Tag Archives: ideas

China Stumbles But Does Not Fall: ETFs To Play The ‘Chinese Century’

The Chinese government has the will and resources to create national wealth while helping smooth economic bumps and market volatility. Chinese ‘B’ shares trade at a PE of 21.6 (‘A’ shares trade at 16.7x), comparable with the S&P 500. FXI (iShares) is the largest China ETF, while Vanguard’s VWO is 27% invested in China. China’s stock market has been on a roller-coaster ride in 2015, with the largest China ETF, the iShares China Large-Cap ETF ( FXI), down 8% YTD. Recently, China’s market has been in the news, first for its huge run-up, then for its dramatic decline. I wanted to share some perceptions on the strength of China, and its internal resolve, that I think provides some perspective on the long-term opportunities in the Middle Kingdom. (click to enlarge) Source: Yahoo! I recently had the privilege of attending a conference in Miami sponsored by the Financial Times- ‘Trade Links With The New Latin America.’ While I learned a tremendous amount regarding the resource, political and financial/structural issues regarding trade with Latin America, my biggest takeaways were about China. A discussion regarding China is especially timely, as that country’s recent stock market meltdown, government response and growth forecasts have been in the news in recent months. Below I will discuss several of the more interesting observations; many of the observations will be directly attributable to Charles Tang, Chairman, China-Brazil Chamber of Commerce & Industry. Mr. Tang is not formally a part of the Chinese government, but spoke as if he was representing the views of his government, and equally as important, was thought by other panelist and conference participants to be representing the views of the Chinese government. Non quotes are my perception of comments by Mr. Tang and other participants at the conference (bankers, scholars, businesspeople and government representatives). I will start with the summary observations, and support with examples throughout the article. 1) China views the US as a competitor eager to keep the growing country down, 2) China has literally trillions of dollars saved to support its economy, help its friends and to secure its goals, 3) China is generous with its friends and does not (think it) attach moralistic strings to its aid/deals. 4) China will do what it takes to gain power, influence and respect. A very frank and telling quote, “The current administration will not be successful in dealing with China.” My initial thought was, are we (the US) playing the same game (as the Chinese)? It is well-known that we tend to view events and actions through our own prism. The conference brought into stark focus how actions can be viewed very differently depending on your ‘side.’ For example, actions by the US (and the West in general), that may be thought as motivated to help our partners or our economy are viewed by the Chinese as structured to isolate (China). The Trans Pacific Partnership (“TPP”), while controversial in the US for a variety of domestic reasons is viewed in China as a tool to exclude and isolate that country. While not a primary motivator, I think the Chinese, at least perceptually, have a point. A quote was, because the TPP excludes China “it will be difficult to be very successful.” The International Monetary Fund (“IMF”) is well known as the agency that tries to help troubled economies. From China’s perspective, it has been excluded from participation; ironic to China as it is the great creditor nation (and those that have the most say at the IMF are big debtors- bad at running their own economies!). Having successfully kept China out of the leadership of the IMF, the country decided to start its own development bank, the Asian Infrastructure Investment Bank (“AIIB”). Despite heavy lobbying by the US against joining the bank, the UK was the first western country to join; the headline in the New York Times summed up the situation: “Stampeded to Join China’s Bank Stuns Even Its Founder.” China’s success in getting the AIIB off the ground promises to increase the country’s stature and influence. Unfortunately (for the US), China’s gain is at the expense of the US. Poorly played by the US; the lack of influence (with heavy lobbying) is a real sign of diminished US influence. China wants its currency, the Renminbi, to be a trade and reserve currency, like the US Dollar and (to a lesser extent) the Euro. China’s attempts at currency control and manipulation have hurt itself in this regard. However, as conference attendees demonstrated, banks such as Commerzbank ( OTCPK:CRZBY ) are eager to facilitate Renminbi transactions (as opposed to having a transaction conducted in US Dollars or Euros); it appears almost inevitable that China will eventually succeed in having its currency join the US dollar as a trading and (later) a reserve currency. China will need to remove most capital controls before the currency can truly be a reserve currency. China is not “on the rocks.” While tacitly acknowledging some clumsiness in dealing with the stock market situation, the real point emphasized was that China has $4 trillion (with a ‘T’) to play with. Interesting quotes included: (the first part partially in jest), “China is not going broke . . . it has tremendous financial depth.” And, there