Tag Archives: ideas

Quant Investing: Improving The Value Of Shareholder Yield

Part of quant investing is always being on the look out for better metrics and systems that enhance performance. Today I want to look at a simple improvement to the value metric shareholder yield. I’ll look at this in the context of the quant index replication strategy I posted on here . First, lets look at shareholder yield in more detail. Recently there has been some interesting discussion on the level of buybacks, as a percentage of market cap, and how strong a conviction by management that represents. The idea being that the higher percentage of shares a company is buying back, the more conviction management has on the value of the company, and thus leading to better stock performance. The best analysis of the topic is here . The analysis going back to 1987 shows two key things; the largest buybacks (greater than 5% of market cap) are done at cheaper valuations and this leads to better performance over the following year. The large stock shareholder yield quant value strategy is a big improvement on the traditional indices. But maybe we can do better armed with this new information on the level of buybacks. I’ll take the original large stock SHY value strategy and compare it to a new version which only buys the large cap stocks sorted by SHY if the buyback yield is greater than 5%. We’ll go back to Jan 1999 and run the backtest through yesterday’s market close. First, the performance for the original large stock SHY strategy. Pretty darn good, 16.44% per year since 1999 with a Sharpe of 0.75 and Sortino of 1.06. Now lets add the filter that only buys stocks with a buyback yield greater than 5%. Even better as the research suggested. 17.59% per year since 1999 with a Sharpe of 0.80 and a Sortino of 1.17. That a 1.1% per year return enhancement with an improvement in risk adjusted returns as well for a very simple addition to an already powerful strategy. In short, screening for high conviction buybacks is a powerful addition to a large cap shareholder yield value strategy.

UTES: New Actively Managed Utilities ETF Targets Infrastructure

Summary UTES, a new ETF offered by Reaves Asset Management, is the first actively managed utilities ETF. Reaves intends to use its 37 years of experience with the utilities sector to build a portfolio that will feature growth. I was able to interview Joseph (“Jay”) Rhames, the fund manager, to get insights into the philosophy behind this fund. Utilities are one of the more popular sources of income for investors, with yields typically in the 3.00% – 5.00% range. Utilities are attractive because they are a defensive investment – these are the sort of companies that are constantly in demand, in terms of what they provide – namely, power . Everyone uses it, everyone needs it; everyone pays for it. In terms of growth , however, this may not be the most attractive segment of the market. As noted by one colleague, prices for utility stocks rose from the period of 2008 – 2014 primarily due to the fact that other sources of income (CD’s and money markets) were not offering much. 1 However, along with everything else in recent months, utilities have seen a drop in value. The extent to which this is associated with the general market declension remains to be seen, but utilities are not usually known for rapid growth, anyway. As an industry, utilities are usually regulated by local and state authorities, and regulators do constitute an effective cap on a utility’s potential growth. The Utilities ETF As we will see later in this article, ETFs do offer an interesting means of achieving effective yield from utilities. Until recently, all utilities ETFs have been passive, indexed funds; in September, however, Reaves Asset Management – a company that has been managing institutional portfolios since 1978 – decided to put its experience in the area of utilities behind an actively managed fund: the Reaves Utilities ETF (NASDAQ: UTES ). 2 Historically, Reaves has been intimately involved with the utilities sector, and has extensive experience working with utility management companies. UTES represents their effort to translate that experience into a marketable ETF that can improve growth prospects over those of passive funds. In preparing this article I had the opportunity to speak with fund manager Joseph “Jay” Rhame, III , about plans for the fund. 3 I came away impressed with the depth of understanding Reaves has of utilities and their awareness of the factors currently influencing the business. Selection UTES currently has 21 holdings, or about one-fourth the holdings of larger ETFs and fewer than half as many as the average for the eight other utilities-focused ETFs. No index is used in the selection of the holdings; Mr. Rhame is focusing on companies that are profitable , that may be underweight , and – in particular – companies that are oriented towards utilities infrastructure , rather than power generation. For purposes of the fund, a company constitutes a ” Utility Sector Company ” when either 50% of the company’s assets or customers are committed to, or at least 50% of the company’s “revenue, gross income or profits” are realized from “products, services or equipment for the generation or distribution of electricity, gas or water.” 