Author Archives: Scalper1

Duke Energy Corporation: Growing Debt Should Trouble Investors

Summary Duke Energy consistently runs cash flow deficits to fund the large dividend yield. The company will have added $14B in debt from 2010-2017 using management guidance. Management may be tempted to add on risk by scaling up potentially higher margin international operations to grow cash flow, but 2015 shows how volatile these earnings can be. Duke Energy Corporation (NYSE: DUK ) is the largest utility in the United States, with a heavy concentration of its revenues coming from its regulated businesses in the Midwest, the Carolinas, and Florida. As the largest publicly-traded utility with a consistent dividend-paying history, Duke Energy has become a staple of retail investors seeking safety and reliable income in what has been a volatile market. But below the surface, Duke Energy appears to have some issues driven by its size – the 2012 merger with Progress Energy has created a massive entity with over 50 GW of energy generation in the United States alone. With so many assets, can Duke Energy maintain competitiveness and efficiency to remain on par with smaller, more nimble peers? And has the debt load of the company, now around $40B, become too much of a burden? Burgeoning Debt Load Utilities have just a handful of uses for the stable cash flow they generate. Outside of upgrading and maintaining their property and equipment (capital expenditures), most operational cash flow is used to either acquire new businesses, pay down debt, or give back to shareholders (dividends/share repurchases). (click to enlarge) Both pre- and post-merger, Duke Energy has consistently outspent what it earns from its operations. Cash from operations has not been able to cover the cost of capital expenditures and dividends over the past six years, with this deficit always exceeding one billion dollars or more a year. To fund these consistent shortfalls, Duke Energy has issued more than $8B in debt over this time. Because of this, the company now spends over $1.6B each year on interest expense, or more than 30% of its annual operating income. These levels aren’t unreasonable provided that deficit spending ends. (click to enlarge) * Duke Energy 2014 Form 10-K, projected future cash flows However, per management’s guidance above, this is unlikely to change in the short term. Duke Energy projects it will add another $6B of long-term debt in 2016/2017, a roughly 15% increase which will lead to around $200M in additional annual interest expense. While operational cash flow is slated to increase over time as these capital expenditures are recovered through rate increases, further continuation of this trend is still simply unsustainable. Net debt/EBITDA stood at 3.2x at the end of 2010; in 2014, the number reached 4.9x, with similar numbers likely in 2015. The decision to repatriate $1.2B in cash generated by the International Operations segment (incurring nearly $400M in taxes) was likely driven, at least in part, by the need for funds to pay for obligations like dividend payments. We aren’t the first to notice this as these negatives haven’t slipped by the big three debt agencies. Duke Energy has seen the firm’s ratings consistently fall below the credit quality ratings of other large utilities like Dominion Resources (NYSE: D ) or better capitalized firms in other industries like Microsoft (NASDAQ: MSFT ). Trends regarding debt should be concerning to investors, and I think it is a question both shareholders and the analyst community alike must begin taking a firm stance on with management. Asset Retirement Obligations (click to enlarge) As a further headwind, asset retirement obligations are costs associated with the cleanup and remediation of Duke Energy’s long-lived assets. As an example of these costs, when Duke Energy closes down a nuclear power plant, there are costs associated with decontamination and property restoration that the company must bear. Asset retirement obligations are a fuzzy area of accounting, in my opinion, where management has a lot of discretion in calculation costs. What we see with Duke Energy is that these obligation costs have ballooned, according to management estimates, from $12B in 2012 to $21B in 2014. These increased costs primarily relate to the Coal Ash Act, which occurred as a direct result of the Dan River spill and other coal ash basin failures. Duke Energy’s management notes a significant risk associated with these new obligations: “An order from regulatory authorities disallowing recovery of costs related to closure of ash basins could have an adverse impact to the Regulated Utilities’ financial position, results of operations and cash flows.” – Duke Energy, 2014 Form 10-K At best, these additional liabilities will increase depreciation expenses for Duke Energy, which will impact earnings per share. At worst, public outcry and regulators will force Duke Energy to bear some or all of these coal ash cleanup costs on its own rather than recover the costs through rate increases on customers, either directly or indirectly, through more harsh rate case approvals. Compounding, Don’t Forget It (click to enlarge) Duke Energy likely draws in quite a few income investors based on the current yield. At an approximate 4.65% yield as of this writing, shares pay a handsome premium to many other utilities. However, investors need to remember the impact of their investing time horizon and do their best to anticipate the value of their investments decades from now. Based on our look at Duke Energy’s debt and recent dividend increase history, it is safe to assume big bumps in the dividend are not on the table. 2.0-2.5% annual raises, in line with recent historical averages, may actually be optimistic, in my opinion. As shown above, for a dividend-payer that pays 4.65% today and grows its dividend at 2.0%/year (not far off Duke Energy’s 2.2% average for the past five years), the yield-on-cost of this investment will be 5.13% at the end of year six. Dividend B, with a 3.5% yield today and 8% annual dividend growth, would actually have a higher yield-on-cost in just a mere six years. Conclusion Duke Energy trades cheaply on most valuation measures, but that appears to be within good reason. Yearly cash flow obligations consistently exceed operational cash flow, which has led to a growing debt burden that will approach $50B in just a few short years. Without cuts to spending (freezing the dividend, cutting operational costs) or raising additional revenue somehow (through risky expansion in non-regulated businesses), there doesn’t seem to be a clear path for Duke Energy to grow and deleverage its balance sheet. I believe investors would be much better served looking at smaller utilities as a means of gaining exposure to the sector, such as through Southwest Gas Corporation (NYSE: SWX ).

