Tag Archives: management

The Good Business Portfolio: Second-Quarter Earnings And Performance Update

Summary The portfolio of good company businesses is doing 6.87% better than the Dow average year-to-date of -9.71%. The 24 businesses of The Good Business Portfolio comprise 99% of the portfolio, with the other 1% cash, and the average total return of 33.24% over the Dow average return. Create a portfolio that is balanced, not income, not dividend growth, not bottom-fishing, not value, but balanced among all styles. Of the 24 companies in the portfolio, 18 beat the Dow average for total return and 6 missed the total return over the test period of 32 months. For the second-quarter earnings season, 20 companies beat or met the expected earnings and 4 missed the expected earnings. This article gives a review of the second-quarter earnings and YTD performance of the Good Business Portfolio. Earnings data will be looked at for 5 of the top positions in the portfolio. Guidelines (Company selection) The intent in the Good Business Portfolio guidelines is to create a portfolio that is a large cap balanced portfolio between the different styles of investing. Income investors take too much risk to get their high yields. Bottom-fishing investors get cat fish. Value investors have to have a foresight to see the future. These are guidelines and not rules. (For a complete set of guidelines, please see my article ” The Good Business Portfolio: All 24 Positions “.) They are meant to be used as filters to get to a few companies on which further analysis can be done before adding the company to the portfolio. So, it’s alright to break a guideline if the other guidelines indicate a Good Company Business. I’m sure this eliminates some really good companies, but it gets me a short list to work on. There are too many companies to even look at 10% of them. You see from the portfolio below that I want a portfolio that is defensive, provides income and does not take significant risks. I limit the portfolio to 25 companies, as more than this is almost impossible to keep track of. At present, I have 24 companies and have an open slot awaiting General Electric (NYSE: GE ) and Hewlett Packard (NYSE: HPQ ) spin-offs. Portfolio Performance The performance of the portfolio created by the guidelines have year in and year out beat the Dow average total return for over 23 years, giving me a steady retirement income and growth. The table below shows the portfolio performance for 2012, 2013, 2014, and YTD of 2015. Year Dow Gain/Loss Good Business Beat Difference Portfolio 2,012 8.70% 16.92% 8.22% 2,013 27.00% 39.70% 12.70% 2,014 6.04% 8.67% 2.63% 2015 YTD -9.71% -2.84% 6.87% In a great year like 2013, the portfolio did fantastic. In normal years like 2012 and 2014, it beat the Dow by a fair amount. So far this year, the portfolio is being defensive at 6.87% total return gain above the Dow average loss of -9.71%, for a slight loss. Dividend companies and defensive businesses like Johnson & Johnson (NYSE: JNJ ) give the portfolio a downside beta of less than 1.0. Companies like Walt Disney (NYSE: DIS ) and Boeing (NYSE: BA ) provide growth in a good year like 2013 (an up market) for a beta greater than 1.0. 24 Companies In The Portfolio The 24 companies and their percentage in the portfolio and total return over a 32-month test (starting January 1, 2013) period are shown in the table below. I chose this time frame, since it included the great year of 2013 and the moderate years of 2014 and 2015 YTD. The Dow baseline for this period is 22.89%, and each of the top six easily beat that baseline. The next 18 have six companies that did not beat the Dow baseline, but still are great businesses. I limit the portfolio to 25 companies and let the winners grow until they reach 8-9% of the portfolio, and then I trim the position. BA and HD are now in trim position. I start the companies at a base percentage of the portfolio of 1% and add to the position if they perform well during the next six months. At 4% of the portfolio, I stop buying and let the company percentage of the portfolio grow until it hits 8% – then it’s time to trim. In the portfolio, only one company is actually losing money over the 32-month test period – Freeport McMoran Inc. (NYSE: FCX ). This is my full list of the 24 Good Businesses. I hope to write individual articles on some of these businesses as time permits. Dow Baseline 22.89% Company Total Return Difference Percentage of Portfolio Cumulative Total 32 Months From Baseline Percentage of Portfolio Home Depot (NYSE: HD ) 89.07% 66.18% 8.75% 8.75% Boeing 73.50% 50.61% 8.46% 17.22% L Brands Inc. (NYSE: LB ) 113.34% 90.45% 7.74% 24.96% Johnson & Johnson 38.09% 15.20% 7.59% 32.55% Walt Disney 97.88% 