Tag Archives: ideas

VFINX/VBLTX Power-Up: Replace VFINX With UPRO Or SPXL

Summary I recently wrote about VFINX/VBLTX portfolios, and how to choose an asset allocation to maximize returns for the level of volatility you can tolerate. Swapping VFINX for a leveraged S&P 500 ETF makes the maximization game much more profitable. You can achieve a greater expected return for any particular level of volatility. You lose the benefit of completely free trades in a Vanguard account, but the improvement in expected returns is definitely worth it. Mathematically, using a leveraged version of VFINX allows you to increase your allocation to VBLTX, capturing a greater percentage of its alpha. I believe UPRO/VBLTX (or SPXL/VBLTX) can be an excellent core portfolio for many investors. VFINX and VBLTX In a recent article, I looked at the performance of various two-fund “stocks and bonds” portfolios comprised of Vanguard mutual funds. I paired the Vanguard 500 Index Fund Investor Shares (MUTF: VFINX ) with Vanguard bond funds of various durations, and found that the long-term bond fund, the Vanguard Long-Term Bond Index Fund (MUTF: VBLTX ), was generally the best choice in terms of maximizing expected returns for a particular level of volatility. Here is a slightly modified version of a graph from that article (curves for the other bond funds removed): (click to enlarge) To get you up to speed, the upper-right point on the curve shows that for a portfolio comprised of 100% VFINX, and 0% VBLTX, the mean and standard deviation of daily gains going back to 1994 are 0.042% and 1.192%, respectively. The next point, which represents 90% VFINX and 10% VBLTX, results in a slightly lower mean (0.041%) and considerably lower standard deviation (1.061%), making it arguably the better portfolio. You can see how mean and standard deviation vary as VFINX allocation increases in 10% increments all the way to 0% VFINX, 100% VBLTX. Notably, standard deviation is minimized for 25.8% VFINX, 74.2% VBLTX. So if you were a relatively conservative investor who wanted to take on no more than 75% of the S&P 500’s volatility, you would look at the second-from-the-right vertical line, and see that to maximize expected return you would need to be just below the 3rd data point from the right, or a VFINX allocation slightly below 80%. A nice aspect of a two-fund strategy based on Vanguard mutual funds is that trading costs are very low. The mutual funds have very low expense ratios and can be traded commission-free in a Vanguard account. 3x VFINX and VBLTX Something magical happens when you swap VFINX for a hypothetical 3x daily version of it: you get a drastically better expected returns for any given level of volatility. Take a look: (click to enlarge) (Note: Data points represent 10% allocation steps for VFINX/VBLTX, and 5% allocation steps for 3x VFINX/VBLTX. Also, daily gains for the hypothetical 3x VFINX fund were calculated by simply multiply VFINX gains by 3 and then subtracting a fixed value corresponding to a 1% annual expense ratio.) You can see that the blue curve offers drastically better mean returns than the red curve. For example, 90% VFINX/10% VBLTX (second point from the right on the red curve) has a standard deviation of 1.061% and a mean of 0.042%; 30% 3x VFINX/70% VBLTX (7th point from the bottom on the blue curve) has a very similar standard deviation of 1.064, with a much greater mean of 0.058%. In addition, with 3x VFINX/VBLTX you have the option of taking on more volatility than the S&P 500, and getting an excellent additional return. For example, if you can tolerate up to 50% more volatility than the S&P 500, you can achieve an 84.3% greater mean return (51.2% 3x VFINX/48.8% VBLTX: standard deviation 1.788%, mean 0.077%). CAGR vs. MDD I think the mean vs. SD plot best describes the performance of various VFINX/VBLTX portfolios. But CAGR vs. MDD is also very interesting, and highlights the huge improvement you get with 3x VFINX. (click to enlarge) You see drastically better raw returns for various maximum drawdowns with 3x VFINX/VBLTX compared to VFINX/VBLTX. One interesting special case, 35% 3x VFINX/65% VBLTX has about the same MDD as VFINX (55.4% vs. 55.3%), but with a much greater CAGR (14.7% vs. 9.1%). Also noteworthy, the CAGR for 3x VFINX/VBLTX portfolios starts to decrease once the allocation to 3x VFINX reaches about 70%. How to Invest in 3x VFINX Vanguard does not offer a leveraged version of VFINX (or any leveraged funds for that matter), but there are several 3x daily S&P 500 ETFs to choose from. The ProShares UltraPro S&P 500 ETF (NYSEARCA: UPRO ) and the Direxion Daily S&P 500 Bull 3x Shares ETF (NYSEARCA: SPXL ) are two options. They both have expense ratios right around 1%, and both have done an excellent job tracking 3x daily S&P 500 gains over their 6-7 year lifetimes. I know some readers will take issue with the fact that my results are based on sort of “fake” data, as I just multiplied daily VFINX gains by 3 to simulate a leveraged version of the fund (or, equivalently, the performance of UPRO or SPXL before they were around). I wouldn’t worry about this too much. All signs indicate that daily leveraged ETFs like UPRO and SPXL have very minimal tracking error. Mathematical Basis Intuitively, the reason 3x VFINX/VBLTX provides better mean returns for a given level of volatility is that it allows for a greater allocation to the alpha-generating VBLTX. Suppose you can achieve a volatility of 1% with either 90% VFINX/10% VBLTX or 40% 3x VFINX/60% VBLTX. Which will have greater expected returns? The second, because it retains 40% of VBLTX’s alpha rather than only 10%. Now for a more mathematical approach (feel free to skip). Consider a VFINX/VBLTX portfolio where C represents the proportion allocated to VFINX, and (1-C) the allocation to VBLTX; and a 3x VFINX/VBLTX portfolio where D represents the proportion allocated to 3x VFINX, and (1-D) the allocation to VBLTX. Suppose we start at the top-right part of the first figure (i.e. C = D = 1) and decrease both C and D to the point where both portfolios have the same volatility. It is easy to see that D will be less than C, i.e. you will have to allocate less to 3x VFINX than to VFINX to achieve a certain portfolio volatility. So the two portfolios have the same volatility, and D < C. Let's compare their expected returns. Let X = daily VFINX return and Y = daily VBLTX return. The first portfolio's daily return, say Z 1 , is given by Z 1 = C X + (1-C) Y. The second portfolio's daily return, say Z 2 , is given by Z 2 = 3D X + (1-D) Y. How do Z 1 and Z 2 compare? Let's subtract their expected values, and see if we can figure out if the difference favors one or the other. E(Z 2 ) - E(Z 1 ) = [3D E(X) + (1-D) E(Y)] - [C E(X) + (1-C) E(Y)] = [3D - C] E(X) + [(1-D) - (1-C)] E(Y) We know E(X) and E(Y) are both positive (otherwise we wouldn't invest in stocks or bonds). The coefficient [(1-D) - (1-C)] is also positive since D < C. Thus the entire expression will be positive as long as 3D > C, or equivalently D is greater than one-third of C. I’m sure there’s some way to prove this is true under certain circumstances. But it’s good enough to just look at a plot of C and D vs. volatility, and observe that indeed 3D > C (i.e. dotted black line is above blue line), except at the very left side of the graph. (click to enlarge) Conclusions The more I think about leveraged ETFs, the more valuable I realize they are. Here, I show that you can drastically improve performance of a S&P 500/long-term bonds portfolio by simply replacing the S&P 500 fund with a 3x version. Whatever level of volatility you are willing to tolerate, you can achieve higher expected returns by simply using a leveraged S&P 500 fund. The reason is positive alpha. Using a leveraged stocks fund lets you achieve a particular level of volatility while allocating a greater percentage of your assets to an alpha-generating bond fund. More capital generating more alpha means greater returns. The results here are shown for VBLTX, but the main points should also hold for other long-term bond mutual funds or ETFs. Additionally, for those wary of investing in long-term bonds given that interest rates are about to rise, I would suggest considering a similar approach with a short or intermediate-term bond funds.

Why Invest In Emerging Market Small Cap Stocks?

