Author Archives: Scalper1

Multi-Factor Investing

Multi-factor investing that combines value, momentum, quality (profitability), or low volatility factors is today’s hot new investment approach. There has been an explosion of multi-factor ETFs recently with nine of the fourteen existing U.S. multi-factor funds coming to market this year, and five of them showing up within the past 60 days. Multi-factor funds may be a good thing, since single factor funds can have some serious drawbacks. However, multi-factor funds can also have their own quirks and issues. If the large variety of factors is thought of as the “factor zoo,” then multi-factor approaches may be the “factor circus” with its own collection of silly clowns, dangerous acrobats, and amusing jugglers. Factor Investing Issues With factor investing in general there are three potential problem areas: tractability, scalability, and volatility. With respect to tractability, it is well-known that value investing can have long periods of serious under performance. This happened in the late 1990s and also somewhat during the past two years. Not all value investors may be willing to watch this happen without losing patience and giving up on their factor portfolios. To a lesser degree, momentum and other factors are also subject to sustained tracking error. Scalability has to do with too much money chasing after too few stocks. Factors perform best when you can focus on those stocks having the strongest factor characteristics. For example, Van Oord (2015) showed that from 1926 through 2014, only the top decile of U.S. momentum stocks outperformed the market. Stocks below the top decile added nothing to strategy results. Yet just two out of the twelve large-cap U.S. equities single factor ETFs only include stocks that are within the top decile of their factor rankings. For example, the oldest and largest single factor value ETFs are iShares S&P 500 Value (NYSEARCA: IVE ), iShares Russell 1000 Value (NYSEARCA: IWD ), and Vanguard Value (NYSEARCA: VTV ). They hold 72%, 69%, and 50% respectively of the stocks that are in their investable universes. This makes them, to a great extent, closet broad index funds with higher fees. Their large sizes ($8.3 billion, $23.5 billion, and $34.6 billion, respectively) may impede them from focusing on just fifty (the top decile of S&P 500 stocks) or one-hundred (the top decile of Russell 1000) value stocks. The same is true with respect to momentum. The largest momentum fund, with over $1 billion in assets, is the AQR Large Cap Momentum Style mutual fund with an expense ratio of 0.45. It holds 532 out of an investable universe of 1000 stocks. This is a far cry from the top decile of momentum stocks. Large amounts of investment capital may make it difficult for single factor funds of all types to focus exclusively on the relatively small number of stocks that appear in their top factor deciles. The third problem for single factor portfolios is increased volatility and high bear market drawdowns that accompany value, momentum, and small cap factors. Trend following filters, such as absolute momentum, can help reduce downside exposure with respect to long-term bear markets, but it does little to alleviate uncomfortable short-term volatility. Trend following is also less effective when applied to value factors than when applied to other factors like momentum. Multi-Factor Solutions All three of these problem areas for single factor investing – tractability, scalability, and volatility – can be significantly reduced by using intelligently constructed multi-factor portfolios. Multiple factors can obviously reduce tracking error, since it is unlikely that several factors will substantially under perform at the same time. As for scalability, if a fund uses four factors instead of just one, it can handle four times the investment capital without eroding its ability to enter and exit the markets. Finally, the volatility and large bear market drawdown associated with value and momentum factors can be reduced by combining these factors with less volatile ones, such as quality and low volatility. However, I intentionally included the words “intelligently constructed” when I referred to the potential benefits of multi-factor portfolios. It surprises me that six out of the fourteen U.S. multi-factor funds include small size as a factor. Sponsors of these funds must have been asleep during the past 25 years when abundant academic research showed that small cap stocks, while giving higher returns, add nothing positive on a risk-adjusted basis because of their high volatility. When combined with value or with value and momentum, which is what all six funds of these funds do, small cap can be particularly undesirable, since it can aggravate already high portfolio volatility and bear market drawdown exposure. It is also surprising that the “premier anomaly,” price momentum, is included in only eight of the fourteen U.S. multi-factor funds. Abundant research has shown that momentum is the most powerful