Tag Archives: management

Basic Chemicals Industry Has Been Hammered

Summary Introduction to Basic Chemicals. Industry overview. Top Companies in this industry by the numbers. Conclusion. Introduction to the Basic Chemicals Industry There are three distinct Industries that fall into the category of Chemicals: Basic, Diversified and Specialty. It depends upon what the primary focus, or the main source of revenue and earnings, is as to which category a company belongs. Basic chemicals are best defined as commodity chemicals. This group is primarily made up of polymers (about 33%), petrochemicals and intermediates (about 30%), other derivatives (about 20%), inorganic chemicals (about 12%) and fertilizers (about six percent). As a group the average annual growth rate is generally only a fraction of overall GDP growth. Petrochemicals, which are made primarily from liquid petroleum gas, crude oil and natural gas. There are usually used as feedstock to manufacture polymers and other more complex chemicals. Polymers are primarily used to make plastics and man-made fibers. Other derivatives includes resins, dyes, synthetic rubber, pigments, turpentine, carbon black and explosives. Fertilizers include phosphates, ammonia and potash. Inorganic chemicals include salt, chlorine, caustic soda, hydrogen peroxide, soda ash, titanium oxides and acids. Some of the companies in the basic chemicals industry contain smaller divisions that involve the life sciences, specialty chemicals, and consumer products. But the key to being classified as a basic chemical company is having the majority of product, revenue and earnings from those chemicals that fall into the basic or commodity chemical category. One might argue that huge chemical companies like Dow (NYSE: DOW ) and DuPont (NYSE: DD ) should be relegated to the diversified chemicals industry. But one would be mistaken since both companies derive the majority of revenue and income from basic chemicals that are generally used as feedstock to be made into other products. Both companies do make a variety of products that could be considered specialty chemicals or, in the case of DD, consumer products, but that does not preclude the fact that most of the revenue and earnings come from basic chemicals. Diversified chemical companies are what the name implies: more diversified and usually with a stable of products that could fit in either basic or specialty chemicals or as non-chemical products that are derived from using chemicals as a feedstock. These companies generally do not derive a majority of revenue or earnings from any one category. Specialty chemical companies derive the majority of revenue and earnings from more complex chemicals such as industrial gases, solvents, coatings, adhesives, cleaning chemicals and catalysts. The growth rate of demand for these products is generally much higher than the rate of GDP growth. These chemicals are used to make paints and other surface treatments, adhesives, sealants, pigments, inks, advanced polymers, and additives. But today I am focusing on the basic chemicals industry. It may grow slowly but it generally offers the highest average dividend yield. Industry Overview Most basic chemicals companies have fallen hard due to lower demand which led to lower revenue and earnings than expected. Several of the major companies in the industry are near 52-week lows. This factor caught my eye, along with the above average yields, and enticed me to dig deeper into future prospects for the industry. This spring witnessed a global bumper corn crop which, in turn, reduced demand in the short term for fertilizers. Global industrial demand has softened as well with the deceleration of China and many emerging markets. Growth in Europe is tepid and the U.S. is stuck in low gear as well with below average two percent GDP growth. The strength of the U.S. currency has also created a headwind for chemical manufacturers that are domiciled in the U.S. and derive a significant portion of revenue from exports. The recent market volatility in equities has been overly harsh on the companies in this industry. It appears that by bidding these shares lower many investors seem to expecting a recession. It should be noted here that even the companies in this industry considered to be of the best quality can get hit very hard during a recession. In 2008-09, the stock of DOW fell by some 87 percent; DD fell by 70 percent and Potash (NYSE: POT ) fell 80 percent. Thus, it is important to not buy stocks in this industry at or near the top. I expect additional headwinds to keep growth slow for much of this