Author Archives: Scalper1

Strategy Ideas: How To Trade Earnings Forecast Upgrades

Summary Buying stocks with recently upgraded earnings is a well-documented and profitable strategy. How does trading costs impact the return of this strategy? What are 2 other factors that can enhance return of stocks with positive earnings revisions? The American Association of Individual Investors is an interesting resource for investors who want to see historical performance for a wide-range of value, growth, momentum and guru-type strategies. One basic strategy that has been of great interest to me for many years is buying after a positive earnings forecast revision . Since 2000, the strategy (as reported by AAII) returned 25.9% annually with an annual performance of -18.1% in the year 2008. Over the past 15+ years, only 2 years ended with a negative return. It would seem like a simple slam-dunk. But before you start hitting the ‘market order’ button – you may want to read about a hidden danger in addition to a couple of enhancements to this strategy. What Is the Earnings Revision Strategy? The concept is very basic. Analysts typically estimate future earnings. The various estimates are averaged and called a consensus. When the analyst consensus rises by 5% or more, you buy and hold for the following month (or some other length of time). Why Might This Work? The thought is that investors, while aware of the earnings revision, are hesitant to fully price this new information in. The price often drifts upwards for 30 days or more after the initial spike that follows the upgrade. Who Might Like This Strategy? This would be a strategy for an active trader. The turnover is bound to be high. Thus, the trader needs to have skill in purchasing (selling) stocks without unduly driving the price up (down). Does This Simple Concept Really Work? The short answer is, yes – but not as high or as consistent as one would hope. We will look at why in a moment. Before we do so, I wanted to run my own independent test of this phenomenon. Gross Returns of Earnings Revision Strategy Utilizing Portfolio123’s back-testing engine I ran a simple test. I stipulated that earnings must be positive and that the current estimate must be 5% greater than it was 4 weeks ago. There are no other rules. This screen is run across all stocks trading on all USA exchanges which have at least some fundamentals. (click to enlarge) The returns are not as high as AAII’s screen but significant outperformance is present on a massive pool of stocks. The Hidden Cost of Trading If you have ever tried to re-create some of the higher performing screens, you may have learned that simple stock screens often have massive hidden costs. Many of the stock recommendations in this screen come from illiquid tickers with huge bid/ask spreads . You may not be able to buy and sell hundreds of thousands of dollars per stock without moving shares 5 – 10% against the trade. So to get around this, you can raise the minimum criteria which will lower trading costs. What would be the impact if you boosted the minimum requirements to the criteria below? Minimum share price $5 Minimum average daily turnover value of $500,000 Minimum market capitalization of $50 million Increasing liquidity lowers trading costs but also gross performance. (click to enlarge) And once you factor in even a very reasonable amount of slippage per trade, your returns will struggle to remain positive. A good idea also needs a well-executed plan. Going to the open market and buying up stocks with a minimum of 5% earnings revisions without any further consideration can destroy capital fast due to high trading costs but also lower than expected alpha if you trade super-liquid tickers. Yet, we do not throw out the earnings revision strategy because of this. We need to consider other factors that play nice with earnings revisions. What other criteria should we be on the lookout for? Size Matters When it comes to revisions in earnings estimates, stock size matters. To prove the point, look at the performance difference (annualized returns since 1999) between the smallest and largest stocks in the Russell 3000 universe. What does this chart mean? The only stocks represented in the chart are Russell 3000 stocks with a 5% or