Tag Archives: ideas

The Active Share Debate: AQR Versus The Academics

By Jack Vogel, Ph.D. There is an interesting discussion in the geeky world of academic finance literature between the intellectual muscle at AQR and academia. The discussion revolves around the following question: ” Does Active Share matter? ” This is an important topic for active ETFs and Mutual Funds in the marketplace. The original paper on this measure was written by Cremers and Petajisto and was published in the Review of Financial Studies in 2009 (top finance journal). Links to the paper can be found here and here . The abstract of the paper is the following: We introduce a new measure of active portfolio management, Active Share, which represents the share of portfolio holdings that differ from the benchmark index holdings. We compute Active Share for domestic equity mutual funds from 1980 to 2003. We relate Active Share to fund characteristics such as size, expenses, and turnover in the cross-section, and we also examine its evolution over time. Active Share predicts fund performance : funds with the highest Active Share significantly outperform their benchmarks, both before and after expenses, and they exhibit strong performance persistence. Nonindex funds with the lowest Active Share underperform their benchmarks. Main Finding of the paper: For non-index funds, the higher the active share, the better the performance. We tend to agree, as we have talked about diworsification in the past. However, just because a manager creates a more active portfolio (a necessary condition for outperformance ), this doesn’t imply an active manager will actually have outperformance. The team at AQR (Frazzini, Friedman, and Pomorski), in a forthcoming article in the Financial Analyst Journal (link to the paper is here ), address this question. The abstract is the following: We investigate Active Share, a measure meant to determine the level of active management in investment portfolios. Using the same sample as Cremers and Petajisto (2009) and Petajisto (2013) we find that Active Share correlates with benchmark returns, but does not predict actual fund returns ; within individual benchmarks, it is as likely to correlate positively with performance as it is to correlate negatively. Our findings do not support an emphasis on Active Share as a manager selection tool or an appropriate guideline for institutional portfolios. Main point of the paper: Active share should not be used as a manager selection tool. Basically, for a given index, they find that active share cannot be used as a reliable tool to identify out-performance. So is Active Share a waste of time? As Lee Corso says every Saturday morning during College Gameday, “Not so fast!” The two authors of the original paper, Martijn Cremers and Antti Petajisto were quick to shoot down the AQR findings. Here is the executive summary from Antti Petajisto: All of the key claims of AQR’s paper were already addressed in the two cited Active Share papers: Petajisto (2013) and Cremers and Petajisto (2009). 1) The fact about the level of Active Share varying across benchmarks has been widely known for many years. Its performance impact was explicitly studied and discussed in the first drafts of Petajisto (2013) back in 2010, and the performance results remained broadly similar. The reason for the apparent discrepancy is AQR’s choice of summarizing results by benchmark, which effectively gives the same weight to the most popular index (S&P 500, assigned to 870 funds) and the least popular index (Russell 3000 Growth, assigned to 24 funds), which is not sensible as a statistical approach. 2) The issue about four-factor alphas varying across benchmark indices does nothing to change the fact that higher Active Share managers have been able to beat their benchmark indices. However, it does raise an interesting point about the four-factor approach to measuring performance, and in fact my coauthors and I wrote a long and detailed paper about this exact issue first in 2007 (published later as Cremers, Petajisto, and Zitzewitz (2013)). 3) AQR’s researchers argue that there is no theory behind Active Share and they remain mystified by the differences between Active Share and tracking error. It is unfortunate that they have entirely missed the lengthy sections of both Active Share papers that discuss this exact topic: pages 74-77 in Petajisto (2013) and sections 1.3, 3.1, and 4.1 in Cremers and Petajisto (2009). The short answer is that Active Share is more about stock selection, whereas tracking error is more about exposure to systematic risk factors. So clearly ignoring large and essential parts of the original Active Share papers is simply not the way to conduct impartial scientific inquiry. If that executive summary wasn’t scathing enough, Martijn Cremers actually wrote a paper titled ” AQR in Wonderland: Down the Rabbit Hole of ‘Deactivating Active Share’ (and Back Out Again?) ” Here is the abstract: The April 2015 paper “Deactivating Active Share”, released by AQR Capital Management, aims to debunk the claim that Active Share (a measure of active management) predicts investment performance. The claim of the AQR paper is that “neither theory nor data justify the expectation that Active Share might help investors improve their returns,” arguing that previous results are “entirely driven by the strong correlation between Active Share and the benchmark type.” This paper’s first and main aim is to establish that the AQR paper should not be interpreted using typical academic