Tag Archives: management

4 Important Lessons From Psychology For Investors

Summary Beware of overconfidence – your predictions may be incorrect, prepare yourself. Don’t neglect competition – don’t fall prey to what-you-see-is-all-there-is. Avoid loss aversion/sunk costs – only hold stocks because you believe will outperform. Anchoring and adjustment – Ignore useless information as much as you can when valuing a stock. Humans are not fully rational beings. Most of the time, this irrationality serves a useful evolutionary purpose, but for investing, it can be devastating. The pitfalls laid out below are well-known concepts in behavioral economics. To get a better grasp of how they affect your investment decisions, they are illustrated with my personal experience. Beware of overconfidence Duke University conducts annual surveys among CFOs. Among other things, the CFOs are asked for an estimate range of the S&P 500 returns over the following year. They were asked to provide a value of which they were 90% sure it was too high and another that they would be 90% sure of that would be too low. This would provide a range of 80% accuracy. The findings are shocking: only one in three was correct, versus the 80% one would expect with such a prediction. Their range was too narrow and they were too overconfident. With many decisions that rely on estimates, this overconfidence can be dangerous. Being aware of overconfidence can help a lot. To the credit of the CFOs, they are not in a position where they can give a realistic 80% accurate forecast (which would be between -10% and +30%) because they are seen as experts and look clueless when they provide a very wide range. The best professional forecasters are aware of the low value of their predictions and share less of the overconfidence bias. One of the best sell-side analysts of the Netherlands told me once about analyst estimates: ‘we know one thing for sure: actual earnings won’t match the estimates.’ Don’t neglect competition Colin Camerer and Dan Lovallo observed that often in decision making people ignore competing possibilities and coined the term ‘competition neglect’. It can be illustrated with an example of eBay (NASDAQ: EBAY ). Many sellers let their auction end during peak-visit hours in the evenings to increase the price of the item they try to sell. They neglect the fact that normally auctions should have the same distribution as bids, and therefore bids per auction should not differ. Even worse, they ignore the fact that many people (competitors) use the same strategy. The consequence of neglecting this competition is a lower price obtained for the item as well as a lower probability of a sale ( this is a link to that study ). Investors can learn from this. Every time you study a business, be aware of the most obvious things the market will see. If people like IBM (NYSE: IBM ) because Warren Buffett invests in it, you should be aware that this is already reflected in the stock price. On a deeper level, it pays to see what the competitors of the business you study are doing. It is easy to get optimistic about a company when you only see the competitive landscape from its own perspective. One of such examples is R&D spending at GM’s (NYSE: GM ) competitors. GM has been lagging in R&D expenditure growth as I point out in this article . Not taking into account the increased competitive pressure from other automakers, will create a lot of room for disappointment. Avoid loss aversion/sunk costs The loss-aversion theory explains that people generally are more sensitive to losses than they are to gains. For investors, the relevant part of this theory is often closely related to the sunk-cost theory. After making a bad investment that turns out worse than expected Philip Fisher has described this in his book Stocks and Uncommon Profits as: “More money has probably been lost by investors holding a stock they really did not want until they could ‘at least come out even’ than from any other single reason.” In my case this stems from anticipated regret. I know that if I sell a stock that is down over 30% and it rebounds thereafter that I will experience a great deal of regret. It is very hard to ignore this anticipated emotion. One way to deal with it is to just sell the stock and never look at it again, or sell half of the position to mitigate future underperformance. What I did in one case was going short on other stocks in the same industry that were overvalued compared to the stock I owned. Beware of anchoring