greater earnings revision. Next, I ranked stocks weekly according to market capitalization. The red bar on the left represents the S&P 500 annual return since 1999. The next bar represents the annual return of stocks that ranked in the bottom one-fifth of the universe according to market cap. The bar farthest right represents the largest capitalization stocks which also had a 5% earnings revision. Therefore, if you are timing a short-term trade based on a revision of earnings consensus, you might be less inclined towards buying larger firms. Some big names that revised current fiscal year earnings upwards over the past few months are Amazon (NASDAQ: AMZN ), AT&T (NYSE: T ), Gilead Sciences (NASDAQ: GILD ) and Ford (NYSE: F ). It would seem that any additional value added by such a revision gets priced in quickly in these highly traded stocks. Therefore, trying to jump on a trade after the revision may not produce the desired results. There appears to be a greater likelihood of an upwards drift in smaller names such as Aceto Corp (NASDAQ: ACET ), Concert Pharmaceuticals (NASDAQ: CNCE ) and Exar Corp (NYSE: EXAR ) which have very small market capitalizations. Value Matters Another important concept relating to upgraded earnings is value. If the share price is very low compared to the earnings, perhaps at a multiple of 10x, and then earnings are forecast upwards by a significant amount – one would expect the price to rise accordingly. But if the price was already trading at a very high PE ratio, perhaps 50 or more, and the earnings forecast was bumped up giving the stock a projected PE ratio of 47 – the upwards price drift may be slight to non-existent. Determining if the projected PE is high or low becomes increasingly important when trading big stocks with earnings upgrades. Over the past 10 years, S&P 500 stocks which had a projected PE ratio higher than average (in this case the average of the R3K index), had an annual return of 6% if you rebalanced weekly. S&P 500 stocks with revised earnings which had lower than average projected PE ratios showed an annualized return of almost 15%. If you traded only Russell 2000 stocks (small-cap), then the’ lower than average’ forward PE ratio stocks would have returned 33% annually over the past 10 years vs. 20% if the projected PE ratio was higher than average. Trading Earnings Revisions Of course, you still have the burden of lowering trading costs to keep as much of this potential return as you can. Here are a few tips I would encourage: Try to keep slippage around 0.25 – 0.35%. You can achieve this by lowering your trading size or moving to slightly more liquid stocks. Also remember that 1 cent represents 1% in a stock trading at $1.00. You may also want to buy higher priced stocks so that you do not lose as much on the bid/ask spread. A rule of thumb is to trade no more than 5% of the daily volume, 10% if you have trading skill. Scan the market for upgrades every week and buy as soon as possible. While you can hold for the full 4 weeks, consider selling early if prices move up very fast. When prices go parabolic, you often do well to lock in profit. If you are holding at the 4 week mark and prices have continued to drift up gradually, analyze if there is reason to hold longer – perhaps an additional 4 weeks. Some stocks continue to benefit from the positive revision longer than the first few weeks. Do you trade earnings revisions? What has been your experience? I would like to hear how you trade this strategy.

The Real Cost Of Hedging With Leveraged ETFs

Summary Scaled hedging has some advantages over usual market-timing. Leveraged ETFs are convenient hedging tools, but they suffer from a decay. This article calculates the additional cost of hedging a stock portfolio with leveraged ETFs. A timed, scalable hedging tactic has at least 3 advantages over usual market-timing consisting in going out of the market: adaptability to the risk level, lower transaction costs, and cashing all dividends. This previous article shows how to use a systemic risk indicator to scale a hedging position and protect my premium portfolio with SPXU . ETFs are not necessarily the best hedging tools, but they are available and understandable for all investors. SPXU has the advantage