Tag Archives: management

The Amazing Beauty Of Equal Weight

Summary Most investors look only at capital-weighted indices. They miss two positive anomalies of equal weight. Here are equal-weight ideas and ETFs for passive investing and tactical allocation. Capital-weighted indices in the broad market and specific sectors are getting all the attention of investors. This article aims at proving that equal-weighted indices are better investment vehicles for passive investing and tactical allocation. We will stay in the S&P 500 universe. A few words of theory The statistical bias in favor of an equal weighted set of stocks over the same set weighted on market capitalization has two reasons: Size effect: Lower-range large-caps usually perform better than mega-caps. Rebalancing: Periodically equalizing position sizes in dollar amount among a big set of stocks is a simplistic “buy-low-sell-high” strategy. Simplistic, but not stupid. The interest bias in favor of capital-weighted indices has also good reasons: It is a good representation of real economic activity. Inheritance of the pre-computer era, capital-weighted indices are easier to calculate manually. They are linear functions of share prices, adjusted of structural and corporate events (component list modifications, splits, public offerings, buybacks). It generates less transaction costs for a mutual fund or ETF following it. Equal-weighted S&P 500 The next chart shows in red the equity curve of all S&P 500 stocks, equal-weighted rebalanced on weekly opening between January 1999 and September 2015. The blue line is SPY . In both cases, dividends are accounted and reinvested. It is impossible to implement as a strategy for an individual investor because of the capital needed to absorb transaction costs. Moreover, there is an ETF for that: the Guggenheim S&P Equal Weight ETF (NYSEARCA: RSP ). Since inception on 4/24/2003, it has an annualized excess return of 2% over SPY, making it a better instrument of passive index investing. On the same period, the theoretical annualized excess return of equal-weight S&P 500 with dividends is 3.5%. The difference can be explained by trading costs, management fees, rebalancing frequencies. Next chart: RSP in red versus SPY in blue since 4/24/2003: (click to enlarge) S&P 500 with sectors in equal weight The next chart shows the equity curve of an equal weight portfolio of the 9 Select Sector SPDR ETFs rebalanced weekly: utilities (NYSEARCA: XLU ), energy (NYSEARCA: XLE ), materials (NYSEARCA: XLB ), financials (NYSEARCA: XLF ), healthcare (NYSEARCA: XLV ), industrials (NYSEARCA: XLI ), IT & telecom (NYSEARCA: XLK ), consumer staples (NYSEARCA: XLP ), and consumer discretionary (NYSEARCA: XLY ). Here, the size effect is questionable, but the rebalancing bias applies. (click to enlarge) Individual sectors in equal weight Guggenheim has also sector equal-weight ETFs. The next table compares their annualized returns with the Select Sector SPDR series since inception date (11/1/2006), and the theoretical return of stocks rebalanced weekly in equal weight: Sector Stocks Eq. Weight weekly Eq. weight ETF Ann. return Cap. weight ETF Ann. return Cons. Disc. 9.76% (NYSEARCA: RCD ) 8.63% XLY 9.96% Industrials 9.08% (NYSEARCA: RGI ) 7.64% XLI 7.01% Cons. Staples 12.61% (NYSEARCA: RHS ) 11.72% XLP 9.92% Materials 7.63% (NYSEARCA: RTM ) 6.73% XLB 5.16% Energy 2.83% (NYSEARCA: RYE ) 1.97% XLE 3.26% Financials 2.46% (NYSEARCA: RYF ) 0.02% XLF -2.63% Healthcare 14.91% (NYSEARCA: RYH ) 14.18% XLV 10.96% Technology 8.41% (NYSEARCA: RYT ) 6.95% XLK 8.32% Utilities 7.24% (NYSEARCA: RYU ) 6.33% XLU 5.59% In theory, equal weight brings a better or similar return in all sectors, except energy. After management fees and tracking errors, the consumer discretionary and technology equal-weight ETFs are also failing. Equal weight of equal-weighted sectors As a last paragraph, here is the return since the inception of the Guggenheim ETFs in equal-weight rebalanced weekly compared with the Sector SPDR ETFs in equal weight, RSP and SPY. 1/01/2006-09/16/2015 Guggenheim series eq. weight SPDR series eq. weight RSP SPY Ann. Return 8.35% 7.16% 7.43% 6.31% The solutions with individual stocks in equal weight for each sector work better (1st and 3rd columns), which makes sense: size effect is more beneficial. For an individual investor seeking an equal-weight strategy on the broad index, RSP may be a better solution than the Guggenheim series in equal weight after transaction costs, depending on transaction fees and portfolio size. Conclusion With the exception of the energy sector, equal weight has been systematically superior to capital weight in the S&P 500 universe on the 2 last market cycles (1999-2015). In ETF implementations, fees and tracking errors result in a lag for 2 other sectors. Investors can find here useful investing instruments and ideas for passive investing and sector tactical allocation. Data and charts: Portfolio123 Disclosure: I/we have no positions in any stocks mentioned, and no plans to initiate any positions within the next 72 hours. (More…) I wrote this article myself, and it expresses my own opinions. I am not receiving compensation for it (other than from Seeking Alpha). I have no business relationship with any company whose stock is mentioned in this article. Additional disclosure: I short the S&P 500 for hedging purposes

