Tag Archives: ideas

How To Build An Alpha-Rich Portfolio Around Preferred Shares

Summary After taking a look at PFF, I decided it would be worth looking into ways that an investor could use it heavily in a low risk portfolio. The resulting portfolio underperforms SPY in a strong bull market, but does very well at limiting volatility. Looking at the max drawdown shows that over the last 4 years the worst drawdown on the portfolio was only 7.9%. If investors are considering holding cash in their portfolio to reduce the volatility, they may want to consider this style of portfolio instead. After covering the iShares U.S. Preferred Stock ETF (NYSEARCA: PFF ) and noticing that it had some very attractive risk characteristics and a very strong yield at 6%, I decided it was worth looking into the impacts of designing a portfolio for very low volatility at the portfolio level while maintaining a fairly strong yield for investors. I think this is one of the most reasonable ways to incorporate a heavy allocation to PFF in a portfolio. I built a portfolio using only a few tickers so it is reasonably simple to duplicate. Portfolio The Portfolio uses the Schwab U.S. Dividend Equity ETF (NYSEARCA: SCHD ) as the core of the portfolio since it has been noticeably less volatile than whole market ETFs, has a respectable dividend yield with dividends regularly growing, and an expense ratio of only .07%. The next major allocation is a very long duration treasury ETF, the Vanguard Extended Duration Treasury ETF (NYSEARCA: EDV ). The iShares U.S. Preferred Stock ETF gets the same 20% allocation as EDV. The next holding is the iShares MSCI USA Minimum Volatility ETF (NYSEARCA: USMV ) because it has a fairly low beta and fits very well in portfolios designed to minimize total risk at the portfolio level. The final allocation goes to the iShares J.P. Morgan USD Emerging Markets Bond ETF (NYSEARCA: EMB ) with 5% of the portfolio. This is incorporated because it has such unique risk factors that it ends up having only moderate correlations with each other investment while having a yield just over 4.5%. The portfolio is demonstrated below: (click to enlarge) The great thing about this portfolio is that over a sample period of nearly 4 years the annualized volatility is only 6.5% which puts the portfolio volatility at slightly under half of the volatility on the SPDR S&P 500 Trust ETF ( SPY). In other words, an investor holding 50% SPY and 50% cash would have witnessed a higher level of volatility in their portfolio. During the period the worst drawdown was falling 7.9%. All around this is a very resilient portfolio because the risk factors have been so effectively diversified. Alpha Investors may notice that this portfolio has materially underperformed SPY over the sample period, but it is meant to underperform SPY during strong bull markets. When SPY is up almost 77% in less than 4 years, I’m going to call that a strong bull market even if we saw some huge shocks in August. The annual rate of return on SPY is about 16%. The annual rate of return on the portfolio was 11.4%. If investors start from portfolio volatility (rather than beta) for establishing alpha, this portfolio would to create about half of the difference between SPY and the risk free rate. Since the portfolio only underperformed SPY by 4.66% annually during a solid bull market. If we round up the risk on the portfolio to being half of SPY, then we subtract (4.66% * 2) or 9.31% to find the risk free rate necessary to eliminate the entire alpha. The risk free rate that would have neutralized the alpha is 6.73%. I think it is reasonable to say that this portfolio performed very well on a risk adjusted basis relative to investors that were going 100% into SPY or another very similar broad ETF. Correlations A major reason for the strong performance is the correlation within the portfolio. The long term treasury ETF has only a slight positive correlation with the emerging market bond fund, but it is negative with everything else. Both SCHD and USMV have lower levels of volatility than SPY and PFF and EMB have reasonably low levels of annualized volatility combined with moderate correlations to the rest of the portfolio. Conclusion Over the last 4 years this ETF strategy has demonstrated very reasonable returns while being substantially more resilient to periods of weakness. In a prolonged bull market it will fall behind SPY, but on a risk adjusted basis it is still performing very well and if there was a major correction it would be in position to lose substantially less. In my opinion, this kind of strategy is the most reasonable way to incorporate a heavy allocation of PFF into a portfolio. Why would you want to build a portfolio with a heavy allocation to a preferred share ETF? I can think of one solid reason off the top of my head, a dividend yield over 6% at a time when interest rates in much of the economy fail to offer any compelling returns. Disclosure: I am/we are long SCHD. (More…) I wrote this article myself, and it expresses my own opinions. I am not receiving compensation for it (other than from Seeking Alpha). I have no business relationship with any company whose stock is mentioned in this article. Additional disclosure: Information in this article represents the opinion of the analyst. All statements are represented as opinions, rather than facts, and should not be construed as advice to buy or sell a security. Ratings of “outperform” and “underperform” reflect the analyst’s estimation of a divergence between the market value for a security and the price that would be appropriate given the potential for risks and returns relative to other securities. The analyst does not know your particular objectives for returns or constraints upon investing. All investors are encouraged to do their own research before making any investment decision. Information is regularly obtained from Yahoo Finance, Google Finance, and SEC Database. If Yahoo, Google, or the SEC database contained faulty or old information it could be incorporated into my analysis.