4 Companies that are focused more towards power generation are subject to pressure from regulators who control prices; as a result, their share prices tend to be volatile , fluctuating according to changes in the regulatory environment. Infrastructure, on the other hand, is a more stable operation with regular demand and less influence from regulators ; this makes their business more reliable , improving prospects for share prices. Furthermore, the fund seeks (primarily U.S.) 5 holdings that display at least one of the following characteristics: They have conservative capital structures. They present solid balance sheets. They have a history of, and/or the potential for, growing earnings or raising dividends. There are positive catalysts that could potentially unlock value. Their levels of volatility, correlation or similar characteristics are lower than market levels. 6 Eligibility is independent of the company’s market capitalization; further, companies may be evaluated on earnings/cash flow potential, dividend prospects, strength of franchises and estimates of net asset value. 7 Weighting There is no formal weighting system for the holdings; rather, holdings are evaluated on their growth potential and relevant developments that may affect the companies and their performance. According to Mr. Rhame, this enables the fund to be weighted towards those companies which are seen as having the greatest prospects. The intention is for the management to have the flexibility to shift assets as changing situations warrant. The fund would be subject to reconstitution and rebalancing at the discretion of the portfolio manager. Dividends Based on the fund’s current holdings and the dividends paid by those companies, I have estimated that UTES will be paying a little more than $0.61/share . This figure is based on dividend income the fund is projected to receive; the fund could realize additional income in the form of capital gains , interest , etc. The fund should see close to $90,000 in gross income from dividends, giving it a realized yield of 3.22%, based on current NAV. This is in keeping with the average yield of 3.33% amongst its holdings. Given its expense ratio, the fund should see a return on NAV of 2.27%. Mr. Rhame did affirm that the fund would not use derivatives or other instrumentalities (options, shorts) to increase yield. He is satisfied that the approach they are taking will result in greater growth, and he is inclined to invest in those companies having lower yields where it indicates price growth is most likely to occur. He projected yield in the neighborhood of 2.5% , which is consistent with my projections which indicate a yield of approximately 2.31% . Dividends are expected to be distributed quarterly, with capital gains being paid at least annually. 8 Testing the Portfolio As usual, I like to take the portfolio of a new ETF for a “spin,” running its holdings into the past to see how the portfolio might have performed had it been in existence. This “pseudo portfolio” is not used by way of a claim that the results would have been true had UTES been in existence – only that the companies in the portfolio did actually perform in said manner. As usual, past performance should never be taken as an indication of future activity. I ran the portfolio back to 1 January 2005, and seeded it with $10,000. Due to the proprietary nature of the weighting of UTES’ actual portfolio, I opted to weigh the holdings equally. The portfolio was rebalanced every six months. Because utilities are largely used as means of acquiring yield, I ran the test twice: once using the actual closing prices from January 2005 to the present, and once using the adjusted closing price, which reflects a company’s dividends and stock splits for the period covered. 9 The following chart illustrates the portfolio’s performance on both accounts: (click to enlarge) As one can see, there is a marked difference between the return realized in terms of share price alone, and the total returns one would expect once dividends are figured in. The main value in such a portfolio is to be had by holding it for the long term, pulling in the yield, rather than anticipating significant growth of share value. Comparison The portfolio of which UTES is comprised looks to be productive; the question remains whether it is competitive with what is out there now. Besides UTES , there are 10 other ETFs that focus on utilities, 10 with a range of portfolio sizes and offering a range of yields that seem, on first blush, to be superior to that offered by Reaves ‘ fund. For sake of comparison, I have chosen four funds to run side by side with UTES . The funds are: Vanguard Utilities ETF (NYSEARCA: VPU ) iShares U.S. Utilities ETF (NYSEARCA: IDU ) Utilities Select Sector SPDR ETF (NYSEARCA: XLU ) Guggenheim S&P Equal Weight Utilities ETF (NYSEARCA: RYU ) These ETFs were tested using the same procedure as that used for the UTES portfolio. They were run with both the