Author Archives: Scalper1

Is The Bull Market About To End?

Summary Volatility spikes in the absence of systemic risk could offer higher future returns. The current environment is not similar to 2008. Forecasted volatility isn’t high compared to history. A rate hike by the Fed could significantly increase volatility. In our last update , we pointed out the risks in the emerging markets. That theme has continued to play out. By now, investors would’ve experienced maximum losses of -44% in China and -32% in EM equities. US equities are still doing better than other markets – currently at -12% maximum loss. In this environment, every online robo-advisor is telling their investors to keep calm and carry on. We here at Cassia prefer to be more proactive when it comes to managing risk. We have been performing emergency rebalances in all of our client accounts since August 22. And we continue to monitor the situation in real-time to ensure accounts can move quickly as new data comes in. Quantifying the risk The best decisions are data driven. So what is the data telling us about the current markets? Let’s talk about risk. No, I’m not talking about the flawed risk measures that everyone can calculate in Excel. I’m talking about a GARCH volatility forecast that accounts for nuances like clustering and mean reversion that we wrote about in our white paper . Typically, the S&P 500 has a volatility of 12%. In October 2008, it had a forecasted volatility of 51%. Today, our advanced risk forecasting system sees short-term volatility at 18% and 3-month volatility at 13%. This tells us two things about US Equities. The current level of volatility isn’t crazy high by historical standards. The forecasted volatility in the short-term is higher than the long-term (i.e. backwardation). Volatility spike – what does it mean? The second point warrants some investigation. So we ranked the volatility forecasts into four buckets (quartiles). We ask ourselves: “how volatile is the market relative to the long-term volatility?” Do spikes in the short-term volatility have any implications for future returns? Lo and behold. During the bull market from 2009 to present, the market appears to yield higher returns after volatility spikes. Q4 represents the days where the volatility is the highest, and Q1 represents volatility being the lowest, relative to forecasted long-term volatility. The results hold for returns 1, 5, 10, 20, 60 days into the future. This makes intuitive sense because volatility spikes tend to coincide with short-term lows in the market. Buying the dips tend to yield higher returns – in a normal environment. But look what happens when we include the highly abnormal period of 2008. Buying when volatility spikes becomes a terrible idea. Instead of yielding a higher return, buying the dips in a financial crisis, yields negative returns. Another 2008? Let’s look at systemic risk So the key question now is. Is this a 2008 environment or not? Rising correlation could indicate contagion between markets, indicating increased systemic risk and potentially a 2008 environment. Here’s what the data says as of the end of August 2015. The chart on the left shows the correlation between the S&P 500 and other major asset classes such as real estate, bonds, commodities, and emerging equities. Do you see any signs of an increase in correlation? Correlation (click to enlarge) Standardized Change (click to enlarge) We don’t. The current environment does not look similar to 2008. To make it easier to see, the chart on the right is the standardized change. If anything, the correlation between equities and other assets is experiencing the largest drop in 10 years – by almost 2 standard deviations! In contrast, correlation increased by 1.5 standard deviations at the start of 2008. For robustness, we also consulted another measure of systemic risk called the Absorption Ratio and ran it on 9 US sector funds (Kritzman 2010). The authors note that a +1 standard deviation increase in the Absorption Ratio is an indication of increased systemic risk. The current reading is at -1 standard deviation, nowhere close to systemic risk territory. Absorption Ratio (click to enlarge) Standardized Change (click to enlarge) We also repeated our test on days where systemic risk is heightened (absorption ratio greater than +1 SD). Our findings are consistent. In periods where volatility spikes are accompanied with heightened systemic risk, future 1-month returns tend to be low. And future returns are high after volatility spikes during normal periods (absorption ratio below +1 SD). GARCH volatility term structure vs. next month return (annualized) Volatility spikes during increased systemic risk: 0% Volatility spikes during normal periods: 38% Conclusion The data suggests that a) the current environment is not similar to 2008, b) forecasted volatility isn’t high compared to history, and c) volatility spikes in the absence of systemic risk have historically offered higher future returns. What can change this? We would put a September rate hike by the Fed at the top of the list. Based on the current data, we feel that there’s no overwhelming case to scale back on equities allocation. Should forecasted volatility or correlation increase dramatically, Cassia’s systems stand ready to step in and adjust allocations for its clients, faster than a human manager can react. References Kritzman, M., Li, Y., Page, S., & Rigobon, R. (2010). Principal components as a measure of systemic risk. Disclosure: I/we have no positions in any stocks mentioned, and no plans to initiate any positions within the next 72 hours. (More…) I wrote this article myself, and it expresses my own opinions. I am not receiving compensation for it. I have no business relationship with any company whose stock is mentioned in this article.