Built For Action

We humans are doers. We want to move, to make, to accomplish, to act. We do not take kindly to sitting idly by. We do not enjoy being bored and most of us struggle to sit quietly alone. It is increasingly easy to distract ourselves, to push away the quiet. Unless I’m asleep I am within arm’s reach of my phone about 95% of the day. Why sit quietly when Twitter and Instagram await?! Last year I read 10% Happier: How I Tamed the Voice in my Head by Dan Harris (at the recommendation of this post by Shane Parrish at Farnam Street). It is a great reflection on the difficulty of our busy lives and our ability to focus and slow down. Harris, after having a panic attack on national television, explores a path towards meditation and trying to relieve his anxiety. In doing so, he finds that meditation is hard. It’s really hard. Sitting and trying to focus on a single thing (typically breathing) without being distracted by thoughts of work, family, hobbies, to-do lists, dentist appointments and everything else. We are just not very good at doing nothing. This is especially true as investors. And we really don’t like it when are portfolios do nothing. We’re sitting in the doldrums right now. Returns everywhere are nowhere. Here’s a quick rundown of 12-month returns through 9-15-15: S&P 500: 1.77% Russell 2000: 3.05% Barclays Aggregate Bond: 2.32% MSCI EAFE: -6.34% MSCI Emerging Markets: -23.58% US Real Estate: 1.89% Other than Emerging Markets being pretty painful, those are some pretty unexciting numbers. A weighted average of those for a balanced investor is probably going to put you in the -3%ish range for twelve months. A little painful, but probably not panic-inducing for most. And yet, it itches. You get your statement and look at the numbers and it just tickles your nerves a little bit. “Should I do something?” it asks. “What’s not working?” it wants to know. “Have I made a mistake?” “What should I do?” “How do I fix it?” They are quiet questions, but there they are, lingering in the back of our minds. We only get one chance at this investing thing, and we’re terrified that we’ll get it wrong. We’ll miss out on opportunities or hire the wrong advisor or buy at the wrong time or have to listen to our brother-in-law at Thanksgiving talk about how he nailed it AGAIN this year. Hopefully, we have the other voice too. The calm, rational one that reminds us that we have a plan. A pretty well-thought-out plan. A plan that involves boring years and periods where returns don’t meet our expectations. This voice should remind us that we knew about that going in. It doesn’t necessarily make it easier to remember that, but it ought to handcuff us. Even though we simply hate to do nothing, we should. We are not built for it. We are built for action! If it looks broken, fix it! The problem is that what “looks broken” to us is based on our desperate need for immediate gratification and split-second feedback about our decisions. But split-second feedback makes us absolutely terrible investors. In the moment, we can’t take the long view, so we need to listen to our past selves about why we made the plans we did and how we already know what to do in these situations. Generally: nothing.

What Lies Ahead For Dollar ETFs?

