Scalper1 News
Summary Oil and oil companies seem like attractive bets, however there are many near term risks. In an environment of persistent low oil prices, the BOJ has assured continued QE or increases in QE. The dollar has an inverse correlation to oil, therefore a dollar hedge allows for a pure supply/demand bet on oil. The case for being long oil (NYSEARCA: OIL ) has been made numerous times on this website and others, but I will recap a few of the salient points here for completeness. Oil may be attractive from a supply point of view. Most of the new supply that led to the recent glut came from shale oil wells in the United States. In fact, oil production from other sources of world oil actually declined during the period from 2012 to 2014. Source: Resilience.org Shale oil wells have rapid decline curves compared to conventional wells. Source: oilprice.com As shown above, the production rate is a small fraction of the initial production by years 2-3. Therefore, we ought to expect that roughly two years after oil rig counts began to decline, the supplies of crude oil ought to begin to fall rapidly. However, the timetable for this recovery in oil price has been delayed due to the fact that several E&P companies were slow to stop drilling. In a last ditch effort to produce cash flows from their land, many companies continued to drill even at unfavorable prices. Source: marketrealist.com Though crude began to fall in July of 2014, companies didn’t start reducing rig count until many months later, and rig counts didn’t reach the current lower range until the spring of this year. This led to a situation where US supply didn’t start to roll over until the beginning of this year. Despite the drop in rig counts, the supply coming out of US shale is still higher than it was at the start of the crash in oil prices: Source: QuintoCapital.com This makes for an interesting situation of time arbitrage. The sharp decline in shale wells, combined with a lack of new drilling in the U.S., means that by 2017 (2 years from the peak shale oil supply seen in the above chart) the U.S. supply should be low enough to begin to positively affect oil prices. Investors who are convinced of the above argument may take a long position either in the commodity (via futures) or in specific, cash-rich E&P names that are unlikely to go bankrupt, and wait out the supply-demand imbalance. However, there is a danger in catching a falling knife – commodity speculators are currently riding the trend for lower prices, and stock traders are following suit with oil stocks. In addition, there is a risk that the oil supply/demand mismatch may worsen when Iran brings new production online. A long position in oil or oil stocks could pay off eventually, but lead to disastrous portfolio results in the meantime. Therefore, it is desirable to hedge such a position. The Case for Shorting the Yen ( YCS ) Japan’s central bank, unlike the Federal Reserve, uses a measure of inflation that includes the cost of energy. Thus, the fall in oil prices has set back its goal of ending deflation. Though Haruhiko Kuroda has been insisting that this is a temporary setback, one must consider what would have to happen for an investment in a cash-rich E&P firm to go poorly – namely, we would have to see much lower oil prices before the supply glut ends. Take a look at comments Kuroda made earlier this year (emphasis added): “…however, based on the assumption that crude oil prices are expected to rise moderately from the recent level , the CPI is likely to reach 2 percent in or around fiscal 2015. Needless to say, the Bank maintains its policy stance that it will make adjustments as necessary without hesitation, when there are changes in trend inflation, in order to achieve the price stability target at the earliest possible time. The Bank will not respond to developments in crude oil prices themselves, but in conducting monetary policy, it will closely monitor how they affect inflation expectations — or, in other words, whether conversion of the deflationary mindset will nevertheless proceed.” And, more recently, “The timing of reaching the inflation target depends on oil, he told reporters in Tokyo. Kuroda, 71, reiterated that the BOJ won’t hesitate to adjust policy if necessary.” And “Kuroda said he didn’t see limits to further policy steps, amid concern among private analysts that the BOJ’s campaign — mainly purchases of Japanese government bonds, or JGBs — is running up against constraints. He didn’t think a limit on buying JGBs would come soon.” The latest inflation numbers for September showed inflation at -.1% , a far cry from the 2% goal. While Kuroda stated that the BOJ will not specifically respond to oil prices, lower oil prices are bound to continue to bring down inflation expectations. I take the above comments as basically an assurance that as long as oil prices stay low, the BOJ will continue its QE program, and if oil prices fall further, there is a high likelihood that the BOJ will ramp up its QE program yet again. The Case for Being Long The U.S. Dollar There has been a strong inverse relationship between the dollar (NYSEARCA: UUP ) and oil: Source: quintocapital.com This correlation makes sense: because oil is priced in dollars, the strong dollar has contributed to the fall in oil prices. While Japan has been concentrated on stepping up its QE program, the US Federal Reserve has basically told market participants that it plans to raise rates in December. This divergence in policies is driving the USD/JPY higher, and the oil price lower. So going long the dollar in addition to being long oil provides investors a way to play oil purely for its supply-demand characteristics, rather than its aspect as an alternative currency. A word about China There has been a perception that the crash in Chinese stock prices will lead, or already has led, to weakening oil demand. However, the opposite is actually true – Chinese oil demand is actually up 9.2% year-over-year , as lower prices have stimulated demand. As Stanley Druckenmiller said earlier this year , the cure for high prices is high prices, and the cure for low prices is low prices. Putting it together I think there’s a strong case out there for being long oil right now. However, there is always a risk that the fall in oil could become overdone, and we could see oil prices that are in the $20-$30 range before we see prices in the $60-70 range. In order to hedge this volatility, I think there’s a good case for being long the US dollar, specifically against the yen, which will devalue further if oil either stays low or drops further. Any thoughts are always appreciated. Scalper1 News
Scalper1 News