industry at least into early 2016. If the U.S. economy slides into a recession, which seems a possibility at this point, waiting for a better entry point would be warranted. I will discuss my plans and expectations for the industry in the conclusion. But there is also a very, very good side to this story that is coming in the not too distant future. With the prices of much of the basic feedstock for the basic chemicals industry near multi-year lows and likely to remain depressed compared to the highs reached in 2014, input costs are falling also. Those costs should remain low globally, but due discrepancies between U.S. energy prices and most global prices the producers with large capacity domiciled in North America should have a decided cost advantage. Secondly, when companies in this industry recover, the stock prices tend to rebound much faster than the broader market. POT rose by 200 percent in less than a year off its 2009 low. DOW jumped 600 percent in just two years. DD required two years and two months to rise just over 250 percent. POT and DD never cut dividends but DOW did, significantly. But the dividend is now above where it had been prior to the financial crisis. One more positive for some of the companies here is that the global population is expected to continue to grow and that will require more food productions. Companies that make and market fertilizers should amass revenue growth faster than overall economic growth over the long term. The point to this monologue is simply that finding the best entry point can be very important and, with yields well above the average for the S&P 500, this industry can offer a solid combination of great income and rock solid appreciation. Top Companies by the numbers This list does not constitute a recommendation to buy any of these companies at current prices. I make this statement in each of my industry analysis articles because this process is meant to provide a list of candidates for further inspection. I will write focus articles on my favorite company(s) when I believe the value proposition is most favorable. Also, I should make clear that I update my analysis on each industry only once a year and generally use audited year-end data with the exception of current price, dividend and yield. I prefer not to rely on data from quarterly reports since it is not audited and is often presented in an adjusted format that does not comply with GAAP which reduces comparability. Remember, I am not trying to make final picks here; I am trying to winnow down the list for consideration. With that said: Let’s look at the metrics for the leaders of the industry in no special order. Dow Chemical Metric DOW Industry Average Grade Dividend Yield 3.8% 4.2% Neutral Debt-to-Capital Ratio 46.9% 39.4% Fail Payout Ratio 54.0% 57.6% Pass 5-Yr Average Annual Dividend Increase 22.9% 18.7% Pass Free Cash Flow per Share $2.78 N/A Pass Net Profit Margin 7.0% 16.0% Fail 5-Yr Average Annual Growth in EPS 37.6% 3.9% Pass Return on Total Capital 10.9% 10.8% Pass 5-Yr Average Annual Growth in Revenue 5.2% 7.1% Fail S&P Credit Rating BBB N/A Pass DOW receives a report card with six Pass ratings, one neutral and three Fail ratings. I consider a reading within ten percent of the industry average to be neutral; below that is a fail. In the case of debt-to-capital, ten percent of 39.4 equals 3.9 percent. Dow’s ratio is 7.5 percent higher, thus it fails the category. I like DOW in many ways but cannot get too excited about the company since it did cut the dividend during the last crisis and I would prefer to not to have to endure such an event if a similar event occurred in the future. The net profit margin is much below the industry average. Expectations are higher for DOW than many of its peers as the current price (as of the close on Friday, August 28) of $44.00 is already more than 25 percent above its 52-week low and only 20 percent below its high. This is not a bad company, but it does not make my list for further review this year. The current price is slightly below its fair market value of $45.09 using the dividend discount model. E.I. DuPont de Nemours and Company Metric DD Industry Average Grade Dividend Yield 3.7% 4.2% Fail Debt-to-Capital Ratio 43.8% 39.4% Fail Payout Ratio 48.4% 57.6% Pass 5-Yr Average Annual Dividend Increase 3.4% 18.7% Fail Free Cash Flow $3.59 N/A Pass Net Profit Margin 10.7% 16.0% Fail 5-Yr Average Annual Growth in EPS 14.5% 3.9% Pass Return on Total Capital 17.1% 10.8% Pass 5-Yr Average Annual Growth in Revenue 5.8% 7.1% Fail S&P Credit Rating A N/A Pass DuPont receives only five pass ratings and five