factor for generating positive returns. More sleepy time among fund sponsors? The final issue associated with multi-factor funds is their average annual expense ratio of 42 basis points for what are enhanced index funds. This is higher than the Morningstar US ETF Large Blend Strategic Beta expense ratio of 38 basis points and the Morningstar US ETF Large Blend Index expense ratio of 36 basis points. Until just recently, an investor who wanted multi-factor exposure would have been better off creating it herself by combining the single factor iShares MSCI USA Value Factor, USA Momentum Factor, USA Quality Factor, and USA Minimum Volatility ETFs, since these all have expense ratios of only 15 basis points. New Solution This situation changed dramatically last month when Goldman Sachs entered the ETF business with an offering called Goldman Sachs Active Beta U.S. Large Cap Equity (NYSEARCA: GSLC ). GSLC is the only multi-factor fund having what I consider an optimal mix of factors: value, momentum, quality, and low volatility. Here is a description of how they determine these factors: • Value: The value measurement is a composite of three valuation measures, which consist of book value-to-price, sales-to-price and free cash flow-to-price (earnings-to-price ratios are used for financial stocks or where free cash flow data are not available). • Momentum: The momentum measurement is based on beta- and volatility-adjusted daily returns over an 11-month period ending one month prior to the rebalance date. • Quality: The quality measurement is gross profit divided by total assets or return on equity (ROE) for financial stocks or when gross profit is not available. • Low Volatility: The volatility measurement is defined as the inverse of the standard deviation of past 12-month daily total stock returns. Even though the fund holds 432 stocks out of an investable universe of 500, it uses a weighting scheme (most multi-factor funds with a large number of holdings do the same) that allocates substantially more of its capital to stocks with high factor ratings. GSLC rebalances positions quarterly and uses a turnover minimization technique (especially useful for momentum stocks) of buffer zones to reduce the number of portfolio transactions. I use a similar buffer zone technique myself with some of my more active momentum models. What is especially appealing about GSLC is its low cost structure. The fund came into existence because some of Goldman’s largest clients wanted to invest this way using an ETF wrapper to minimize their tax consequences. Because of this sponsorship, the fund was set up with an annual expense ratio of only 9 basis points. This is the same expense ratio as the biggest and most popular ETF in the world, the SPDR S&P 500 ETF Trust (NYSEARCA: SPY ). GSLC already has $78 million invested in it since coming to market one month ago. GSLC is not an ideal investment from our point of view, since it doesn’t have a trend following filter like absolute momentum to help it avoid severe bear market drawdown. GSLC is also unable to benefit from international diversification during those times when international stocks show greater relative strength than U.S. stocks. However, because of its low cost structure, GSLC might be a good asset to consider along with the S&P 500. If GSLC continues to attract considerable assets so that it has good liquidity and if it performs well relative to the S&P 500 over the next year, I may add GSLC to my dual momentum models. Multi Factor Funds Symbol Factors Assets Stocks Exp Ratio 4 Factor Goldman Sachs Active Beta U.S. Large Cap GSLC Value, Mom, Quality, LoVolty $78 m 432 0.09 ETFS Diversified Factor U.S. Large Cap SBUS Value, Mom, Size, LowVolty $17 m 492 0.40 iShares Factor Select MSCI USA LRGF Value, Mom, Size, LowVolty $5 m 135 0.35 3 Factor SPDR MSCI USA Quality Mix QUS Quality, Value, LowVolty $6 m 624 0.15 JP Morgan Diversified Return U.S. Equity JPUS Value, Mom, Quality $11 m 561 0.29 John Hancock Multifactor Large Cap JHML Size, Value, Profit $79 m 772 0.35 AQR Large Cap Multi-Style (non-ETF) QCELX Value, Mom, Profit $1.2 b 338 0.45 iShares Enhanced U.S. Large Cap IELG Value, Quality, Size $71 m 109 0.18 PowerShares Dynamic Large Cap Value PWV Value, Quality, Mom $927 m 50 0.58 FlexShares U.S. Quality Large Cap Index QLC Quality, Value, Mom $3 m 120 0.32 Gerstein Fisher Multi-Factor Growth Equity (non-ETF) GFMGX Size, Value, Mom $227 m 298 1.03 2 Factor ValueShares Quantitative Value QVAL Value, Quality $47 m 41 0.79 FlexShares Morningstar U.S. Market Factor Tilt TILT Value, Size $740 m 2249 0.27 Cambria Value and Momentum VAMO Value, Mom $3 m 100 0.59 Nothing contained herein should be interpreted as personalized investment advice. Under no circumstances does this information represent a recommendation to buy, sell or hold any security. Users should be aware that all investments carry risk and may lose value. Users of these sites are urged to consult their own independent financial advisors with respect to any investment.