XLY: Do You Need More Aggressive Allocations?

Summary XLY offers investors a fairly aggressive portfolio that is more volatile than the market but benefits from diversification. Most of the allocations seem very reasonable, but MCD looks like a fairly conservative option. If an investor is going to buy into this aggressive fund, they should have a rebalancing plan in place. Investors should be seeking to improve their risk adjusted returns. I’m a big fan of using ETFs to achieve the risk adjusted returns relative to the portfolios that a normal investor can generate for themselves after trading costs. One of the funds that I’m reviewing is the Consumer Discretionary Select Sector SPDR ETF (NYSEARCA: XLY ). I’ll be performing a substantial portion of my analysis along the lines of modern portfolio theory, so the goal is to design portfolios that perform well on a risk adjusted basis, not portfolios that necessarily beat the market. Expense Ratio The expense ratio for XLY is .15%. That isn’t too bad. I’m usually expecting to see high expense ratios that drain away the investor’s money, but XLY scores well in this regard. Largest Holdings (click to enlarge) The top of the holdings for XLY is Amazon (NASDAQ: AMZN ). For investors seeking to find companies trading at low fundamentals such as P/E ratios, Amazon’s history of not turning a meaningful profit may be a concern. While earnings are a concern for Amazon, sales have been an area of strength as the company blossomed over the last 15 years and has become a household name. The difficulty for this portfolio is the reliance on discretionary spending. This is a reason for the portfolio to show some substantial volatility when investors are concerned about another recession and falling personal expenditures. The interesting holding here is McDonald’s (NYSE: MCD ) coming in as the 5th holding. I would not put MCD in the same category as the other top holdings. MCD pays a very strong dividend, has a long history of doing so, and in a bad economy the restaurant can pick up new customers that are trading down to buy McDonald’s products rather than more expensive food. The rest of the top 10 holdings are all companies that I would expect to perform best when consumers are readily disposing of income. Building the Portfolio This hypothetical portfolio has a fairly aggressive allocation for the middle aged investor. Only 25% of the total portfolio value is placed in bonds and a fifth of that bond allocation is given to high yield bonds. If the investor wants to treat an investment in an mREIT index as an investment in the underlying bonds that the individual mREITs hold, then the total bond allocation would be 35%. Given how substantially mREITs can deviate from book value, I’d rather consider the allocation as an equity position designed to create a very high yield. This portfolio is probably taking on more risk than would be appropriate for many retiring investors since a major recession could still hit this pretty hard. If the investor wanted to modify the portfolio to be more appropriate for retirement, the first place to start would be increasing the bond exposure at the cost of equity. However, the diversification within the portfolio is fairly solid. Long term treasuries work nicely with major market indexes and I’ve designed this hypothetical portfolio without putting in the allocation I normally would for equity REITs. An allocation is created for the mortgage REITs, which can offer some fairly nice diversification relative to the rest of the portfolio and they are a major source of yield in this hypothetical portfolio. The portfolio assumes frequent rebalancing which would be a problem for short term trading outside of tax advantaged accounts unless the investor was going to rebalance by adding to their positions on a regular basis and allocating the majority of the capital towards whichever portions of the portfolio had been underperforming recently. Because a substantial portion of the yield from this portfolio comes from REITs and interest, I would favor this portfolio as a tax exempt strategy even if the investor was frequently rebalancing by adding new capital. The portfolio allocations can be seen below along with the dividend yields from each investment. Name Ticker Portfolio Weight Yield SPDR S&P 500 Trust ETF SPY 35.00% 2.06% Consumer Discretionary Select Sector SPDR ETF XLY 10.00% 1.36% First Trust Consumer Staples AlphaDEX ETF FXG 10.00% 1.60% Vanguard FTSE Emerging Markets ETF VWO 5.00% 3.17% First Trust Utilities AlphaDEX ETF FXU 5.00% 3.77% SPDR Barclays Capital Short Term High Yield Bond ETF SJNK 5.00% 5.45% PowerShares 1-30 Laddered Treasury Portfolio ETF PLW 20.00% 2.22% iShares Mortgage Real Estate Capped ETF REM 10.00% 14.45% Portfolio 100.00% 3.53% The next chart shows the annualized volatility and beta of the portfolio since April of 2012. (click to enlarge) A quick rundown of the portfolio Using SJNK offers investors better yields from using short term exposure