Tag Archives: ideas

A Third Way: Quantitative Multi-Factor Investing Explained

Summary Factors are observable and quantifiable firm-level characteristics that can explain differences in stock returns. Factor-based investing involves building portfolios with exposures to certain factors that may compensate investors with excess. Multi-factor investing have distinct advantages for long-term investors over both passive indexing and traditional active management. Building a factor-based strategy and optimizing the factor mix is quite complex. I regard some of my success in investment management as stemming from the serendipity of graduating from college and founding Gerstein Fisher in the same year that William Sharpe, as well as Eugene Fama and Ken French, published two seminal papers that gave rise to quantitative multi-factor investing.[1] What’s more, dramatic advances in computing power at that time (the early 1990s) were enabling quantitative investment managers to organize and analyze vast amounts of information to construct factor-based investment strategies in a highly disciplined and mathematical fashion. Gerstein Fisher did not invent factor-based investing, but we were among the first to translate academic theory into practical solutions for investors via multi-factor strategies. Not surprisingly, I am a passionate believer that quantitative multi-factor investing-which I might call a third way of investing-has distinct potential advantages for long-term investors over both passive indexing and traditional active investing. But I’m also aware that factor investing is less familiar and may seem opaque to some investors. For this reason, with this entry I am inaugurating a comprehensive, multi-part series on multi-factor investing that can serve as a primer to equip readers with a greater understanding of this exciting and rapidly evolving field. So let’s get started. Compensated Risks First, what is a factor? Factors are observable and quantifiable firm-level characteristics that can explain differences in stock returns. A large body of academic research[2] demonstrates that over the long term, returns of an equity portfolio can almost entirely be explained through the lens of these investment factors (some factor examples are value and momentum). Andrew Ang, a finance professor at Columbia University, has an insightful analogy to help explain factors: factors are to investment assets as nutrients are to food.[3] For example, much as we eat foods for their underlying nutrients-soy beans for protein, nuts for healthy oils, grains for fiber-to the quantitative investment manager it’s the investment factors that compose the assets that really matter, not the assets themselves. Just as foods are bundles of nutrients, securities are bundles of factors. Compelling and successfully implemented factors typically share the following characteristics: Abundant academic evidence and a strong theory based on financial or economic logic for why it works (i.e., empirical evidence alone is insufficient) and is expected to work in the future. The theory may be risk-based, behaviorally based, or a combination of both. Can explain differences in returns in different industries, countries, and markets over long time periods. Able to be implemented in liquid, tradable securities. Exhibit 1 names and briefly describes eight distinct, important investment factors. (Note that this is hardly an exhaustive list, but encompasses some commonly researched and implemented factors.) (click to enlarge) Factor-based investing involves building portfolios with deliberate exposures, or tilts, to certain factors, or risks, that research has shown compensate patient investors with excess returns (relative to the relevant benchmark) over the long run, and tilting away from uncompensated risk factors. For example, in Gerstein Fisher’s domestic Multi-Factor® Growth Equity strategy we maintain a positive tilt to the profitability and momentum factors (versus the Russell 3000 Growth Index), but negative exposure to capital expenditures and the fastest-growing small companies. Information from both company fundamentals and market prices are used to calculate numerous factor scores for each company (each security has characteristics that make it different from the profile of the market average). Exhibit 2 compares actual scores for two companies. Interestingly, the scores (for just seven of many factors) and compounded returns are remarkably similar despite the fact that the securities are in entirely different industries. (click to enlarge) Harvesting Factors Conceptually, a multi-factor strategy seeks to generate superior long-term risk-adjusted returns relative to a benchmark by collecting risk premiums in a systematic, targeted way through strategic tilts toward securities with desirable factor exposures. Much as equity investors have collected an annual risk premium of 6.6% historically for putting money into volatile stocks rather than into virtually risk-free Treasury bills[4], factor-oriented investors seek to collect factor premiums as a reward for holding factors through the bad times (remember that risk and return are related). By contrast, we can say that an investor who holds a passive market index collects no factor risk premiums. Actively managed funds, with which most readers are quite conversant, deviate from the benchmark but they have different issues. Many studies by academics, ourselves and others have repeatedly demonstrated that, after fees, the majority of active funds struggle even to match their benchmarks’ returns over extended time periods, and that the likelihood of past outperformance persisting into the future is low.[5] Exhibit 3 summarizes several of the key differences between the quantitative multi-factor and active approaches. (click to enlarge) Before I close, I would like to stress that building a factor-based strategy is far more complex than simply identifying and tilting towards factors that have been academically shown to reward over long market periods. One of the great challenges in building a multi-factor portfolio is how to combine factors in an intelligent, efficient way that works for investors-in other words, how to take academic research and make it work in the real world. I will devote an entire column to the important topic of how we combine factors later in the series, but here I do at least want to explain why we combine factors. Recall from above that factor-based investors seek to be rewarded with a risk premium for sitting tight through the bad times. While factor indexes have exhibited excess risk-adjusted returns over long time periods, as with asset class indexes they all have cycles and periods of underperformance. But since different factors have distinct performance patterns and cycles and are relatively uncorrelated over time (i.e., while some will be performing well, others will be doing poorly), a manager can combine factors to build a more- diversified portfolio with better risk-adjusted returns that potentially provides a smoother ride for long-term investors (Exhibit 4 illustrates the historical cycles of two important factors). Now, how to optimize that factor mix is a science unto itself, but that is a subject for a future article. (click to enlarge) In the next installment in this series, I will trace the history and evolution of several important investment factors. Conclusion Multi-factor investing can be thought of as a third way to invest with distinct advantages for long-term investors over both passive indexing and traditional active management, which are generally better understood by investors. This is the first in a series of educational articles that should help investors to acquire a sound understanding of the relatively modern and fast-evolving field of quantitative multi-factor investing. [1] Asset Allocation: Management Style and Performance Measurement (1992) by William F. Sharpe The Cross-Section of Expected Stock Returns (1992) by Eugene F. Fama and Kenneth R. French [2] See for example: Ang, A., W.N. Goetzmann, and S. Schaefer, 2009, Evaluation of Active Management of the Norwegian Government Pension fund-Global, Report to the Norwegian Ministry of Finance [3] Asset Management: A Systematic Approach to Factor Investing by Andrew Ang, Oxford Univ. Press, 2014 [4] During the period from January 1926 to August 2015 (Source: Bloomberg) [5] See for example ” In Mutual Funds, is Active vs. Passive the Right Question? ” and ” Should You Bet Your Future on a Manager’s Past Performance? ”

