Tag Archives: ideas

As Oil Prices Plummet, Investors Flee Natural Resources Funds

By Patrick Keon Over the past two months, we witnessed a repeat of last summer’s oil price activity. As in 2014, prices of the U.S. and global oil benchmarks (West Texas Intermediate Crude [WTI] and Brent Crude) peaked near the end of June and then headed into decline. Last year, this resulted in seven consecutive months of negative price performance for both WTI and Brent, during which time they lost 54.9% and 57.2%, respectively. As the end of August approaches, the descent for both benchmarks has been more volatile than that in 2014; both WTI and Brent have recently traded at six-year lows, and are down roughly 36% and 30% from their highs at the end of June 2015. This slump in oil prices has impacted the performance and fund flows activity as well as the buy/sell decisions for funds in Lipper’s Global Natural Resources (GNR) Funds and Natural Resources (NR) Funds classifications. Mutual funds in the GNR and NR categories invest primarily in the equity securities of domestic and foreign companies engaged in the exploration, development, production, or distribution of natural resources (including oil, natural gas, and base minerals) and/or alternative energy sources (including solar, wind, hydro, tidal, and geothermal). For the purposes of the current discussion, we look only at those funds that invest the majority of their assets in oil companies; these types of funds account for the lion’s share of the funds in the GNR and NR classifications. Since July 2014, the returns on funds in the GNR and NR categories showed a positive correlation to the movement in oil prices. As illustrated in the table below, the average performance for GNR funds and NR funds followed the direction of WTI and Brent prices during the vast majority of the period. The only times all four groups did not move in the same direction occurred during August 2014 and May 2015. In August 2014, both NR (+3.2%) and GNR (+1.8%) experienced slight bumps when WTI (-0.4%) and Brent (-3.6%) trended downward, while in May 2015, WTI prices appreciated slightly (+1.1%) as the other groups fell off a bit. During the latest slide for WTI and Brent prices (late June through August), funds in the GNR (-24.2%) and NR (-24.5%) categories also experienced a similar sharp downward trend. There was also consistency within the universe: every fund in the two categories suffered at least a double-digit loss during this time frame. Lipper’s data indicates that a positive correlation also existed between the direction of oil prices and fund flows for the GNR and NR categories. During the most recent period in which WTI (-36%) and Brent (-30%) were both down significantly, we saw net outflows from both the fund classifications. GNR funds saw over $480 million leave their coffers, while NR funds had net negative flows of approximately $330 million. Within GNR, three funds were responsible for most of the money leaving the group. Leading the way was the T. Rowe Price New Era Fund No Load (MUTF: PRNEX ) with outflows of over $165 million, followed closely by the Prudential Jennison Natural Resources Fund B (MUTF: PRGNX ) and the Vanguard Energy Fund Inv (MUTF: VGENX ), down $146 million and $126 million, respectively. Within the NR grouping, one fund family accounted for the bulk of the net outflows: Fidelity Management & Research. Fidelity, which has six NR funds, had roughly $240 million leave during this time, with the Fidelity Select Energy Service Portfolio No Load (MUTF: FSESX ) and the Fidelity Select Natural Gas Portfolio No Load (MUTF: FSNGX ) (with net outflows of $71 million and $63 million) taking the two biggest hits. (click to enlarge) When oil prices rose this year (from the late first quarter to the late second quarter), the GNR and NR classifications both responded with overall net inflows. The NR group took in over $840 million, once again paced by the Fidelity family of funds. Fidelity accounted for $340 million in net new money total, with the Fidelity Select Energy Portfolio No Load (MUTF: FSENX ) taking in the largest chunk (+$183 million). Also contributing significantly to NR’s positive showing during this time frame was the Invesco Energy Fund Inv (MUTF: FSTEX ), which registered $118 million of positive net flows. The net flows into GNR (+$423 million) were roughly half of the NR net intake. The largest positive net flows were recorded by VGENX and the RS Global Natural Resources Fund A (MUTF: RSNRX ), at $353 million and $167 million. Of note, going against this trend was PRNEX, which posted net outflows (-$153 million) during the time of oil price appreciation to go along with its $165 million of negative flows during the current oil price decline. Focusing our scope on the changes in holdings in oil company stocks for GNR and NR funds during the current oil price slump, we see the selling was fairly concentrated within NR, but spread out among more stocks within GNR. Within the NR classification, four companies saw their net overall shares reduced by over one million shares, while this number grew to sixteen for the GNR category. The four companies within NR that experienced the most selling were Vantage Drilling (NYSEMKT: VTG ) (-27.6 million shares), BG Group Plc ( OTCQX:BRGXF ) (-3.1 million shares), Halliburton (NYSE: HAL ) (-2.7 