74.99% 7.50% 40.05% Altria Group Inc. (NYSE: MO ) 76.76% 53.88% 6.75% 46.80% Harley Davidson Inc. (NYSE: HOG ) 18.55% -4.33% 6.60% 53.39% Eaton Vance Enhanced Equity Income Fund II (NYSE: EOS ) 45.15% 22.27% 6.06% 59.45% Philip Morris Intl. INC. (NYSE: PM ) 1.71% -21.18% 5.55% 65.00% Cabela’s Inc. (NYSE: CAB ) 1.65% -21.24% 5.66% 70.66% General Electric 24.32% 1.43% 4.74% 75.40% McDonald’s Corp. (NYSE: MCD ) 15.22% -7.67% 4.65% 80.05% Automatic Data Processing (NASDAQ: ADP ) 37.45% 14.56% 4.13% 84.18% Ingersoll-Rand plc (NYSE: IR ) 39.77% 16.88% 2.42% 86.60% Hewlett-Packard 89.58% 66.70% 2.31% 88.91% Omega Health Inv. (NYSE: OHI ) 53.32% 30.44% 1.69% 90.60% Mondelez (NASDAQ: MDLZ ) 65.21% 42.32% 1.64% 92.24% Novartis AG (NYSE: NVS ) 58.54% 35.65% 1.62% 93.86% Texas Instruments (NASDAQ: TXN ) 46.23% 23.34% 1.33% 95.19% AmerisourceBergen (NYSE: ABC ) 132.33% 109.44% 1.14% 96.33% Kraft Heinz Corp. (NASDAQ: KHC ) 67.93% 45.04% 0.81% 97.13% Alcoa (NYSE: AA ) 5.95% -16.94% 0.87% 98.00% Freeport McMoran -63.21% -86.10% 0.72% 98.72% Hanesbrands Inc. (NYSE: HBI ) 218.64% 195.75% 0.34% 99.06% Average 33.24% Recent (Last Two Months) Portfolio Changes and Comments McDonald’s is being trimmed, as the total return for the past 32.0 months is below the Dow average total return. MCD is now 4.65% of the portfolio, and will be held at this total percentage until signs of a turnaround are seen. Short-term out-of-the-money covered calls of 2-3 weeks are also being used to generate income while we wait for the turnaround. The objective of the Good Business Portfolio is to embrace all styles of investing, Alcoa was increased to 0.8% of the portfolio. The change into a manufacturing business will take some time and is a move in the right direction. At the current stock price, it has good risk-versus-reward possibilities. Hanes Brands has been increased to 0.34% of the portfolio, and is just a starter position that will be increased slowly until it gets to be a full position at 4% of the portfolio if the growth continues. Eaton Vance Enhanced Equity Fund II was increased to 6.06% of the portfolio; I need more income, and EOS is the portfolio’s way of buying a diversified group of tech companies when the market dips. I trimmed Home Depot down to 8.75% of the portfolio from 9.0%. HD is a great growth business, but you must have some diversification and not let any position get too high. HD will be trimmed again when it reaches 9.0% of the portfolio. One comment: I have never bought commodity companies before, and both AA and FCX have disappointed me. A new guideline is being added to guideline 7 “to avoid commodity companies, metals and oil/gas”. It just seems too much risk in the face of uncontrolled world events to predict what the price of a commodity will be in the future. Second-Quarter Earnings Season For the second-quarter earnings season, 15 of the portfolio’s companies beat the estimated earnings, while 5 met the earnings estimate and 4 missed the estimate. A short summary of earnings for some of the companies is below. Boeing’s earnings were good at $2.31 before it had to take a charge against the tanker program. In the last month, the company delivered 14 787 planes – 4 more than planned. This should lead to a great earnings report in October. Revenue also beat by $320 million. Last year, Boeing got above 10% of the portfolio, and I trimmed it a little to get it below 10% of the portfolio. Walt Disney’s earnings beat expected by a few pennies at $1.45, compared to expected earnings at $1.42 and last year’s earnings of $1.28. Revenue missed by $130 million. Mr. Market did not like this, and the major factor was that ESPN lost 300,000 subscribers and Walt Disney went down 10%. The market recently took another 10% off Disney. I have a full position in Walt Disney and think it’s a screaming buy at its current price of $100.97. The Star Wars toys are already on sale and are expected to have sales of $500 million alone. Disney gets a share of this through licensing fees, and the movie is still to come in December. Home Depot’s earnings met expectations at $1.71, compared to last year’s earnings of $1.52, for a great gain year over year. Revenue beat by $110 million. HD is the portfolio’s largest holding at 8.75%. As the housing market continues to perform, HD will grow with it. It will be trimmed when it reaches 9% of the portfolio. I love HD, but must not be a pig. Johnson & Johnson beat expected earnings at $1.71, compared to expected earnings at $1.68 and last year’s earnings at $1.66. Revenue beat by $30 million, and the company projected forward earnings of $6.10-6.20 for the year. JNJ is in a defensive business. Its problem is the strong dollar, but the company continues to see moderate