Summary The notion of a “small-cap premium” is deeply established in investors’ consciousness. Many investors include an explicit allocation to U.S. and international small-cap stocks in their portfolios in order to benefit from the implied outperformance of this market segment. Recently there has been a growing interest in whether making a similar allocation to emerging market small-cap stocks can be beneficial. We detail the motivations of EM small cap investors and whether empirical evidence supports those motivations. By Tim Atwill, Ph.D., CFA, Head of Investment Strategy and Mahesh Pritamani, Ph.D., CFA, Senior Researcher An investor in emerging market small-cap stocks typically has three main motivations behind their interest in the asset class: presumed higher return; better diversification with their developed equity allocation; and more “focused” exposure to the emerging markets, in that small-cap companies tend to be more domestically focused in their economic activities. Below, we lay out the empirical evidence which supports these motivations. We show that while the return advantage and “pure exposure” arguments are strongly supported, the diversifcation benefit is relatively modest. HIGHER RETURNS Historically, small capitalization stocks have been seen as having higher potential returns than mid- and large-cap stocks. However, the bulk of the research examining this premium has focused primarily on the U.S. markets, and, to a lesser extent, the international markets. Below, we compare the excess returns of the MSCI® Emerging Markets Small Cap Index to the MSCI Emerging Markets Index to evaluate whether a similar small-cap premium exists in emerging markets. (click to enlarge) Figure 1 shows that in most years, small-cap stocks earn a relative premium to large- and mid-cap stocks. However, as with most matters in investing, there is no such thing as a free lunch, and several years had notable underperformance. Moreover, the oversized small-cap premium in 2009 highlights the timing risk associated with trying to capture the small-cap premium. This is also evident in Figure 2 which shows the annualized small-cap premium on a rolling 3-year basis, where the realized premium ranges from -5.4% to 9.2%. (click to enlarge) These results indicate that although there is evidence of a small-cap premium in the emerging markets, one has to be invested for the long-term in order to earn it. LOWER CORRELATION WITH DEVELOPED ECONOMY EQUITIES Many argue that small-cap companies are more focused on their local economies, and because of this are less connected to the global economy. Accordingly, such small-cap stocks should provide higher diversification benefits within an investor’s portfolio, versus the benefit from buying equities of larger, more globally-focused companies, which are included in more traditional emerging markets equity allocations. To demonstrate the diversification benefits associated with investing in emerging market small-cap stocks, we calculate the correlation of the MSCI World Index (which represents the equities of the developed markets) to the MSCI Emerging Markets Index, as well as the MSCI Emerging Markets Small Cap Index. (click to enlarge) As can be seen, emerging market small-cap stocks have historically shown a modestly lower correlation with the developed markets than large and mid-cap emerging market stocks. That is to say, emerging market small-cap stocks should provide a higher degree of diversification if included in an investor’s portfolio. Moreover, Figure 3 shows that this diversification benefit persists over most time periods. Therefore, a portfolio which includes an allocation to emerging market small cap stocks should expect to achieve some minor benefits from this lower correlation, including lower predicted portfolio volatility versus a similar portfolio which only includes large- and-mid-cap emerging market stocks. A “FOCUSED” EMERGING MARKETS EXPOSURE One of the reasons for investing in emerging markets, in general, is to gain exposure to smaller, less developed economies which have the potential to grow at a faster rate than developed economies. However, given the globalization of the world economy, several emerging market countries now have a small number of companies that are global in nature and known worldwide. A prime example of this is Korea-based Samsung, a truly global company, whose consumer products (such as TVs and smart phones) are bought all over the world and whose profitability is more likely tied to the world economy than the local Korean economy. A portion of the MSCI Emerging Markets Index constituents is in such global companies, under-cutting to some degree this motivation for investing in the emerging markets. By avoiding such companies, an investor in the small-cap segment of the emerging markets has the potential to obtain an exposure more focused on the local emerging market economies. To quantify this, we look at each company within both the MSCI EM Small Cap Index and the MSCI EM Index, and calculate the percentage of revenue which comes from outside its “home” country. We then capitalization-weight these percentages for each index, and present the results below. (click to enlarge) As shown in Figure 4, emerging market small-cap companies do receive much less of their revenue from outside their home economies (approximately one-quarter, versus almost one-third for large/mid-cap stocks). In addition, this focus on local economies remained relatively static over the past decade, while globally, small-cap companies saw growth in foreign revenues. This data suggests that an investor in the small-cap segment of the emerging markets captures a “focused” exposure to the local emerging market economies, because small-cap names are generally more reflective of local economies, and that this focus is more persistent than is observed globally. CONCLUSION Investors currently hear many arguments for investing in emerging market small-cap stocks, and while these arguments appeal to intuition, we have found varying degrees of support for them in the historical data. After exploring the three most common reasons for investing in the emerging market small-cap stocks – earning a small-cap premium, realizing the benefits of increased diversification, and achieving a more focused exposure to the local economies in emerging market countries – we find supporting evidence for all three of these arguments. One can potentially earn a small-cap premium by investing in small-cap stocks, though there is the risk that small-cap stocks will underperform large- and mid-cap stocks over multiple years. Historical evidence also demonstrates that although emerging market small-cap stocks are less correlated with the developed markets, this diversification benefit is relatively modest in size. It also appears that small companies in the emerging markets are more focused on their local markets, and so are potentially well positioned to benefit from the higher expected growth rates in these developing economies. All in all, we find the data encouraging for those investors who are considering a long-term strategic allocation to emerging markets small-cap stocks.