million shares), and Weatherford International Plc (NYSE: WFT ) (-2.1 million shares). The number of shares of Vantage Drilling sold represented 8.8% of the company’s shares outstanding (SHOUT). Four funds completely sold out of Vantage, led by FSENX, which closed out an 18.1-million-share position. For the remainder of the group, the shares sold of each accounted for less than 1% of the company’s SHOUT. Weatherford’s activity was the result of four funds liquidating their positions, while BG Group had three funds close out their entire positions. We observe that for the selling within GNR, nine companies went from having a total aggregate position of over one million shares of their stock being held to being completely liquidated. The companies that had the largest positions closed out were Pacific Exploration and Production Corporation ( OTCPK:PEGFF ) (-3.9 million shares) and Brightoil Petroleum Holdings Ltd. ( OTC:BRTPF ) (-2.2 million shares). In each case for these nine stocks, one fund accounted for the entire initial position. The most widely held stocks within NR were essentially static during this period. Schlumberger (NYSE: SLB ) (11 funds) and Baker Hughes (NYSE: BHI ) (10 funds) were the most widely held within NR, and their totals did not change. The GNR classification showed a little more movement in its most widely held stocks. GNR started with five stocks being held by a double-digit number of funds: EOG Resources (NYSE: EOG ) (held by 15 funds), Cabot Oil & Gas (NYSE: COG ) (12 funds), Anadarko Petroleum (NYSE: APC ) (11 funds), Concho Resources (NYSE: CXO ) (11 funds), and Antero Resources (NYSE: AR ) (10 funds). Within this group, EOG Resources was unchanged, while Cabot Oil & Gas, Anadarko Petroleum, and Concho Resources all added one fund each to their totals. Antero Resources had three funds liquidate their positions, to reduce the funds holding Antero to seven. For Antero Resources, the Putnam Global Natural Resources Trust A (MUTF: EBERX ), the AllianzGI Global Natural Resources Fund Inst (MUTF: RGLIX ), and the Putnam Global Energy Fund A (MUTF: PGEAX ) liquidated positions of 4.9 million shares, 550,400 shares, and 353,200 shares, respectively. Oil prices as well as their impact on the performance and fund flows activity of natural resources funds warrant continued observation going forward. The glut in the oil supply does not show signs of abating anytime soon, since the U.S. and OPEC have not indicated any plans to reduce production. If this summer’s downturn in oil prices stretches out as long as last year’s (seven months), we can expect to see additional significant net outflows from funds in Lipper’s natural resources classifications, as well as negative returns for the groups.

Material ETFs Up On Dow Chemical, DuPont Earnings Beat

We are in the middle of the earnings season, and the materials sector is seemingly tempering the overall Q3 growth picture after energy. This is especially true as total earnings from 60.9% of the sector’s total market capitalization reported so far are down 26.8% on 21% revenue decline. Despite the earnings weakness, the sector is showing impressive performance, having gained an average 1.76% (average price difference between a day before and after the earnings announcement of a stock), per the Zacks Earnings Trend . In particular, Dow Chemical (NYSE: DOW ) and DuPont (NYSE: DD ) led the rally in the sector as both companies beat on their earnings. However, revenues remained weak and missed our estimates. DOW Earnings in Focus The largest U.S. chemical maker continued its streak of earnings beat for the eight consecutive quarter. Earnings per share came in at 82 cents, easily trumping the Zacks Consensus Estimate of 68 cents and improving from 72 cents earned a year ago. Healthy earnings were credited to the incredible performance by the Performance Plastics segment due to lower cost of raw materials like oil and natural gas. Revenues dropped 16% year over year to $12.04 billion and missed our estimate of $12.25 billion. EBITDA margin expanded 370 bps to 20%, representing the best third-quarter margin since 2005 even as a strong dollar took a toll on revenues. The company remained committed to cost reduction and efficiency programs that are likely to boost margins and shareholders returns in the coming quarters. It is selectively spinning off or selling its underperforming assets and gradually shifting to high-growth markets such as construction, packaging and automotive. Dow Chemical raised its quarterly dividend by 10% to 46 cents, taking the annualized dividend to $1.84 per share, which is the highest in the company’s history. This new dividend is payable on January 29 to shareholders of record on December 31. Driven by a solid earnings beat, shares of Dow Chemical has risen 8.2% to date post its earnings announcement on October 22. DD Earnings in Focus While DuPont crushed our earnings estimate due to cost-reduction initiatives, revenues and profits tumbled on a strong dollar, a soft agriculture business and weakness in emerging markets. The world’s second-largest seed maker reported earnings per share of 13 cents, which beat the Zacks Consensus Estimate by 3 cents but deteriorated from 39 cents from the year-ago quarter. Total revenue slipped 17% year over year to $4.9 billion and fell short of our $5.2 billion estimate. Cost