Author Archives: Scalper1

ETFs To Watch As Emerging Market Asset Outflow Doubles

Emerging markets have been out of investors’ favor over the past several months piling up heavy losses. Domestic strength in the U.S. raising the possibility of a Fed rate hike, lower commodity prices and economic turmoil in China have resulted in a massive sell-off in emerging market stocks in the past few months. The last week was disastrous for the emerging market ETFs as outflows from these funds more than doubled over the previous week, according to data put together by Bloomberg . Outflows from emerging-market ETFs were $566.1 million last week compared with $262.1 million in the previous week. About 85% of the outflow comprised stock funds and the remaining bond funds. According to Bloomberg, Taiwan witnessed the biggest outflow, all from stock funds. Withdrawal from Taiwan funds reached $93.3 million last week, compared with redemptions of $19.9 million in the previous week. Brazil experienced the second biggest outflow, with more than 90% from stock funds. Investors pulled back $68.7 million from this country ETFs last week in sharp contrast to an inflow of $12.8 million in the previous week. Below, we highlight three popular emerging market ETFs that have experienced significant net asset outflow in the week ended October 2. iShares Core MSCI Emerging Markets (NYSEARCA: IEMG ) – $530.9 Million This ETF tracks the MSCI Emerging Markets Investable Market Index, designed to measure large-, mid- and small-cap equity market performance in 21 emerging market countries. The fund has the highest exposure to China (22.2%), followed by South Korea (15.8%) and Taiwan (13%). It has amassed roughly $7 billion in its asset base while it trades in a volume of roughly 3 million shares a day. It charges 18 bps in fees from investors per year and currently has a Zacks ETF Rank #3 (Hold) with a Medium risk outlook. Vanguard FTSE Emerging Markets ETF (NYSEARCA: VWO ) – $318.8 Million This is the top asset grossing emerging market ETF, which follows the market-cap weighted FTSE Emerging Index that measures the performance of roughly 850 large and mid-cap companies in 22 emerging markets. This fund is also highly focused on China (26.6%), followed by Taiwan (14.1%) and India (12.7%). VWO has garnered nearly $35 billion in assets and trades in a heavy volume of roughly 16 million shares per day. It charges 15 bps in annual fees and carries a Zacks Rank #3 with a Medium risk outlook. iShares MSCI Emerging Markets Mini Vol (NYSEARCA: EEMV ) – $139.5 Million This ETF tracks the MSCI Emerging Markets Minimum Volatility Index, measuring the performance of large- and mid-cap securities in 21 emerging markets that have lower absolute volatility. EEMV is heavily biased toward China (18.7%) as well, while Taiwan and South Korea occupy the next two spots with shares of 17% and 12.3%, respectively. The fund has gathered around $2.5 billion in assets and trades in an average volume of 500,000 shares. It charges 25 bps in fees per year and carries a Zacks Rank #3 with a Medium risk outlook. Original Post