Active Performance With WisdomTree

WisdomTree Investments (NASDAQ: WETF ) is an exchange traded fund (ETF) manager. They are the pioneers behind fundamentally-weighted ETFs that weigh stocks based on fundamentals like dividends and earnings, rather than market value. Their most popular products are international ETFs that hedge out currency movements. Their European and Japanese ETFs have been extremely popular with investors making them the 5th largest ETF provider in the US with nearly $60 billion under management. WETF have received the third largest inflows year to date behind only traditional market weighted indexes like Vanguard and BlackRock’s iShares. (click to enlarge) Source: WisdomTree investor presentation Unique among fund managers WETF is the only listed pure-play ETF manager. It’s a scarce asset with a superior business model to traditional managers. There is no key person risk, and because they construct the indexes have little chance of sustained under-performance. ETFs also benefit from first-mover advantage; once an ETF gains mindshare for its ticker, the volume and liquidity this generates makes it very difficult for new indexes to gain traction. Also unlike other fund managers, there are little concerns over capacity – an index is much more scalable than other investment strategies. No key person risk WETF have only 124 employees, there are no expensive fund managers and analysts to pay bonuses out to. The employees they do have are exceptional. The chairman and largest shareholder is Michael Steinhardt, a legend in the hedge fund world, who returned 24% per annum over a 28-year period. Jeremy Siegel, the Wharton professor and author of Stocks for the Long Run, is their investment strategy advisor. ETFs are the new mutual funds There are $2.1 trillion in ETFs in the US with $1.4 trillion in inflows since 2007 (see below). WETF has taken 4% of those inflows. This ETF trend is likely to continue with advisor moves to fee-for-service. The US ETF market grew at 18% last year. If market share continues to grow (only 13% see below), assuming that ETF inflows total $3 trillion over the next 10 years and WETF continues to take 4% of these inflows, WETF will eventually have hundreds of billions of funds under management. As funds under management triple, the stock should follow. Note these assumptions do not include the growth opportunities in Europe and the rest of the world who prefer the liquidity of ETFs based in the US. Their margins should also expand rapidly with this growth. It’s interesting to see that WETF is not only one of the fastest growing fund managers but also already one of the most profitable. Source: WisdomTree investor presentation The balance sheet is nice and simple. WETF is asset lite with $189 million in cash, free cash flow is very attractive due to tax losses. It’s also paying a 1.9% dividend. The risk is a weaker dollar and poor performance from the European and Japanese markets that will impact inflows. This is the key risk, but hedging is still low as a % of international ETFs being 15% of the international market. WETF have shown themselves to be innovative in coming up with new products, starting with a focus on dividends, emerging markets and currency hedging. Given their track record we believe they can come up with more fundamental products that the market needs. Outperforming with a passive investment WETF is the only listed pure-play ETF provider. Traditional funds management businesses are good businesses as they scale easily with very little people required. ETF providers have an even better business model. There is no key fund manager risk, it’s hard to underperform when you create your own benchmark, and indexes have few capacity constraints in how much capital they can manage. As advisers move to fee-for-service, the move to passive ETFs is a trend that will likely continue. WETF now has scale, but it’s also small enough to keep growing. As an active manager it’s a little ironic buying an ETF provider, but their superior business model should help WETF outperform the market. Disclosure: Decisive has a long position in WisdomTree ( WETF ). The material in this article is for informational purposes only and in no way constitutes a solicitation of business or investment advice. The material has been prepared without regard to any client’s or other person’s investment objectives. Before making an investment decision you should consider the assistance of a financial adviser and whether any investment or service is appropriate in light of your particular investment needs.

