Tag Archives: ideas

A Critic Of Valuation-Informed Indexing Offers A Concise Case For Why Buy And Hold Is Superior

By Rob Bennett There’s only one difference between Buy and Hold and Valuation-Informed Indexing. Both are numbers-based strategies rooted in peer-reviewed research. The difference is that Valuation-Informed Indexers always make adjustments for valuation levels (believing, as Shiller showed in 1981, that valuations affect long-term returns) while Buy and Holders never do (believing that the market is efficient and that, thus, the market can never be overpriced or underpriced). I thought that this week I would present here a concise and clear and simple and sincere case for Buy and Hold that one of my critics posted as a comment at my site. Then I’ll offer my response to his words. To me, as a self-described ACTUAL Buy-n-holder, it’s this simple: Markets tend to go up over time. Ownership of common stocks have proven to be the best way for an average person to participate in, and profit from this ongoing economic growth. It has proven impossible to determine which particular stocks will outperform, or when they might do so. Buying, and then holding a market basket of ALL stocks that constitute the market, on a regular and recurring basis, without respect to ‘timing’, removes the uncertainty of guessing which particular stocks will be best, or which is the best time to purchase them. That’s it. People can refine, add gimmicks, accessories, etc., or even purposefully misconstrue (AHEM, looking at YOU, Rob!) but to me, THIS is the essence of buying and holding. So, for you to go on a decades long intense daily public jihad against those principles, and the people who espouse, and apply them, seems frankly… well, insane. You are free to use whatever market timing scheme, or other method you chose to invest, or course. But for you to characterize the above technique as “Get Rich Quick,” just to irk people and to hopefully draw attention to yourself, shows how both intellectually feeble, and also morally challenged you are. (I dare you to publish this.) Is it a “gimmick” to consider valuations when making decisions as to what stock allocation to go with at a particular time? I don’t think so. The research shows that the long-term return earned by an investor changes with changes in valuations. That means that stock investing risk is variable rather than constant. It follows that an investor seeking to keep his risk profile roughly constant MUST change his stock allocation in response to big valuation shifts. Why do the Buy-and-Holders have such a hard time with this idea? It’s because they start with an assumption that the market is efficient. That’s another way of saying that the investors who set the market price are rational. Is it? Are they? I don’t think so. I have engaged in discussions with tens of thousands of investors over the years. I certainly have seen many rational arguments advanced. But I have also seen many emotional arguments advanced. If investors are as emotional when making decisions as to their stock allocations as they are when presenting arguments on internet discussion boards, I think it would be fair to say that it would be dangerous to assume that the stock market is priced rationally. That said, I believe that the market in the long term really does set prices properly. It has to. The purpose of a market is to get prices right. In the long term, the stock market is like all other markets. But in the short term, it is not. That makes all the difference. Take a look at the disparity between the irrational price that applies today and the rational price that applies in the long term and you know in which direction prices will be headed over the next 10 years or so. It always works. We have 145 years of stock market history available to us. For that entire time period, investors have been able to effectively predict the price that will apply in 10 years by looking at the price that applies today. That’s amazing. That changes our understanding of how stock investing works in a far-reaching way. It means that, when prices go up by more than the 6.5 percent gain justified by the economic realities, we are collectively borrowing from our future selves to fool ourselves into thinking that we are richer than we really are today. That causes devastating problems down the line. Investors cannot plan their financial futures effectively if they believe numbers on their portfolio statements that do not reflect the long-term realities. And the bear market that must follow a bull market causes an economic crisis as trillions of dollars in pretend wealth disappears, causing hundreds of thousands of businesses to fail and millions of workers to lose their jobs. For numbers-based strategies to work, it is critical that we get the numbers right. And, if Shiller is right that valuations affect long-term returns, it is impossible for Buy-and-Holders – who do not make adjustments for valuations – to get any of the numbers right. The valuations factor is not a small factor. It is huge. A regression analysis of the historical data shows that the most likely annualized 10-year return in 1982 was 15 percent real but that the same number was a negative 1 percent in 2000. Yowsa! The bad news is that it is very hard for Buy-and-Holders to accept these realities. They have staked their lives on the old understanding of how stock investing works. The good news is that Shiller’s “revolutionary” (his word) findings change things in a highly positive way. If we can effectively predict long-term stock returns, stocks are not nearly as risky an asset class as we have long believed them to be. Perhaps I am wrong. But, if I am right, the future of stock investing will be a lot better for all of us than anything that we have seen or even dared to hope for in the past. Disclosure: None.

