Author Archives: Scalper1

Making Sense Of Long-Term Returns

By Michael Batnick, CFA All advisers face the same challenge: How can we best help investors understand what sort of long-term returns they can rationally expect? This is an extremely important topic. It forms the basis of Social Security projections, pension estimates, and determining how much a household needs to save to retire comfortably. What’s often absent from a discussion on stock returns is the many ways in which returns can be measured. There are a lot of questions: What is the appropriate time period? Does one year make more sense than three years? What about a rolling return versus an annual return? When do we start measuring? Should we include the Great Depression or look at post World War II numbers? If you can’t see the importance of this conversation yet, it may be time for a quick reminder. Let’s go over a couple of different ways that we could measure the return of the S&P 500 Index. Remember as you’re reading this that it’s our job to make sure investors understand these nuances. Price Return vs. Total Return If you invested one dollar in the S&P 500 in 1928 (no, this was not possible at the time), it would have been worth ~$109 by the end of August 2015. If you were to measure the total return, however, that $1 jumps from $109 to $3,362! Nominal Return vs. Real Return It’s always important to account for inflation. If we do that, our $1 invested in 1928 becomes $342 in 2015. Compounding at 6.8% after inflation is still an impressive long-term return, even if it is just a tenth of what the total return looks like before inflation is accounted for. Average Return vs. Compound Return The S&P 500 (total return) has averaged nearly 12% a year since the mid-1920s, however, investors’ wealth would have compounded at just under 10%. The reason there is such a large gap between arithmetic and compound returns is because the 12% average returns are not earned in a straight line. There were years like 2008, when the index fell 37%. Once stocks lose 37%, they need to gain 58% to get back to even. As we often find ourselves explaining to the investing public, there are major differences between average annual returns and the returns of any individual year. In the chart below, you’ll notice that the average return of 7.5% (price only) was rarely seen in any one year. Only about 5% of the time did investors generate returns even close to the average. S&P 500 (Price Only) Perhaps a better way to present this data is the distribution of returns. S&P 500 Distribution of Annual Returns (Price Only) This can provide investors with a better idea of what the range of possibilities is. Expecting an average return of X% over a 20-year period is one thing, but being prepared for the outlier years and surviving them is something else entirely. And, of course, these outlier years can happen one after another. How does it change the way that you look at the world if you learned about markets during a year when they performed terribly? It’s a helpful exercise to break returns into different time periods to demonstrate the life-cycle experience an investor might have had. The chart below shows “bull” (green) and “bear” (red) market regimes throughout history. S&P 500 (Log Scale) People born in 1900 would probably count the Great Depression as the formative experience of their investing life cycle. It’s hard to imagine that living and working through it would not leave an indelible impression. Although every period in history is unique, one thing we can say with certainty is that bull and bear markets are permanent features of investing. Take a look at the returns in the table below. In the last 90 years, there were several periods of time when investors’ wealth compounded at very low rates. Pointing to average historical returns is little comfort to investors in the depths of a protracted bear market. Likewise, when markets get overextended, people tend to throw caution to the wind, learning nothing from history. Of course, we have to consider the reliability of the data itself. In an eye-opening paper published in The Journal of Investing, entitled ” The Myth of 1926: How much Do We Know about Long-Term Returns on US Stocks ?” Edward McQuarrie looks at the Center for Research in Security Prices (CRSP) database , which many argue is the gold standard for historical stock returns. He writes: “1) The CRSP time frame, which begins in 1926, excludes more than 50% of the historical record of widespread, large-scale stock trading in the United States, which goes back almost 200 years; and 2) for more than 50% of its time frame, the CRSP dataset excludes the majority of stocks trading in the United States, especially the smaller and more vulnerable enterprises. Putting these two facts together, we may say that CRSP provides comprehensive price series data for less than 20% of the total US stock trading record, aggregating across time period and type of stock.” McQuarrie shares some interesting insights about the way we think about historical stock returns. While not suggesting that the CRSP has failed in its due diligence, he makes the point that there are listing requirements that have undoubtedly omitted stocks from the database. We have seen that different starting periods and different ways of measuring returns can have significant implications for investors. So what if anything can we conclude and suggest to our clients? Here are a few things to remember: Past performance is absolutely not predictive of future results. Data can be manipulated! Sticking with an investment plan during a bad year (or a series of bad years) is what will make them successful. The results of diversification are predictable even if the results of an investment are not. Having a command of these issues and laying them out for our clients beforehand will make for a much more enlightening – and realistic – presentation. Disclaimer: Please note that the content of this site should not be construed as investment advice, nor do the opinions expressed necessarily reflect the views of CFA Institute.