and adjustment In making decisions in uncertain environments decision makers frequently make an initial estimate and then adjust this estimate when new information arrives. Anchoring can be the result of anything. Even when answering a simple question like ‘how many people live in Luxembourg?’, hearing a completely unrelated statement like ‘there are a billion butterflies in New York’ can influence you answer. For investors the question is ‘how much is stock X worth’ and the information we should avoid is the stock price in the market. I too often fall prey to this type of thinking. In this article on ING (NYSE: ING ), I remained conservative on my assumptions on growth, ROE, and discount rate in order to keep the target price closer to the market price. I now believe the same stock is worth over €15.50, versus €12.40 then (the +25% is roughly in line with the stock price appreciation since then), while operationally, the company is almost the same as it was 10 months ago. Hedge, always hedge This one is not directly related to any psychological concept, but it does have ties with overconfidence and ignoring what is out there. Never gamble when you don’t have to. Both of my two worst investments of the past two years could have been hedged. The first one is Ensco (NYSE: ESV ). I knew oil price was a risk but confident in fact that I had no idea where the oil price would go, I thought it would be a prudent thing to assume the futures market showed was the most accurate forecast. Perhaps it was, and of course it is not unreasonable to assume an efficient market when it comes to commodities. What I should’ve done, however, is recognize that the oil price was such an important part of the investment case that I was unfit to make that call without a view. Alternatively I could have chosen to hedge the risk, but instead I took a hit of over 50% on the investment. Luckily, I later started to hedge this risk and prevented much worse by doing so. In another case, I discovered that the ArcelorMittal (NYSE: MT ) mandatory convertible notes ( prospectus ) could be proxied by a bond and a long put and short call option on MT stock. My conclusion was that the note was undervalued compared to prevailing interest rates and options that would mitigate any exposure to Arcelor’s stock price. In fact, I saw an arbitrage opportunity. Instead of buying the notes and purchasing a put option while selling a call, I only bought the notes because I found the spreads on the options painfully high, and was tempted by the upside. Again, this investment turned sour and I suffer a loss of over 40%. If the spreads on the options really were too big, I should’ve refrained from buying the notes. How to cope with these behavioral issues? As the behavior is natural, it is hard to overcome. It is perhaps even impossible to overcome all of them. But knowing and acknowledging it affects you is half the battle and helps to put yourself back on the track of rationality when you need it most. Disclosure: I am/we are long MT, IBM, ESV, ING. (More…) I wrote this article myself, and it expresses my own opinions. I am not receiving compensation for it (other than from Seeking Alpha). I have no business relationship with any company whose stock is mentioned in this article.

The Global X MSCI Pakistan ETF: High Growth, Low Valuation And Decreasing Terrorism

Summary Pakistan’s stock market has risen substantially since 2012, yet valuation is still extremely low. Pakistan’s stock exchange has had substantial performance with a YTD return of 8.87%, and a 1 year return 21.18%. Terrorism has been decreasing substantially in Pakistan, according to a report released by the Department of State. Inflation has recently improved from the high levels consistently experienced between 2010 and 2014. Certain industries have displayed substantial growth, such as the cement industry, which grew by 57% this year. The Global X MSCI Pakistan ETF (NYSEARCA: PAK ) is an excellent value pick, and a closer examination of Pakistan’s economy, stock market, and political risk all verify that soon to emerging Pakistan is an excellent investment climate. The fund’s P/E ratio is currently 9.12, which is low for Pakistan, and is also lower when compared to other ETFs in frontier and emerging markets. The ETF was just created this year, and its price has consistently been between 14.00-16.94. PAK data by YCharts The Karachi Stock Exchange Pakistan’s stock exchange has had substantial performance with a YTD return of 8.87%, and a 1 