Tag Archives: management

Finding Bargains Among High Income CEFs Selling At Historic Discounts

Summary The discounts associated with CEFs are at historic highs, with many discounts over 2 standard deviations from the mean. The highly discounted CEFs have been significantly more volatile than high yield bonds. MGU and GLO had the best risk-adjusted performance among the CEFs analyzed. As an income focused investor, I was a fan of high distribution Closed End Funds (CEFs). Many of these funds have been hit hard by the Fed’s plans to increase interest rates. As the prices deteriorated, the discounts of these CEFs have widened to historically large levels. This is evidenced by their Z-score, a statistic popularized by Morningstar to measure how far a discount (or premium) is from the mean discount (or premium). The Z-score is computed in terms of standard deviations from the mean so it can be used to rank CEFs. A good source for Z-scores is the CEFAnalysis website . (Thanks to SA author, Left Bank, for his article on where to find Z-scores). A Z-score more negative than minus 2 is relatively rare, occurring less than 2.25% of the time. However, in today’s environment, there are over 150 CEFs that have one year Z-scores more negative than minus 2, which illustrates the current lack of demand for these CEFs. There were too many CEFs to analyze so I reduced the sample size by using the following selection criteria: A Z-score more negative than minus 2.9. This will occur (assuming a normal distribution) less than 0.2% of the time. A history that includes October 12, 2007 (the beginning of the 2008 bear market) A daily average volume greater than 100,000 shares A market cap of at least $100 million. A distribution of 6% or higher The following CEFs satisfy all these criteria. Clough Global Opportunities Fund (NYSEMKT: GLO ). The CEF sells at a discount of 16.7% and has a Z-score of negative 3.59. This CEF has a “go anywhere” philosophy and has a portfolio of 167 securities, with 60% allocated to the equities, 28% to cash alternatives, and 7% to bonds. The fund may also use an option strategy to increase income. The fund uses a high leverage of 52% and has an expense ratio of 2.2%. The distribution is 10.7%, consisting primarily of gains and Return of Capital (ROC). Over the past year, ROC has been used 50% of the time, with the amount of ROC ranging from 30% to 100%. Invesco Credit Opportunities Fund (NYSE: VTA ). This CEF sells at a discount of 15.3% and has a Z-score of negative 3.59. It has a portfolio of 610 securities invested primarily in senior loans (76%) and high yield bonds (18%). The fund uses 33% leverage and has an expense ratio of 2.5%. The distribution is 8.2% with no ROC. Madison Covered Call and Equity Strategy Fund (NYSE: MCN ). This CEF sells at a discount of 15.1% and has a Z-score of negative 3.3. The portfolio consists of 47 securities, with 78% in equities and 20% in short-term debt. The fund does not use leverage and has an expense ratio of 0.8%. The distribution is 9.7% with no ROC. LMP Corporate Loan Fund (NYSE: TLI ). This CEF sells for a discount of 13% and has a Z-score of negative 3.25. The portfolio consists of 268 securities invested primarily in senior loans (87%) and high yield bonds (8%). The fund uses 33% leverage and has an expense ratio of 1.8%. The distribution is 8.4% with no ROC. Macquarie Global Infrastructure Total Return Fund (NYSE: MGU ). This CEF sells for a discount of 16.9% and has a Z-score of negative 3.09. The fund is concentrated with 51 holdings in infrastructure companies (89%) and 6% in master limited partnerships. The fund uses 30% leverage and has an expense ratio of 2.2%. The distribution is 7%, paid from income and capital gains with no ROC. Calamos Convertible Opportunities and Income Fund (NASDAQ: CHI ). This CEF sells at a discount of 11.2% and has a Z-score of negative 3.04. The portfolio consists of 287 securities, with 57% in convertible bonds and 38% in high yield bonds. The fund uses 28% leverage and has an expense ratio of 1.5%. The distribution is 10.8% with 2 months of ROC during the past year. MS Emerging Markets Debt Fund (NYSE: MSD ). This CEF sells for a discount of 18.3% and has a Z-score of negative 