fail ratings. The first two fails are not horrible nor would those misses cause me to keep DD off the list. But, the average annual dividend increase is too low as there are far better options to consider. The current price of $51.84 is well above the estimated fair value of $21.80 using the dividend discount model. The low value is primarily due to very low expectations for future dividend increases that are likely to continue at the slow pace of the past five years. It is another huge company with a very stable and predictable future, but it is not among the best, in my humble opinion. Potash Corporation of Saskatchewan Metric POT Industry Average Grade Dividend Yield 5.9% 4.2% Pass Debt-to-Capital Ratio 32.3% 39.4% Pass Payout Ratio 83.1% 57.6% Fail 5-Yr Average Annual Dividend Increase 63.5% 18.7% Pass Free Cash Flow $1.33 N/A Pass Net Profit Margin 21.7% 16.0% Pass 5-Yr Average Annual Growth in EPS 10.5% 3.9% Pass Return on Total Capital 13.6% 10.8% Pass 5-Yr Average Annual Growth in Revenue 13.9% 7.1% Pass S&P Credit Rating A- N/A Pass POT receives a glowing report card by the numbers: 9 Pass and 1 Fail ratings. The one fail is a concern to the extent that it means that future increases in the dividend will necessarily be more muted than in the past five years. But when we start so near six percent it is less of a concern. Potash has potential for the long term. I think we may be able to get a better entry price sometime over the next six to nine months, but the current price ($25.95) is only pennies above my estimated fair value of $25.33. The current price is also just 8.6 percent above its 52-week low and a full 31 percent below the 52-week high. The long-term prospects are also very good as fertilizer, the main business of POT, will continue to grow in demand as the world population expands. The Mosaic Company (NYSE: MOS ) Metric MOS Industry Average Grade Dividend Yield 2.7% 4.2% Fail Debt-to-Capital Ratio 26.3% 39.4% Pass Payout Ratio 41.0% 57.6% Pass 5-Yr Average Annual Dividend Increase 40.6% 18.7% Pass Free Cash Flow $2.31 N/A Pass Net Profit Margin 11.4 16.0% Fail 5-Yr Average Annual Growth in EPS -8.9% 3.9% Fail Return on Total Capital 7.6% 10.8% Fail 5-Yr Average Annual Growth in Revenue 1.2% 7.1% Fail S&P Credit Rating BBB N/A Pass MOS receives five Passes and five Fails. While the long-term prospects are bright, management failed to respond as well to adverse circumstances as did rival POT. While that may be more a matter of product mix, that would suffice as an explanation but not dismiss the relative lackluster results. On the other hand, MOS is trading at a considerable discount to estimated fair value ($66.70) with a current price of $41.04. That is based primarily upon significantly higher expectations for future dividend growth. The higher rate of growth is possible due to its relatively low payout ratio compared to the industry and future EPS growth prospects from a modest 2104 base. It is about ten percent above its 52-week low and nearly 24 percent below its high. MOS does not make the list for further review. CVR Partners, LP (NYSE: UAN ) Metric UAN Industry Average Grade Dividend Yield 14.1% 4.2% Pass Debt-to-Capital Ratio 23.2% 39.4% Pass Payout Ratio 151.5% 57.6% Fail 5-Yr Average Annual Dividend Increase 12.3% 18.7% Fail Free Cash Flow $1.12 N/A Pass Net Profit Margin 25.5% 16.0% Pass 5-Yr Average Annual Growth in EPS -17.1% 3.9% Fail Return on Total Capital 15.0% 10.8% Pass 5-Yr Average Annual Growth in Revenue -5.5% 7.1% Fail S&P Credit Rating NR N/A Fail UAN receives five Pass and five Fail ratings. Since it is a limited partnership created primarily to provide income in the form of dividends to its unit holders, I would not be too concerned about the payout ratio in and of itself. However, no matter how enticing the yield may be, negative growth in EPS and revenue per share are red flags. But the current price ($11.04) seems to already reflect many of the problems and looking to the future the prospects begin to show signs of hope for future growth. Long-term, fertilizer will be in greater demand and prices should rise with demand while input costs remain relatively low. Fair value for UAN is estimated at $22.59, more than double the current share price. But the price is already nearly 20 percent above the 52-week low and 31 percent below the high. This is a very volatile stock, so if you find yourself enticed by the yield consider waiting for a better entry price closer to the low of $8.52 and do not forget that this issue carries higher risk. Terra Nitrogen, LP (NYSE: TNH ) Metric TNH Industry Average Grade