Strongest Market Sectors Since 1933: Smoking Wins, Steel Rusts Away

Summary A new review sorts the performance of 30 sectors over the past 82 years. So-called ‘sin stocks’ such as tobacco and beer run away with the best returns. Cyclical sectors and basic materials tended to fare poorest. The article specifically considers the implications of these data for DG investors. Philosophical Economics, one of my must-read financial blogs, recently put up a fascinating post showing the returns of the US market by industry with dividends reinvested since 1933. If you’re wondering about the methodology used to create the results, check the linked post, it’s too complicated to explain here briefly. The winning sectors showed a truly shocking degree of outperformance. The #2 performing sector, beer turned $1,000 in 1933 into $26 million today! By contrast, the worst sector, steel, turned that same $1,000 into just $57,000 today. $57,000 isn’t bad, but over an 82 year investment period, it certainly isn’t great. $57,000 pales in comparison to $26 million for sure. Here’s some key takeaways for dividend growth investors. The Worst Investment Sin? Socially Responsible Investing For long-term investors, the message is clear, you need to own the so-called sin stocks. Hold your nose and donate profits to charity if you must, but these stocks can’t be passed up if you want market-beating performance. The top 3 sectors over the past 82 years were cigarettes at 8.34% real annualized return, beer at 7.51%, and oil at 6.84%. Investors in “ethical” funds that avoid these sectors are virtually guaranteeing drastic underperformance. I heard recently, and I’d love to attribute it but I can’t remember the source, that socially responsible investing suffers from two primary flaws. That is, by choosing not to invest in these sorts of companies, you’re actually rewarding both the sinful investors and giving the sinful companies an easier ride. Stock prices, on a day to day basis are set by supply and demand. If you convince a large portion of the investing public not to back an alcohol, tobacco, or oil company, for example, you lower that company’s share price. Since the share price is artificially lowered due to lessened demand, shares will return higher than otherwise anticipated returns. Companies that regularly buy-back shares perform particularly well if their shares remain artifically depressed for long periods of time. Thus ‘sinful’ investors, along with the ‘sinful’ managers of these companies see their investments become more profitable thanks to the socially conscious investor. Management in particular earns fat performance bonuses for their superior stock returns. In short, you’re depriving yourself of investing profits so people that aren’t as morally upstanding as you can earn more money. What good does that accomplish? Perhaps more problematically, by not owning companies, you lose the ability to influence them. If you own an oil company and its operations destroy a water supply and poison the local population you and other ethical investors can raise hell and force them to change their ways. If only morally oblivious people own oil companies, there will be no reaction and the company can continue in its unethical behaviors. Mining companies, for example, engage in ethically questionable behavior and only rarely get called on it because their shareholder bases don’t tend to complain about bad practices. By contrast, a Nike (NYSE: NKE ) for example, if it tries to mistreat its employees hears no end of it from upset shareholders. Finally, it should be noted that most of the sin stocks don’t need fresh capital frequently, if ever. How often does Altria (NYSE: MO ) or Diageo (NYSE: DEO ) need to offer new stock to the market? By not buying their shares, you aren’t even depriving the company of capital – you’re only depressing the after-market value of shares already issued. To actually harm these companies, you’d have to be able to block them from getting the capital necessary to expand their operations. Not buying the shares of companies that generate sufficient free cash flow to buy small nations; you aren’t really going to set them back too much. Other Top Performing Sectors Of The Past 82 Years The #4 returning sector, electrical equipment (6.61%) is a bit surprising, at least to me. For people thinking about Emerson Electric (NYSE: EMR ), it’s an encouraging result. I’d guess this segment of the market is probably significantly underweighted in most of our DGI portfolios. Mainstays of many folks DGI portfolios, #5 food and #6 healthcare come in nicely, though they trail the sin stocks dramatically. While necessary for life, these products simply don’t have the addictive function that drives the returns of the very top performing stocks. Still, they’re key sectors we should all own in large quantities. The 7th top performing sector, paper and business supplies is a real head-scratcher. And returns have been very steady over the past 8 decades, it’s not like this one got a fast start and trailed off recently. I’m not sure how to incorporate this into my DGI portfolio. Ideas anyone? Next up, retail at #8 isn’t too surprising. Though for the DG investor