2.95. The portfolio consists of 115 emerging market holdings, with 41% investment grade bonds and the rest in high yield bonds. The fund uses only 8% leverage and has an expense ratio of 3.5%. The distribution is 6.6% with no ROC. GDL Fund (NYSE: GDL ). This CEF sells for a discount of 18.1% and has a Z-score of negative 2.9. The fund seeks total return by using arbitrage transactions and investing in reorganizations and spinoffs. It has 159 holdings, with 75% in equity and 21% in Government bonds. It uses 35% leverage and has an expense ratio of 3%. The distribution is 6.5% with only a small amount of ROC over the past year (the distribution for one quarter had 25% ROC). Based on the Z-score, these high income CEFs appear to be bargains, but Z-score is only one metric to consider. I also like to look at the reward-versus-risk over different time frames. In my mind, the best fund is the one that delivers the highest reward for a given level of risk. This article will analyze these CEFs in terms of risk-versus-reward to help you determine which may be right for your portfolio. To assess the performance of the selected CEFs, I plotted the annualized rate of return in excess of the risk free rate (called Excess Mu in the charts) versus the volatility of each of the component funds over the past bear-bull cycle (from October 12, 2007 to August 28, 2015). The risk free rate was set at 0% so that performance could be easily assessed. This plot is shown in Figure 1. Note that the rate of return is based on price, not Net Asset Value (NAV). I used the iShares iBoxx $ High Yield Corporate Bond ETF (NYSEARCA: HYG ) as a reference. (click to enlarge) Figure 1. Risk versus Reward over the bear-bull cycle The plot illustrates that these CEFs have booked a wide range of returns. To better assess the relative performance of these funds, I calculated the Sharpe Ratio. The Sharpe Ratio is a metric, developed by Nobel laureate William Sharpe that measures risk-adjusted performance. It is calculated as the ratio of the excess return over the volatility. This reward-to-risk ratio (assuming that risk is measured by volatility) is a good way to compare peers to assess if higher returns are due to superior investment performance or from taking additional risk. In Figure 1, I plotted a red line that represents the Sharpe Ratio associated with HYG. If an asset is above the line, it has a higher Sharpe Ratio than HYG. Conversely, if an asset is below the line, the reward-to-risk is worse than HYG. Some interesting observations are evident from the figure. High Z-score CEFs are substantially more volatile than HYG. This is not surprising since CEFs can sell at discounts and many use leverage. With the exception of VTA, the CEFs had larger absolute returns than HYG. However, when volatility is factored into the calculation, only 4 CEFs (GDL, GLO, MGU, and MSD) beat HYG on a risk-adjusted basis. Two other CEFs (TLI and MCU) had risk-adjusted performances similar to HYG. Among the CEFs, MSD was the best performer followed by GLO, MGU, and GDL. The worst performer on a risk-adjusted and absolute basis was VTA. These funds utilized different investment strategies, so I wanted to assess how much diversification you might receive by buying multiple funds. To be “diversified,” you want to choose assets such that when some assets are down, others are up. In mathematical terms, you want to select assets that are uncorrelated (or at least not highly correlated) with each other. I calculated the pair-wise correlations associated with the funds. For reference, I also included the SPDR S&P 500 Trust ETF (NYSEARCA: SPY ) as a proxy for the overall stock market. The results are presented in Figure 2. (click to enlarge) Figure 2. Correlation over the bear-bull cycle The figure presents what is called a correlation matrix. The symbols for the funds are listed in the first column on the left side of the figure. The symbols are also listed along the first row at the top. The number in the intersection of the row and column is the correlation between the two assets. For example, if you follow VTA to the right for three columns, you will see that the intersection with GLO is 0.650. This indicates that, over the past bear-bull