An Opportunity During Cloudy Days

Summary The volatility in the markets continues . With anxiety arrives opportunities. Here is one ETF with relatively low volatility and high dividend yield. The stock markets continue to move aggressively up and down. The uncertainty regarding the FED’s action next week drives the investors to levels of high anxiety where every small publication or clue regarding the coming interest rate hike leads to high volatility. History showed us that volatility phases are not short by nature and the best example to use is the 2011 summer selloff that took place due to the European debt concerns, and moreover, due to the U.S. credit rating downgrade. The length of high volatility phase back than was about three months, from early August till mid October. As the markets continue to be highly volatile opportunities for the long term, patient, investor are piling up. The first group of candidates to explore are the group of Aristocrats. Dividend Aristocrats are companies that have increased their dividend payouts to shareholders every year for the last 25 years. Among the more familiar names in this group are The Coca-Cola Company (NYSE: KO ), Chevron (NYSE: CVX ), AT&T (NYSE: T ) and Johnson & Johnson (NYSE: JNJ ). Overall there are about fifty members in this prestigious list of dividend stocks that are included in the Dividend Aristocrats index. Since pursuing fifty stocks in not really achievable the next best thing is to pursue an holding in an ETF that follows this index. SPDR Dividend ETF (NYSEARCA: SDY ) is a passive ETF that seeks to replicate S&P High Yield Dividend Aristocrats Index. I have written about SDY back in April when concerns regarding a correction that was coming about arose. Based on etfdb.com SDY has total of 101 holdings. That means that beyond tracking the Dividend Aristocrats Index the ETF is following the “Index of Champions” which, based on David Fish’s latest article , includes 106 companies. In order to assess the attractiveness of SPY compared to other ETFs I used the list of my best Big Cap ETFs that were published back in July : Vanguard Value ETF (NYSEARCA: VTV ), Vanguard Russell 1000 Value ETF (NASDAQ: VONV ), Vanguard S&P 500 Value ETF (NYSEARCA: VOOV ) and SPDR S&P 500 Trust ETF (NYSEARCA: SPY ). The behavior back in 2011: (click to enlarge) When looking at the graph which compares the performance of the five ETFs, going from January to October 2011, we can see that SDY delivered the best return compared to all benchmarks. During that time period between January to October it delivered a positive 1.8% while the other ETF delivered negative returns up to -3.9% . When zooming in to the crisis period, between June to October 2011 it was again SDY that delivered the best performance, dropping by only 2.2% while the other benchmark ETFs went down by up to 7.8% . When comparing the volatility of these ETFs using a Coefficient of Variation metric (Standard deviation divided by Average price) SDY also comes out with the lowest volatility score. Back to 2015: (click to enlarge) When comparing the same list of ETFs during a similar timeframe in 2015, going from January to September, SDY is still one of the better ETF performers delivering a -8.8% which is only second to SPY which delivered -6.3% during that timeframe. When zooming in to the crisis period, June to September 2015, SDY delivered the best return at -8.9% while the other ETFs delivered lower performance all the way down to -10.7% . While delivering the highest performance DY also demonstrated the lowest volatility during that timeframe of high volatility. Based on Morningstar.com SDY’s current dividend yield is at 2.46%. In 2014 the ETF delivered more that $3 to its shareholders and therefore I believe that the dividend return at these levels is higher that 3%. Conclusions: With high volatility arrive opportunities. SDY is an ETF that follows one of the most prestigious indexes. With lower volatility compared to its benchmarks I find it very attractive and waiting for it at $65. Happy investing Disclosure: I/we have no positions in any stocks mentioned, and no plans to initiate any positions within the next 72 hours. (More…) I wrote this article myself, and it expresses my own opinions. I am not receiving compensation for it (other than from Seeking Alpha). I have no business relationship with any company whose stock is mentioned in this article. Additional disclosure: The opinions of the author are not recommendations to either buy or sell any security. Please do your own research prior to making any investment decision.