growth and pays a 3.5% dividend, which has been increased and paid for 48 years. JNJ is 7.59% of the portfolio, and should be in all portfolios. L Brands just beat expected earnings by a penny at $0.68, compared to expected earnings of $0.67 and last year’s earnings of $0.63. Revenue missed by $30 million. In August, LB announced an 8% sales increase year over year. It pays a fair regular dividend of 2.4%, but has been paying a special dividend for the past few years. Alcoa had a mixed report, with earnings of $0.19 missing the expected earnings of $0.24, but the revenue beat by $110 million. The transformation of the company is starting to take effect, and I will wait at least two more quarters to see if it’s a turnaround or sell this small position. I always like the earnings season, since most of my Good Business companies have increasing earnings. Conclusion The 10 guidelines referenced in the article give me a balanced portfolio of good companies that are large cap and can grow their revenues, earnings, and dividends for years. They have the staying power to fix whatever goes wrong. In each case, the company has the size and good management to fix the problem. The portfolio has growth companies, defensive companies, income companies and companies with international exposure, giving it what I call balance. Of the 24 companies presently in the portfolio, six are underperforming the Dow average in total return over the 32-month test period. All six companies are being hurt by the strong dollar, since they are multi-national and have a large portion of their income coming from foreign operations. It is my intention to write separate comparison articles on the individual companies. The Beta for the portfolio in a down market is less than 1.0 and in an up market is greater than 1.0, and this makes the Good Business Portfolio is a money maker that beats the Dow average over time – what more can you want? Of course, this is not a recommendation to buy or sell, and you should always do your own research and talk to your financial advisor before making any purchase or sale. This is how I manage my IRA retirement account, and the opinions on the companies are my own. Disclosure: I am/we are long BA, HD, JNJ, DIS, LB, HOG, CAB, MO, PM, MCD, HPQ, GE, FCX, EOS, ADP, IR, OHI, HBI, NVS, KHC, MDLZ, AA, ABC, TXN. (More…) I wrote this article myself, and it expresses my own opinions. I am not receiving compensation for it (other than from Seeking Alpha). I have no business relationship with any company whose stock is mentioned in this article.

Big Oil Portfolio – Reviewing It After The Recent Lows

Summary Like all other oil investments, the Big Oil Portfolio has taken a significant hit over the past few months. The fundamentals of none of the portfolios in the company has changed, instead, the only that has changed has been oil prices. The portfolio has a large amount of cash at hand should future opportunities present themselves. Introduction I have not provided an update for my Big Oil Portfolio since July . However, over the past few weeks, oil (NYSEARCA: USO ) has taken a significant hit dropping down to recent lows of less than $40 per barrel. The goal of this article is to take another look at the Big Oil Portfolio since the last update. Last Five Year Oil Prices – Bloomberg Oil prices remained relatively constant from 2011 – 2014. However, since reaching a peak, oil prices took a major hit dropping down to a bottom in January 2015. Oil prices bounced back up and then dropped back down forming a double bottom in March 2015 before recovering to around $60. In recent weeks, two majors things have weighed down on the market. The first was slowing economic growth in China, a major economic producer. The second was fears of a nuclear deal being signed with Iran which would result in a significant market glut. This resulted in another drop down in oil prices down to less than $40 per barrel followed by a recent small recovery. Goal The Big Oil Portfolio was originally created during a period of higher oil prices with the stated goal of building a strong portfolio for a recovery in oil prices. The goal of the article was to take a hypothetical person with $100,000 to invest in oil stocks. In this case, we will assume that you want to invest in large oil companies that are financially secure and will provide investors with income for many years to come. There are several reasons to invest in financially secure large caps during such a crash. However, the biggest one are the two words, ‘financially secure’. Should the oil crash last for longer than expected or get worse than expected, these companies will be able to last significantly longer than the competition. Portfolio Name Number of