Q4 Sector Momentum Composition

Not all sector exposure is created equal. In fact, there can be significant differences in holdings and performance between a momentum-weighted and capitalization-weighted sector ETF. Consider the table below which shows the top 5 holdings of our PowerShares DWA Momentum Sector ETFs shaded in green and the weights of those same positions in a capitalization-weighted ETF, shaded in blue. (click to enlarge) Source: Powershares and State State Street Advisors, 10/19/15 What accounts for the differences in holdings? A stock can have large capitalization, but weak momentum. The investment universe for the PowerShares Momentum ETFs includes Small, Mid, and Large Cap stocks. Also, keep in mind that the number of stocks in each momentum sector ETF can range from approximately 30-75. When small caps have better relative strength we will tend to have more holdings and when large caps are in favor we will tend to have fewer holdings. See the table below for the current number of stocks in each sector momentum index as well as their current market value. Source: PowerShares, as of 10/19/15 YTD performance of our momentum sector ETFs vs. their capitalization-weighted peers is shown below: As of 10/19/15. The performance above is based on pure price returns, not inclusive of dividends or all transaction costs. Past performance is not indicative of future results. Potential for profits is accompanied by possibility of loss. So far in 2015, 6 of our 9 momentum sector ETFs is outperforming their capitalization-weighted peers. The relative strength strategy is NOT a guarantee. There may be times where all investments and strategies are unfavorable and depreciate in value. See www.powershares.com for a prospectus. Dorsey Wright is the index provider for a suite of momentum ETFs with PowerShares.

4 Portfolio Recipes That Consistently Beat The ‘Lazy Portfolios’

Summary We analyzed several Lazy Portfolios (e.g., static asset allocation portfolios) by running a full set of risk and return metrics. We compared these Lazy Portfolios to over 250 other asset allocation portfolio recipes, both tactical (with dynamic reallocation) and strategic (with a fixed allocation). Four portfolio recipes emerged as winners that consistently beat the Lazy Portfolios. These winners have lower risk and higher return over both the 1-year and 10-year time periods. We recently received a question about the performance of the 8 “Lazy Portfolios” tracked by investment columnist Paul B. Farrell. The term “Lazy Portfolio” refers to a fixed asset allocation that is periodically rebalanced. We like to call this a “strategic portfolio recipe,” but a fixed asset allocation like this can also go by several other names, such as buy-and-hold portfolio, static portfolio, or passive allocation. A strategic portfolio with a fixed allocation can be contrasted with a tactical/dynamic portfolio that changes its allocation over time. Each of the Lazy Portfolios has a backstory or underlying theme, such as modeling the Yale endowment’s asset allocation or copying Ted Aronson’s family portfolio. This article will focus on the overall performance of the 8 portfolios, not their origin stories. Since VizMetrics already tracks over 250 portfolio recipes , we decided to add these 8 Lazy Portfolio recipes to the list of portfolios that we analyze monthly. We were eager to see how these compared to our entire set of strategic and tactical portfolio recipes. The Analysis Process We followed four steps to analyze the risk and return of the Lazy Portfolios and then search for portfolios that outperform the 8 Lazy Portfolios. Create the Lazy Portfolios . We used the exact Vanguard mutual funds and