Dividend Yield 8.7% 4.2% Pass Debt-to-Capital Ratio 0.0% 39.4% Pass Payout Ratio 78.2% 57.6% Fail 5-Yr Average Annual Dividend Increase 13.5% 18.7% Fail Free Cash Flow 17.47 N/A Pass Net Profit Margin 57.1% 16.0% Pass 5-Yr Average Annual Growth in EPS 17.5% 3.9% Pass Return on Total Capital 121.4% 10.8% Pass 5-Yr Average Annual Growth in Revenue 5.0% 7.1% Fail S&P Credit Rating NR N/A Neutral TNH has no debt so the neutral rating could easily be a Pass. In all, it receives six pass, one neutral and three fail ratings. EPS growth is an aberration since it was calculated from the base year of 2009, a year in which EPS dropped from $14.90 to $5.40 per share. Growth has not been steady. That is a problem for me. But the margins are consistently among the highest in the industry. I like the yield and lack of debt, but not the inconsistent results. The inconsistency of the dividend, similar to the case of UNH, results from this company being structured as a limited partnership design to provide as much income as possible to unit holders. For this reason the payout ratio does not concern me. This is another stock for those seeking yield and able to withstand the rollercoaster ride. It does not make my list for further review. Conclusion For those who are wondering why I did not include Compass Minerals (NYSE: CMP ), Axiall Corporation (NYSE: AXLL ) or Olin Corporation (NYSE: OLN ), it is because the credit ratings on debt issued by these companies is below investment grade. That is one of my thresholds. CF Industries (NYSE: CF ) and FMC Corp (NYSE: FMC ) yield too far below the industry average and below my 2.5 percent threshold, so those companies were also not included. Agrium (NYSE: AGU ) and CF also missed the list because both companies have negative free cash flow. Positive free cash flow is a must for inclusion. I believe that share prices for this industry could go lower from here and test the 52-week lows again, so I plan to wait for better entry prices on my favorite companies in this industry. I will write focus articles on each when I believe the worst is behind the industry and greater future opportunity exists. I do not believe that the volatility is over, but we will see. If I am proven wrong this coming week I could be kicking myself for not pulling the trigger. But I need to invest according to my convictions and from what I am reading in this market I expect more volatility and another opportunity to buy at better values. I would like to explain a little about my investment philosophy: My focus is to add income when it is cheap enough. In other words, I like to determine the ideal yield I would accept from a stock as my target for entering a new position. I rely on my patience that took some time and age to develop. A good example that illustrates these principles, if you are interested, is a recent article that I wrote about XOM. If you are not familiar with how I analyze companies and industries please consider my age-old favorite, ” The Dividend Investors’ Guide to Successful Investing ,” where I provide more details about my process for selecting companies for my master list and details about why I use the metrics that I do. I have made one primary adjustment from that earlier set of rules regarding the debt to total capital ratio. While I remain very cautious regarding free cash flow and companies’ ability to service and repay debt if the economy experiences another financial crisis, which I believe is still possible, I place an emphasis on debt levels relative to a company’s industry peers. But I have adjusted my calculation to be more in line with traditional convention and now use the total of debt plus equity to represent total capital. It is easier to understand and there is really very little difference from my earlier method, so the variance is of little consequence. As always, I welcome comments and will try to address any concerns or questions either in the comments section or in a future article as soon as I can. The great thing about Seeking Alpha is that we can agree to disagree and, through respectful discussion, learn from each other’s experience and knowledge. Disclosure: I/we have no positions in any stocks mentioned, and no plans to initiate any positions within the next 72 hours. (More…) I wrote this article myself, and it expresses my own opinions. I am not receiving compensation for it (other than from Seeking Alpha). I have no business relationship with any company whose stock is mentioned in this article. Additional disclosure: I intend to start a position in POT, but probably not within the next 72 hours.

