Author Archives: Scalper1
Why Hasn’t Active Investing Outperformed Passive Investing In Recent Years?
By Jason Voss, CFA Over the last several months, I’ve explored why active investing has been unable to outperform passive investing in recent years. My series is called Alpha Wounds, and so far, the issues covered are the unintended consequences of benchmarks on active management, the poor measurement techniques of investment industry adjuncts, and the lack of diversity in the human resources portfolio . In this week’s CFA Institute Financial NewsBrief , we decided to ask our readers their explanation for the lack of active management outperformance. Rare for our polls, we included a large number of options to try and capture a wide swathe of opinions. The options provided appear to have successfully reflected the broad range of views, as 90% of the 743 respondents selected one of the specific choices rather than “other”. Because it is difficult to know the precise reason for choosing the “other” category, it makes sense to recalculate the percentages without including “other”. These modified results are the ones listed in parentheses below. Note: We did receive one e-mailed response from a reader who opted for “other”. The reader explained, “I marked ‘other’ [because] the market is illogical, so trying to apply logic is bound to fail.” Why has active investing been unable to outperform passive investing in recent years? (click to enlarge) Active Managers Can Do Nothing to Outperform About 24% (27%) of respondents believe that the reason for active management’s underperformance is the deleterious effects of high fees on net performance . This is not surprising, given the large number of studies highlighting this fact. Many asset management firms are, in fact, trying to reduce their expenses to mitigate this alpha drag. Another 15% (16.5%) believe that individual investment managers cannot compete with the wisdom of financial markets. Combined, this means that about 40% (43.5%) believe that no matter what active managers do, they cannot beat passive investment strategies. Active Managers Can Do Something to Outperform Of the remaining five options, 10% (10.8%) believe that the concentration of top stocks in indices detracts from the success of active managers. For those not familiar with the argument, it recognizes that indices have built in momentum effects because many of them are market capitalization-weighted. Indices are, effectively, “must buy” lists of securities that create demand, not because of fundamentals, but because passive strategists must buy the securities in order to closely track their index. Controlling for these momentum effects is outside the specific capabilities of active managers as security prices advance. When indices fall, however, active managers not invested intimately with the securities in the index should be able to avoid some of the downside. What hope do active managers have of beating passive strategies? Together, the four remaining options provide some insight. Most importantly, according to 18% (20.2%) of respondents, active managers should minimize their use of benchmarking, style boxes, and tracking error, which lead to a sameness of results. Next, 13% (14.7%) believe that active managers are guilty of short-termism and need to change their investment time horizon and lower turnover. Incidentally, lowering turnover reduces trading costs and will reduce the expense ratio of active funds. Increasing diversity of opinion in active management is believed by about one in 20 respondents (5.5%) to be critical for improving success. Lastly, approximately 5% (5.2%) of those polled think that active managers should improve their due diligence to better compete with passive strategies. Active vs. Passive Tug-of-War Taken together, the above four tactics, all well within the purview of active management, represent about 46% of total responses as compared with the roughly 44% of responses from those who believe active strategies can never beat passive ones. This result indicates a tug-of-war between camps and, to my mind, reflects the conversation occurring in the financial community in the long-running active vs. passive debate. Disclaimer: All posts are the opinion of the author. As such, they should not be construed as investment advice, nor do the opinions expressed necessarily reflect the views of CFA Institute or the author’s employer.
Think Flexible With Emerging-Market Asset Classes
By Morgan Harting A midyear sell-off in emerging-market stocks highlighted the challenges investors face in volatile times. We think a flexible approach that spans the asset classes can help. Equities dropped by about 25% between April and August, and volatility spiked to levels not seen since the mid-2013 “taper tantrum.” The cause: investors fretted about slowing Chinese growth, weaker commodity prices and looming US Federal Reserve rate hikes. It was particularly tough for passive equity investors whose exposure was concentrated in the BRIC countries – Brazil, Russia, India and China. Don’t Pay for Beta in Emerging Markets This experience seemed to reinforce the notion that investors shouldn’t “pay for beta,” particularly in emerging markets. Passive equity strategies in that arena can be as much as 50% more volatile than in developed markets. The added return needed to justify a passive equity allocation requires a lot of conviction – or disregard for higher volatility. The good news is that emerging markets are still pretty inefficient. Active managers can add value by generating higher returns to justify higher risk, or by reducing the risk in passive strategies. We think the flexibility to tap multiple asset classes in one portfolio – including bonds – can be effective. It’s a compelling way to get more active, seeking to dampen volatility and improve risk-adjusted returns. Episodes like the taper tantrum – a global sell-off across asset classes – can disrupt things. But we think those are the exception, not the rule, in cross-asset diversification. In the recent downturn, multi-asset strategies did indeed outperform passive broad-market equity strategies. Multi-Asset: Newer to Emerging Markets Developed-market multi-asset strategies have been around for a while, but the emerging-market versions are relative newcomers. Many investors still prefer asset-class “pure” emerging-market strategies: all equity or all debt. As the thinking goes, it’s better for managers to focus on asset-class expertise than venture into other areas. We think high volatility in passive emerging-market equity changes the argument. Investors should use every tool to reduce risk and preserve returns. Multi-asset emerging-market approaches offer a tool that controls volatility better than just moving to lower-volatility stocks. The average volatility of emerging-market stocks? It’s 22% over the past decade. For bonds, it’s less than 5%, and with much less downside risk. The recent sell-off in emerging markets has made the volatility and downside risk-reduction benefits more evident, as these managers have outperformed meaningfully. The Case for Crossing Asset-Class Boundaries Granted, some active managers are very skilled in individual asset classes. But no matter which emerging-market asset class you’re in, the main return driver is broad emerging-market risk. The proof is in the return patterns. Over the past decade, the correlation between emerging-market stocks and bonds has been 0.7, much higher than the 0.1 between developed-market equity and debt. 1 With so many common return drivers among emerging asset classes, it seems to make more sense to manage emerging-market equity and debt together in a single portfolio than it does with developed markets. After all, the correlation between US and Japanese stocks is just 0.5, 2 but it’s hardly controversial anymore to suggest one manager for a global equity portfolio. Many investors want to take part in emerging-market growth and may see today’s attractive valuations as an enticing entry point. But they also might question whether it’s really worth it after factoring risk into the equation. We think multi-asset approaches offer a way to reduce some of that risk. Morgan C. Harting, CFA, CAIA Portfolio Manager – Multi-Asset Solutions 1,2 For the 10-year period ending September 25, 2015. Emerging-market stocks represented by the MSCI Emerging Markets Index; emerging-market bonds by the J.P. Morgan EMBI Global; US and Japanese stocks by their respective MSCI indices. Disclaimer: MSCI makes no express or implied warranties or representations, and shall have no liability whatsoever with respect to any MSCI data contained herein. The views expressed herein do not constitute research, investment advice or trade recommendations and do not necessarily represent the views of all AB portfolio-management teams.