Don’t Bother With Small-Cap Growth ETFs – Invest In The Internet Instead

Summary I compared a highly diversified small-cap ETF with an Internet-based ETF. The Internet has not finished permeating our lives, yet we have no need to fear another Internet stock bubble. Going forward, a portfolio or ETF of Internet stocks should outperform both the market and small-cap growth stocks. Source: Wikipedia Commons Through my daily random analyses of stock prices, correlations, and whatnot with R software, I occasionally find something interesting. I especially enjoy looking for patterns in ETFs, as such patterns can give us an idea of where the economy is at and headed. Today I was looking at how Internet-based companies have performed in respect to other industries. Let’s start with the facts: Some investors like small-cap stocks in developed countries because of the huge upside associated with growing companies. Small-cap stocks of developed countries grow in strong economies with few restrictions on business. This makes them good stocks for speculation and for diversification into the “growth stock” sector. However, in these countries, many small-cap companies are heavily reliant on the Internet to run their businesses. In contrast to large-cap stocks that began prior to the time of the Internet, many of these small-cap companies would likely go under if they lost the power of the Internet to transcend geographics, save on communication costs, and monitor the habits and demographics of their clients. When I began looking into the correlation between Internet-based companies and small-cap stocks I found – unsurprisingly – that said correlation was quite high. Of course, not all small-cap stocks are Internet companies. However enough are to show a strong correlation between the two industries. In my analysis, I looked at the following ETFs: PowerShares NASDAQ Internet ETF (NASDAQ: PNQI ) iShares MSCI EAFE Small-Cap (NYSEARCA: SCZ ) The first is a portfolio of NASDAQ Internet companies. The included companies are large-cap growth stocks. The second is a portfolio of small-cap companies in developed countries, mainly the Europe and Japan. After importing the data from these two ETFs, I checked the correlation coefficient: an astounding 0.97! Yes, some of this correlation is due to an overall correlation with the general market, but below I’ll be showing some charts that show how these two ETFs differ from the market as a whole. Also realize that these portfolios have little overlap in actual securities: One is U.S.-centric (over 80%); the holds less than 1% of U.S. stocks. One is small-cap; the other large-cap. One is growth-only; the other mixes in some value stocks (I’m speaking of SCZ). Yet these two ETFs are almost perfectly correlated! It’s as if the NASDAQ Internet companies are working in tandem with small-cap companies. Or perhaps small-cap companies are gaining their business from NASDAQ Internet companies? Instead of speculating, let’s take a look at how the stocks move in respect to each other. I want to do this for multiple periods. I’ll explain why in a second: The Past Year: (click to enlarge) When you look at the first chart, it looks like PNQI and SCZ are pretty similar. It might appear that PNQI has done better in the past few months. But overall, these two ETFs look like the perform roughly at the same quality. Since the Existence of Both ETFs: (click to enlarge) Now we see a significant difference. Though these two ETFs are highly correlated, PNQI outperforms SCZ. That is, if you switched out small-cap growth stocks for large-cap Internet companies, you’d have realized a gain of over 200%. Sticking with the small-cap “growth” stocks, which are supposed to outperform during a bull market (the time period we are currently looking at), you would have underperformed – the SPDR S&P 500 ETF (NYSEARCA: SPY ), during this time, realized gains of 50%, while SCZ only grew 10%. The Past 3 Months: (click to enlarge) So here’s where things get interesting. While the previous two charts showed PNQI to be the better choice, in this chart, we see SCZ higher than PNQI. Notice that both these ETFs are in negative territory, so one explanation might be that PNQI is a risky ETF. However, to say that PNQI is risky simply not true, unless you believe that SPY is risky: both ETFs are down 4% in the past three months. Yet as we have seen in the chart going back to 2008, PNQI has outperformed SPY by 150%. That is, PNQI appears to have much more upside than both SCZ and SPY yet the downside is the same as that of SPY. Is SCZ an Outlier? To check if SCZ is an outlier, I checked other EAFE funds’ correlations to both SCZ and PNQI. The quick answer is that SCZ is not an outlier; the result holds for other EAFE small-cap and growth funds. For instance, SCZ and the iShares MSCI EAFE Growth ETF (NYSEARCA: EFG ) are 99% correlated. EFG is also 94% correlated with PNQI, showing a unique connection with EAFE small cap companies and Internet companies. Likewise, Vanguard MSCI EAFE ETF (NYSEARCA: VEA ) shows 0.99 and 0.94 correlations to SCZ and PNQI, respectively. The Future of Internet Companies The Internet bubble of the 90s taught us to be weary of investing too much in Internet-based companies. But unlike other bubbles (e.g., the housing bubble), we were dealing with a new invention in the 90s (Internet-based business). Today, we have a much better understanding of how Internet companies work. Thus, I don’t see PNQI’s extreme returns as a bubble but as the result of a legitimately good business model: putting your money where business is booming – online. The Internet has and will continue to permeate our lives (how are you reading this article right now?). And the last three months has shown that Internet companies don’t hurt more than the general market when a correction comes. Internet traffic is growing and bandwidth requirements are increasing for current users. One reason for this is the transition to video, which comes from two sources: A preference for consuming content in video form. A shift to streaming entertainment (e.g., Netflix (NASDAQ: NFLX ), which PNQI holds). By 2017, 70% of Internet traffic will be directed toward video, according to Cisco. The Internet is also changing how people shop. Today, consumers are using an omnichannel shopping method, which essentially means that they are browsing multiple sites at once to find the best deal. Such an activity would have been time-consuming and gas-consuming in the era where one had to drive store-to-store for price comparisons. Look at some of the holdings in PNQI to appreciate the fund’s appreciation of the growth of the omnichannel shopping preference: Amazon (NASDAQ: AMZN ) Priceline (NASDAQ: PCLN ) EBay (NASDAQ: EBAY ) Expedia (NASDAQ: EXPE ) Tripadvisor (NASDAQ: TRIP ) This is where the real growth is at. PNQI also has holdings in Chinese Internet companies, such as Baidu (NASDAQ: BIDU ), which PNQI first bought in 2008. To this, they’ve added other important Chinese Internet stocks, such as… JD.com (NASDAQ: JD ), an online “mall” for electronic products (omnichannel shopping). Ctrip.com (NASDAQ: CTRP ), an airline and hotel booking service (omnichannel shopping). NetEase (NASDAQ: NTES ), an IT company known for being the largest email service provider in China. …and anything else they can get their hands on via NASDAQ. Yet, investors looking for “growth” often turn to these investing concepts: “Invest in small-cap stocks.” “Invest in foreign countries; U.S. stocks are overpriced.” “Diversify among many growth stocks.” Investors agreeing with such statements would find SCZ the perfect ETF. SCZ does not hold more than 1% of its portfolio in a single stock – the maximum weight to any given stock is less than half a percent. And SCZ’s holdings are all over the place: Switzerland, the U.K., Japan… In contrast, PNQI attaches close to 10% of its portfolio. AMZN, PCLN, Facebook (NASDAQ: FB ), and Alphabet Inc (NASDAQ: GOOG ), all individually occupy more than 8% of the PNQI portfolio. PNQI also certainly doesn’t see U.S. stocks as overbought, as the vast majority of its portfolio is in the U.S. In other words, PNQI is virtually the antithesis of SCZ. Conclusion The two ETFs we just looked at correlate… but only one consistently outperforms. And I believe that PNQI will continue to outperform both SCZ and SPY, at least until the next big thing (can something possibly surpass the Internet?). We are not repeating the bubble of the 90s because the Internet is no longer a mere novelty but an integral part of culture in the developed world. The demand for the stocks PNQI holds will increase as long as the companies behind those stocks are continually making improvements in our lives (or finding ways to addict us to their products – FB, I’m looking at you). In addition, PNQI’s exposure to the Chinese Internet market shows a stark contrast to what I see in SCZ management sa being more of a “spray-and-pray” shotgun approach to a growth portfolio: Invest a little in everything and hope we keep attracting clients; no portfolio manager every gets fired for diversifying. I am assigning a strong buy rating for PNQI going into 2016 and an underperformer rating to SCZ. I would recommend, based on the most recent chart comparing PNQI to SCZ, that SCZ holders sell their shares now, while SCZ is above both the market and PNQI. Once sold, take the capital that was in SCZ and put it in PNQI, while it’s at a relative discount. Request a Statistical Study If you would like for me to run a statistical study on a specific aspect of a specific stock, commodity, or market, just request so in the comments section below. Alternatively, send me a message or email.