standards. Instead, our conjecture is that this AQR paper falls into a wonderfully creative but altogether different genre, which we label the Wonderland Genre, as its main characteristic seems to be “Sentence First, Verdict Later.” For example, the results in the AQR-WP cannot be taken at face value, as the information that is not shared reverses their main conclusion. Secondarily, we consider the plausible claim that benchmark styles matter and find that controlling for the main benchmark style, the predictability of Active Share is robust. While Active Share is only one tool among many to analyze investment funds and needs to be carefully interpreted for each fund individually, Active Share may indeed plausibly help investors improve their returns. Thirdly and finally, we impolitely consider why AQR may not be a big fan of Active Share by taking a look at the AQR mutual funds offered to retail investors. We find that these tend to have relatively low Active Shares, have shown little outperformance to date (with performance data ending in 2014) and thus seem fairly expensive given the amount of differentiation they offer. So who is the winner in the debate? The answer is both are probably correct at some level. More concentration (less diworsification) probably has higher active share and in the past had higher returns. However, one cannot just take any random selection of stocks and expect to outperform, the style of the investment matters, which was AQR’s argument (we prefer Value and Momentum ). Let us know what you think! Link to the original post on Alpha Architect

Catalyst And 361 Capital Soft Closing Futures Funds

By DailyAlts Staff Mutual funds are closed for a variety of reasons, but the most common is probably a lack of sufficient investor interest, normally as the result of poor performance. On the opposite end of the spectrum, funds that become too popular and command too much investor interest must close themselves to new investors to avoid exceeding the maximum capacity of their strategies. This latter type of fund closing is known as a “soft closing,” and two alternative funds – the Catalyst Hedged Futures Strategy Fund (MUTF: HFXAX ) and the 361 Managed Futures Strategy Fund (MUTF: AMFZX ) – recently joined the ranks of funds that have gotten too popular to continue taking investors’ money. Catalyst Hedged Futures Strategy Fund The $1.6 billion Catalyst Hedge Futures Strategy Fund debuted as a private fund way back in 2005 and was subsequently converted to a mutual fund by Catalyst in August 2013. As of August 31, the fund’s year-to-date returns of 7.61% ranked in the top 10% of funds in the Morningstar Managed Futures category, and the fund has shone particularly bright over the past six months, generating gains while most of its peers were in the red. Undoubtedly, this stellar performance contributed to increased interest in the fund, which Catalyst says is “rapidly approaching capacity.” As a result, the Catalyst Hedged Futures Fund will be closed to new investors starting October 31, 2015. Closing the fund will help Catalyst “maintain the integrity of the strategy” and not sacrifice performance, according to a statement. The fund’s existing shareholders – and possibly advisors – will be “grandfathered in” and allowed to add more money to the fund, while prospective new shareholders will have to wait for a “Part 2” version of the fund, set to be ready “in the coming weeks.” The “Part 2” fund will pursue a very similar strategy to the original fund, which distinguished itself from other managed futures funds by being 100% options-based. The new fund will be of interest to investors concerned about a repeat of the 2008 financial crisis, as the original Catalyst Hedged Futures Fund gained nearly 50% during that period, thanks to its virtually nonexistent correlation to stocks and bonds. For more information, visit catalystmutualfunds.com . 361 Managed Futures Strategy Fund Investors interested in gaining exposure to managed futures via the 361 Managed Futures Strategy Fund , which returned 7.87% in the first eight months of 2015 and ranked in the top 8% of funds in its Morningstar category, have until September 30 to jump on board – after that date, the fund will cease taking money from new investors. “Since our founding in 2001, we’ve endeavored to be excellent stewards of our clients’ capital,” said 361 Captial CEO Tom Florence, in a recent announcement. “With that in mind, we’ve put forth great effort into measuring the capacity of our strategies, in order to ensure that asset growth doesn’t degrade return potential.” Like the Catalyst Hedged Futures Strategy Fund, the 361 Managed Futures Strategy Fund will remain open to existing investors. The fund had just over $1 billion in assets under management as of September 8, and the 361 investment team feels that a “soft close” allows capacity for existing clients, but keeping the fund open for new investors would risk hampering performance. One of the features that makes the 361 Managed Futures Strategy Fund so attractive is the low correlation it has exhibited to major asset classes. According to 361 Capital, the fund has had negative correlations to foreign (-0.07) and domestic equities (-0.15), and very low correlations to bonds (0.22), real assets (0.05), and even other managed futures strategies (0.10), from its December 2011 inception through June 30, 2015. For more information, visit the fund page at 361 Capital . Past performance is not necessarily indicative of future performance.