be careful, these names tend to come and go. I don’t like Target (NYSE: TGT ) and seems I’m one of the view that likes even Wal-Mart (NYSE: WMT ) anymore. Next up is a classic picks and shovels example. Transportation vehicles (ships, aircraft, railcars) came in at 9th, while transportation (the operation of said vehicles) was 26th, among the worst five industries. It’s frequently better to supply the tools to run a business rather than to be the actual operator, and transportation is one of those categories. Boeing (NYSE: BA ) is a great business. The airlines? Not so much. Rounding out the top 10 would be chemicals, an indispensable though under-the-radar segment of the modern economy. Middle of the Pack Sectors Coming up in the middle third are quite a few of the DGI mainstays. Doing less well than you might expect, for example, would be consumer goods which come in at only #14. Utilities (#15), and Telecom (#17) rank in the middle of the 30 sector pack, showing you’re giving up a good deal of total return for that high yield. If I’d had to guess, I would have thought telecom would beat utilities though, I’m honestly impressed that utilities came in the dead middle of the 30 sector spread despite being very low growth names. Restaurants and hotels came in 12th, but that almost comes with an asterisk, as a great deal of the performance came from 2005 onward. This sector has lagged for long periods of time – between 1992 and 2005 for example, you lost half your money in this sector and that includes reinvested dividends. Compared to the steady gains most of these top sectors made over the decades, this one stands out as a real dud despite the reasonable overall ranking. Financials came in at 16th, but they were in the top 6 until 2008, when the US financial system rudely decided to self-immolate. The lesson I’d take from this is that financials are a must-own sector, but you should avoid the wild west gamblers’ market that is large US banks. The US weighs in poorly, with the world’s 49th soundest banking system. The lesson here seems clear: Buy sound banks in foreign countries that don’t lever their balance sheet to massive degrees and bet heavily on opaque instruments. The Worst Sectors: Tread Carefully The worst sectors tend to either involve basic materials or be highly cyclical. And that makes sense, to compound money effectively over an eight decade span, you need to avoid wiping out your equity too frequently, as these sectors are prone to do. The very worst sectors were steel and textiles, both of which were effectively terminated by foreign competition. Offshoring and globalization essentially destroyed these industries inside the US’ borders. As DG investors, we must be aware of changing global trends that threaten to not just destroy an individual company but potentially a whole industry. #25 Printing and Publishing is another one that has suffered greatly with recent changes to the entire industry’s dynamic. A dividend investor buying a newspaper stock like Gannett (NYSE: GCI ) 15 years ago would likely never have imagined what would happen in the coming years. Mining at #21 and coal at #23 also fair poorly being cyclical industries. Autos and trucks at #22 also came in with weak results. I’m always amazed at the number of DGIs that own stocks like General Motors (NYSE: GM ) that I wouldn’t buy in a million years. But we all have our weaknesses, I own Barrick (NYSE: ABX ) in the equally pitiable mining sector. My personal lowest-ranked holding comes in the 27th ranked sector of the 30, construction. I’m frankly shocked, given just how much stuff the world has built over the last 80 years how badly this segment has done. I know construction is hyper-cyclical, but businesses like Caterpillar (NYSE: CAT ), which I own, seem to be strong and have a decent moat. Takeaways For me, I only have a few companies in the bottom performing sectors, namely Caterpillar and Barrick mentioned above. From the top 5, I lack electrical equipment and smoking. I want to buy a tobacco stock but I haven’t seen any near what I’d judge to be a fair value, unlike in alcohol, where a stock like Diageo screams “buy me” every time I look at its long-term fundamentals. And for electrical equipment, I’d never viewed this to be a must-own sort of asset. Consider me interested now. My top weighted sector is financials which only scored 16th. Though noted above, this was a top 6 segment until 2008, and the financials I own all grew earnings and raised dividends during the 2008-09 stretch. Since I avoid US financials, I think I get a pass here – banking is still a must-own area. For investors heavily overweighted in popular sectors outside the top 10, say, consumer goods, telecoms, and utilities, think about some potential reallocation. Those segments are all very popular with DGIs, and with good reason, they offer nice yields and defensive stock performance. However, moving more of your money into higher performing areas such as tobacco, oil, liquor, and food might boost your returns without taking more risk. Here’s the full 30 in a table and the link again if you want to see the original post where you can see charts of each industry over the decades.