The Benchmarks Lie, Here’s How

Many investors, new and experienced alike, are intent upon “beating the Dow” or “beating the S&P.”. A laudable goal except that… …those indices are always moving targets! The benchmarks lie. Many investors, new and experienced alike, are intent upon “beating the Dow” or “beating the S&P” rather than seeing their capital increase over time. It isn’t that difficult to beat the benchmarks. We’ve done it over 15 years from 1999-2014 and this year the markets, so far, are down 6% to our 1% so we ​hope to keep that trend alive. On the other hand, for investors ​who place their faith in buying only companies that are in the benchmarks often find ​it is difficult to beat the indexes. That’s because “the benchmarks lie.” Every time a company disappoints the keeper of these benchmarks, S&P Dow Jones Indices (a McGraw Hill Financial subsidiary) they boot it out of the index and replace it with something they consider more “representative.” I don’t believe it is a coincidence, however, that “representative” usually equates to rising relative momentum, making the index performance look considerably more attractive — although that index may have a completely different composition than the one you bought before all their changes. As for the companies booted out, they are still in business but, if you bought a mirrored portfolio of those 30 stocks, you own the same 30, but the index and its ETF​ clones own a very different index — and not because the​ component companies went out of business or failed to meet regulatory requirements. Assuming S&P Dow Jones Indices are correct in their momentum assessment, the results are regularly skewed upward. So if you obsess over, “why didn’t the 30 Dow stocks in my portfolio keep up with the Dow Jones Index?” well, in Nov 1999, did you toss Chevron (NYSE: CVX ), Goodyear (NASDAQ: GT ), Sears (NASDAQ: SHLD ), and Union Carbide out of your portfolio and replace them with Home Depot (NYSE: HD ), Intel (NASDAQ: INTC ), Microsoft (NASDAQ: MSFT ), and SBC Communications (which a few years later acquired/became AT&T?) S&P Dow Jones Indices​ did.​ In April 2004, did you sell AT&T (NYSE: T ) (after just 5 years in the index,) Eastman Kodak (out of bankruptcy ​now ​and again trading on the NYSE) and International Paper (NYSE: IP ) and instead buy AIG , Pfizer (NYSE: PFE ), and Verizon (NYSE: VZ )? Or in Sep 2008 sell Altria Group (NYSE: MO ) and Honeywell (NYSE: HON ) in order to buy Bank of America (NYSE: BAC ) and Chevron (which I suppose the indices gurus decided was worthy once again?) In 2009, when Citigroup (NYSE: C ) and General Motors (NYSE: GM ) stocks were plunging, did you switch to Cisco (NASDAQ: CSCO ) and Travelers (NYSE: TRV )? Or did you exchange AT&T for Apple (NASDAQ: AAPL ) this year? There are many other examples but you get the idea. “Representative” seems to mean “on its way up” — though it doesn’t always work out that way. A recent anomaly in the last couple years indicates some boot-ees do better than the new inductees, though it remains to be seen if this will continue. That brings us to an interesting example ​just today ​​of how trying to read too much into a benchmark can confuse or backfire. The S&P closed down 0.35% and the Nasdaq closed down 0.7% — but the Dow is up .08%. How come? Well, the Dow has only 30 components so if one of them soars or plunges on one day it can affect the index out of proportion to its long-term trend. Today it was DuPont that sent the Dow ahead (which will no doubt lead some feckless commentator to claim that, since the Dow means Blue Chips, that the “leadership of the Dow today proves” that the markets will rise.) But the reason ​the Dow rose as ​DuPont rose 10% today? The CEO said she would retire, giving rise to speculation the company may be broken up, hardly an event likely to be repeated every day. The bottom line is that I continue to believe that intelligent stock (and preferred, bond, ETF, CEF and mutual fund) selection remains key to market success, that indexes can be beaten by this approach, and that markets go up and down, meaning there are times to enter trailing stops, adjust your portfolio percentages to include more cash, bonds or hedges. In my next article, I will give some ​current ​examples. Disclaimer: As Registered Investment Advisors, we believe it is essential to advise that we do not know your personal financial situation, so the information contained in this communiqué represents the opinions of the staff of Stanford Wealth Management, and should not be construed as “personalized” investment advice. Past performance is no guarantee of future results, rather an obvious statement but clearly too often unheeded judging by the number of investors who buy the current #1 mutual fund one year only to watch it plummet the following year. We encourage you to do your own due diligence on issues we discuss to see if they might be of value in your own investing. We take our responsibility to offer intelligent commentary seriously, but it should not be assumed that investing in any securities we are investing in will always be profitable. We do our best to get it right, and we “eat our own cooking,” but we could be wrong, hence our full disclosure as to whether we own or are buying the investments we write about. Best regards, Joseph L. Shaefer