Hedging For The Next Market Correction: 5 Winning Investments And 5 Surprising Losers

Summary More market correction indicators are incoming. One method of hedging against a market correction is in choosing ETFs uncorrelated to the market. Here, we look at 10 investments that should be good hedges. Five emerge as winners while five more emerge as losers. (click to enlarge) As I run an “at least weekly” newsletter about hedging against bear markets , market corrections, and market crashes, I am often watching the leading indicators that might imply such an event in the future. My partner at Stock Barometer, Jay DeVincentis, recently sent me an email explaining that he has seen data from the ECRI and infers another correction a la last August, as in the chart above. I have also seen the bearish leading indicators on the rise through my own record. For instance, we’ve recently seen a drop in retail sales, PPI, industrial production, and job openings. I’m not exactly 100% with Jay here because from a seasonal viewpoint, we are approaching a time at which stocks tend to enter a bull market (e.g., November of a pre-election year). As you can see from the chart above, we only recently have recovered from the last correction. Some might say we still haven’t fully recovered. In a way, I wanted to wait to write this article, but the truth is: knowing this earlier is better than later. Overall, we falling economic leading indicators, weak money flow, and higher volatility, the more conservative of us should reconsider the method of hedging used in our portfolio allocation. Though the standard of “diversification” varies across investors, one rather “solid” method of choose stocks to use as hedging vehicles is tracking the correlations of said stocks to the market as a whole. In this article, I’m doing this for you, pointing out the winners as well as some stocks that many would think are winners but are actually not. Now, you just saw me mention “correlation,” which can be interpreted in several ways. In this article, my definition of correlation is – while still a objective statistical number – the variability that market movements can explained for a given stock’s variability. When I refer to a stock “uncorrelated” to the overall market, I’m using correlations of 0 to 0.3. I am purposefully ignoring negatively correlations because the purpose of this article is to inform you of some safe investments during the wait for a bear market , not investments that will fall during a bull market yet rise during a bear market. With the correlation cutoff points I’ve chosen, statistically, general market changes can only account for 10% or less of the variation in the investments I mention below that are “uncorrelated” to the general market. The other investments I mention – those that seem as if they should be uncorrelated to the market but are really not – move in ways explainable by the market to an extent of 10% to 40%. We are looking to build a portfolio – or at least section of a portfolio – that is hedged against a market correction similar to that in the graph above. For this reason, I pored over a large selection of investments, mainly tracking indices and ETFs against the S&P 500 during the period of the last market correction, using August 18 as the starting date because that was when the volume shows the beginning of the selling. What follows are winners and close-calls. Note that some of the following will seem like common sense. However, you are likely to find a few surprises. Unless otherwise mentioned, true prices or direct indexes were used to calculate correlations (e.g., the correlation with gold was calculated with historic gold prices and the correlation with treasury bonds was calculated with the ^TYX index, whereas that with municipal bond prices was calculated with the MUNI ETF and recalculated with other municipal bond ETFs to ensure the correlation). Read on: Winners Gold. Gold is falling, yes, and it might be coming back, yes… but that’s not the point here. Gold overall was uncorrelated to the market during the last market correction. Gold is still a good hedge today, even if you’re not sure where it’s headed. Invest in: the SPDR Gold Trust ETF (NYSEARCA: GLD ) or the iShares Gold Trust ETF (NYSEARCA: IAU ). Municipal Bonds: Municipal bonds often come with the benefit of allowing you to hedge against inflation (and market corrections, of course) without having to deal with federal income tax. Local governments (e.g., states) issue these bonds to fund long-term projects such as the construction of hospitals and roads. The interest rates and open interest in these instruments are unlikely to change during a market correction, and ETFs of municipal bonds seem to hold their value quite well during a bear market. This correlation was calculated using MUNI as a proxy. Invest in: the PIMCO Intermediate Municipal Bond Strategy (NYSEARCA: MUNI ) or the Market Vectors High-Yield Municipal Index ETF (NYSEARCA: HYD ) Mexican Airports: Yes, it’s weird that I’d mention this as a general area fit for hedging against a market correction, but I came across a specific stock perhaps mislabeled as an ETF. I looked into it in the same way and found it to be uncorrelated to the market during the most recent correction. The name of the stock is Grupo Aeroportuario del Pacifico (NYSE: PAC ). In a sense, it really is an ETF on Mexican airports because this company essentially owns a monopoly on airport management and development throughout Mexico. While it has a market cap of nearly $6 billion, fewer than 600 Seeking Alpha readers hold it in their portfolios. This correlation was calculated with PAC directly. Invest in: Grupo Aeroportuario del Pacifico Treasury Bonds: You can buy a treasury bond with denominations starting at $1,000. This makes them available to virtually every type of investor. Every six months, you gain a fixed interest rate. The maturity of a treasury bond tends to be long: sitting at 30 years. These long-term investments are uncorrelated with the