have been “a few hick-ups” in transitioning China to a consumer economy. Also, “China was a slight cold . . . the US has had pneumonia for the last 16 years.” Note the confidence, arrogance and (by being arrogant) lack of confidence. In talking about the financial situation, it was noted that almost none of Chinese property is subject to a property tax. The imposition of a property tax was noted as a lever that could be used to support indebted regions. From a practical point of view, China feels, instead of exploiting Africa as the colonial powers (or the post-colonial rulers) did, they have “transformed Africa into a continent of hope.” After hearing this quote, I did realize there was a certain ‘Alice in Wonderland’ feel to the perspectives of the Chinese and the West. However, China feels its investments in Latin America are a counter-point to the historically more exploitive investments of the US. Coincidently, on September 3, the Financial Times reported that China had made a $5 billion loan to beleaguered Venezuela. While risky from a credit point of view, China is clearly buying influence with money (even at the risk of default) and securing supplies of commodities (in this case oil). China also continues to invest in Brazil, though more cautiously as the Petrobras (NYSE: PBR ) scandal has made the money-for-influence transaction more challenging (who know who will be in power in six months). However, never one to miss a good crisis, China is “taking advantage of opportunities to buy assets” in Brazil. Like Donald Trump, you have to admire the straightforward audacity of the Chinese even if you do not respect the underlying morals/motivations. Frankly, lending when all others have left is a great way to gain favors and bargains. Another interesting quote regarding investment, “Chinese money has no conditions.” Of course Chinese money has conditions, just not the moral conditions or requirements used to satisfy local political constituents (e.g. unions) in the US. While I don’t know if anything I heard was entirely new. What was new to me was the blunt, forthright and unapologetic way the Chinese perspective was presented; hearing a direct Chinese justification was certainly different than a Western interpretation. My takeaways are: China is buying assets and influence on the cheap. China is amoral and guided by enhancing security and stature. China views the US as attempting to isolate the country; China’s response is to create parallel institutions that will ultimately weaken US influence. The US would be better to compromise (in some areas) than compete. China’s $4 trillion war chest gives it flexibility and a long-term perspective the US (and the West) cannot match. A parallel thought is the impact to the US if China stops buying US Treasury bonds (he who has the gold . . .). China’s arrogance and insecurity will cause it to waste a good portion of its war chest (e.g. Japan in the 1990’s). The influence China’s money will buy, will be somewhat like what the old Soviet Union used to buy. Effective, but generally in areas where ideology trumps economics. China’s no-strings attached money come with ‘other’ strings (see: Godfather Part I). The US is wasting goodwill and money in threatening the Chinese; the Chinese are proud, determined to be respected and will create a lose-lose situation if necessary (e.g. Creation of the AIIB). The lack of a well-articulated and consistently applied economic policy is hurting the US vis a vis the Chinese. I would regard any commitments the Chinese make with respect to climate change as credible as the commitments the Iranians make on nuclear weapons (probably well-intentioned when made, but not likely to be adhered to in the long term). I mention this topic as it is one where the US would likely make concessions in international agreements in order to get cooperation from the Chinese. While much of the above was not directly about the stock market, much of it has a direct impact. In short, China is playing the long-game to enhance its financial and strategic power. The government will do what is necessary for stability. From a market perspective, that means investors benefit from the government’s desire to increase overall national wealth and use its resources to smooth bumps and minimize market volatility. The macro growth of 7% (or even 5% or 6%) is a strong tailwind. Last week’s announcement changing the one-child policy is a new (with a nine-month lag ) tailwind. The Shanghai Stock Exchange reports an average PE ratios of 16.7x and 21.6x for ‘A’ shares (those available for purchase by mainland Chinese) and ‘B’ shares, respectively. By comparison, the S&P 500 currently trades at a 21.9x PE ratio. While confidence in earnings reported by Chinese firms is not as high as those reported by US firms, the valuations provide a sense of relative value. Despite recent volatility, given Chinese tailwinds, valuation does not seem excessive. From a long-term perspective, China should be considered a part of a well-diversified portfolio. FXI is the largest ETF (0.74% expense ratio), though eight other China ETF’s exist with assets of more than $100 million (see the ETF database for more information). Personally, I participate in China via the Vanguard FTSE Emerging Markets ETF (NYSEARCA: VWO ) (0.15% expense ratio). VWO’s portfolio is 27% China.

