Tag Archives: management

3 Looks At Current Market Multiples

Summary The S&P 500 has come of its all-time high, down 9% from its May peak. This article puts the current level in historical context by examining three different earnings multiples. Trailing 1-year earnings, estimated forward 1-year earnings, and a measure of cyclically-adjusted price/earnings are used to frame the current market level. I leave readers with three takeaways on my views of this data. When the S&P 500 (NYSEARCA: SPY ) was hitting new all-time highs in early 2015, I authored an article entitled ” A View From the Top: 3 Looks at Market Multiples “. Given the recent market pullback, this article reprises these different views to put the market drawdown in context. This article looks at the current price level of the index via three different measures: 1) a historical examination of the index relative to trailing one-year earnings; 2) a historical examination of the index relative to forward one-year earnings; and, 3) a historical examination of the cyclically adjusted price earnings multiple. (Source: Standard and Poor’s; Bloomberg) The graph above shows the most commonly cited earnings multiple, the Price/Earnings (P/E) ratio, which shows the index level relative to trailing one-year earnings. When I wrote a version of this article in February, the market was valued at roughly eleven percent more than its average since the broad market gauge went to its current five-hundred constituent form in 1957. With the recent pullback, we are trading at just a 1.6% premium to the market’s historical multiple. (Source: Standard and Poor’s; Bloomberg) The second graph shows the current index level relative to a best estimate of forward earnings from Bloomberg. Based on the current expectation of continued strong growth in earnings, the index is valued at 16.2x forward earnings. In February, this valuation was 6.5% greater than the trailing 25-year average, which is the extent of the ratio history available on Bloomberg. Today, the market is actually trading at a small discount of 2.7% relative to this historical valuation multiple. (click to enlarge) (Source: Robert Shiller ) While we often talk about valuation relative to trailing or forward one-year earnings, as we did in the previous two sections, examining the index level relative to earnings over a length of time more consistent with an entire business cycle can be viewed as more appropriate. Above is a version of Yale economics professor and Nobel laureate Robert Shiller’s cyclically adjusted price-to-earnings ratio (CAPE or Shiller P/E), a valuation measure applied to the equity market that divides the price level of the index by the average of ten years of earnings, adjusted for inflation. With the index multiple now roughly equivalent to the post-crisis market peak in 2007, and trailing only the historic bubbles in 1929 and 2000, the CAPE is the most oft-cited reason for lowered forward return expectations in the domestic equity market. The current multiple is 46% above its trailing 144-year average. Three takeaways: When I wrote a version of this article in early 2015, the valuations looked stretched by all three measures. In my article, ” 10 Themes Shaping Markets in 2015 “, I wrote: “Stretched equity multiples domestically will necessitate that valuations be driven by changes in earnings, tempering further price gains”. Well, we have not received price gains, with the S&P 500 producing a -6.7% return in 2015. This reduction in the index level has outpaced lower earnings from the commodity-sensitive sectors of the market, making the current market valuation appear more fair. Low interest rates have contributed to higher market multiples. In the CAPE graph above, notice that the market multiple moves inversely to the long-term interest rate level. With interest rates in the U.S. again rallying with increased macro volatility, market multiples have expanded. I covered this relationship in the 2012 article, ” Equity Multiples and Interest Rates: Is the Current Risk Premium Sufficient? ” Common stock valuation techniques include discounting future earnings back to the present, which demonstrates why lower (higher) interest rates would be consistent with a higher (lower) equity multiples. Low interest rates and near-zero short-term interest rates have pushed investors from cash and fixed income into more risky asset classes, which has also driven equity multiples higher. As rates began selling off in the taper tantrum in mid-2013, it felt like rate-driven equity gains could be peaking. With long Treasuries again rallying, and the Fed signaling to the market that they are likely to move slowly even if they move the Fed Funds rate higher, perhaps this upward pressure on valuations could stick around. 16.5 still looks to be a magic number. In all three of these valuation measures, which feature different perspectives and time horizons, the average market multiple has been around 16.5x (16.19x forward earnings multiple; 16.63x CAPE; 16.96x trailing earnings multiple). Over extended time horizons, elevated earnings multiples above 16.5x are going to be consistent with below-average forward returns. Conclusion In February, these three multiples signaled that the market was rich. After our first correction in several years, the valuations now appear more fair, although the CAPE multiple is still historically elevated. Shortening the lookback period in the CAPE multiple from ten years to five years strips out the 2008-2009 downturn, and the multiple is just 28% above its historical average. Readers must ascertain whether they believe that a proper risk premium is being reflected in this market valuation, and where they believe earnings growth is headed in the context of their own risk tolerance and portfolio construction. Disclosure: I am/we are long SPY. (More…) I wrote this article myself, and it expresses my own opinions. I am not receiving compensation for it (other than from Seeking Alpha). I have no business relationship with any company whose stock is mentioned in this article.