reductions from operational redesign contributed 10 cents to third-quarter earnings and are expected to add 40 cents per share to the full-year bottom line. The action will further save $1.3 billion in annual costs by 2016, a year ahead of the earlier expectation, and an additional $1.6 billion by 2017 end. With its cost-cutting initiatives, the chemicals and seed producer maintained its 2015 earnings per share guidance of roughly $2.75, which was below the Zacks Consensus Estimate of $2.93 at the time of earnings release. It expects currency headwinds to dilute full-year earnings by 72 cents per share. Following the earnings announcement on October 27, DD shares climbed nearly 5% over the past two days. ETFs in Focus Solid price performance of these two chemical titans has led to a rally in material ETFs that are heavily invested in these two stocks. Though these funds have an unfavorable Zacks ETF Rank of 4 or ‘Sell’ rating, they have gained over 3.5% in the past five days and are on investors’ radar for the weeks ahead: Materials Select Sector SPDR (NYSEARCA: XLB ) The most popular material ETF follows the Materials Select Sector Index. This fund manages about $2.1 billion in its asset base and trades in heavy volume of around 6.1 million. The ETF charges 14 bps in fees per year from investors. In total, the fund holds about 30 securities in its basket with DOW and DD taking the top two spots, with nearly 11% allocation each. In terms of industrial exposure, chemicals dominates the portfolio with three-fourth share while metals & mining and containers & packaging round off the top three positions. iShares U.S. Basic Materials ETF (NYSEARCA: IYM ) This ETF tracks the Dow Jones U.S. Basic Materials Index and holds 54 stocks in its basket. The fund has AUM of $361 million and charges 43 bps in fees and expenses. Volume is good as it exchanges around 106,000 shares in hand a day. DOW and DD occupy the top two positions in the basket, with over 10% of assets each. The product is heavily skewed toward the chemical segment, as it makes up for more than three-fourths of the portfolio while steel, forestry & paper, metals & mining receive minor allocations. Vanguard Materials ETF (NYSEARCA: VAW ) This fund has amassed about $1 billion in its asset base and offers exposure to 121 stocks by tracking the MSCI US Investable Market Materials 25/50 Index. The ETF has 0.12% in expense ratio while volume is moderate at 75,000 shares. Here, DOW and DD are the top two firms accounting for nearly 6% share each. Chemicals make up for nearly 70% of assets while container & packaging and steel also make a nice mix in the portfolio. Fidelity MSCI Materials Index ETF (NYSEARCA: FMAT ) This fund provides exposure to 122 materials stocks with AUM of $51.1 million. This is done by tracking the MSCI USA IMI Materials Index. Here too, DOW and DD are the top two firms with nearly 8% allocation. Chemicals accounts for 69.7% share while container & packaging, and metals & mining round off the top three spots with double-digit exposure each. The ETF has 0.12% in expense ratio while volume is moderate at 80,000 shares a day. Original Post

How To Optimize Warren Buffett’s Asset Allocation Advice

In Berkshire Hathaway’s 2013 annual letter to shareholders, Warren Buffett gave some retirement savings advice to investors. The Oracle of Omaha wrote in his letter to shareholders that he had given the trustee designated to manage the bequest his wife will receive, the following advice: “What I advise here is essentially identical to certain instructions I’ve laid out in my will. One bequest provides that cash will be delivered to a trustee for my wife’s benefit … My advice to the trustee could not be more simple: Put 10% of the cash in short-term government bonds and 90% in a very low-cost S&P 500 index fund. (I suggest Vanguard’s.) I believe the trust’s long-term results from this policy will be superior to those attained by most investors – whether pension funds, institutions or individuals – who employ high-fee managers.” Buffett’s advice sparked a debate in the financial community. Many market commentators asked if this really was the most sensible asset allocation approach for retirees, or indeed any investors at all. Javier Estrada at the IESE Business School, Department of Finance, Barcelona, Spain set out to answer this question in a paper titled, “Buffett’s Asset Allocation Advice: Take It … With a Twist”. In particular, the paper set out to answer the following question: “Is the asset allocation Buffett advised for his wife appropriate for other investors? If yes, why? If not, why not?” The study considers several different variations of Buffett’s recommendation. Eight static asset allocations with varying stock/bond proportions are evaluated, with particular attention to the 90/10 split suggested by Buffett. A further two minor dynamic strategies are also considered with valuation based twists. What’s more, the study is designed around the needs and skills of the average retiree. For example, the dynamic strategies are trivial to implement, and the person managing the portfolio will only need information about the performance of stocks, or that of stocks and bonds, over the previous year, which is publicly and widely available. Asset allocation: Data The data used for the study is based on the two asset classes suggest