Investors Should Avoid This New Fund-Of-Funds ETF

Summary The IQ Leaders GTAA Tracker ETF was just launched at the end of September. It’s designed as an “ETF of ETFs,” but its high expense ratio makes it less than an ideal choice for long-term investors. I offer two alternatives that would achieve a similar investment objective to this ETF at a much lower cost. I have a generally negative sentiment when it comes to “fund of funds” products whether they are mutual funds or ETFs. The main reason is that I think many of them layer on unnecessary fees for investors and can generally be replaced by an index mutual fund or ETF that charges a razor-thin expense ratio (the Vanguard funds, for example). I found myself feeling that way again when the IQ Leaders GTAA Tracker ETF (NYSEARCA: QGTA ) was launched at the end of September. This ETF is designed to be an “ETF of ETFs,” and looks to, according to the fact sheet , “track the performance and risk characteristics of the 10 leading global allocation mutual funds.” What it’s doing essentially is taking the most popular sector ETFs and investing in order to maximize the fund’s risk/return profile. The fund’s holdings are detailed below: (click to enlarge) There are a couple of things that immediately stand out to me when looking at this list. All of these products are managed by either State Street (NYSE: STT ), Vanguard or BlackRock (NYSE: BLK ). These companies are very low-cost providers generally speaking, and each of these ETFs have an expense ratio in the range of 0.07% to 0.20% (with the exception of the SPDR Barclays Capital Convertible Bond ETF (NYSEARCA: CWB ) that carries a 0.40% expense ratio and the iShares iBoxx USD High Yield Corporate Bond ETF (NYSEARCA: HYG ) with a 0.50% expense ratio). So individuals would be paying very little to invest in any of these funds. According to the fund’s fact sheet, this new ETF is charging a 0.60% annual expense ratio. Keep in mind that this fee is charged on top of the expenses that are already being charged by each ETF individually and that additional expense charge really adds up over time. Consider the two graphs below (courtesy of Vanguard’s website ): This examines how an expense ratio erodes the return of an investment over time. In this example, I use an estimated expense ratio of 0.20% (a close estimate of what someone would pay investing in each of these ETFs individually) and an average return of 6% annually. Over a 50-year time frame on a $10,000 investment, returns lost to expenses come to a total of $111,606. A large number to be sure, but take a look at what the GTAA Tracker ETF would do over time. With the same assumptions, except using an expense ratio of 0.80% (the 0.60% charge of the fund plus the individual ETF expense ratio already detailed above), the total lost to expenses jumps to $385,760. That’s over $250,000 (roughly a third of the fund’s returns) that is being paid over time to the fund managers instead of staying in your own pockets. That’s a lot of money sacrificed for not managing the ETFs one’s self. Which brings me to my second point. Most people, understandably, don’t want to manage a portfolio of ETFs and reallocate them regularly. That’s where the fund-of-funds concept holds its appeal. But investors can do better. If you look at the fund’s holdings, you’ll find that the total allocation works out to roughly 47% stocks and 53% bonds. I’ve written before about how the Vanguards Wellington Fund (MUTF: VWELX ) is one of the best mutual funds for retirement out there. It maintains an allocation of roughly 2/3 stocks and 1/3 bonds, so it doesn’t perfectly match this ETF’s allocation, but it’s still a good comparison. Wellington’s sister fund, the Vanguard Wellesley Income (MUTF: VWINX ) is another option for more conservative investors with its 1/3 stocks and 2/3 bond allocation. Both of these funds are rated 5 stars by Morningstar and carry expense ratios of just 0.25%, putting them closer to the low-cost category than the GTAA Tracker ETF. Conclusion While there’s nothing inherently wrong with the investment choices made within this ETF (in fact, most are among the lowest-cost choices within their chosen class), the high expense ratio of this fund makes it less than ideal for long-term investors. Trimming fund expenses is the easiest way to improve the long-term returns in one’s investment portfolio. I’ve offered two alternatives that combine both an excellent long-term performance record and low costs, leaving more of the investment return where it belongs. For the time being, investors should look for other alternatives to this ETF.