Share Purchase Price Current Price ExxonMobil (NYSE: XOM ) 150 $86.87 $72.48 Chevron (NYSE: CVX ) 200 $106.62 $76.62 Royal Dutch Shell (NYSE: RDS.A ) 100 $62.16 $49.51 ConocoPhillips (NYSE: COP ) 100 $65.62 $47.19 Schlumberger Limited (NYSE: SLB ) 100 $92.69 $74.96 Phillips 66 (NYSE: PSX ) 100 $80.99 $77.20 Total S.A. (NYSE: TOT ) 430 $52.80 $44.11 Total Amount Invested: $99,894.50 Approximate Dividend Received: $971.00 Annual Dividend Income: $3884.95 Portfolio Cash: $14,578.45 Portfolio Discussion For those who are new to the realm of cyclical business, especially ones like oil where an oversupply of a few percent can cause a 50% drop in price, numbers like those seen above can be quite scary. However, it is worth pointing out that the numbers seen above solely exist because of the change in the price of oil. In fact, with the exception of the drop in oil prices, which has fallen approximately 20% since the last article, the fundamentals of none of the other companies has changed. In fact, the only thing that has changed fundamentally in the portfolio since the original article was the decision to sell Apache Corporation (NYSE: APA ). Apache Corporation is a strong corporation with solid potential, however, the thing I disliked about it is the fact that the majority of its assets are located in the United States. The goal of the portfolio is to form a broad portfolio of stable oil companies with exposure to a number of areas and Apache Corporation did not fit within that mandate. Purchases Now that we have discussed the changes in the portfolio, the portfolio now has $14,578.45 in cash sitting around. Recent factors have combined to make the perfect storm of oil prices. SSE Index Crash – Thomson Reuters The above image shows the Chinese SSE stock index. Partially due to a slowing economic growth rate and partially due to fear of a bubble, the Chinese stock index peaked around June before dropping sharply. As a major consumer of oil, fear of a decreasing Chinese growth rate has also hurt oil prices. This has been combined with recent ideas of a potential nuclear deal between the United States and Iran. Should Iran bring its production back online, that could result in a huge amount of new production that could cause a significant oil surplus. This money will be used to purchase 252 shares of the Lehman Aggregate Bond Fund (NYSEARCA: LAG ). The Lehman Aggregate Bond Fund invests in safe bonds with a modest dividend paid on a monthly basis. More so, the fund maintains a relatively solid price and remains a solid holding of cash for potential future purchasing opportunities. Future Market Situation Now that we have talked about the portfolio’s goals along with its holdings and discussed the portfolio along with its purchases, it is now time to talk about the true driver of this portfolio. The future market situation. Because in the end, it’s really oil prices that move this portfolio around. Annual Change in U.S. Crude Production – EIA The above image shows the change in U.S. crude production. Since 2008, as a result of growing shale production, American production has been steadily increasing. This surplus is what led to the current oil crash. However, in recent weeks, U.S. oil production has been steadily decreasing. The spending cuts are finally starting to have an affect and production is starting to decrease. This is starting to solve the overall oil supply. I expect the recent lows in oil production to potentially be tested again but I would be surprised if prices fall any distance below that. Production has started slowing down while demand, driven partly by lower prices, has continued increasing. This should help cause a recovery in oil prices. Conclusion The Big Oil Portfolio is made of a number of strong oil majors several of which have a long record of paying dividends. These companies have a strong dividend that they will be able to continue paying despite the recent slump in oil prices. However, decreasing economic growth in China coupled with the potential of higher oil production from Iran has caused oil prices to take a significant hit these past weeks which has also affected the portfolio. The portfolio does however have a good amount of cash in reserve should an opportunity present itself. This cash along with dividend growth should help support a recovery in the portfolio when prices eventually recover. Disclosure: I/we have no positions in any stocks mentioned, and no plans to initiate any positions within the next 72 hours. (More…) I wrote this article myself, and it expresses my own opinions. I am not receiving compensation for it (other than from Seeking Alpha). I have no business relationship with any company whose stock is mentioned in this article.

