow deficit. In my opinion, for investors that want safety, there are better picks in the utility or dividend aristocrat space that would present less material downside risk. At current prices, I simply could not become a shareholder.