2 Better Ways To Play Chinese Growth

The WSJ recently featured an article about the silver lining in Chinese growth. Even though the GDP growth rate had fallen below 7% to 6.9%, there was evidence of rebalancing away from the same old, same old lending-based model of infrastructure spending to the household sector (emphasis added) : There is robust growth in China if you know where to look, some contrarian investors believe. Monday’s gross domestic product report offered the latest sign that the world’s second-largest economy is slowing. But the gloom is overdone, said some portfolio managers who are focusing on the nation’s booming service sector: Their purchases amount to a bet on Beijing’s efforts to engineer an economic rebalancing, toward a consumer-led, service-driven economy from one dominated by manufacturing and trade. While slowing Chinese economic growth and declines in the country’s use of materials such as copper, nickel and cement have rippled through financial markets, some traders say some less-publicized metrics paint a more upbeat picture. To name a few, box-office sales are up more than 50% this year, Internet traffic through mobile devices has nearly doubled and railway passenger traffic and civil aviation are increasing steadily, government data show. The most recent numbers highlighted the Chinese economy’s increasingly dual nature. China reported its economy expanded at a 6.9% annual rate in the third quarter, its slowest pace since the global financial crisis. At the same time, the services sector expanded 8.4%, accounting for more than half of China’s GDP growth for the first time , according to official statistics. For years, US investors have either bought FXI or commodity-related vehicles as a way to play Chinese growth. Now that there is growing evidence of growth rebalancing, those vehicles may not be the most appropriate anymore. Consider this chart of two “New China” versus “Old China” pairs. (click to enlarge) The first is a long position in PGJ (NASDAQ Golden Dragon Index) versus a short position in FXI (FTSE China 50), which is depicted in black. The Golden Dragon Index is far more heavily weighted in consumer services and technology, which are also consumer e-commerce oriented (think Baidu (NASDAQ: BIDU ), etc.), while the FTSE China 50 Index is tilted towards financials, which represent “Old China” finance and infrastructure plays. The second pair is a long position in the Global X China Consumer ETF (NYSEARCA: CHIQ ) and a short position in the Global X China Financials ETF (NYSEARCA: CHIX ), depicted in green. In both cases, these pairs tell the story of progress of growth rebalancing towards the consumer sector of the economy. Even if you don’t want exposure to China, monitoring these pairs is a useful way of seeing how rebalancing is progressing in real time. Disclaimer: The opinions and any recommendations expressed in this blog are solely those of the author. None of the information or opinions expressed in this blog constitutes a solicitation for the purchase or sale of any security or other instrument. Nothing in this article constitutes investment advice and any recommendations that may be contained herein have not been based upon a consideration of the investment objectives, financial situation or particular needs of any specific recipient. Any purchase or sale activity in any securities or other instrument should be based upon your own analysis and conclusions. Past performance is not indicative of future results. Mr. Hui may hold or control long or short positions in the securities or instruments mentioned.