allocations specified for each Lazy Portfolio, and then we backtested their performance using monthly total returns and monthly rebalancing. Our data covered the 10 years ending September 30, 2015. Run the analysis . Then we compared risk and return over the past 1 year and over the past 10 years. We like using the 1-year period since we’ve seen some market turbulence recently, and we like looking at the last 10 years since that period includes the downturn of 2008-2009. If you look at risk vs. return for only a short, upward period, then you can overlook the true risk of the portfolio since the evaluation period doesn’t include much downside variation. Create scatterplots. We plotted risk vs. return for the Lazy Portfolios and all the other portfolios that we track. Filter the results . We found portfolios that beat the Lazy Portfolios, based on both risk and return. Identify the winners . We identified 4 portfolios that beat every Lazy Portfolio over both the 1-year and 10-year periods. The winners included two mutual funds, and two tactical portfolio recipes. Step 1: Create the Lazy Portfolios We created the Lazy Portfolios using Vanguard mutual funds, matching Farrell’s allocations. ETFs could be used instead of mutual funds, but we wanted to remain true to the original portfolio recipes. The Lazy Portfolios are constructed as follows: Lazy Portfolio Name Lazy Portfolio Recipe (ingredients and percentages) Lazy Portfolio: Aronson Family Taxable VEURX =5%, VIPSX =15%, VPACX =15%, VWEHX =5%, VISGX =5%, VISVX =5%, VTSMX =5%, VEIEX =10%, VEXMX =10%, VUSTX =10%, VFINX =15% Lazy Portfolio: Fundadvice Ultimate Buy & Hold VFINX=6%, VFISX =12%, VFITX =20%, VEIEX=6%, VGSIX =6%, NAESX =6%, VISVX =6%, VIVAX =6%, VIPSX=8%, VTMGX =12%, VTRIX =12% Lazy Portfolio: Coffeehouse VFINX=10%, VGSIX=10%, NAESX=10%, VISVX=10%, VIVAX=10%, VGTSX =10%, VBMFX =40% Lazy Portfolio: Margaritaville VIPSX=33%, VGTSX=33%, VTSMX=34% Lazy Portfolio: Dr. Bernstein’s No Brainer VFINX=25%, VEURX=25%, NAESX=25%, VBMFX=25% Lazy Portfolio: Second Grader’s Starter VBMFX=10%, VGTSX=30%, VTSMX=60% Lazy Portfolio: Dr. Bernstein’s Smart Money VEIEX=5%, VEURX=5%, VPACX=5%, VGSIX=5%, NAESX=5%, VISVX=10%, VIVAX=10%, VTSMX=15%, VFSTX =40% Lazy Portfolio: Yale U’s Unconventional VEIEX=5%, VTMGX=15%, VIPSX=15%, VUSTX=15%, VGSIX=20%, VTSMX=30% Step 2: Run the analysis Next we calculated the risk and return metrics for each of the 8 Lazy Portfolios. For the risk measure, we used Maximum Drawdown, which is the maximum percentage that each portfolio lost in value during the period, as measured at the end of each month. We like Maximum Drawdown for measuring risk since it captures quantitatively the “ouch!” that we feel when our portfolio hits the bottom. For the return measure, we used total annual return, which assumes that distributions are reinvested during the period. The Lazy Portfolios showed the following risk and return characteristics, for the period ending September 30, 2015: Lazy Portfolio Name 1-year annual return (%) 1-year maximum drawdown (%) 10-year annual return (%) 10-year maximum drawdown (%) Lazy Portfolio: Aronson Family Taxable -2.8 -9.2 5.9 -41.1 Lazy Portfolio: Fundadvice Ultimate Buy & Hold -2.4 -7.2 5.3 -35.7 Lazy Portfolio: Coffeehouse 0.7 -5.6 6.1 -36.0 Lazy Portfolio: Margaritaville -4.0 -8.5 5.0 -40.5 Lazy Portfolio: Dr. Bernstein’s No Brainer -1.6 -7.8 6.0 -43.3 Lazy Portfolio: Second Grader’s Starter -3.4 -9.6 5.7 -49.2 Lazy Portfolio: Dr. Bernstein’s Smart Money -1.0 -6.3 5.5 -37.6 Lazy Portfolio: Yale U’s Unconventional 0.9 -7.0 6.5 -42.2 Benchmark: The SPDR S&P 500 Trust ETF (NYSEARCA: SPY ) -0.8 -8.5 6.7 -50.8 Note that all the Lazy Portfolios had a maximum drawdown exceeding -35% over