year return 21.18%. Such a high index gain could be met with further growth, by strategically investing in undervalued companies. The Global X MSCI Pakistan ETF is an excellent way to potentially outperform the index, while the true value of value investing in individual companies is unfortunately unavailable to US investors. (click to enlarge) Source: Trading Economics The fund invests in some of the largest market cap companies from the KSE 100 index. Liquidity of the Karachi stock exchange is very high, with the top 20 most liquid stocks trading between 2 million to 12 million shares daily. The average P/E for the 20 most undervalued companies from the KSE 100 index is 6.6. Substantial higher valuation can be found for other companies from the KSE 100, verifying that the fund can overall be considered cheap. Pakistan’s Annual GDP Growth (click to enlarge) Source: Trading Economics Pakistan’s annual GDP growth is expected to increase to 4.96% by the 2nd quarter of 2016 . The correlation between GDP growth and the gain of Pakistan’s stock market is clear, by examining the rise that began in 2012, and the lower levels of growth experienced in 2010. Consumer Spending/Inflation (click to enlarge) Source: Trading Economics Consumer spending growth has been substantial in Pakistan, further attributing to the country”s economic growth. (click to enlarge) Source: Trading Economics Inflation has currently become drastically lower, and is projected to remain near 2% during the next 12 months. This represents substantial improvement from the drastically higher levels of inflation between 2010 and 2014. From Frontier to Emerging Pakistan is on track to soon be an emerging market, and high levels of economic growth can be seen, with specific industry outliers that are displaying substantial growth. Charlie Robertson, London-based chief economist at Renaissance Capital Ltd., said the following regarding the untapped potential of Pakistan: “It is the best, undiscovered investment opportunity in emerging or frontier markets. What’s changed is the delivery of reforms-privatization, an improved fiscal picture and good relations with the IMF.” The IMF has said that Pakistan is making excellent progress in meeting targets for economic growth. Pakistan’s cement industry in particular has displayed substantial growth, with 57% growth in the past year. D.G Khan Cement gained 62% this year, Maple Leaf Cement Factory Ltd. gained an impressive 161% this year, and Fauji Cement Co. gained 81%. The nation’s construction industry is also a bright spot, as it grew by 11.3%, nearly double the 5.7% target. Decreasing Terrorism Apart from the fact that Pakistan’s stock market has done nothing but soar since 2012, amidst issues with terrorism, investors can feel further confidence regarding the trends of reduction of terrorism in Pakistan. According to a report released by the US Department of State , Pakistan was among the top of a list of 95 countries in the world where terror attacks decreased. The overall increase of terrorist attacks and deaths in these 95 countries was 35% and 81% respectively, edifying that Pakistan is an outlier in terms of decreasing terrorism. With low valuation and high growth, investors can feel further confident in Pakistan, as terrorism is decreasing substantially. Conclusion Now is certainly a strategic time to invest in Pakistan, as valuation is current low, and the country is experiencing substantial growth. Inflation has drastically improved from the high levels from 2010 to 2014, and terrorism has very recently been declining faster than other countries. The Global X MSCI Pakistan ETF is an excellent way to profit from Pakistan’s growth, with the superior model of directly invest in equity in Pakistan not being available to US investors. The newly launched fund’s price has remained relatively consistent, and valuation is still incredibly low. Now would buy an excellent time to buy and hold long term, waiting for an increase in price to come as investors realize Pakistan’s potential. Until then, Pakistan’s status is certainly being relegated, and the early movers are sure to receive substantial returns. Disclosure: I/we have no positions in any stocks mentioned, and no plans to initiate any positions within the next 72 hours. (More…) I wrote this article myself, and it expresses my own opinions. I am not receiving compensation for it (other than from Seeking Alpha). I have no business relationship with any company whose stock is mentioned in this article.