to credit sensitive debt. The yield on this is fairly nice and due to the short duration of the securities the volatility isn’t too bad. PLW on the other hand does have some material volatility, but a negative correlation to other investments allows it to reduce the total risk of the portfolio. FXG is used to make the portfolio overweight on consumer staples with a goal of providing more stability to the equity portion of the portfolio. FXU is used to create a small utility allocation for the portfolio to give it a higher dividend yield and help it produce more income. I find the utility sector often has some desirable risk characteristics that make it worth at least considering for an overweight representation in a portfolio. VWO is simply there to provide more diversification from being an international equity portfolio. While giving investors exposure to emerging markets, it is also offering a very solid dividend yield that enhances the overall income level from the portfolio. XLY offers investors higher expected returns in a solid economy at the cost of higher risk. Using it as more than a small weighting would result in too much risk for the portfolio, but as a small weighting the diversification it offers relative to the core holding of SPY is eliminating most of the additional risk. REM is primarily there to offer a substantial increase in the dividend yield which is otherwise not very strong. The mREIT sector can be subject to some pretty harsh movements and dividends from mREITs should not be the core source of income for an investor. However, they can be used to enhance the level of dividend income while investors wait for their other equity investments to increase dividends over the coming decades. If you want a really quick version to refer back to, I put together the following chart that really simplifies the role of each investment: Name Ticker Role in Portfolio SPDR S&P 500 Trust ETF SPY Core of Portfolio Consumer Discretionary Select Sector SPDR ETF XLY Enhance Expected Returned First Trust Consumer Staples AlphaDEX ETF FXG Reduce Beta of Portfolio Vanguard FTSE Emerging Markets ETF VWO Exposure to Foreign Markets First Trust Utilities AlphaDEX ETF FXU Enhance Dividends, Lower Portfolio Risk SPDR Barclays Capital Short Term High Yield Bond ETF SJNK Low Volatility with over 5% Yield PowerShares 1-30 Laddered Treasury Portfolio ETF PLW Negative Beta Reduces Portfolio Risk iShares Mortgage Real Estate Capped ETF REM Enhance Current Income Risk Contribution The risk contribution category demonstrates the amount of the portfolio’s volatility that can be attributed to that position. Despite TLT being fairly volatile and tying SPY for the second highest volatility in the portfolio, it actually produces a negative risk contribution because it has a negative correlation with most of the portfolio. It is important to recognize that the “risk” on an investment needs to be considered in the context of the entire portfolio. To make it easier to analyze how risky each holding would be in the context of the portfolio, I have most of these holdings weighted at a simple 10%. Because of TLT’s heavy negative correlation, it receives a weighting of 20% and as the core of the portfolio SPY was weighted as 50%. Correlation The chart below shows the correlation of each ETF with each other ETF in the portfolio. Blue boxes indicate positive correlations and tan box indicate negative correlations. Generally speaking lower levels of correlation are highly desirable and high levels of correlation substantially reduce the benefits from diversification. (click to enlarge) Conclusion XLY offers investors a fairly aggressive allocation that is heavy on companies that should succeed when the market is doing well and should struggle more during a market downturn. To take advantage of the investment investors would want to be ready to buy into the ETF when fear is stronger in the economy. In my opinion, the most effective way to do that would be to set up an automatic rebalancing schedule or use allocation bands and buy in/sell off whenever the allocation was exceeding the desired range. Due to some diversification benefits, a small allocation can be used in a portfolio without driving up the total risk of the portfolio. However, investors aiming to use the ETF for more than 10% or so of the portfolio may find their volatility across the portfolio increasing. An investor could counteract some of that additional risk by increasing their allocation to treasury securities with an ETF like PLW where the correlation between the two funds is a negative .4. Despite a fairly low expense ratio, if an investor is using a large enough portfolio they may still find it worthwhile to imitate the portfolio by buying up the major holdings because so much of the portfolio is held in the top 10. For the investor that wants to get a little more aggressive without a large enough portfolio to replicate XLY, it looks like a fairly solid option for the sector. Disclosure: I/we have no positions in any stocks mentioned, and no plans to initiate any positions within the next 72 hours. (More…) I wrote this article myself, and it expresses my own opinions. I am not receiving compensation for it (other than from Seeking Alpha). I have no business relationship with any company whose stock is mentioned in this article. Additional disclosure: Information in this article represents the opinion of the analyst. All statements are represented as opinions, rather than facts, and should not be construed as advice to buy or sell a security. Ratings of “outperform” and “underperform” reflect the analyst’s estimation of a divergence between the market value for a security and the price that would be appropriate given the potential for risks and returns relative to other securities. The analyst does not know your particular objectives for returns or constraints upon investing. All investors are encouraged to do their own research before making any investment decision. Information is regularly obtained from Yahoo Finance, Google Finance, and SEC Database. If Yahoo, Google, or the SEC database contained faulty or old information it could be incorporated into my analysis.

FFFDX: A Target Date Fund In Need Some Work

Summary FFFDX offers investors a high expense ratio to go with a needlessly complex portfolio. Investors seeking superior risk adjusted returns could go with allocations as simple as SPY + any long term treasury ETF. By incorporating an enormous volume of other mutual funds the target date fund incorporates a higher expense ratio with suboptimal holdings. If the fund needs exposure to the total US market, they can ditch the complicated combination of funds and just use FSTVX (Disclosure: long FSTVX). Lately I have been doing some research on target date retirement funds. Despite the concept of a target date retirement fund being fairly simple, the investment options appear to vary quite dramatically in quality. Some of the funds have dramatically more complex holdings consisting with a high volume of various funds while others use only a few funds and yet achieve excellent diversification. My goal is help investors recognize which funds are the most useful tools for planning for retirement. In this article I’m focusing on the Fidelity Freedom 2020 Fund (MUTF: FFFDX ). What do funds like FFFDX do? They establish a portfolio based on a hypothetical start to retirement period. The portfolios are generally going to be designed under Modern Portfolio Theory so the goal is to maximize the expected return relative to the amount of risk the portfolio takes on. As investors are approaching retirement it is assumed that their risk tolerance will be decreasing and thus the holdings of the fund should become more conservative over time. That won’t be the case for every investor, but it is a reasonable starting place for creating a retirement option when each investor cannot be surveyed about their own unique risk tolerances. Therefore, the holdings of FFFDX should be more aggressive now than they would be 3 years from now, but at all points we would expect the fund to be more conservative than a fund designed for investors that are expected to retire 5 years later. What Must Investors Know? The most important things to know about the funds are the expenses and either the individual holdings or the volatility of the portfolio as a whole. Regardless of the planned retirement date, high expense ratios are a problem. Depending on the individual, they may wish to modify their portfolio to be more or less aggressive than the holdings of FFFDX. Expense Ratio The expense ratio of Fidelity Freedom® 2020 is .66%. That expense ratio is simply too high. Investors using a target date fund need to keep an eye on those expenses. It is possible to create a very efficient portfolio using only a few funds. Ideally the funds selected for building the portfolio would be selected for offering excellent diversified exposure at very low expense ratios. At the most simplistic level, an investor is looking for domestic equity, international equity, domestic bonds, and international bonds. If any of those had to be left out, the international bond allocation is the least important. In my opinion, there is no need to use both growth and value indexes. There is no need to individually use large, medium, and small-cap allocations. For instance, the Fidelity Spartan® Total Market Index (MUTF: FSTVX ) has a net expense ratio of .05% and offers exposure to the vast majority of the U.S. market. If you were building a target date fund from Fidelity funds, you could simply use FSTVX and eliminate all other domestic equity funds. This method would provide investors with a low expense ratio on the underlying domestic equity position and excellent diversification. That is precisely why I am including FSTVX as a holding in my portfolio. Holdings / Composition The following chart demonstrates the holdings of Fidelity Freedom® 2020: If you were making