the past 10 years, with most worse than -40%. By comparison, the SPDR S&P 500 Trust ETF had a maximum drawdown of -50.8% with a 10-year return of 6.7%. Step 3: Create the scatterplots Now let’s separate the wheat from the chaff using a risk vs. return scatterplot. We plotted the performance of all the Lazy Portfolios along with all the other portfolio recipes in one view. This allows us to visualize two important metrics (risk and return) at the same time. With risk and return shown on the scatterplots below, the best portfolios (with the highest return and lowest risk) appear at the top left. In the plots below, the orange diamonds are the Lazy Portfolios. The blue squares are the portfolio recipes that showed both higher return and lower risk compared to the Lazy Portfolios. The yellow triangles are the additional portfolio recipes tracked by VizMetrics . For a benchmark comparison, we’ve also added SPY, shown as the purple circle. (click to enlarge) The 10-year scatterplot covers the period October 2004 to September 2015. The 1-year scatterplot covers the period October 2014 to September 2015. Step 4: Filter the results You can see that several blue squares are “northwest” (above and to the left) of all the orange Lazy Portfolios. Each blue square represents a portfolio with higher return and lower risk than every one of the Lazy Portfolios. In the 1-year scatterplot, there are 36 blue squares that beat all the Lazy Portfolios. In the 10-year scatterplot, there are 38 blue squares that beat all the Lazy Portfolios. Over the past 10 years, the broad U.S. equity market (represented by an exchange-traded fund, SPY) has generated a higher return than each of the Lazy Portfolios. But this higher return is accompanied by higher volatility. The Lazy Portfolios each have some fixed income exposure and this offers a lower-risk alternative to SPY that some investors may prefer. If we consider both the 1-year and 10-year time period, we find that the following four portfolios beat every Lazy Portfolio based on risk and return: The Four Winners (that outperform all of the Lazy Portfolios) 1-year annual return (%) 1-year maximum drawdown (%) 10-year annual return (%) 10-year maximum drawdown (%) Vanguard Wellesley ( VWINX ) 0.9 -3.2 6.8 -18.8 Vanguard Balanced ( VBIAX ) 1.0 -5.2 6.6 -32.5 Minimum Conditional Value-at-Risk Portfolio ( t.cvar ) 4.1 -4.0 10.0 -11.0 Minimum Drawdown Portfolio ( t.loss ) 8.0 -4.6 9.8 -13.4 Benchmark: S&P 500 ETF -0.8 -8.5 6.7 -50.8 Another portfolio, the “Strategic 60-40 Portfolio” ( s.6040 ) nearly beats all of the Lazy Portfolios, too. This portfolio beats 7 of the 8 Lazy Portfolios (all except “Yale U’s Unconventional”) over the 1-year and 10 year periods. The Strategic 60-40 Portfolio returned 6.4% over 10 years, and “Yale U’s Unconventional” returned 6.5%. Conclusions The 8 Lazy Portfolios do provide some diversification and have shown middle-of-the-pack performance. But there are better choices for investors. If you want a lazy, easy-to-maintain portfolio then either of the Vanguard funds, VWINX or VBIAX, are a better choice. These funds are even lazier than the 8 Lazy Portfolios, since you don’t have to buy and rebalance the ingredients yourself. Importantly, these Vanguard funds also provide better performance with lower risk. That’s a true “no brainer.” Or if you seek higher returns, and if you’re willing to rebalance monthly, you can look at tactical portfolio recipes, such as t.cvar and t.loss . To view the full set of risk and return scatterplots for over 250 portfolio recipes, sign up for a free trial of the VizMetrics Investor subscription. This also includes risk and return analytics for the 1-, 3-, 5-, 7-, and 10-year periods.