Investing Alongside Buffett, Klarman, And Other Top Investors While Limiting Your Risk

Summary An investor can precisely limit his risk while maximizing his expected return by creating a hedged portfolio. When creating a hedged portfolio, you can start from scratch or start with a list of top picks. We lay out the second method here and provide an example. The example hedged portfolio was designed for investors willing to risk a maximum drawdown of 20%. Investors with lower risk tolerances can use a similar process, though their expected returns would likely be lower. Investing In An Uncertain Market Investors could be forgiven for wanting to limit their risk given the uncertainty about the current economic environment. Let’s recap the latest bit of news adding to the uncertainty, and then look at a way we can invest alongside some of the world’s best investors while limiting our risk. Reactions to the August jobs report released on Friday varied. The White House highlighted the positive: Our economy has now added 8.0 million jobs over the past three years, a pace that has not been exceeded since 2000. And while the economy added jobs at a somewhat slower pace in August than in recent months, the unemployment rate fell to 5.1 percent-its lowest level since April 2008-and the labor force participation rate remained stable. And the Wall Street Journal pointed out the dark cloud inside that silver lining: The labor-force participation rate stayed the same last month at 62.6%.The participation rate-the share of the population either working or actively looking for work-has been dropping for several years and is near levels last consistently recorded in the late 1970s, a time when women were entering the workforce in larger numbers. The latest reading is a result of the labor force shrinking by 41,000 last month, despite other signs of an improving jobs market. As the New York Times noted , the jobs report gave ammunition to both sides of the Fed rate debate, but, as Seeking Alpha news editor Carl Surran summarized it, the market’s verdict seemed to be negative, with the major market indexes down on Friday and all ten sectors in the red. Dealing With Uncertainty After all the analysis, no one knows what direction the market will take from here. One way to deal with uncertainty about market direction is to invest in a handful of securities you think will do well, and hedge against the possibility that you end up being wrong. That approach is systematized in the hedged portfolio method, which we detailed in a previous post (“Backtesting The Hedged Portfolio Method”). One advantage of the hedged portfolio method is that it can accommodate a broad range of risk tolerances. If you can tolerate a drawdown of more than 20%, our research (summarized in the previous post we mentioned above) suggests that with our security selection method you can achieve returns as good or better than the market over time with less risk. Maybe You Can Do Better It’s possible you can get even better returns with the hedged portfolio method by selecting your own securities. And if you’re going to do that, a good starting place for ideas is to look at what some of the best investors in the world have been buying. Seeking Alpha contributor and hedge fund manager Chris DeMuth, Jr. did just that in a recent article (“Best Q2 Picks From Top Investors”). In that article, DeMuth examined reported buys from leading investors and highlighted a number of them. These were the stocks, along with the investors who bought them: SunEdison Semiconductor (NASDAQ: SEMI ) – Seth Klarman. Precision Castparts (NYSE: PCP ) – Warren Buffett SunEdison (NYSE: SUNE ) – David Einhorn Perrigo (NYSE: PRGO ) – Stephen Mandel (former analyst for Julian Robertson) Williams (NYSE: WMB ) – Dan Loeb Danaher (NYSE: DHR ) – John Griffen (another former protege of Julian Robertson) Time Warner Cable (NYSE: TWC ) – John Paulson Baker Hughes (NYSE: BHI )- Jeff Ubben Shire (NASDAQ: SHPG ) – Leon Cooperman Office Depot (NASDAQ: ODP ) – Richard Perry Humana (NYSE: HUM ) – Larry Robbins Cigna (NYSE: CI ) – Andreas Halvorsen Altera (NASDAQ: ALTR ) – Andrew Spokes Icahn Enterprises (NASDAQ: IEP ) – Carl Icahn Brookdale Senior Living (NYSE: BKD ) – Barry Rosenstein T-Mobile (NYSE: TMUS ) – Phillippe Lafont DeMuth’s article is worth a read for some color on these stocks and investors (particularly, the less well-known investors). But we’ll start with the assumption that most of these are solid stocks, and we’ll use them as a starting point to construct a hedged portfolio for an investor who is unwilling to risk a drawdown of more than 20%, and has $1 million he wants to invest. First, though, address the issue of risk tolerance, and how it affects potential return. Risk Tolerance and Potential Return All else equal, with a hedged portfolio, the greater an investor’s risk tolerance — the greater the maximum drawdown he is willing to risk (his “threshold”, in our terminology) – the higher his potential return will be. So, we should expect that an investor who is willing to risk a 20% decline will have a chance at higher returns than one who is only willing to risk, say, a 10% drawdown. Constructing A Hedged Portfolio In the previous article mentioned above, we discussed a process investors could use to construct a hedged portfolio designed to maximize potential return while limiting