cycle, the price of VTA and GLO were 65% correlated. Note that all assets are 100% correlated with themselves so the values along the diagonal of the matrix are all ones. As shown in the figure, the CEFs were not very correlated with HYG or among themselves. The highest correlation was between SPY and GLO, which was expected since GLO contained a large position in equities. The overall conclusion is that you can obtain diversification by purchasing more than one of these funds. Next, I wanted to see how these funds fared during more recent times so I used a 5-year look-back period. The results are shown in Figure 3 and what a difference a few years made. The CEFs are still more volatile than HYG, but HYG now beats all the CEFs in terms of risk-adjusted performance. MSD fell from being the best performer to the worst, and VTA moved up from being at the bottom to the third best. MGU had by far the best risk-adjusted performance among the CEFs, with GLO coming in second. GDL was again the least volatile but also did not have a high return. (click to enlarge) Figure 3. Risk versus reward over past 5 years My final analysis used a 3-year look-back period, and the results are shown in Figure 4. During this period, GLO, MGU, and MCN were the top performers on a risk-adjusted basis. These CEFs outperformed HYG on both an absolute and risk-adjusted basis. MSD continued its poor performance, booking a negative return. (click to enlarge) Figure 4. Risk versus reward over the past 3 years Bottom Line These large Z-score CEFs had a wide range of performance relative to each other and to HYG. All of these CEFs are much more volatile than high yield bonds so they would only be suitable for risk tolerant investors. These CEFs are at historically wide discounts and may be bargains in terms of discounts but their overall performance left something to be desired. If you want to take a gamble on these funds, I would recommend MGU. GLO could also be considered, but I am a little cautious of this fund’s ROC. No one can predict the future, but based on the past, these two CEFs have consistently outperformed their peers on a risk-adjusted basis. Disclosure: I/we have no positions in any stocks mentioned, but may initiate a long position in MGU over the next 72 hours. (More…) I wrote this article myself, and it expresses my own opinions. I am not receiving compensation for it (other than from Seeking Alpha). I have no business relationship with any company whose stock is mentioned in this article.

Debunking The Misleading Big Data ETF

PureFunds introduces new big data-focused ETF, tracking the ISE big data index. A deeper look at the index reveals social media networks, credit data providers, and Internet companies in the ETFs’ top holdings. Investors should look under the hood of non-trivial sector-focused ETFs. ETF provider PureFunds is a relatively new player in the ETF market, competing fiercely with financial giants that dominate the ETF market, like Vanguard, Blackrock’s (NYSE: BLK ) iShares, State Street’s (NYSE: STT ) SPDR, etc. PureFunds is familiar to most investors as the provider of the Cyber Security ETF (NYSEARCA: HACK ) that was launched in November 2014, which attempts to provide a passive investment vehicle into the emerging cybersecurity market. Since its inception, HACK yielded a 10% return, providing a modest return for the $1.1B in net assets that were invested in the ETF. As shown in Chart 1 below, HACK’s return is much lower than the leading cyber security stocks, but it also offers a passive investment vehicle into the industry that allows investors to invest in this emerging industry without cherry-picking particular stocks. Since PureFunds introduced the HACK ETF, the firm released three more ETFs: the PureFunds ISE Junior Silver ETF (NYSEARCA: SILJ ), the PureFunds ISE Mobile Payments ETF ( IPAY ), and the PureFunds ISE Big Data ETF ( BDAT ). As a strong believer in the growth potential of the big data industry and its leading players, I cover many big data topics, both in Seeking Alpha and in my firm, from industry trends through earnings reviews to extensive long/short investment thesis and ad-hoc analyses. There are so many public companies involved in the big