EWZ – September Review: Brazil In A Deep Crisis, Share Market Reacts Accordingly

Summary EWZ lost 12% of its value in September. S&P downgraded Brazil to BB+, which is a junk level. The unpopularity of President Rousseff and her government grows. EWZ declined by 40% YTD and it will probably fall further. After falling by 13% in August, share price of the iShares MSCI Brazil Capped ETF (NYSEARCA: EWZ ) declined by another 12% in September. The ETF is down by 40% year-to-date, and it is at levels last seen back in 2005. Although the share price managed to bounce off of the $20 level, it is quite probable that it will retest and maybe even break this level some time in October. The situation is complicated in Brazil. S&P downgraded its credit rating of the country to BB+, which is a junk level. Brazil expanded its austerity measures, cutting agricultural subsidies, infrastructure investments, public health and low-cost housing expenditures. The aim of the new measures is to save approximately $17 billion, as the Brazilian government budget deficit climbed to a scary 9% of GDP. The support for Rousseff’s government keeps on declining. Only 10% of respondents are satisfied with the government, according to a September survey . As a result, the Rousseff opposition grows stronger and anti-government protests occur more and more frequently. The four biggest EWZ holdings remain the same as in August, shares of beverages producer Ambev (NYSE: ABEV ), preferred shares of major banks Itau Unibanco (NYSE: ITUB ) and Banco Bradesco (NYSE: BBD ), and shares of refrigerated and frozen food producer BRF-Brasil Foods (NYSE: BRFS ). Ordinary shares of Banco Bradesco are no longer one of the top 15 holdings, as they were surpassed by shares of Fibria Celulose (NYSE: FBR ), one of the world’s biggest pulp producers. Source: own processing, using data of iShares.com Shares of the airplane producer Embraer (NYSE: ERJ ) rose by almost 11% in September, as the company announced a new deal worth $800 million and its Legacy 450 model gained EASA certification for the European market. On the other hand, ordinary and preferred shares of Petrobras (NYSE: PBR ) declined by approximately 20% after another series of bad news, including new lawsuits against the company. Shares of the mining giant Vale (NYSE: VALE ) recorded significant decline as well, as weak metals prices weight on its financial outlook. (click to enlarge) Source: own processing, using data of Bloomberg After four months of relatively stable correlation between EWZ and Petrobras, which moved in the 0.8-1.0 range, the relation between the Brazilian ETF and former flagship Brazilian company started to weaken. However, we can see that it managed to climb back up at the end of the month. The correlation between EWZ and Petrobras reached an extremely high level of 0.9879 for the 10 trading days preceding September 30. It means an almost perfect positive correlation. The correlation between EWZ and oil prices, represented by the United States Oil ETF (NYSEARCA: USO ), was relatively weak for a better part of September. (click to enlarge) Source: own processing, using data of Yahoo Finance Although the global financial markets were relatively calm in September, especially when compared to August, this statement is not valid for the Brazilian share market and EWZ. The 10-day moving coefficient of variation climbed