actual closing costs and the adjusted closing cost. The chart for the actual closing cost follows: (click to enlarge) Although the UTES portfolio drops off in the early stages of the trial it comes back to lead the other funds, beating VPU handily by 785bps. RYU has an inception date of 1 November 2006, and that has no doubt adversely affected its comparison in this trial. As one might expect, the ETFs tend to bunch up together (other than RYU ) The following chart represents the adjusted closing price: (click to enlarge) As earlier, RYU’s performance is well back of the other ETFs. IDU , XLU and VPU are grouped together, just as they were in the previous trial – still within about 600bps of each other. The UTES portfolio, however, outperforms VPU by 77 full percentage points (7700bps). The extent to which this is due to the fact that there is no internal loss of income in the portfolio – as is the case with the ETFs – is not clear, although no doubt were the portfolio an actual ETF, its returns would be more than marginally moderated. Some Additional Considerations I asked Mr. Rhame directly how he thought their active management of UTES would set it apart from the passive funds it competes against. His response focused on the fact that Reaves was in a position that enabled them to put their experience to work. They were familiar with the issues facing various companies, the effectiveness of companies’ management, and the prospects each company had. As examples of their ability to put their knowledge of companies to use, he cited the following: Atmos Energy Corp. (NYSE: ATO ): This company is involved in the gas pipeline business. One of the largest natural-gas-only distributors in the U.S., and located in Texas, Atmos is involved in a long-term pipeline replacement project that assures the Company of regular rate increases to cover its costs. On 4 November 2015, the Company announce it would raise its dividend by 7.7%, to $1.68 from $1.56. 11 DTE Energy Holding Co. (NYSE: DTE ): Located in Detroit, DTE is one of the best-managed utility companies in the country, according to Mr. Rhame. The Company is one of the largest employers in Detroit, and is heavily involved in efforts to revitalize the city. The Company is committed to keeping its utility costs low; its efforts are recognized and supported by the Michigan state government. Both companies are in the fund’s portfolio ( DTE is the fourth-largest holding). Mr. Rhame also expressed Reaves’ commitment to making UTES completely transparent , a concern many investors have when considering actively managed funds. I do have some reservations about the yield UTES seems positioned to offer. A yield of 2.31% (if my estimation is correct) is significantly lower than that offered by other ETFs. Growth prospects would have to be pronounced if they are to compensate for the lower dividends. Of course, the primary influence on how much of its income a fund is able to distribute to shareholders are the fund’s expenses. The following graph shows how the funds in the graph above compare in this regard: [*Note: again, I must point out that dividend figures for UTES are my projection, and discussions thereof must be considered in that light.] Clearly, the premium exacted by UTES takes a toll on the dividends it is able to pay out; the expenses for actively managed funds is, as a rule, higher than that of passive funds, and UTES is on the lower side of active funds. Key to UTES success, again, is going to be whether the active management justifies its higher costs by bringing value into the fund. If that value is not going to be in the form of dividends, it will have to be by virtue of the value of the shares in its portfolio – either UTES will have to grow in value or it will have to return substantial capital gains to its shareholders. One last point needs to be made. Utilities tend to have high debt-to-equity (D/E) levels; on the whole, utilities as a sector have an average total-D/E of 1.55 , up noticeably from the average of 1.42 for the past three quarters. 12 The companies currently held by UTES have an average D/E of 1.20 . No doubt regulatory controls influence the level of debt these companies have, and Reaves’ strategy of focusing more on the infrastructure-related companies, which may encounter less regulatory influence than power-related companies, is a good one. Assessment I think it is clear that UTES has the potential to be a very profitable holding; however, the difference between it and other utilities ETFs is going to rest on the ability of its managers to effectively populate its portfolio with stocks that increase in value . The dividends to be realized from the fund will be good, but may not be as good as those offered by other utilities funds. Given Reaves ‘ extensive background in tracking the utilities sector, I am confident that this would be the right group to manage a portfolio on a day-to-day basis. Their current portfolio reflects a choice of holdings that have noteworthy potential . It might serve well to give this ETF a few months as a sort of shakedown before buying, and then buy shares gradually. Disclaimers