to allow hedging in an account where only long positions in stocks and ETFs are possible, and without margin. Like all leveraged ETFs, it has the drawback of suffering from a decay called beta-slippage. This article calculates the real additional hedging cost incurred by this decay in 2015 for SPXU, and for another leveraged inverse S&P 500 ETF: SDS . It also shows the decay of long leveraged ETFs. What is beta-slippage? If a volatile asset goes up 25% one day and down 20% the day after, a perfect double leveraged ETF goes up 50% the first day and down 40% the second day. On the close of the second day, the underlying asset is back to its initial price. At the same time, the perfect leveraged ETF has lost 10%: (1 + 0.5) x (1 – 0.4) = 0.9 This decay is called beta-slippage. It is a mathematical property of a leveraged and frequently rebalanced portfolio (leveraged ETFs may hold futures, options and/or swap contracts). In a trending market, beta-slippage can be positive. If an asset goes up 10% two days in a row, on the second day, the asset has gone up 21%. The perfect 2x leveraged ETF is up 44%: (1 + 0.2) x (1 + 0.2) = 1.44 It is 2% better than holding the underlying leveraged 2x on margin. Beta-slippage is path-dependent. If the underlying gains 50% on day 1 and loses 33.33% on day 2, it is back to its initial value, exactly like in the first example. This time, the perfect leveraged ETF loses one third of its value, which is much worse than the 10% of the first case: (1 + 1) x (1 – 0.6667) = 0.6667 Without a formal demonstration, it shows that the higher the volatility, the higher the decay. Hence the name of beta-slippage: “beta” is the best known statistical parameter of volatility. Of course, it is uncommon to have such price variations on an ETF’s underlying asset. These numbers are here to give an amplified vision of what happens with more realistic daily returns, day after day and month after month. (click to enlarge) SPXU in red, SPY in blue. Chart and data: portfolio123 Decay of S&P 500 ETFs in 2015 The next table gives the decay of leveraged ETFs on the S&P 500 index from 1/1/2015 to 10/15/2015 (9.5 months). It was a sideways and quite volatile market, with a worse than usual beta-slippage. The decay includes beta-slippage, and also tracking errors and management fees. Ticker Return Return of SPY x leveraging factor Decay (difference) Drag on portfolio SPY -0.52% SH (1xshort) -1.84% 0.52% -2.36% -1.18% SSO (2xlong) -3.92% -1.04% -2.88% -0.96% UPRO (3xlong) -8.69% -1.56% -7.13% -1.78% SDS(2xshort) -4.84% 1.04% -5.88% -1.96% SPXU(2xshort) -9.45% 1.56% -11.01% -2.75% When using SDS or SPXU for hedging, the hedging position represents 1/3 of the total portfolio (stocks + hedge) in the first case, and 1/4 in the second one. So the real drag on the portfolio was respectively 1.96% and 2.75% compared with shorting SPY. This is the additional cost of hedging the whole portfolio during the whole period (setting it in market neutral mode), which is not the best tactic proposed in my previous article (and service ). The cost of using leveraged ETFs with any of the proposed variable hedging tactics was much lower. Rebalancing the hedge weekly also lowers the decay due to beta-slippage (but not tracking errors). Finally, the cost is lower than losing all dividends when going out of the market in a classic market-timing approach, and it is likely to provide a better long-term risk-adjusted performance. SSO and UPRO also look like decent alternatives: SSO had the lowest portfolio drag. But short selling always incurs additional risks and borrowing costs. SDS and SPXU allow to hedge without borrowing cost and with less or no margin cost. These costs depend on the broker, so the best choice for hedging with an ETF may depend on your broker. If you have the skills and possibility to manage other instruments like futures, options, CFDs, they may be more cost-effective. Keep also in mind that the hedge and the stock portfolio can be in different accounts. If you like this article, you might be interested in the next ones. Click the “Follow” tab at the top if you want to stay informed of my free-access publications on Seeking Alpha. You can even choose the “real-time” option if you want to be instantly notified.

