PIMCO Total Return: 1 Bill Gross-Less Year Later
Summary The PIMCO Total Return Fund assets under management have shrunk from $293B in early 2013 to less than $100B today. The new managers of the fund were part of the investment committee working with Bill Gross during his tenure so management style should remain consistent. The fund, at least in the year-to-date period without Gross managing, has outperformed its benchmark and Morningstar category. The managers are currently retaining a cautious approach to the portfolio in anticipation of future rate hikes. In the relatively mundane world of mutual fund investing there was perhaps no news bigger than last year’s surprising announcement that Bill Gross was leaving PIMCO – the company he founded – to jump over to Janus. The move resulted in a mass exodus from Gross’ Total Return Fund (MUTF: PTTRX ). Once the largest mutual fund in the world back in 2013 with $293B in assets now has less than $100B. Many investors felt that Gross was the key that drove the engine and fled for greener pastures when he departed (although his current fund – the Janus Global Unconstrained Bond Fund (MUTF: JUCDX ) – has just $1.5B in assets). For investors that have stuck around it’s worth wondering if the “new” PIMCO Total Return fund is the same now as it was when Gross was in charge. Gross himself has said in the past that investors maintain at least a five year outlook when formulating their portfolios. However, Gross has been known to quickly change directions. This is perhaps most notable in his 2011 call on interest rates. Gross thought that interest rates would rise once QE was done and took his portfolio’s allocation in Treasury bonds all the way down to zero. Of course, interest rates went down, the fund badly underperformed its benchmarks and the flow of money out of the fund began. The new fund managers for their part have pledged largely to maintain the groupthink investment style that was part of the decision making process even when Gross was involved. Style-wise, the fund still falls into Morningstar’s intermediate term bond category where it’s been for the last many years. There are a couple of important things to note in the figure above. First, performance on a one year basis can’t really be used as a long term predictor of success but at least the new managers are off to a reasonable start. Year-to-date, the fund is beating its benchmark index by 27 basis points and the broader intermediate term bond fund category by 64 basis points. That puts Total Return in the top 15% of funds – a notable departure from recent performance that saw the fund fall into the bottom half three of the last four years. Second, turnover and trading frequency remain at comparable levels to the end of Gross’ tenure. The fund is running at a turnover rate of about 265% which is fairly comparable to the past two years’ rate of 227%. Going forward, the fund’s managers are limiting duration in the United States anticipating coming rate hikes maintaining roughly ⅔ of the portfolio in government and mortgage-backed securities. Smaller allocations to corporates, high yields and even some emerging markets adds return potential and yield to the portfolio. Consistent with its more defensive outlook, the current portfolio duration is around 4 years – much lower than the benchmark’s 5.6. Conclusion It’s understandable that investors would begin looking elsewhere following Gross’ departure. But shareholders who have stuck around have done just fine in the meantime. I think we’ve seen in the first year post-Gross that the fund is managed in a substantially similar way. The consistency of the portfolio management team that worked behind Gross is still largely intact. Gross’ decades of expertise may no longer be around but Total Return is still in able and, at least thus far, in solidly performing hands. Despite the wave of outflows that is still occurring yet today there’s no reason why the current PIMCO Total Return fund shouldn’t at least be considered for the income part of a portfolio. Disclosure: I/we have no positions in any stocks mentioned, and no plans to initiate any positions within the next 72 hours. (More…) I wrote this article myself, and it expresses my own opinions. I am not receiving compensation for it (other than from Seeking Alpha). I have no business relationship with any company whose stock is mentioned in this article.