We Have Heard This Message For A Long Time: Solomon, The Talmud, Diversification And Cash

Summary The investment community is divided on the importance of cash. This piece shows that it was very important for some ancient people. While there are references in the Bible regarding investing, there is scant advice on how to invest. The Talmud does offer investing advice, and this piece will show you how to use it, and how it performs. Biblical Diversification One of my passions has always been faith based investing, and using ancient texts to guide one’s money decisions. Jesus talked about money more than anything, except the kingdom of God. There are 101 verses in Proverbs about money, and there are many more in the Old Testamant. I have written about these topics before, but sometimes one should take another look at things to see if they still hold true. There is one, I specifically on which I want to focus. It is found in Ecclesiastes (11:1-6), and it comes from Solomon: “Ship your grain across the sea; after many days you may receive a return. Invest in seven ventures, yes, in eight; you do not know what disaster may come upon the land. If clouds are full of water, they pour rain on the earth. Whether a tree falls to the south or to the north, in the place where it falls, there it will lie. Whoever watches the wind will not plant; whoever looks at the clouds will not reap. As you do not know the path of the wind, or how the body is formed in a mother’s womb, so you cannot understand the work of God, the Maker of all things. Sow your seed in the morning, and at evening let your hands not be idle, for you do not know which will succeed, whether this or that, or whether both will do equally well.” Simply it means: Be involved in commercial enterprise. Invest in many things (seven is a special number). You simply cannot predict what will happen. Why should one diversify? As the English proverb says, “Don’t venture all your eggs in one basket.” If one concentrates all of their investments in one asset class, it is possible the entire investment could head straight to zero. Simply, diversification helps one to avoid unsystematic risks, those that are specific to particular investment or investment class. It goes beyond that, however. Brinson, Hood and Beebower conducted a landmark study, “Determinants of Portfolio Performance,” and presented in Financial Analysts Journal (May – June, 1992) there was an update in 1996. They showed that asset allocation decisions, far more than any other factor, affected the long-term performance of an investment portfolio. In fact, Brinson and his colleagues show that asset allocation effects over 90% of a portfolio’s performance. The results are illustrated in the chart below. (click to enlarge) Asset allocation is 15 times more influential than security selection and timing. Interestingly, the financial media spends the bulk of their market news in the latter. Of course, it is doubtful one would be able to sell much ad space if the media outlet spent the bulk of its time talking about asset allocation. When I see sites like the American Association of Individual Investors recommend seven asset classes for specific portfolios, I usually have a wry smile, and wonder if that was by accident or by design. Who knows? What is interesting is that Solomon did not specifically state how to invest. In fact there is no specific advice on how to invest in the bible. Talmudic Investing Now we look at the Talmud ; “…the body of Jewish civil and ceremonial law and legend comprising the Mishnah and the Gemara.” The Talmud evolved after the destruction of the second temple, and was the recordings of discussions and debates regarding the Torah. It was an attempt by Rabbinic Jews to write the oral law; an explanation of how to live under Biblical law. It was a guidebook on how to live. As for this piece, the focus is on the Tractate Baba Mezi’a folio 42a: R. Isaac also said: One’s money should always be ready to hand, for it is written, and thou shalt bind up the money in thy hand. R. Isaac also said: One should always divide his wealth into three parts: [investing] a third in land, a third in merchandise, and [keeping] a third ready to hand. Two parts of this investing strategy are pretty obvious. First, to invest in land simply means real estate. That is understood, and there are plenty of real estate investments one can make, some are in the form of real estate investment trusts (REITs) and are traded in the stock markets. Second, investing in merchandise means to invest in business; equity investing. It is the third part to this formula where there seems to be some disagreement. Where I see some debate is defining, “…and [keeping] a third ready to hand.” There are some who feel that means to invest in short-term securities which are safe. U.S. Government