risk. We’ll recap that process here briefly, and then explain how you can implement it yourself. Finally, we’ll present an example of a hedged portfolio that was constructed this way with an automated tool. The process, in broad strokes, is this: Find securities with high potential returns (we define potential return as a high-end, bullish estimate of how the security will perform). Find securities that are relatively inexpensive to hedge. Buy a handful of securities that score well on the first two criteria; in other words, buy a handful of securities with high potential returns net of their hedging costs (or, ones with high net potential returns). Hedge them. The potential benefits of this approach are twofold: If you are successful at the first step (finding securities with high potential returns), and you hold a concentrated portfolio of them, your portfolios should generate decent returns over time. If you are hedged, and your return estimates are completely wrong, on occasion — or the market moves against you — your downside will be strictly limited. How to Implement This Approach Finding promising stocks In this case, we’re going to start with the list of Q2 best picks curated by Chris DeMuth. To quantify potential returns for these stocks, you can, for example, use analysts’ price targets for them and then convert these to percentage returns from current prices. In general, though, you’ll need to use the same time frame for each of your potential return calculations to facilitate comparisons of potential returns, hedging costs, and net potential returns. Our method starts with calculations of six-month potential returns. Finding inexpensive ways to hedge these securities First, you’ll need to determine whether each of these top holdings are hedgeable. Then, whatever hedging method you use, for this example, you’d want to make sure that each security is hedged against a greater-than-20% decline over the time frame covered by your potential return calculations (our method attempts to find optimal static hedges using collars as well as protective puts going out approximately six months). And you’ll need to calculate your cost of hedging as a percentage of position value. Selecting the securities with highest net potential returns In order to determine which securities these are, out of the list above, you may need to first adjust your potential return calculations by the time frame of your hedges. For example, although our method initially calculates six-month potential returns and aims to find hedges with six months to expiration, in some cases the closest hedge expiration may be five months out. In those cases, we will adjust our potential return calculation down accordingly, because we expect an investor will exit the position shortly before the hedge expires (in general, our method and calculations are based on the assumption that an investor will hold his shares for six months, until shortly before their hedges expire or until they are called away, whichever comes first). Next, you’ll need to subtract the hedging costs you calculated in the previous step from the potential returns you calculated for each position, and exclude any security that has a negative potential return net of hedging costs. Fine-tuning portfolio construction You’ll want to stick with round lots (numbers of shares divisible by 100) to minimize hedging costs, so if you’re going to include a handful of securities from the sort in the previous step and you have a relatively small portfolio, you’ll need to take into account the share prices of the securities. Another fine-tuning step is to minimize cash that’s leftover after you make your initial allocation to round lots of securities and their respective hedges. Because each security is hedged, you won’t need a large cash position to reduce risk. And since returns on cash are so low now, by minimizing cash you can potentially boost returns. In this step, our method searches for what we call a “cash substitute”: that’s a security collared with a tight cap (1% or the current yield on a leading money market fund, whichever is higher) in an attempt to capture a better-than-cash return while keeping the investor’s downside limited according to his specifications. You could use a similar approach, or you could simply allocate leftover cash to one of the securities you selected in the previous step. Calculating Expected Returns While net potential returns are bullish estimates of how well securities will perform, net of their hedging costs, expected returns, in our terminology, are the more likely returns net of hedging costs. In a series of 25,412 backtests over an 11-year time period, we determined two things about our method of calculating potential returns: it generates alpha, and it overstates actual returns. The average actual return over the next six months in those 25,412 tests was 0.3x the average potential return calculated ahead of time. So, we use that empirically derived relationship to calculate our expected returns. An Automated Approach Here we’ll show an example of creating a hedged portfolio starting with Chris DeMuth’s best Q2 picks using the general process described above, facilitated by the automated hedged portfolio construction tool at Portfolio Armor . In the first step, we enter the ticker symbols in the “Tickers” field, the dollar amount of our investor’s portfolio (1000000), and in the third field, the maximum decline he’s willing to risk in percentage terms (20). In the second step, we are given the option of entering our own return estimates for each of these securities. One of these securities, PCP, appeared in a hedged portfolio in a previous article (“An Alternative To Cash For A Risk Averse Investor), and there, we used Portfolio Armor’s calculated potential return for it. In this case, for illustration purposes, we’ll enter a potential return for it based on the assumption that the Berkshire Hathaway deal closes at the announced price of $235 per share. For the other securities, we’ll let Portfolio Armor supply its own potential returns. A couple minutes after clicking the “Create” button, we were presented with the hedged portfolio below. The data here is as of Friday’s close. Why These Particular Securities? The site included all of the entered securities for which it calculated a positive potential return, net of hedging costs. Interestingly, one of the stocks it rejected, Icahn Enterprises , is one Chris DeMuth mentioned as a short position earlier this year, as he noted in his Best Q2 Picks article. In its fine-tuning step, Portfolio Armor added Google (NASDAQ: GOOG ) as a cash substitute. Let’s turn our attention now to the portfolio level summary for a moment. Worst-Case Scenario The “Max Drawdown” column in the portfolio level summary shows the worst-case scenario for this hedged portfolio. If every underlying security in it went to zero before the hedges expired, the portfolio would decline 19.67%. Negative Hedging Cost Note that, in this case, the total hedging cost for the portfolio was negative, -1.03%, meaning the investor would receive more income in total from selling the call legs of the collars on his positions than he spent buying the puts. Best-Case Scenario At the portfolio level, the net potential return is 13.44% over the next six months. This represents the best-case scenario, if each underlying security in the portfolio meets or exceeds its potential return. A More Likely Scenario The portfolio level expected return of 4.63% represents a conservative estimate, based on the historical relationship between our calculated potential returns and backtested actual returns. However, since these securities are picks of some of the world’s best investors, it’s possible Portfolio Armor is underestimating their returns over the next six months. By way of comparison, if you created a hedged portfolio on Friday using the same dollar amount ($1,000,000) and decline threshold (20%), but without entering any ticker symbols (i.e., you let Portfolio Armor pick the securities), the expected return for that hedged portfolio would have been 7.97%. That hedged portfolio would have only had one primary security in common with this one; as you can probably guess from the potential returns shown in the hedged portfolio above, that security was Advance Auto Parts. Each Security Is Hedged Note that each of the above securities is hedged. Google, the cash substitute, is hedged with an optimal collar with its cap set at 1%; Advance Auto Parts and Precision Castparts are hedged with optimal puts; and the remaining securities are hedged with optimal collars with their caps set at each underlying security’s potential return. Here is a closer look at the hedge for Advance Auto Parts: The cap field above is blank, because this isn’t a collar. Portfolio Armor used optimal puts in this case instead of an optimal collar because the position had a higher net potential return this way (it calculated the net potential returns both ways for each of the primary positions in the portfolio). As you can see at the bottom of the image above, the cost of this hedge was $2,500, or 2.90% of position value.[i] Note that, although this hedge had a positive hedging cost, the hedging cost for the portfolio as a whole was negative. Possibly More Protection Than Promised In some cases, hedges such as the ones in the portfolio above can provide more protection than promised. For an example of that, see this recent instablog post on hedging Tesla (NASDAQ: TSLA ). Hedged Portfolios For Smaller Investors The hedged portfolio shown above was designed for someone with $1 million to invest, but the same process, with a couple of minor adjustments, can be used for those with smaller amounts to invest. We walked through creating a hedged portfolio for someone with $30,000 to invest in an article last month (“Keeping a Small Nest Egg from Cracking”). [i] To be conservative, the cost of the put protection was calculated using the ask price of the puts. In practice, an investor can often buy puts for less than the ask price (i.e., at some price between the bid and ask). So, in practice, an investor would likely have paid less than $2,880 for this hedge. A similarly conservative approach was used for calculating the costs of all of the hedges in this portfolio (with the cost of puts calculated at the ask and the income from calls calculated at the bid). Disclosure: I/we have no positions in any stocks mentioned, and no plans to initiate any positions within the next 72 hours. (More…) I wrote this article myself, and it expresses my own opinions. I am not receiving compensation for it (other than from Seeking Alpha). I have no business relationship with any company whose stock is mentioned in this article.