S&P 500 ETFs Vs. Ex-Sector ETFs

The replication of the broader U.S. market – the S&P 500 index – may be surging lately on Fed-induced optimism, but on the year-to-date frame it is still a laggard (as of October 15, 2015), having slid about 1.6%. Relentless global growth worries, be it over China, Europe, Japan or the emerging market block, and occasional issues in some specific corners of the domestic market hit the index hard this year. Even if the market rebounds in the final quarter of the year on hopes of persistent inflows of cheap dollar from the Fed, cheaper valuation and the seasonal tailwind of the all-important holiday season, the odds are not out of the way. After all, the S&P 500 index is made up of large-cap stocks which are largely tied to the global perspective. This is where the idea of the Ex-Industry S&P 500 ETFs launched by ProShares comes from. As of now, ProShares has four ETFs, namely the ProShares S&P 500 Ex-Financial ETF (NYSEARCA: SPXN ), the ProShares S&P 500 Ex-Health Care ETF (NYSEARCA: SPXV ), the ProShares S&P 500 Ex-Technology ETF (NYSEARCA: SPXT ) and the ProShares S&P 500 Ex-Energy ETF (NYSEARCA: SPXE ). As the names suggest, all these ETFs provide exposure to the companies of the S&P 500, with the exception of those companies included in the financial, healthcare, technology and energy sectors, respectively. How Do These Fit in a Portfolio? Notably, Financials, Medical, Technology and Energy account for about 20.7%, 13.7%, 20.6% and 4.1% of the S&P 500 index, respectively. So, if a particular sector is underperforming at a given period of time, investors can easily chuck that out from the broader S&P 500 index by investing in that ex-sector ETF. What could be a better example than the energy sector, which has been a pain for the last one and a half year in the marketplace, and is still not showing any definite sign of a recovery anytime soon? In such a situation, an ex-energy S&P 500 ETF – SPXE – could an intriguing pick. The technique is equally gainful even at the time of short-selling. If a sector is outperforming the broader market, investors can easily short-sell that particular ex-industry ETF and earn smart gains. The aforementioned sectors outperformed/underperformed the broader market index this year and in previous years as well by a wide margin. The chart below can be used to understand the trend: ETFs YTD Return 1-Year Return 5-Year Return Financial Select Sector SPDR ETF (NYSEARCA: XLF ) -5.34% 5% 60.3% Energy Select Sector SPDR ETF (NYSEARCA: XLE ) -12.7% -16.4% 16.6% Technology Select Sector SPDR ETF (NYSEARCA: XLK ) 1.3% 11.2% 73.8% Health Care Select Sector SPDR ETF (NYSEARCA: XLV ) 1.1% 13% 121.4% SPDR S&P 500 Trust ETF (NYSEARCA: SPY ) -1.6% 7.3% 71% Moreover, the issuer noted that investors might have enough sector exposure from the other holdings, and so, could be intrigued by an ex-sector ETF. Below, we highlight the concerned ETFs in detail so that investors can get a fair idea of which ex-sector ETF can emerge as a game changer and when. As far as competition goes, the newly launched funds should receive their share of success ahead, given that their underlying idea is novel. SPY in Focus This most popular ETF with $131 billion of assets charges 9 bps in fees. IT (20.6%), Financials (16.1%), Healthcare (14.4%), Consumer Discretionary (13%) and Industrials (10.2%) get doubt-digit exposure in it. Energy has a relatively low exposure of 7.4% in the fund. SPXN in Focus This new 441-stock fund charges 27 bps in fees and has amassed about $4.1 million of assets, having debuted in late September. IT (24%), Healthcare (18.3%), Consumer Discretionary (15.5%), Industrials (11.9%) and Consumer Staples (11.6%) are the top sectors with double-digit weight. The product has a P/E ratio of 23.59 times. Given the low interest rate environment and the potential pressure on the financial companies’ net interest margin, some investors might choose to pick this fund at the current level. SPXV in Focus This 446-stock fund also has $4 million in assets. Here, IT (23.6%), Financials (19.6%), Consumer Discretionary (15.2%), Industrials (11.7%) and Consumer Staples (11.4%) get doubt-digit exposure. The product has a P/E ratio of 20.50 times. Occasional sell-offs in healthcare stocks on overvaluation and pricing issues can be opportune times for this fund. SPXT in Focus This 428-stock fund has a P/E of 22.10 times. Financials (21.5%), Healthcare (19.7%), Consumer Discretionary (16.6%), Industrials (12.8%) and Consumer Staples (12.5%) get doubt-digit exposure in the fund. While the technology sector saw great momentum lately, this high-growth sector normally succumb to a slowdown if global growth concerns flare up or a flight-to-safety trend sets up. SPXT can be an answer to these sector-specific tough times. SPXE in Focus This 462-stock ETF has a P/E of 22.01 times. IT (21.6%), Financials (18%), Healthcare (16.4%), Consumer Discretionary (13.9%) and Industrials (10.7%) get doubt-digit exposure in it. This should be the most-eyed fund now, given the relentless energy price slump. Original Post