An 80/20 Filter On How The DJIA Weathered The Week

Volatility is the subject of the week. Investors have the opportunity, even the responsibility, to determine how to manage volatility. Using my investment club as an example, an 80/20 filter applied to the DJIA analyzes how the index weathered the week and identifies the top six components for investment consideration. A record-setting week is over. Industry experts are still debating what actually happened and why. Yet, the advice seems to be consistent – expect the volatility to continue. With volatility comes an opportunity, even responsibility, to understand your personal price points. At what point would you sell? At what point would you buy? It’s probably a fair statement that even if one had limit orders set, the odds were small of actually having enough cash to cover all of one’s desirable trades or actually seeing all the orders execute. But, that doesn’t mean the exercise to determine buy points or sell points would be fruitless. I rarely construct an article based wholly on my investment club. But, this article inspired me to start laying a foundation with the members – just in case a bear market is here or around the corner or down the road. I realized the volatility described in the article would fit perfectly with the club’s 2015 goals. At the beginning of the year, we set a theme for 2015 of “Why don’t we?”. We’ve been a club for nearly a decade. It was time to ask the question: “Why don’t we own X or Y or Z?”. For example, why haven’t we invested in the businesses from where we purchase our gasoline, drive through for our snacks or drinks, do our Christmas shopping or to where we pay those expensive insurance premiums? That’s not to say every business would warrant an investment. But, we should at least do the analysis and know the reasons why we were waiting on or eliminating the option. So, with the club in mind, this week provided a prime opportunity to muse over the thirty components of the DJIA (Dow Jones Industrial Average). The club doesn’t currently have an investment in each component for a variety of reasons. In some cases, we’ve truly opted to pass. In others, we’ve not yet done the work. Since hindsight is supposedly 20/20, if this week were to repeat, which components should capture our attention? What would be our buy point? To begin consideration of the DJIA components in the past week, the primary questions centered on how they weathered the storm. How far did they fall? Did they recover? This wasn’t to be an exercise in analyzing each component but rather an exercise in narrowing the focus. Like most individuals, we don’t have an abundance of cash sitting and waiting to be invested. After all, we are an investment club not a savings club. Therefore, using the 80/20 rule, it seemed wisest to determine on which six (20%) of the DJIA to focus. Choosing the six means (hopefully) eliminating twenty-four based on reasonable criteria. Many industry experts say that a true correction requires a pullback of at least 10%. In this case, the question is a pullback from what? One could use the closing price from August 21st. The problem is that some stocks had already started a correction pattern. One could use a stock’s 52 week high. But, there are a variety of reasons why a stock may have pulled off its high. For example, the energy-related stocks are well off their highs. The fairest starting point for each stock seemed to be its 50-day moving average. Returning to the concept that there are companies well off their 52-week highs, there are logical reasons why now or the near future may not be a good time for investing in those companies. A reasonable rule of thumb seemed to be that it’s not time to invest in a company whose 50-day moving average was more than 25% from its 52-week