Muddling Through Works For Me

The global economy, including the United States, is muddling through with growth well below potential, but better than a year ago. The global consumer is the winner while the global producer is suffering from excess capacity, excess inventory and much lower prices. Lower prices for the producer means higher disposable income for the consumer as long as his income is at least constant and hopefully, rising. There are clear winners and losers out there due to this conundrum. It’s not so hard really to construct a long/short portfolio in this environment if you use common sense and in-depth research. It is most interesting to see how managements are reacting to this environment. If they bite the bullet and make the right strategic changes, they will come out stronger and their stock price will reflect it but if they keep their head down and maintain the status quo, their business and stock price will erode over time. The portfolio manager who uses historical analysis and doesn’t listen to or see what is happening out there won’t see the change. But the one with an analytical proclivity, an open mind and who puts in the hard work will see the change or lack thereof and construct a winning portfolio accordingly. This is an analyst’s delight. My strength! This is a worldwide phenomenon so you need a global perspective and knowledge. That’s what we at Paix et Prospérité are all about. The financial markets continued to move up last week on the “wall of worry” that we have been discussing in previous blogs. Our view was, and remains, that the Fed is out of the way until at least December, and most likely next March, and this has become the prevailing wisdom on Wall Street. You could hear the sigh of relief around the world. The global financial markets acted accordingly: stock markets for the most part rose, led by China and the emerging markets; bond yields remained ridiculously low as fears of deflation override fears of inflation; commodity prices, including oil, fell for the week; the dollar held constant after falling over the last two weeks; a huge deal was announced in the beer industry; Dell bid over $67 billion for EMC which was under attack from an activist; and corporate earnings season began. Quite a busy week! Our portfolio continues to outperform by a wide margin. I have spent a lot of time over the last year declaring that this is a market of stocks, not a stock market. Step back and think about this for a moment. Historically, investors rotated industry sectors based on where you were in the economic cycle. For instance, you would want to have the stable growers like food and drug stocks when the economy turns down and parenthetically you would want to own the economically sensitive stocks late in a cycle as capacity utilization increases to the point that prices increase accelerate and stick. Not now! What’s different today? Globalization. The lowest common denominator, for the most part, sets prices. For example, Chinese steel imports have forced tremendous pricing pressure here and in Europe. Some nations don’t have the same profit motive as we do and may be nationalized. It could all be about jobs over profits. Currencies play a major role here too. It used to be that our high-energy costs penalized our chemical industry in competing globally. Not anymore as our feedstock costs are as low as any country, including the Middle East. Products move globally and if you don’t have a competitive advantage either in price or technology, you’ll lose out over time. It’s our job to find them. We’re pretty good at that. Change can take many forms. Take a look at Amazon (NASDAQ: AMZN ), Netflix (NASDAQ: NFLX ), and Uber as three examples whose business models turned their respective industries upside down. Just ask Wal-Mart (NYSE: WMT ) and the networks. We will discuss all of this in more depth later but you can guess where I am going with this. Do the work; don’t follow the chart, as that is history; and find the future winners as your longs and the losers as your shorts. I waited over a year for Nelson Peltz to wake up the analysts and investors in GE . Be patient and let the thesis play out. Don’t forget to maintain your liquidity and control risk too. Let’s quickly take a look at the events of the week by region, see if there any changes in core beliefs and then turn to asset allocation and specific recommendations. 1. As I mentioned last week, the U.S consumer is in great shape and continues to support the economic expansion more than offsetting industrial weakness most prevalent in weak export numbers. Specifically, consumer confidence rose to 92.1 in October from 87.2 in September; consumer expectations out six months rose to 82.7 from 78.2 in September; the consumer view of their personal finances rose to 106.8 from 101.2 last month; consumer comfort index rose to 45.2 and is up 5 points in a month and retail sales rose a mere 80.1% in September from August. The surprise for the week was that the Consumer Price Index fell a seasonally adjusted 0.2% in September and was unchanged year over year. Excluding food and energy, the core CPI actually rose 0.2% in September and 1.9% year over year. Social security recipients, over 56 million strong, will not get an increase in the cost of living index in 2016. Tell them there is no