market and stayed strong during the recent market crash. You can also gain exposure to these bonds through ETFs, such as the one I mention below. Invest in: the iShares 20+ Year Treasury Bond ETF (NYSEARCA: TLT ). Biotechnology: Strange right? Biotech stocks tend to trade on NASDAQ, which is even more volatile than the NYSE. We typically think of biotech stocks being great growth stocks during a strong economy and underperformers when the economy is hurting. But the success of the biotech industry relies more on innovation than the economy, it would appear, as per the low correlations I found. That is to say, perhaps investors realize that drugs will always be needed, even when people are afraid of spending money during a recession. The market correction didn’t seem to hurt the biotech industry much. The following ETF tracks this industry and showed to be uncorrelated with the general market during the recent correction. This correlation was calculated with IBB as a proxy. Invest in: the iShares NASDAQ Biotechnology ETF (NASDAQ: IBB ) Close Calls Here are the investments that you’d think would perform much like the investments above. I am probably not the only one surprised to find that these following investments followed the market to considerable extent during the last correction. Intermediate-Term and Short-Term Bonds: You would think that most bonds move in a similar fashion during a market correction, despite the maturity of the bond. Well, you’d be wrong. I found investment-grade bonds with shorter maturities falling during the last market correction. These bonds won’t keep you safe if we see a repeat of the August fiasco. These correlations were calculated with the ETFs as proxies. Avoid: The PIMCO Total Return ETF (NYSEARCA: BOND ) and the iShares 10+ Year Credit Bond ETF (NYSEARCA: CLY ) Base Metals: Unlike gold, base metals such as aluminum, copper, and zinc were correlated with the recent market dip. If you’re looking to invest in metals but want to avoid the falling gold and silver markets, you’re barking up the wrong tree with base metals. Avoid these. Avoid: The PowerShares DB Base Metals ETF (NYSEARCA: DBB ) Crude Oil: Yes, oil seems to be doing its own thing these days. Oil is a complex beast affected by international events and seems to have hit a bottom. But still, oil was correlated with last quarter’s market slump. So if we hit another correction and you’re thinking of “buying oil at a low,” think again. At least wait until the economy is looking up to dip your hands into oil. Avoid: The United States 12 Month Oil ETF, LP (NYSEARCA: USL ) Emerging Markets Debt: Another bond category that betrays common sense is that of emerging market debt. Though at this point in history, all stock markets are correlated to an extent, you would think foreign bonds wouldn’t have fallen the dive the US stock market took. But you’d be wrong. Bonds from emerging markets fell as well. Some investors use emerging market bonds – which tend to be more risky than US bonds for obvious reasons – as low-risk investments because they believe that bonds issued by foreign countries are uncorrelated to the US market. The recent correction shows this strategy to be incorrect. This correlation was calculated with PCY as a proxy. Avoid: The PowerShares Emerging Markets Sovereign Debt Portfolio ETF (NYSEARCA: PCY ) Corporate Bonds: Bonds issued by corporations are often looked upon as safe, especially those that are of investment grade. For hedging while still retaining aggressive growth, many investors choose these bonds over government-issued bonds because of the higher yield rate. The common believe in the investment community is that junk-grade corporate bonds correlate with the market and shouldn’t be used for hedging but that long-term investment-grade corporate bonds are perfectly fine for hedging. I found this to be false, with corporate bonds falling during the recent correction. This correlation was calculated with VCLT as a proxy. Avoid: The Vanguard Long-Term Corporate Bond Index ETF (NASDAQ: VCLT ) Example Portfolios and Their Performances So what would happen if we took these two lists and made from them two portfolios? Let’s take a look at what would have happened during the recent market correction for portfolios of the “winners” and “close calls.” And then let’s see what would happen if you built these portfolios at the beginning of the year, holding all the way to today. The Winners This portfolio consists of all the ETFs I recommended in the “Winners” section above. Again, this list is: Here is what happened during the market correction: (click to enlarge) That is, your portfolio would have trended sideways while the market itself fell 10%. And here is where you’d be if you built this portfolio at the beginning of the year: (click to enlarge) Your portfolio would have climbed 6%, while an index fund would be still recovering. The Close Calls This portfolio consists of all the ETFs we’d expect to do well in a bear market yet showed a correlation with the market during the time of the correction beginning in mid-August. This portfolio consists of all the ETFs in the “Close Calls” section above. Here is our portfolio: Here is what happened during the market correction: (click to enlarge) The close calls started dropping even before the bear market and then moved in tandem – but under – the market during the correction. And here is where you’d be if you built this portfolio at the beginning of the year: (click to enlarge) You’d still be below the market, unfortunately. I Want Your Input Obviously, I simply don’t have the time to cover every industry. While reading this article, you probably thought of at least one investment that should have gone in my “Winners” section. Let me know about it in the comments section below. Request a Statistical Study If you would like for me to run a statistical study on a specific aspect of a specific stock, commodity, or market, just request so in the comments section below. Alternatively, send me a message or email.