high. This guideline eliminated Caterpillar (NYSE: CAT ), Chevron (NYSE: CVX ), E.I. Du Pont (NYSE: DD ), Intel (NASDAQ: INTC ), Wal-Mart (NYSE: WMT ) and Exxon Mobil (NYSE: XOM ). Component 50-Day Moving Average 52-Week High 50-Day From 52-Week AAPL $118.85 $134.54 13.20% AXP $77.86 $94.89 21.87% BA $142.00 $158.83 11.85% CAT $78.37 $109.73 40.02% CSCO $27.73 $30.31 9.30% CVX $86.57 $129.53 49.62% DD $55.22 $76.59 38.70% DIS $111.93 $122.08 9.07% GE $25.89 $28.68 10.78% GS $202.66 $218.77 7.95% HD $116.40 $123.80 6.36% IBM $158.29 $195.00 23.19% INTC $28.67 $37.90 32.19% JNJ $98.74 $109.49 10.89% JPM $67.46 $70.61 4.67% KO $40.76 $45.00 10.40% MCD $98.04 $101.88 3.92% MMM $149.69 $170.50 13.90% MRK $57.75 $63.62 10.16% MSFT $45.81 $50.05 9.26% NKE $112.86 $117.72 4.31% PFE $34.78 $36.46 4.83% PG $77.04 $93.89 21.87% TRV $104.45 $110.49 5.78% UNH $120.64 $126.21 4.62% UTX $100.33 $124.45 24.04% V $72.82 $76.92 5.63% VZ $46.73 $51.73 10.70% WMT $70.97 $90.97 28.18% XOM $78.56 $99.67 26.87% Next, using the “rule” that a correction requires a decrease of 10%, American Express (NYSE: AXP ) and Traveler’s Companies (NYSE: TRV ) were both eliminated. Component 50-Day Moving Average August 24th Low Low From 50-Day AAPL $118.85 $92.00 29.18% AXP $77.86 $71.71 8.58% BA $142.00 $115.14 23.33% CSCO $27.73 $23.03 20.41% DIS $111.93 $90.00 24.37% GE $25.89 $19.37 33.66% GS $202.66 $172.10 17.76% HD $116.40 $92.17 26.29% IBM $158.29 $143.00 10.69% JNJ $98.74 $81.79 20.72% JPM $67.46 $50.07 34.73% KO $40.76 $36.56 11.49% MCD $98.04 $87.50 12.05% MMM $149.69 $134.00 11.71% MRK $57.75 $45.69 26.40% MSFT $45.81 $39.72 15.33% NKE $112.86 $94.50 19.43% PFE $34.78 $27.51 26.43% PG $77.04 $65.02 18.49% TRV $104.45 $95.21 9.70% UNH $120.64 $95.00 26.99% UTX $100.33 $87.17 15.10% V $72.82 $60.00 21.37% VZ $46.73 $38.06 22.78% Likewise, if a company recovered to within 10% of its 52-week high, it doesn’t seem that company would be offering a “bargain” opportunity. That’s not to say the company is not fairly valued. However, if the goal is to take advantage of volatility, there may be companies with more room left to run. This filter eliminated Home Depot (NYSE: HD ), McDonald’s (NYSE: MCD ), Nike (NYSE: NKE ), United Healthcare (NYSE: UNH ) and Visa (NYSE: V ). Component August 29th Close 52-Week High Current to 52-Week AAPL $113.29 $134.54 18.76% BA $133.24 $158.83 19.21% CSCO $26.00 $30.31 16.58% DIS $102.48 $122.08 19.13% GE $25.16 $28.68 13.99% GS $187.75 $218.77 16.52% HD $117.52 $123.80 5.34% IBM $147.98 $195.00 31.77% JNJ $95.17 $109.49 15.05% JPM $64.13 $70.61 10.10% KO $39.45 $45.00 14.07% MCD $96.25 $101.88 5.85% MMM $144.21 $170.50 18.23% MRK $55.37 $63.62 14.90% MSFT $43.93 $50.05 13.93% NKE $112.50 $117.72 4.64% PFE $32.66 $36.46 11.64% PG $71.21 $93.89 31.85% UNH $117.28 $126.21 7.61% UTX $93.24 $124.45 33.47% V $72.46 $76.92 6.16% VZ $46.07 $51.73 12.29% Speaking of recovering, if a company’s share price did not “bounce” back this week, that may suggest weakness. It seemed reasonable to expect at least a 50% bounce or recovery from Monday’s lows. Filtering for components with a recovery of less than 50% eliminated International Business Machines (NYSE: IBM ) and United Technologies (NYSE: UTX ). Component August 24th Low August 29th Close 50-Day Moving Average Percentage Recovered AAPL $92.00 $113.29 $118.85 79.29% BA $115.14 $133.24 $142.00 67.39% CSCO $23.03 $26.00 $27.73 63.19% DIS $90.00 $102.48 $111.93 56.91% GE $19.37 $25.16 $25.89 88.80% GS $172.10 $187.75 $202.66 51.21% IBM $143.00 $147.98 $158.29 32.57% JNJ $81.79 $95.17 $98.74 78.94% JPM $50.07 $64.13 $67.46 80.85% KO $36.56 $39.45 $40.76 68.81% MMM $134.00 $144.21 $149.69 65.07% MRK $45.69 $55.37 $57.75 80.27% MSFT $39.72 $43.93 $45.81 69.13% PFE $27.51 $32.66 $34.78 70.84% PG $65.02 $71.21 $77.04 51.50% UTX $87.17 $93.24 $100.33 46.12% VZ $38.06 $46.07 $46.73 92.39% The club has a predominant goal of a 10% annual return for our portfolio. With total shareholder return as the focus, it’s natural to look at the dividend yield of the components. The current average yield of the DJIA is 2.86%. Of the remaining fifteen components, Disney (NYSE: DIS ) and Goldman Sachs (NYSE: GS ) are not offering a yield at half that mark. Therefore, both were moved to the eliminated bucket. Component August 29th Close Dividend AAPL $113.29 1.84% BA $133.24 2.73% CSCO $26.00 3.23% DIS $102.48 1.29% GE $25.16 3.66% GS $187.75 1.38% JNJ $95.17 3.15% JPM $64.13 2.74% KO $39.45 3.35% MMM $144.21 2.84% MRK $55.37 3.25% MSFT $43.93 2.82% PFE $32.66 3.43% PG $71.21 3.72% VZ $46.07 4.78% At this point, seventeen of the thirty components have been eliminated. In theory, the list now contains thirteen companies with room left to run and a yield tallying at least half the average of the index. Specifically for my club, we already own four companies on the remaining list. It would be easy to just focus on the nine that are left. But, the wiser option would be to include them and evaluate whether any of our four merit a reinvestment. Focusing on the total potential for return aligns with our club goal of 10% annual return. In ten of the thirteen remaining components, the one-year target exceeds the 52-week high. Only 3M (NYSE: MMM ), Procter & Gamble (NYSE: PG ) and Verizon (NYSE: VZ ) have one-year targets below their respective 52-week highs. For the sake of being conservative, when calculating the potential growth for share price appreciation for each of the thirteen, the lower of the 52-week high or the one-year target is used. Calculating the remaining growth from share price appreciation equates to a range of 10.1% to 19.2%. It would be easy to simply eliminate the lowest five companies. However, the company with one of the lowest growth potential rates, Verizon, also happens to offer the best dividend yield at 4.78%. Therefore, it is prudent to add the potential growth for share price appreciation to the dividend yield. In order to achieve a 10% annual return, the club typically targets potential returns of 20%. Thus, even if a company achieves just half its goal, the club hits its target. As shown, at current prices, three of the components offer a potential return over 20% – Procter & Gamble, Boeing (NYSE: BA ) and Apple (NASDAQ: AAPL ). Cisco (NASDAQ: CSCO ) also comes very close. Ironically, these are the four companies in which the club already has positions. Thus, all four companies will be considered for reinvestment when prices are near the August 28th closing price. Component August 28th Close 52-Week High or One-Year Target Potential Growth Dividend Potential Total Return PG $71.21 $84.50 18.66% 3.72% 22.38% BA $133.24 $158.83 19.21% 2.73% 21.94% AAPL $113.29 $134.54 18.76% 1.84% 20.59% CSCO $26.00 $30.31 16.58% 3.23% 19.81% JNJ $95.17 $109.49 15.05% 3.15% 18.20% MRK $55.37 $63.62 14.90% 3.25% 18.15% GE $25.16 $28.68 13.99% 3.66% 17.65% KO $39.45 $45.00 14.07% 3.35% 17.41% MMM $144.21 $164.31 13.94% 2.84% 16.78% MSFT $43.93 $50.05 13.93% 2.82% 16.75% VZ $46.07 $51.42 11.61% 4.78% 16.39% PFE $32.66 $36.46 11.64% 3.43% 15.06% JPM $64.13 $70.61 10.10% 2.74% 12.85% For the purpose of considering new positions in the next six companies on the list above, Johnson & Johnson (NYSE: JNJ ), Merck (NYSE: MRK ), General Electric (NYSE: GE ), Coca-Cola (NYSE: KO ), 3M, and Microsoft (NASDAQ: MSFT ), the club would have to take advantage of volatility and market pullbacks. A buy point must be determined which fulfills the goal of a potential return of at least 20%. As prices fall, the dividend yield will rise as will the potential growth in share price appreciation. The next table establishes buy points