inflation in the country. Relative strength by the consumer is being partially offset by continued weakness in factory output, which declined 0.1% last month. Manufacturing comprises only 12% of the economy and will remain a drag for quite some time. By the way, capacity utilization declined to a three month low of 77.5. Finally the Beige Book came out and supported only a “modest expansion” at the end of the third quarter. Many of the districts blamed the strong dollar saying it was hurting exports and tourism. Clearly the Fed is on hold for now and maybe longer than we think despite several world central bankers asking for the Fed to end the drama and to finally lift rates. Waiting has been unsettling to the global economies, as we have mentioned many times too. Since estimates of future global growth are still falling, the Fed is on HOLD. 2. The big news out of Europe is that Switzerland is set to impose 5% leverage ratios on its largest banks which include Credit Suisse and UBS up from around 3.7% as mandated by Basel III. The Swiss authorities are following the lead of U.S. regulators who set the same levels for our biggest banks. It’s quite simple: higher capital ratios means less lending. Dodd Frank and Basel III have certainly reduced financial risk in the economy at the expense of growth. While growth in Europe has clearly bottomed, it won’t reach earlier estimates due to weakness in foreign economies impacting exports. But the European consumer is clearly doing better which bodes well for 2016. 3. China reported its third quarter GNP on Monday and had the weakest quarter in 6 years. China Premier Li has been vocal, recently committing to moving forward on market oriented reforms to open up the country more to foreigners, ongoing urbanization, more transparency and increased infrastructure spending. Services and consumer spending are supporting growth while manufacturing and exports are relatively weak. A familiar story. By the way, credit growth has accelerated recently as monetary easing has spurred loans. The CPI increased 1.6% in September from a year earlier while the PPI fell 5.9%. There is more room for further monetary and regulatory initiatives to stimulate growth as has occurred elsewhere. 4. Japan’s government recently lowered its targets for growth this year as output/industrial production is weaker than anticipated due to slower growth overseas. Here again, consumer spending is holding up as employment and wages are slowly increasing and lower energy costs are boosting disposable personal income. Catch a theme here? The global consumer is holding up well while the global producer is weaker than anticipated. So why does muddling through work for me? Let’s get back to our core beliefs: the global economy, including the U.S., will continue to grow, albeit slowly, and there will be lower highs and higher lows as imbalances are contained and a conservative bias permeates at every level from government to business to the individual; interest rates will remain surprisingly low as global competition will keep a lid on inflation along with lower energy prices; the dollar will remain the currency of choice as this country’s global competitive situation continues to improve and energy independence remains a possibility down the road; earnings, excluding commodity related industries, will surprise on the upside despite relatively sluggish global growth; speculation is limited to real estate, art and private equity; the stock markets are undervalued as 10 year bonds are around 2.1%, the risk factor should be around 3 as leverage ratios keep falling; and S&P earnings are slightly higher in the aggregate and much higher in energy and commodity companies. It’s hard to imagine M & A getting any stronger. Another of our core beliefs. Finally this is all about asset allocation, stock selection and risk controls. I listened to or read the transcripts of at least a dozen companies last week starting with Alcoa (NYSE: AA ) and ending Friday with GE and Honeywell (NYSE: HON ). I really suggest that you take the time to read some of these transcripts as managements are really doing some amazing things. Alcoa is splitting into two companies; GE is selling most of its financial assets and reinvesting in its higher margin, higher return industrial businesses; Honeywell is churning out 10%+ growth and generating 110% free cash flow; Citi (NYSE: C ), Bank America (NYSE: BAC ), JP Morgan (NYSE: JPM ), PNC etc., are all making great strides not relying on a rising yield curve to make money; Intel (NASDAQ: INTC ) is upgrading its mix. I could go on and on. My portfolio is comprised of being long companies going through positive changes, short those with their heads in the ground, a few Larry Tisch value plays and there is no industry concentration. It really is stock specific. I remain around 93% net long, no bonds and no dollar currency trading position. Take the time to understand the strategic goals of the management of each company in your portfolio, step back and reflect hard and long on it, pause once again and consider all that could go wrong and also right, control your risk by maintaining ample liquidity and be patient as change doesn’t occur over night. There are clear winners and losers out there. Perfect for a hedge fund like ours. Change is a global phenomenon.