Valuation Dashboard: Consumer Discretionary – November 2015

Summary 4 key factors are reported across industries in the Consumer Discretionary sector. They give a valuation status of industries relative to their history. They give a reference for picking stocks at a reasonable value. This article is part of a series giving a valuation dashboard by sector of companies in the S&P 500 index (NYSEARCA: SPY ). I follow up a certain number of fundamental factors for every sector, and compare them to historical averages. This article is going down at industry level in the GICS classification. It covers Consumer Discretionary. The choice of the fundamental ratios has been justified here and here . You can find in this article numbers that may be useful in a top-down approach. There is no analysis of individual stocks. A link to a list of individual stocks to consider is provided at the end. Methodology Four industry factors calculated by portfolio123 are extracted from the database: Price/Earnings (P/E), Price to sales (P/S), Price to free cash flow (P/FCF), Return on Equity (ROE). They are compared with their own historical averages “Avg”. The difference is measured in percentage for valuation ratios and in absolute for ROE, and named “D-xxx” if xxx is the factor’s name (for example D-P/E for price/earnings). The industry factors are proprietary data from the platform. The calculation aims at eliminating extreme values and size biases, which is necessary when going out of a large cap universe. These factors are not representative of capital-weighted indices. They are useful as reference values for picking stocks in an industry, not for ETF investors. Industry valuation table on 11/2/2015 The next table reports the 4 industry factors. For each factor, the next “Avg” column gives its average between January 1999 and October 2015, taken as an arbitrary reference of fair valuation. The next “D-xxx” column is the difference as explained above. So there are 3 columns for each ratio. P/E Avg D- P/E P/S Avg D- P/S P/FCF Avg D- P/FCF ROE Avg D-ROE Auto Components 18.17 15.33 -18.53% 0.8 0.62 -29.03% 45.52 21.23 -114.41% 10.44 3.9 6.54 Automobiles 14.35 17.67 18.79% 1.02 1.06 3.77% 16.58 21.97 24.53% 15.1 0.21 14.89 Household Durables 19.24 15.46 -24.45% 0.89 0.59 -50.85% 31.14 16.33 -90.69% 9.04 5.3 3.74 Leisure Equip.&Products 23.65 17.82 -32.72% 1.2 0.84 -42.86% 35.83 22.05 -62.49% 9.54 2.63 6.91 Textile,Apparel,Luxury 17.6 16.34 -7.71% 1.07 0.71 -50.70% 27.43 17.23 -59.20% 12.15 7 5.15 Hotels, Restaurants, Leisure 28.5 21.67 -31.52% 1.43 1.04 -37.50% 30.66 24.18 -26.80% 8.96 4.51 4.45 Div. Consumer Services* 26.05 21.49 -21.22% 1.41 1.4 -0.71% 15.58 18.64 16.42% 1.08 11.35 -10.27 Media 21.57 23.31 7.46% 1.81 1.55 -16.77% 22.28 19.9 -11.96% 3.44 -3.45 6.89 Distributors 19.47 14.32 -35.96% 1.76 0.48 -266.67% 36.08 16.28 -121.62% 10.24 3.18 7.06 Internet&Catalog Retail 30.77 37.37 17.66% 1.35 1.8 25.00% 24.02 32.11 25.19% 4.31 -14.7 19.01 Multiline Retail 20.3 19.41 -4.59% 0.5 0.48 -4.17% 25.27 26.81 5.74% 7.1 10.44 -3.34 Specialty Retail 19.9 17.95 -10.86% 0.6 0.56 -7.14% 25.05 21.87 -14.54% 11.78 9.85 1.93 *Averages since 2005 Valuation The following charts give an idea of the current status of industries relative to their historical average. In all cases, the higher the better. Price/Earnings: Price/Sales: Price/Free Cash Flow: Quality Relative Momentum The next chart compares the price action of the SPDR Select Sector ETF (NYSEARCA: XLY ) with SPY. (click to enlarge) Conclusion The Consumer Discretionary sector has widely outperformed the broad market in the last 6 months. It hit a new all-time high last week. Automobiles (the group of car and motorcycle manufacturers) and Internet & Catalog Retail look the most interesting industries now: they are underpriced relative to historical averages for the 3 valuations factors, and quality is above historical averages. However, there may be quality stocks at a reasonable price in any industry. To check them out, you can compare individual fundamental factors to the industry factors provided in the table. As an example, a list of stocks in Consumer Discretionary beating their industry factors is provided on this page . If you want to stay informed of my updates on this topic and other articles, click the “Follow” tab at the top of this article.