based on these changes. Component Buy Point 52-Week High or One-Year Target Potential Growth Dividend Potential Total Return JNJ $93.74 $109.49 16.80% 3.20% 20.00% MRK $54.51 $63.62 16.71% 3.30% 20.01% GE $24.66 $28.68 16.30% 3.73% 20.03% KO $38.60 $45.00 16.58% 3.42% 20.00% MMM $140.34 $164.31 17.08% 2.92% 20.00% MSFT $42.74 $50.05 17.10% 2.90% 20.00% Since the club is already familiar with four of the top six components, this exercise actually identified the top 33% (10) of the DJIA components relative, primarily, to weathering the week. The next step for my investment club is to determine if any of the next six companies kindle an interest. If so, our buy points are established. Disclosure: I am/we are long AAPL, BA, CSCO, DIS, INTC, NKE, PG, V. (More…) I wrote this article myself, and it expresses my own opinions. I am not receiving compensation for it (other than from Seeking Alpha). I have no business relationship with any company whose stock is mentioned in this article.

Value Stocks Are Still Not Attractive

There is no mystery in the ongoing behavior of value stocks against growth. It reflects a combination of low 10-year yields and a strong dollar, both of which are positive for growth stocks. As long as U.S. Treasury yields and the U.S. dollar will remain negatively correlated, value stocks may not outperform. Since the Fed started mentioning tapering, the relationship between the relative performance of value against growth and U.S. Treasury yields has broken down at least twice (see chart below). Episodes of higher yields should have benefited value stocks but did actually not. Yet, taking a long view, the long lasting underperformance of value is not really surprising – value stocks have suffered from the long decline in U.S. Treasury yields: conundrum, great recession, secular stagnation… Contrary to the late 1990s, the outperformance of growth is not linked to any bubble (Internet stocks in 98/99). From this perspective, only a significant reversal in U.S. long term yield would call for a structurally long position on value against growth. Once again the arbitrage for value when yields are going up is not linked to the growth expectations embedded in long term yields (which would call for growth stocks to outperform) but rather on the yield arbitrage (growth stocks have a much lower E/P hence a required price adjustment that is much significant than that of high E/P value stocks). The ongoing strength of the U.S. dollar also explains the relative strength of growth stocks. As can be seen below, bullish trends for the USD are generally positive for growth sub-indexes. On a three-month basis, the recent behavior of the USD would yet suggest either that growth-stock outperformance is overdue or that stocks are pricing a sharp rebound in the U.S. currency. Bottom Line: There is no mystery in the ongoing behavior of value stocks against growth. It reflects a combination of low 10-year yields and a strong dollar, both of which are positive for growth stocks (at least on a relative perspective). The question is therefore not about any “weird” behavior of value stocks but rather about the nature of the relationship between 10-year yields and the USD: how long will U.S. Treasury yields and the U.S. dollar remain negatively correlated? The chart below suggests that the correlation break is close to be the longest ever. As long as it lasts, value won’t be attractive. Disclosure: I/we have no positions in any stocks mentioned, and no plans to initiate any positions within the next 72 hours. (More…) I wrote this article myself, and it expresses my own opinions. I am not receiving compensation for it (other than from Seeking Alpha). I have no business relationship with any company whose stock is mentioned in this article. Share this article with a colleague