PDP: Gutsy Momentum Investing For People Braver Than Me

Summary This ETF has a high expense ratio but they are running an aggressive momentum strategy that requires higher costs. The sector allocation combined with a momentum strategy would be enough to put me on edge when I wanted to sleep. If an investor wants to follow momentum investing, this seems like a fine choice. For that investor, I would suggest grabbing some utilities to get a better balance. Investors should be seeking to improve their risk adjusted returns. I’m a big fan of using ETFs to achieve the risk adjusted returns relative to the portfolios that a normal investor can generate for themselves after trading costs. One of the funds that I’m researching is the PowerShares DWA Momentum Portfolio ETF (NYSEARCA: PDP ). I’ll be performing a substantial portion of my analysis along the lines of modern portfolio theory, so my goal is to find ways to minimize costs while achieving diversification to reduce my risk level. Expense Ratio The expense ratio is .63%. I tend to be very frugal with my expense ratios, so I’m less than thrilled with the expense ratio. Of course, portfolios that require more active involvement from managers are going to generally have higher ratios. The question becomes whether the managers will be able to regularly deliver enough performance to justify that higher ratio. Largest Holdings The following chart shows the largest holdings for the fund: The allocations here are fairly interesting, but you expect that momentum portfolios are going to end up having a very strange allocation. It’ll be interesting to see how the various momentum ETFs perform over a sample size of several years during which investors are well aware of the strategy. The presence of ETFs buying stocks based on the stock price having already appreciated seems like it could end up distorting the performance. If the strategy was highly successful, then I would expect whichever ETFs designed their systems to move first to be the winners in the game since their purchases would further drive up prices and encourage other ETFs to buy into the same funds. All around momentum investing is strange beast to me. I’m just a fundamental analysts at heart with a focus on finding the intrinsic value of a company and figure out which factors will be headwinds or tailwinds. Sectors The following chart breaks down the allocation by sector: The consumer discretionary sector has a fairly massive 31.8% weighting. My first thought here is that I would be scared to hold this ETF if this prolonged bull market turned into a bear market. I’m not convinced that we will see that kind of huge drop off in the economy in the next few years because low interest rates can do a great deal to keep market prices high, but I don’t think I have the risk tolerance for this sector allocation. Utilities That utility allocation is credibly low. For an investor opting to use momentum investing and an ETF like PDP for a major position in their portfolio, I would suggest looking to a low fee utility index to add some diversification to the portfolio as a whole. That is, of course, unless you prefer having more volatility in your portfolio. I know some investors are going to be thinking: “Utilities are sensitive to interest rate movements so I don’t want to hold them when interest rates are clearly moving higher.” There is certainly a correlation there. The utilities may suffer if rates increase, but I think they’ll stay low much longer than some investors believe. The macroeconomic environment just doesn’t provide the situation necessary for a sustained increase in rates. I’ve been positioning my portfolio to hold plenty of instruments that are sensitive to interest rates because I really don’t see any high probability paths for interest rates to move higher. An Interesting Option It would be interesting to see a momentum investing strategy that placed caps on sector weightings so that the portfolio wouldn’t end up this heavy on one sector. I have nothing against the consumer discretionary sector; I just prefer the consumer staples for my portfolio. I feel the sector is substantially stronger at resisting a sell off when the market is crashing. All sectors would be likely to fall, but I would expect fewer losses in consumer staples. Conclusion For investors that are interested in momentum investing, this is one option to get that technique into your portfolio. In my opinion the risk of using this strategy is compounded by the aggressive consumer discretionary allocation. In a prolonged bull market this fund should be a solid choice. I’m not predicting a bear market in the near future, but I’m also not willing to make a play that is this aggressive. I just don’t think I’d sleep as well with such an aggressive allocation. If investors opt to use this ETF, I’d suggest checking at least monthly on the sector allocations so the investor can modify their portfolio weights as desired. If investors don’t adjust their portfolio in response they may find themselves going massively overweight on individual sectors.