Investors May Be Doing The Wrong Thing (Again)

Summary In this article, I delve a little deeper into my recommended Model Stock Portfolio funds to try to get a fresh perspective that cannot be found elsewhere. The snapshot that emerges is intended to further help result-seeking investors judge what might be the best choices going forward within a group of already highly recommended funds. Investors often invest heavily in funds whose holdings are tilted toward previously strongly performing but overvalued stocks, rather than from those with a better chance of showing future strength. It should go without saying that no single or even multiple selection criteria hold the key to which funds you should hold on to and with what emphasis in your portfolio. However, in my Newsletters down through more than 15 years, I have tried to make the case that, while there are numerous good funds (or ETFs) to choose from, the best long-term results are more likely when, even within a list of highly rated funds, one focuses on those composed of stocks that are relatively more undervalued vs. those made up of stocks which have already been “discovered,” and therefore, likely have seen most of their potential run-up in prices already. Expressed a little differently, some funds may have achieved their recent success by their emphasis on holding a preponderance of already recognized “winning” stocks and stock categories and continuing to ride those winners. A simple example is funds that hold a relatively large proportion of what has proven to be an amazing stock, Apple (NASDAQ: AAPL ). The same may be said for funds that have a relatively high proportion of recently high-performing technology stocks as a group. Two such funds I have consistently recommended are the Vanguard Growth Index Fund (MUTF: VIGRX ) (or its equivalent ETF) and Fidelity Contra (MUTF: FCNTX ). The former currently holds 7.5% of the fund in Apple and 26% of the fund in Technology companies. The latter holds about 3.8% in Apple and 29% in technology stocks. Given the excellent performance over recent years of these fund components, the heavy weighting has given a boost to both these funds (and many other similarly categorized Large Growth funds), and been a contributing factor as to why these two funds have beaten the S&P 500 Index on average over many years. But another even more striking example can be cited: funds investing heavily in Health Care, such as PRIMECAP Odyssey Growth (MUTF: POGRX ), Vanguard Health Care (MUTF: VGHCX ) or Vanguard Health Care ETF (NYSEARCA: VHT ). Not surprisingly, the latter two highly narrow-focused funds have nearly all their investments in this one sector, a stock subclass that has on average returned over 20% annualized over the last five years. While, unfortunately, I have never included any of these funds in my Model Stock Portfolios, I have recommended at least one fund with greater than a 20% weighting in Health Care currently, namely T. Rowe Price Value Fund (MUTF: TRVLX ), This fund’s track record against its Large Cap Value category peers has been admirable over the last five years. Beyond this, though, is where things get very murky. As an investor, do you want to stick with funds that invest heavily in stocks and categories that have shown a lot of past momentum in the hopes that this outstanding performance will continue? Or, do you want, perhaps, to trim down your holdings of such funds, and instead for at least the next few years, favor funds more heavily invested in stocks and categories that may show even greater potential for success, namely those choosing the majority of their investments in potentially less overvalued segments of the market? Unfortunately, there is no clear-cut answer to this dilemma. Therefore, it is probably wisest to own funds weighted in both, that is, funds that invest heavily in stocks with strong current momentum, and, those that can