This article is for informational use only. It is not intended as a recommendation or inducement to purchase or sell any financial instrument issued by or pertaining to any company or fund mentioned or described herein. All data contained herein is accurate to the best of my ability to ascertain, and is drawn from the Company’s Prospectus, Statement of Additional Information, and fact sheets. All tables, charts and graphs are produced by me using data acquired from pertinent documents; historical price data from Yahoo! Finance . Data from any other sources (if used) are cited as such. All opinions contained herein are mine unless otherwise indicated. The opinions of others that may be included are identified as such and do not necessarily reflect my own views. I would like to thank Mr. Rhame for kindly providing his view of UTES. Before investing, readers are reminded that they are responsible for performing their own due diligence; they are also reminded that it is possible to lose part or all of their invested money. Please invest carefully. ————————— 1 The Yield Hunter on utilities . 2 Data in the table includes projections that are based on my research into UTES and its holdings. In particular, income and dividends/yield are my projections based on dividend income I project UTES to receive from its holdings. Income yield (Inc. Yield) is reached by dividing gross income by NAV; return on NAV (RoNAV) is determined by dividing net income by NAV. Expense margin represents the portion of income that is left after expenses are subtracted from gross income. The fund’s website is here . 3 I spoke with Mr. Rhame by phone on 21 October 2015. All mentions attributed to Mr. Rhame refer to this call. 4 Prospectus, Reaves Utilities ETF ( UTES ), p. 4. 5 Many of the funds’ holdings are multinationals headquartered in the U.S. 6 Prospectus , p. 4. 7 Prospectus , p. 4. 8 Prospectus , p. 12. 9 I need to make a qualification here. The returns realized from the perspective of a portfolio of holdings, each one paying dividends directly to the portfolio holder, will be larger than the returns one would realize from an ETF, where dividends are paid to the fund’s management who then covers expenses with that money, distributing the remainder to the fund’s shareholders. With this in mind, I need to point out that the returns from the portfolio being considered is perhaps significantly higher than the returns from UTES would be. 10 Two of the available funds are leveraged “ultra”-style ETFs. 11 This is also the 28th consecutive year in which the company has increased its dividend. Atmos press release . 12 Data from CSIMarket.com .

It’s A Good Time To Buy A Good Junk Bond Fund

Summary Spread between yield on high yield debt and U.S. Treasuries is above average. Credit loss costs on speculative grade fixed income securities have been below average for the past few years. Among junk bond funds, Lord Abbett High Yield Fund has a strong track record and an attractive portfolio. The recent underperformance of speculative grade bonds has made the asset class attractive to investors focusing on fundamentals. The chart below shows that the spread between high yield fixed income securities and 5 year U.S. Treasuries is above average. Additionally, credit loss rates have been below average for the past four years. Combining these two trends suggest high yield investors are receiving a good premium for the risk in today’s environment. U.S. High Yield Spreads and Credit Loss Rates Sources: Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis and Merrill Lynch Macroeconomic Conditions Since the latest data on high yield credit loss rates is for 2014, it is helpful to briefly assess the macroeconomic conditions in the U.S. and determine their implications on companies with high leverage, volatile cash flows or deteriorating profitability. The U.S. economy continues to recover gradually from the Great Recession. According to the Bureau of Labor and Statistics, the unemployment rate has declined to 5.1% from a crisis era peak of 10.0% in 2009. Last month’s non-farm payroll report was below most economists’ expectations, but the general trend in jobs has been good. The economy has added 13 million jobs since 2009 including 1.6 million in 2015. GDP and corporate earnings have been volatile in 2015, but expectations are for better growth in 2016. The International Monetary Fund expects U.S. real GDP growth to improve to 2.8% in 2016. Analysts surveyed by Thomson Reuters expect earnings for the S&P 500 to increase 9% next year. Some sectors of the economy definitely have blemishes particularly industries that produce energy or depend on sales abroad. Overall, macroeconomic conditions may not be great, but they are decent and improving which should limit corporate defaults. Fund Selection After determining high yield fixed income securities are an attractive asset class, the next step is selecting the appropriate security or securities. Most retail investment accounts do not allow investors to buy high yield bonds directly. Instead, they must use mutual funds or exchange traded funds (ETFs) to gain