Although the Fed rate hike hearsay continues to dominate the headlines, investors haven’t really seen this speculation shift to huge gains for the U.S. dollar, at least not in the recent time frame. In fact, the greenback – as represented by the U.S. dollar Index – has lost its value in the last one month and five-day period (as of September 15, 2015). One of the reasons for this unexpected move was an extremely dour trading scene throughout August and the start of September. Maddening economic issues in China – a currency devaluation and a six-and-half-year low manufacturing data for August – took the global market in its grip, and crushed the global equities in the last one month. Yet the U.S. dollar has held firm in 2015 (so far), as many investors remain long-term bulls on the world’s reserve currency due to a recovering American economy. This was truer as the most developed and emerging nations are dragging their feet currently, leaving the U.S. as the lone star. The U.S. economy underwent an upward GDP revision for the second quarter of 2015, from 2.3% reported earlier to 3.7% upgraded later on strong domestic demand. If this was not enough, the unemployment rate dropped to 5.1% in August, the lowest since April 2008. This more-than-seven-year low unemployment rate should bolster the case for an imminent policy tightening. Additionally, average hourly wages rose 0.3% sequentially and 2.2% year over year. The average work week also nudged up to 34.6 from 34.5 in the prior and the year-earlier months. All these made September lift-off a heightened possibility that should have bolstered the greenback, but kept it range-bound due to global market rout. Can Greenback Gain Post Fed? Things are at a critical juncture at this moment. Two ETFs offering exposure to U.S. dollar (USD) against a basket of world currencies – PowerShares DB US Dollar Bullish Fund (NYSEARCA: UUP ) and WisdomTree Bloomberg U.S. Dollar Bullish Fund (NYSEARCA: USDU ) – are up 4.1% and 5.8% so far this year (as of September 15, 2015) but retreated about 1.3% and 0.2% in the last one month, respectively. While many may view the recent dip in the greenback as a setback, we believe that this fall led the U.S. dollar and the related ETFs toward the fair valuation. These dollar-related products surged from the latter part of last year due to the diverging monetary policies between the U.S. and other developed and some emerging markets. The U.S. wrapped up its QE measure late last year while Japan boosted its gigantic asset-buying program and the Euro zone initiated a QE launch in early 2015. This policy differential made the U.S. dollar a king among its peer currencies while other developed currencies started to lose out on economic stimuli. As a result, the U.S. dollar index surged over 13% in the last one year (as of September 14, 2015). Thus, a certain pull-back will now help the U.S. dollar to better prepare for a rally if the Fed hikes rates this week). And even if the Fed opts for a December lift-off or sometime in early 2016, the U.S. dollar should prevail in the coming days as inflows of ultra-cheap money in Europe, Japan and some emerging economies will continue to weaken their respective currencies against the greenback, which is still stronger. Which ETF is a Better Bet? Given this, investors could definitely play the U.S. dollar by considering either UUP or USDU. UUP looks to track the U.S. dollar against a basket of six world currencies – the euro (57.6%), Japanese yen (13.6%), British pound (11.9%), Canadian dollar (9.10%), Swedish krona (4.20%) and Swiss franc (3.60%). USDU tracks the U.S. dollar against a basket of 10 developed and emerging market currencies. It allocates higher to the Euro zone currency at 32.5%, closely followed by Japanese yen (19.25%) and Canadian dollar (11.21%). Other currencies like Mexican peso, British pound, Australian dollar, Swiss franc, South Korean won, Chinese yuan and Brazilian real receive single-digit allocation each in the fund’s basket. Since, UUP is mostly exposed to the developed economies’ currencies; things are less likely to improve post Fed tightening. On the other hand, USDU gives exposure to a broader basket consisting developed and emerging currencies. Notably, most of the emerging market currencies are tumbling presently and are expected to fall out of favor post-Fed tightening. This should give USDU a scope for outperformance over UUP. Bottom Line Having said this, we would like to note that any resumption in the greenback rally should not be as great as it was late last year. This is because the market has mostly priced in the favorable outcome of the impending Fed lift-off and protracted easing in other developed nations like the Euro zone and Japan and their effects on the exchange rate. Original Post