data industry including analytics, visualization, Hadoop integration, and IaaS/PaaS services that I was pretty excited when I first heard of Purefunds Big Data ETF. However, as the title implies, I was very disappointed by the outcome. The general idea of Purefunds to launch investment vehicles that invest in emerging sectors, such as big data, mobile payments, and cyber security, is great, and I think there is a demand for such vehicles. However, an ETF is a passive investment tool that tracks a third party index – in BDAT’s case, it is the ISE Big Data™ Index. Looking at the component eligibility requirements in the index methodology guide unveils a wider definition of a big data company as shown in the excerpt below. According to the document, there are two types of companies that are entitled to join the index: either a big data product developer/service provider or a company that aggregates massive data sets. While the first part makes sense-this is a big-data index and should include big-data companies-the second part (bullet ii above) basically paves the way for any large Internet company to join the index, whether it has some connection to the big-data market or not. Let’s look at ETF’s top 10 holdings, as presented below in an excerpt from the fact sheet, and see how many big-data companies are there. Out of the top 10 holdings, five companies have very weak links to the big-data industry and are included in the ETF just because of bullet point ii above-Facebook (NASDAQ: FB ), Twitter (NYSE: TWTR ), Thomson Reuters (NYSE: TRI ), Nielsen (NYSE: NLSN ), and Yahoo (NASDAQ: YHOO )-while the other five have stronger links to big data, but it is absolutely not their core business nor the main impact on their financials. Going down the list of holdings (31 in total) will also reveal LinkedIn (NYSE: LNKD ) and Dun & Bradstreet (NYSE: DNB ), which also have a weak link to the big-data industry. I agree that it might be difficult to find 30 companies that are big data focused, but if the criteria are widened, I believe Amazon (NASDAQ: AMZN ), Rackspace (NYSE: RAX ), and EMC (NYSE: EMC ) will be found to have more to do with big data than the social media companies introduced in the index and ETF. In my opinion, this is a big deal. A big data ETF should include big data pure-play companies or companies that directly relate to that industry; having Facebook and Twitter in the top 10 holdings is missing the point. If ISE and PureFunds couldn’t find enough suitable companies to be included in the big data ETF, I would have suggested for them to include prominent SaaS, IaaS, and PaaS providers, rather than social media networks and credit/business data providers, as they have stronger links to the industry and are strongly impacted by it. For now, as BDAT does not provide pure big data exposure, I suggest investors to avoid using this ETF as an investment vehicle into the big data industry. Once PureFunds/ ISE have adjusted their ETF holdings/Index criteria, I will revise the avoid recommendation above, and if another big data ETF is introduced, I will perform the same due diligence again. Disclosure: I/we have no positions in any stocks mentioned, and no plans to initiate any positions within the next 72 hours. (More…) I wrote this article myself, and it expresses my own opinions. I am not receiving compensation for it (other than from Seeking Alpha). I have no business relationship with any company whose stock is mentioned in this article. Additional disclosure: The information provided in this article is for informational purposes only and should not be regarded as investment advice or a recommendation regarding any particular security or course of action. This information is the writer’s opinion about the companies mentioned in the article. Investors should conduct their due diligence and consult with a registered financial adviser before making any investment decision. Lior Ronen and Finro are not registered financial advisers and shall not have any liability for any damages of any kind whatsoever relating to this material. By accepting this material, you acknowledge, understand and accept the foregoing.

OIH: What’s Next For The ETF After Schlumberger, Cameron Intl. Merger?