potentially become better choices when the former momentum-driven stocks start to lose altitude. Unfortunately too, one of investors’ biggest downfalls happen when the winds of change periodically cause a big shift in the performance of previously winning stocks, categories, and the funds investing heavily in them. While we haven’t seen any such sort of massive shift going back perhaps to the 2007-09 financial crisis, or even before, we know that many investors tend to suffer when outsized bets on previous winners turn into outsized losses. While no one can say with any degree of certainty if and when the next reversal of fortune may befall the current crop of big winners in stocks, what follows is an analysis of which of my recently recommended funds are holding stocks perhaps overloaded with past winning, but now likely overvalued, categories of stocks. And, on the other side of the coin, can I identify which of my recommendations are more oriented toward current ownership in categories that seem to be less likely to underperform, when the next big shift in stock market winners and losers takes hold and impacts fund results for possibly years into the future? A Closer Look at My Model Stock Portfolio Funds In the first list of funds below, I analyze broadly diversified domestic stock funds recommended (or recently so) in my Model Stock Portfolio to examine the above issue. I also include some additional funds that I hold in my own personal investment portfolio. Funds more broadly classified as international stock or narrow-focused sector funds, however, are not included. For each listed fund, I have scored the fund on the extent to which it is currently (based on latest data available) invested in either what appear to be fairly priced categories of stocks, or on the other hand, seemingly overvalued categories, based on my own proprietary research. See the note at the bottom of the list for the meaning of scores. Each fund is listed in a descending order of score, starting with those least likely to be overvalued . Those with greater potential for coming out on top over the next 3 to 5 years, assuming my scoring method proves valid, are listed closer to the top; those that may be strong winners recently, but having a greater potential for underperformance when their current chosen and often overvalued stock selections lose momentum, are found further down the list. Note: If one compares the results shown in the list with the allocations shown in my Oct. ’15 Model Stock Portfolio , the results may not completely agree with the recommendations there because the listing below is based on different data. It should come as no surprise that all of the funds below, because they are diversified mixes of stocks, will have a moderate proportion of their investments in overpriced stock categories, given what we have previously labeled as an overall overvalued market. Therefore, inclusion in this list below in no way ensures that most or all of these funds will prove to be great investments over the next few years. But relatively speaking, we chose these funds, that is, those that are managed, aiming to beat market indices, or at least do well against their similarly classified peers. However, it is very possible, too, that perhaps some of the best investments for the next few years instead may turn out to be in funds that are invested internationally, as generally speaking, these fund categories seem to be relatively more undervalued than U.S. domestic funds are at the present time. Best Model Stock Portfolio Choices (from most highly rated* to less highly rated) Fund Name (Symbol) Score 3 Yr. Return (thru 10-27) (ann.) Category 1. T. Rowe Price Equity Income (MUTF: PRFDX ) 76% 10.6% Large Value 2. Vanguard US Value (MUTF: VUVLX ) 74% 16.5% Large Value 3. Fidelity Large Cap Stock (MUTF: FLCSX ) (tie) 70% 15.5% Large Blend 3. Vanguard Equity-Income (MUTF: VEIPX ) (tie) 70% 13.9% Large Value 3. Vanguard Small Cap Index (MUTF: NAESX ) (tie) 70% 14.7% Small Blend 6. Vanguard Extended Market Idx (MUTF: VEXMX ) 68% 15.0% Mid-Cap Blend 7. T. Rowe Price Value (tie) 65% 16.4% Large Value 7. Vanguard