a target date fund, how many allocations would you need? Hopefully it wouldn’t be that many. Note that the holdings chart above simply showed the equity funds. There is another long list of funds for bond exposures. There is simply no need for a portfolio to be this complex. For comparison, Vanguard’s Target Retirement 2020 Fund (MUTF: VTWNX ) includes only five allocations and one of them is less than one percent. Volatility An investor may choose to use FFFDX in an employer sponsored account (if their employer has it on the approved list) while creating their own portfolio in separate accounts. Since I can’t predict what investors will choose to combine with the fund, I analyze it as being an entire portfolio. (click to enlarge) When we look at the volatility on FFFDX, it is dramatically lower than the volatility on the SPDR S&P 500 Trust ETF (NYSEARCA: SPY ). That shouldn’t be surprising since the portfolio has some large bond positions. Over the last five years it has significantly underperformed SPY, but that should be expected given the much lower beta and volatility of the fund. Investors should expect this fund to retain dramatically more value in a bear market and to fall behind in a prolonged bull market. Despite that expectation, for having a beta of .56%, delivering less than half the gains of the S&P 500 is really sad. It isn’t like the portfolio simply has an enormous amount of cash sitting around. A target date fund should have a substantial allocation to treasury securities. As you might recall, treasury securities did fairly well. Over the last five years the iShares 20+ Year Treasury Bond ETF (NYSEARCA: TLT ) was up 36.4%. Want lower volatility with better annualized returns? Simply combine TLT and SPY as demonstrated in this hypothetical portfolio: (click to enlarge) This portfolio produces a lower level of annualized volatility and superior returns despite having only two tickers. SPY provided domestic equity and TLT provided long term treasury exposure. The reason to have a target date portfolio is so that it is automatically readjusted over time to reduce risk (at the cost of expected return). Opinions The first change I would want to make here is to see a lower expense ratio and a dramatically simplified portfolio of holdings. There is no need for a large complicated portfolio. To drive annualized volatility down while using Fidelity funds, I would favor using the Spartan ® Long-Term Treasury Bond Index Fund – Fidelity Advantage Class (MUTF: FLBAX ). The fund has a very high weighted average maturity (around 25 years), over 99% of the portfolio is in treasury securities (low credit risk), and an expense ratio of only .1%. That is a good solid mutual fund and using it in a target date portfolio fund with regular rebalancing allows investors to automatically take advantage of the negative correlation that long term treasuries have with the domestic equity market. Conclusion When an investor takes on an expense ratio that is even .3% higher and pays that ratio for 20 years, they are looking at losing 6% of the value of the portfolio without accounting for compounding. If investors account for the benefits of compounding and assume annual returns are positive, the potential value lost is even greater than 6%. FFFDX is an expensive option for investors looking for a simple “set it and forget it” retirement plan from their employer sponsored retirement accounts. The volatility of the fund is not a problem and the total exposures are not unreasonable. The problem comes down to two issues. One is that the fund has needlessly complicated the portfolio holdings and the other is that the expense ratio is simply too high when compared to similar products offered by competitors. There are some great funds offered by Fidelity and I have positions in a few of them. Unfortunately, this fund just falls short of the mark. Disclosure: I am/we are long FSTVX. (More…) I wrote this article myself, and it expresses my own opinions. I am not receiving compensation for it (other than from Seeking Alpha). I have no business relationship with any company whose stock is mentioned in this article. Additional disclosure: Information in this article represents the opinion of the analyst. All statements are represented as opinions, rather than facts, and should not be construed as advice to buy or sell a security. Ratings of “outperform” and “underperform” reflect the analyst’s estimation of a divergence between the market value for a security and the price that would be appropriate given the potential for risks and returns relative to other securities. The analyst does not know your particular objectives for returns or constraints upon investing. All investors are encouraged to do their own research before making any investment decision. Information is regularly obtained from Yahoo Finance, Google Finance, and SEC Database. If Yahoo, Google, or the SEC database contained faulty or old information it could be incorporated into my analysis.