Market Vectors Oil Services ETF is the largest fund in the oilfield services space with nearly $1.1 billion of assets under management. The fund has outperformed its rivals this year, posted one of its biggest weekly gains last week, and could rise again in the future as M&A activity picks up. Focus now shifts to the fund’s fifth largest holding National Oilwell Varco which could move to acquire FMC Technologies. The slump in oil prices has dragged the oilfield services stocks, but last week, the Market Vectors Oil Services ETF (NYSEARCA: OIH ), posted one of its biggest gains this year as Schlumberger (NYSE: SLB ), the fund’s top holding, announced its decision to acquire Cameron International (NYSE: CAM ), its fourth largest holding. Market Vectors Oil Services ETF is the largest fund in this space with nearly $1.1 billion of assets under management. The fund concentrates on investing in 25 of the largest U.S. listed oil services companies ranging from Schlumberger, to land driller Helmerich & Payne (NYSE: HP ), offshore driller Transocean (NYSE: RIG ), oilfield equipment maker McDermott International (NYSE: MDR ) and fracking sand provider U.S. Silica (NYSE: SLCA ). The fund’s primary strength is its focus on few but well established companies that have significant economic moats. Most of the fund’s underlying holdings have seen several downturns before and are well positioned to face the current one. By comparison, other funds, such as the iShares U.S. Oil Equipment & Services ETF (NYSEARCA: IEZ ) and the SPDR S&P Oil & Gas Equip & Service ETF (NYSEARCA: XES ), have exposure to nearly twice as many companies, but this includes a number of medium to small cap players that have bore the brunt of the oil price collapse. As a result, these funds have underperformed this year when compared against Market Vectors Oil Services. OIH Top Ten Holdings Schlumberger 22.43% Halliburton (NYSE: HAL ) 13.76% Baker Hughes (NYSE: BHI ) 8.57% Cameron International 5.78% National Oilwell Varco (NYSE: NOV ) 5.31% Helmerich & Payne 4.29% Weatherford International plc (NYSE: WFT ) 4.15% Tenaris S.A. (NYSE: TS ) 3.98% FMC Technologies, Inc (NYSE: FMC ) 3.71% Transocean Ltd. 3.12% On a year-to-date basis, Market Vectors Oil Services has fallen by 14.4% while iShares U.S. Oil Equipment & Services and SPDR S&P Oil & Gas Equip & Service have declined by 17.3% and 25.3% respectively. But last week, Market Vectors Oil Services climbed by nearly 13.5% when two of its biggest holdings announced a merger agreement which has been unanimously approved by the boards of the two companies. As I have mentioned in my previous articles ( here and here ), the deal is positive for Schlumberger as well as the offshore drilling industry. But the merger can also open doors to further consolidation in the oilfield services space. And that could push Market Vectors Oil Services higher. The subdued pricing environment, with crude hovering near the low $40s, will force the exit of marginal producers and lead towards industry consolidation with bigger, well established companies buying the weaker ones, just as we’ve seen in every oil cycle over the last three decades. Schlumberger’s purchase should give confidence to other oil service companies who’ve been patently waiting for acquisition opportunities. The four largest stocks of Market Vectors Oil Services, namely Schlumberger, Halliburton, Baker Hughes and Cameron International, are already working towards mega mergers. But investors should watch out for National Oilwell Varco , which provides equipment and components to exploration and production companies. National Oilwell Varco has been struggling in the downturn, but it is one of the oldest and well established companies in the energy sector that has a wide economic moat. Furthermore, the company comes with a solid track record of making bolt-on acquisitions during downturns. In fact, historically, these acquisitions have played a crucial role in fueling the company’s growth. And currently, the company has been actively looking for acquisition opportunities. During the most recent conference call , National Oilwell Varco’s management said that they have already raised the size of their credit facility to $4.5 billion “in preparation for potential [acquisition] opportunities.” There are a number of companies that could be on National Oilwell Varco’s radar such as Dril-Quip (NYSE: DRQ ) and Forum Energy Technologies (NYSE: FET ). But if National Oilwell Varco follows in Schlumberger’s footsteps by buying a company with highly advanced technological capabilities and significant offshore exposure, then there is no bigger name than FMC Technologies which dominates the global subsea equipment market. A potential tie-up would not only give birth to one of the world’s biggest equipment maker in the energy industry, but could also lift Market Vectors Oil Services higher as National Oilwell Varco is the fifth largest and FMC Technologies is the ninth largest holding of the fund. Although Market Vectors Oil Services has struggled this year and could continue to remain under pressure in the near term, at least until we get a clear idea of where the oil price and the 2016 exploration and production budgets are heading, it can prove to be an interesting speculative play on an uptake in mergers and acquisition activity, especially since its underlying companies are actively seeking acquisition opportunities and a merger between National Oilwell Varco and FMC Technologies – two of its ten largest holdings, is very much possible. Disclosure: I/we have no positions in any stocks mentioned, and no plans to initiate any positions within the next 72 hours. (More…) I wrote this article myself, and it expresses my own opinions. I am not receiving compensation for it (other than from Seeking Alpha). I have no business relationship with any company whose stock is mentioned in this article.