Mid Cap Index Adm (MUTF: VIMAX ) (tie) 65% 17.1% Mid-Cap Blend 9. Vanguard Small Cap Growth Index (MUTF: VISGX ) 64% 13.6% Small Growth 10. Vanguard Windsor II (MUTF: VWNFX ) 63% 13.4% Large Value 11. Vanguard 500 Index (MUTF: VFINX ) 62% 15.8% Large Blend 12. Fidelity Contrafund (tie) 58% 17.1% Large Growth 12. Vanguard Growth Index (tie) 58% 16.9% Large Growth 14. Fidelity Low-Priced Stock (MUTF: FLPSX ) 55% 15.2% Mid-Cap Value 15. AMG Yacktman Service (MUTF: YACKX ) 39% 11.7% Large Blend *Note: Top rating possible is 100%; lowest possible rating is 0%. A score of 70%, for example, means that 70% of the stocks in the fund are judged to be within a class of stocks that is fairly valued while 30% are within a category that my research indicates is overvalued. Of course, funds in the above list that are managed (that is, not index funds) will have the option of switching out of overvalued categories if it is decided to make such a switch. Index funds must stick to their mandated benchmark and typically will not change their composition unless the underlying index changes. Funds with the Most Investor Assets As a basis of comparison with the above funds and to see alternative funds chosen by investors that have currently attracted the most investor assets, it is also informative to look at similarly derived scores of the most popular funds using the same criteria to rate each in terms of my measure of fair vs. overvalued stock portfolio composition. (The first list also includes some of the biggest funds; it also includes a few that mirror some of the most important indices such as the S&P 500, so we won’t show funds that are identical or nearly so to those there. And, I again exclude international and sector funds.) Biggest Funds by Assets (from most highly rated* to less highly rated) Fund Name (Symbol) Score 3 Yr. Return (thru 10-27) (ann.) Category 1. Dodge & Cox Stock (MUTF: DODGX ) 71% 16.1% Large Value 2. Vanguard Value ETF (NYSEARCA: VTV ) 69% 15.0% Large Value 3. American Funds Washington Mutual A (MUTF: AWSHX ) 67% 14.4% Large Value 4. American Funds Invmt Co of Amer A (MUTF: AIVSX ) (tie) 64% 15.0% Large Blend 4. Vanguard Total Stock Mkt Idx Adm (MUTF: VTSAX ) (tie) 64% 15.8% Large Blend 6. American Funds Fundamental Inv A (MUTF: ANCFX ) (tie) 61% 15.3% Large Blend 6. American Funds AMCAP A (MUTF: AMCPX ) (tie) 61% 17.0% Large Growth 8. American Funds Growth Fund of Amer A (MUTF: AGTHX ) 54% 16.8% Large Growth 9. Fidelity Growth Company (MUTF: FDGRX ) 50% 19.6% Large Growth 10. T. Rowe Price Growth Stock (MUTF: PRGFX ) 48% 19.9% Large Growth *Note: See the Note under the first table. If you look carefully over these two lists, you will notice that the majority of funds with the highest, that is, best forward-looking scores, are categorized as Large Value funds. And, almost equally noticeable, most of the funds with a large percentage of already “discovered” stock categories, especially in the second list, are Large Growth funds. What this suggests is that the best opportunities for investors for the next several years would appear to lie in US stock funds that are classified as Large Value. Many Large Growth funds, if this analysis is valid, are likely to perform less strongly than Large Value funds because investors may have already realized most of the performance benefits of this category and are more likely to find both a greater degree of safety in Large Value funds when market conditions are no longer as bright, and a greater degree of return potential due to their less overvalued composition. While there is no way to know for sure how long the current “momentum bias” will continue, as it very well may, investors might always want to keep in mind that over long periods of time, the best way to make money in stocks is to establish and maintain your positions when prices are relatively low. It seems apparent, however, that looking at the second list featuring those funds investors have the most money invested in, they seem to be opting for many funds, including unmanaged index funds, with a relatively greater degree of already “stretched” types of stocks.