bonds would fit this quite well. Taken in context, though, the previous part of the discussion is pretty clear where it says, “One’s money should always be ready to hand…and thou shalt bind up the money in the hand.” The footnote to this passage states, “And not in another man’s keeping, so that advantage can immediately be taken of a trading bargain that is available.” To some, including me, this is a pretty clear conclusion that the Rabbi was talking about cash. The approach this is pretty simple. I used the following investments to track the value of a $1 investment since 1978: Wilshire US REIT Index Wilshire 5000 Total Market Index BlackRock Ready Assets Prime Money (MUTF: MRAXX ) The investments were divided in thirds, and rebalanced every calendar year. The chart shows the results: (click to enlarge) Someone who followed this strategy since 1978 would have realized an annual return of 10.25% (±10.44%). Compared to S&P 500 annual return of 11.58%, this is a strategy that holds up nicely, especially considering that 33% is invested in a Money Market Fund. What is more relevant is that it is less volatile than the S&P (±17.32%) for the same period. Why Should One Care? Let’s think about this. Solomon warns us of that we, “…do not know the path of the wind.” Rabbi Isaac says we should keep our money close in hand, which is similar to Deuteronomy 14:25, albeit that passage was referring to tithing. The key is that rabbinical texts suggest that one keep a certain amount in cash, and it is quite a bit of money. Why? The Bible is replete with verses about not knowing what tomorrow will bring. The Old Testament brings us: ” Do not congratulate yourself about tomorrow, since you do not know what today will bring forth. ” ~Proverbs 27:1 And let’s not forget that Solomon warns, “for you do not know which will succeed, whether this or that, or whether both will do equally well.” Was this a warning that we really do not know what will happen with our investments? I say, “Yes.” While the New Testament (albeit not part of the rabbinical text) tells us” ” You never know what will happen tomorrow: you are no more than a mist that appears for a little while and then disappears. ” ~James 14:4 This is just a theory, but I am willing to say that the Rabbi knew one should keep cash because of an uncertain future, and uncertain results. While the financial community is fairly split down in the middle when it comes to cash, it is important to keep a reserve so one can take advantage of opportunities. If one is fully invested, there is no way to buy new securities on the cheap without selling something; thus incurring a commissionable event. Remember the footnote, “so that advantage can immediately be taken of a trading bargain that is available.” One has to have cash on hand to take advantage of opportunities. During this downturn, one is unable to buy the stocks that just went on sale if all of their assets are otherwise invested already. Some proponents of modern asset allocation go as far as to suggest holding up to 15% in cash and its equivalents in a conservative portfolio. If 15% is considered conservative, then 33% would considered ultra conservative. Does this approach work? It depends on what one wants. If one wants to be fully invested in the stock market, that portfolio would yield a full 190% better result than the cash heavy Talmud portfolio over a 20 year period. One should remember, though, that same approach would have suffered a 37% loss in 2008 with no opportunity to respond. Meanwhile the Talmud portfolio would have only lost 24% in 2008, but still leave one with the ability to buy beaten down securities. It is really up to one’s personal psychology to decide. Conclusion I have often said that one should give up beating market averages . Investing is more about psychology, than one realizes. If sudden downturns force one to abandon a plan, then it is not a very good plan. If downside deviation keeps one awake at night, then one should consider a different approach; this is one that does work. It beats the two benchmarks that matter for most investors; zero and inflation. If one is looking for index funds for the Wilshire 5000 and REIT investments, consider BlackRock’s Total Stock Market Index (MUTF: BKTSX ) and BlackRock Real Estate Securities (MUTF: BCREX ) funds. Matching those with the previously mentioned money market fund, and one will have a nice three pack of mutual funds that will deliver over time. Happy Investing! Disclosure: I/we have no positions in any stocks mentioned, and no plans to initiate any positions within the next 72 hours. (More…) I wrote this article myself, and it expresses my own opinions. I am not receiving compensation for it (other than from Seeking Alpha). I have no business relationship with any company whose stock is mentioned in this article.