by Buffett, stocks, and short-term US Treasury bills. Returns are annual, adjusted for inflation and account for capital gains/losses and cash flows. Over the 114 year period considered, from 1900 to 2014, stocks and US T-bills had mean annual compound real returns of 6.5% and 0.9%, with annual volatility of 20.0% and 4.6%. The test portfolio was rebalanced once a year and the study assumes an annual withdrawal is made proportional to the asset allocation. The analysis is based on an initial capital balance of $1,000, an initial withdrawal of 4% of the capital and subsequent withdrawals annually adjusted for inflation over a 30-year period. Asset allocation: Results The chart below shows the results of the eight static portfolios over the period studied. (click to enlarge) Asset allocation results Figures indicated that strategies with equity holdings between 100% and 40% have similar failure rates, but when the allocation of stocks rises above 30% failure rates increase considerably; to above 10% in most cases. Although there are varied opinions regarding what is an acceptable failure rate, most practitioners seem to agree that failure rates below 5% should be viewed as acceptable by most retirees. Upside potential is measured by the mean, median, P90, P95, and P99. Downside protection is measured by both P5 and P10. The author concludes with test with the observation that: “…although the 60/40 strategy never failed, the 100/0 and 40/60 failed 3.5% of the time, and Buffett’s 90/10 failed 2.3% of the time, there does not seem to be a substantial difference in the failure rates of portfolios holding at least 40% in stocks.” “…as far as static strategies is concerned, Buffett’s suggested allocation has a very low (although not the lowest) failure rate; a very high (although not the highest) upside potential; and provides very good (but not the best) downside protection when tail risks strike. Put differently, Buffett’s suggested allocation seems to provide a middle ground between the best performing strategy (100/0) in terms of upside potential and the best performing strategies (60/40 and 70/30) in terms of downside protection.” Adapting Buffet’s advice Javier Estrada goes on to look at two different dynamic asset allocation strategies, which are based on the static strategy recommended by Buffett, but with a few changes. The first change [T1] relates to the annual withdrawal to the behavior of the stock market in the previous year. If stocks have gone up, the retiree takes the annual withdrawal from stocks and then rebalances the portfolio back to the 90/10 allocation. Conversely, if stocks have gone down, the retiree takes the annual withdrawal from bonds and does not rebalance the portfolio. The second change [T2] relates the annual withdrawal to the relative behavior of the stock and bond markets in the previous year. Just like adoption above, if stocks have gone up in the previous year, (more so than bonds) this change calls for the retiree to take the annual withdrawal from stocks and then rebalances. However, if the returns from bonds have exceeded those from stocks over the previous twelve months, the retiree takes the annual withdrawal from bonds but does not rebalance. (click to enlarge) Asset allocation results As the author observes, results of the two twists considered are very similar. T1 has a slightly higher overall upside potential, and T2 provides a slightly better overall downside protection. Both T1 and T2 outperform the 90/10 allocation. Although, the three strategies have the same failure rate (2.3%). T1 and T2 provide retirees with both a higher upside potential (as measured by the mean, median, P90, P95, and P99) and better downside protection (as measured by both P5 and P10) than the 90/10 allocation. Conclusion Overall then, Buffett’s asset allocation advice is sound and simple. However, for those retirees that are concerned about holding such an aggressive portfolio, the two aggressive strategies may offer better returns. The author of the paper concludes: “…the two simple twists considered here improve both the upside potential and the downside protection of the 90/10 allocation. These two twists require retirees neither to collect vast amounts of information nor to make any valuation judgments but only to observe the performance of the stock market, or the relative performance of the stock and bond markets.” “Either way, retirees can, with little effort, improve upon the results of the 90/10 allocation. In fact, because the performance of the two twists considered is so similar, retirees may want to lean towards the first one (T1) and simply adjust their asset allocation according to the observed performance of stocks.” “…those retirees that find a 90/10 portfolio acceptable are likely to find that with an insignificant additional effort, observing the performance of stocks and implementing the first twist discussed, they are likely to improve the performance of their portfolios.” Rupert may hold positions in one or more of the companies mentioned in this article. You can find a full list of Rupert’s positions on his blog. This should not be interpreted as investment advice, or a recommendation to buy or sell securities. You should make your own decisions and seek independent professional advice before doing so. Past performance is not a guide to future performance.