to the 6% level in late September. It reached a value of 5.84% on September 29, which is the highest level in 2015. Given the current problems the Brazilian economy has to face, it is hard to expect that October will be much calmer for the Brazilian share market. (click to enlarge) Source: own processing, using data of Yahoo Finance Some of the more interesting news: S&P downgraded Petrobras ‘ credit rating by 2 levels, from BBB- to BB. Petrobras is in the junk territory now. In late September, the Gates Foundation Trust sued Petrobras over the corruption scandal. The fund, led by Bill and Melinda Gates, is probably the most prominent plaintiff for now. But not all of the news were negative. Petrobras announced that it produced 2.88 million boe per day in August, which is a new historical record. Another announcement claimed that a new well confirmed the light oil potential in Carcará area at the Santos Basin to the south of Rio de Janeiro. Embraer announced that its airplane model, Legacy 450, gained EASA certification. The deliveries of the business jet to the EU countries can start now. Embraer also announced that SkyWest (NASDAQ: SKYW ) ordered 18 E175 jets. The deal is worth $800 million. Vale issued local infrastructure debentures worth R$1.35 billion. The amount was increased from the originally announced R$1 billion due to high demand for the debentures. The debentures are inflation linked and will bear interest of IPCA+6.6232% p.a. (IPCA – The Nation Wide Consumer Price Index). Vale’s executive board proposed a second installment of 2015 dividends, worth $500 million or $0.097 per share. Fibria Celulose progressed with the financing of its Horizonte 2 Project. It secured a $400 million Export Prepayment Facility. It also announced distribution of 500,000 Agribusiness Credit Receivable Certificates worth R$500-675 million. Itau Unibanco announced that the Chilean authorities approved the merger of Banco Itau Chile and CorpBanca. The merger will take place between January 1, 2016 and May 2, 2016. The new subject will be named Itau CorpBanca, and Itau Unibanco will own 33.58% of it. It is expected that the Brazilian GDP will decline by 2.44% this year. Inflation should climb to 9.29%. The 2015 performance of the Brazilian economy should be the worst since 1990 when it slumped by 4.35% Conclusion Brazil is in a bad shape. Its credit rating was downgraded to junk level, its economy is in a recession and the biggest company is in the middle of a huge corruption scandal, moreover it is highly indebted. People don’t trust Rousseff’s government any more and the political situation is far from stable. Adding to it is the collapsing currency and weak commodity prices, and it is not surprising that EWZ’s share price declined by 40% over the first 3 quarters of 2015. Although nothing can fall forever, it doesn’t seem like EWZ has found its bottom yet.

IBM Aims To Expand Watson Deeper Into Business Fields

Flexing the muscle of its powerful Watson computer, IBM (IBM) on Tuesday launched a new business unit called IBM Cognitive Business Solutions. The new division includes 2,000 consulting professionals skilled in data analytics, cloud computing and other areas in support of what IBM calls the next evolution of technology and business. “IBM is embarking today on a company-wide initiative aimed at accelerating the delivery of cognitive computing to