Should You Buy Canada ETFs On The Cheap?

Bearing testimony to global growth worries, the developed economy of Canada slipped into a technical recession in the first half of this year. It was not entirely unexpected, though, given the prolonged pain in oil prices. But the drop-off was the steepest since the Great Recession which rings a panic alarm for those interested in Canada investing. Canada’s economy shrank 0.5% in Q2 (annually) hit by lower energy prices and business investment. Prior to this, the economy had retreated 0.8% in Q1. Canada is among the world’s top 10 oil producers. This data is self-explanatory of the economic underperformance. Is It All Dark About the Economy? All is not unwell with the Canadian economy as GDP growth in June, or the last month of the second quarter, was 0.5% which was the largest monthly advance in the Canadian economy in over a year. Notably, June saw a considerable rise in almost each sector. A subtle bounce in oil prices was basically the savior. Apart from the energy sector lull, the Canadian economy expanded in the second quarter, bolstered by increased consumer spending. A few economists expect a sharp snap-back in the second half of the year and forecast growth of 2.5% by the end of 2015 (per the economist Brian DePratto). Investors should note that though the fresh round of global growth worries induced by China weigh more heavily on oil prices, several analysts projected a recovery, though choppy, in oil prices in recent times. Many are of the opinion that oil prices are close to hitting the bottom and may be due for some way up in the coming days. Plus, the nation’s job picture is quite stable and the inflation rate touched a seven-month high in July. Housing market too is no less than decently growing. Stronger export competitiveness due to the falling Canadian currency relative to the greenback and the increasing purchasing power of the U.S. consumers are other upsides for the Canadian economy. So, things are tied between possibilities and perils with oil prices playing a crucial role in deciding the fate of the Canadian economy going forward. Due to the above-mentioned bullish attributes, several investors can take advantage of the cheaper valuation of the Canadian stocks and the related ETFs. ETF Options The largest ETF on Canada is the iShares MSCI Canada ETF (NYSEARCA: EWC ), which is off 18.4% so far this year. The fund has a Zacks ETF Rank #3 (Hold) and might open up intriguing opportunities for the future, if analysts’ affirmative predictions come true. The Guggenheim Canadian Energy Income ETF (NYSEARCA: ENY ), being an energy-oriented ETF, shed the most this year. ENY was down over 32% in the year-to-date frame but added over 3% in the last five days (as of September 2, 2015) on the August-end global oil price recovery. Small-caps are other interesting options to play any rebound in the Canadian economy. Small-cap ETF, the IQ Canada Small Cap ETF (NYSEARCA: CNDA ), is down about 27% this year. However, CNDA has a Zacks ETF Rank #4 (Sell). Original Post

Is The Bull Market About To End?