Cushing MLP Total Return Fund: A Lesson For CEF Investors

Summary CEF investors are often attracted by the high yields in this space. SRV’s anomalously high yield and premium provided a ripe recipe for disaster. This article identifies three warning signals that investors could have heeded before the devastating event. The date is Dec. 22nd, 2014. With oil prices collapsing around you, you decide that now would be a good time to dip your toes in an MLP close-ended fund [CEF]. You read Stanford Chemist’s just-published article entitled ” Benchmarking The Performance Of MLP CEFs: Is Active Management Worth It? “, where he recommended, among five MLP CEFs yielding 5.43% to 6.85%, the Tortoise Energy Infrastructure Corporation ( TYG ) due to its strong historical total return and outperformance vs. the benchmark Alerian MLP ETF ( AMLP ). But the 5.43% yield of TYG and the 6.25% yield of AMLP are a bit low for your tastes. You decide to invest in the Cushing MLP Total Return Fund ( SRV ) with a whopping 14.02% yield , more than double that of the other two funds. With twice the yield, you might expect twice the return, right? Fast-forward to today. You have lost half of your investment. The following chart shows the total return performance of SRV, TYG and AMLP since Dec. 2014. SRV Total Return Price data by YCharts What happened to SRV? As with some other high-profile CEFs profiled recently, what transpired with SRV in early 2015 was a distribution cut that triggered a massive collapse in premium/discount value. As can be seen from the chart below (source: CEFConnect ), SRV slashed its quarterly distribution by 68%, from $0.2250 to $0.0730 in 2015. Amusingly, after paying one quarter of its reduced distribution, SRV cut its distribution again by 26%, while simultaneously changing to a monthly distribution policy (perhaps to make the second distribution cut less obvious!). Taken together, the overall change from a distribution of $0.2250/quarter to $0.0180/month represented a 84% reduction for SRV holders. (click to enlarge) The distribution cut was accompanied by a massive reduction in premium/discount value, from some +30% to -10%, as can be seen from the chart below. This explains the severe underperformance of SRV vs. TYG and AMLP since Dec. 2014. (click to enlarge) Obviously, hindsight is always 20/20. But I believe that there were some warning signs that SRV investors could have heeded before the disastrous event. Lesson #1: Consider historical performance While historical performance is no guarantee of future results, the past return of a CEF can give an indication of the management’s competency in running the fund. The 3-year total return to Dec. 2014 (the hypothetical start date of this exercise) shows that even before the distribution cut had occurred, SRV had been severely underperforming TYG and AMLP on a total return basis. SRV Total Return Price data by YCharts On a price-only basis, the underperformance of SRV becomes even more visually striking. SRV data by YCharts The above charts indicate that the high distribution paid out by SRV has prevented it from growing its NAV, despite the bull market in MLPs. Even when total returns are considered, SRV still lagged TYG and AMLP in the three years to Dec. 2014. Lesson #2: Premium/discount matters! As investors in the Pioneer High Income Trust (NYSE: PHT ) (see here for my previous article warning of PHT’s expanding premium) and more recently, the PIMCO High Income Fund (NYSE: PHK ), have found out , a high starting premium simply increases the amount that a fund can fall when adversity strikes. On Dec. 22nd, 2014, SRV’s premium/discount had stretched to a massive +28.4%. In comparison, TYG’s premium/discount was -6.1% at the time. The following chart shows the 3-year premium/discount profiles for SRV and TYG. (click to enlarge) The chart above shows that in the two years leading to Dec. 2014, SRV’s premium/discount expanded from around +15% to over +30%. On the other hand, TYG’s premium/discount declined from +15% to around -10% over the same time period. Does it make any sense to you that the perennial underperformer SRV was immune to the MLP sell-off that began in the summer of 2014, while the benchmark-beating TYG was not? No, it doesn’t make any sense to me either. In fact, SRV’s premium continued to expand even while the oil crash was already well underway. My only explanation for this was that retail investors were enamored with SRV’s high yield and pushed up its market price relative to its NAV. CEF expert and Seeking Alpha contributor Douglas Albo frequently laments the “Insanity of CEF Investors.” I believe that this example qualifies. Lesson #3: Beware of yields that seem too good to be true On Dec. 22, 2014, SRV yielded 14.02% with a premium/discount of +28.4%, meaning that its yield on NAV was even greater, at 18.00% (!). Meanwhile, TYG yielded 5.43% with a premium/discount of -6.1%, giving a NAV yield of 5.10%. Given that both funds employ similar leverage (around 30%), and are investing in essentially the same universe, how can SRV be yielding more than three times on its NAV compared to TYG? It just doesn’t make any sense. Simply put, SRV’s yield was way too good to be true. Summary I believe that there were several warnings signs that could have allowed investors to avoid SRV before the calamitous distribution cut in early 2015. These were [i] a poor historical performance, [ii] a rising premium (while other and better funds in the same category witnessed premium contraction), [iii] a yield that seemed way too good to be true. My main regret is not being able to identify this short opportunity for readers, and/or warn existing holders to exit the fund beforehand. Nevertheless, I hope that this article will help investors pick out similar warning signs in their existing or potential CEF investments to allow them to take action earlier. Disclosure: I/we have no positions in any stocks mentioned, and no plans to initiate any positions within the next 72 hours. (More…) I wrote this article myself, and it expresses my own opinions. I am not receiving compensation for it (other than from Seeking Alpha). I have no business relationship with any company whose stock is mentioned in this article.