Summary Volatility spikes in the absence of systemic risk could offer higher future returns. The current environment is not similar to 2008. Forecasted volatility isn’t high compared to history. A rate hike by the Fed could significantly increase volatility. In our last update , we pointed out the risks in the emerging markets. That theme has continued to play out. By now, investors would’ve experienced maximum losses of -44% in China and -32% in EM equities. US equities are still doing better than other markets – currently at -12% maximum loss. In this environment, every online robo-advisor is telling their investors to keep calm and carry on. We here at Cassia prefer to be more proactive when it comes to managing risk. We have been performing emergency rebalances in all of our client accounts since August 22. And we continue to monitor the situation in real-time to ensure accounts can move quickly as new data comes in. Quantifying the risk The best decisions are data driven. So what is the data telling us about the current markets? Let’s talk about risk. No, I’m not talking about the flawed risk measures that everyone can calculate in Excel. I’m talking about a GARCH volatility forecast that accounts for nuances like clustering and mean reversion that we wrote about in our white paper . Typically, the S&P 500 has a volatility of 12%. In October 2008, it had a forecasted volatility of 51%. Today, our advanced risk forecasting system sees short-term volatility at 18% and 3-month volatility at 13%. This tells us two things about US Equities. The current level of volatility isn’t crazy high by historical standards. The forecasted volatility in the short-term is higher than the long-term (i.e. backwardation). Volatility spike – what does it mean? The second point warrants some investigation. So we ranked the volatility forecasts into four buckets (quartiles). We ask ourselves: “how volatile is the market relative to the long-term volatility?” Do spikes in the short-term volatility have any implications for future returns? Lo and behold. During the bull market from 2009 to present, the market appears to yield higher returns after volatility spikes. Q4 represents the days where the volatility is the highest, and Q1 represents volatility being the lowest, relative to forecasted long-term volatility. The results hold for returns 1, 5, 10, 20, 60 days into the future. This makes intuitive sense because volatility spikes tend to coincide with short-term lows in the market. Buying the dips tend to yield higher returns – in a normal environment. But look what happens when we include the highly abnormal period of 2008. Buying when volatility spikes becomes a terrible idea. Instead of yielding a higher return, buying the dips in a financial crisis, yields negative returns. Another 2008? Let’s look at systemic risk So the key question now is. Is this a 2008 environment or not? Rising correlation could indicate contagion between markets, indicating increased systemic risk and potentially a 2008 environment. Here’s what the data says as of the end of August 2015. The chart on the left shows the correlation between the S&P 500 and other major asset classes such as real estate, bonds, commodities, and emerging equities. Do you see any signs of an increase in correlation? Correlation (click to enlarge) Standardized Change (click to enlarge) We don’t. The current environment does not look similar to 2008. To make it easier to see, the chart on the right is the standardized change. If anything, the correlation between equities and other assets is experiencing the largest drop in 10 years – by almost 2 standard deviations! In contrast, correlation increased by 1.5 standard deviations at the start of 2008. For robustness, we also consulted another measure of systemic risk called the Absorption Ratio and ran it on 9 US sector funds (Kritzman 2010). The authors note that a +1 standard deviation increase in the Absorption Ratio is an indication of increased systemic risk. The current reading is at -1 standard deviation, nowhere close to systemic risk territory. Absorption Ratio (click to enlarge) Standardized Change (click to enlarge) We also repeated our test on days where systemic risk is heightened (absorption ratio greater than +1 SD). Our findings are consistent. In periods where volatility spikes are accompanied with heightened systemic risk, future 1-month returns tend to be low. And future returns are high after volatility spikes during normal periods (absorption ratio below +1 SD). GARCH volatility term structure vs. next month return (annualized) Volatility spikes during increased systemic risk: 0% Volatility spikes during normal periods: 38% Conclusion The data suggests that a) the current environment is not similar to 2008, b) forecasted volatility isn’t high compared to history, and c) volatility spikes in the absence of systemic risk have historically offered higher future returns. What can change this? We would put a September rate hike by the Fed at the top of the list. Based on the current data, we feel that there’s no overwhelming case to scale back on equities allocation. Should forecasted volatility or correlation increase dramatically, Cassia’s systems stand ready to step in and adjust allocations for its clients, faster than a human manager can react. References Kritzman, M., Li, Y., Page, S., & Rigobon, R. (2010). Principal components as a measure of systemic risk. Disclosure: I/we have no positions in any stocks mentioned, and no plans to initiate any positions within the next 72 hours. (More…) I wrote this article myself, and it expresses my own opinions. I am not receiving compensation for it. I have no business relationship with any company whose stock is mentioned in this article.