exposure to this asset class. Even if retail investors could buy individual high yield bonds, it would still be a good idea to use mutual funds and ETFs due to the diversification they provide. Below is the criteria used to select mutual funds and ETFs for more thorough analysis. At least 75% of holdings rated BB+ or lower Mutual funds with Morningstar rating of 4 or 5 stars No load or waived Top 20% in 5 year return vs benchmark Applying this criteria identifies the following mutual funds: Fidelity Capital & Income Fund (MUTF: FAGIX ) Oppenheimer Senior Floating Rate A (MUTF: OOSAX ) Lord Abbett High Yield A (MUTF: LHYAX ) Guggenheim Floating Rate Strats A (MUTF: GIFAX ) Selecting one fund for investment will involve more subjective judgment than the process used to identify a list of viable funds. Historical performance is obviously important. Since profiting on the above average spread for high yield debt and the below average loss costs is the investment thesis, the composition of the fund’s assets is important. Exposure to interest rate risk should be examined because rates are likely to increase which negatively impacts the value of bonds. Finally, it is appropriate to compare expense ratios. Fund Performance OOSAX’s performance compares unfavorably to the other funds selected by the screen. It also performed considerably worse than Morningstar’s high yield index over longer periods. FAGIX probably demonstrated the best performance over both short and long-term periods. LHYAX has the best five year total return, but its performance in the past year trails FAGIX and GIFAX by a wide margin. GIFAX has done well recently. However, it is a relatively new fund, and its three year total return is pedestrian. Return (%) YTD 1 Year 3 Year 5 Year FAGIX 2.04 1.26 6.84 6.78 LHYAX 1.99 0.18 5.88 7.01 GIFAX 2.39 2.21 4.45 — OOSAX 0.57 -0.28 2.84 4.06 Morningstar High Yield 0.09 -2.02 3.43 5.19 Source Morningstar Credit Risk LHYAX has the most attractive credit risk profile. It has the highest yield despite having similar interest rate risk and ratings distribution as other funds. FAGIX’s lower allocation to ‘B’ and ‘CCC’ fixed income securities is a negative because the investment thesis focuses on exposure to corporate default risk. Instead of dedicating its portfolio to high yield bonds, FAGIX has allocated about 20% of its assets to equities. Although this strategy has favorably impacted FAGIX’s total return in recent years, it is not consistent with the investment thesis. OOSAX’s greater proportion of ‘B’ and ‘CCC’ securities does not translate into a higher yield because OOSAX only invests in floating rate securities. Credit Risk and Yield (click to enlarge) The table below compares each fund’s actual SEC defined yield to the expected yield based on the credit ratings distribution of its holdings and the current yield for each rating category according to Merrill Lynch. A positive difference means the fund is generating a better yield than would be expected by the ratings distribution of its assets. Oddly, the difference is negative for all the funds. This issue would be more troubling if the funds have been underperforming Monrningstar’s high yield benchmark. Instead, it likely reflects a difference between the duration of the funds’ assets and duration of the securities used to create the benchmarks. Since LHYAX and FAGIX have approximately the same duration, it is reasonable to assert that LHYAX has done a better job of selecting securities that generate a yield consistent with their ratings. It is not surprising that OOSAX and GIFAX have a negative difference because they only invest in floating rate securities which tend to have lower yields. However, the magnitude of GIFAX’s negative difference is troubling. Return (%) SEC Yield Expected Yield Difference LHYAX 5.79% 7.59% -180 FAGIX 4.21% 6.34% -213 OOSAX 4.76% 7.19% -243 GIFAX 3.55% 6.92% -337 Source: Morningstar, Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis and Merrill Lynch Ratings Distribution (click to enlarge) Source: Morningstar Energy companies are in the midst of very challenging environment due to the collapse in oil prices. Fortunately, none of the funds being reviewed have material exposure to this sector. According to Yahoo Finance, investments in fixed income securities represent 4% of LHYAX’s assets and 2% of FAGIX’s holdings. Neither OOSAX nor GIFAX has any exposure to the energy sector. Interest Rate Risk OOSAX and GIFAX have no material exposure to interest rate risk. LHYAX and FAGIX have a moderate amount of interest rate risk. If interest rates rose by 100 basis points in a parallel shift, investors should expect these funds to decrease by 4% to 5% as a result to the increase in interest rates. The actual impact of interest rate changes is extremely difficult to predict for the following reasons. Effective Duration Maturity > 5 (%) LHYAX 4.7 80 GIFAX 0.4 66 OOSAX 0.0 49 FAGIX 4.4 84 Fees and Expenses FAGIX has a moderate expense advantage. GIFAX has a modest expense disadvantage over the other funds under consideration. All of the funds’ expense ratios are below Morningstar’s average for high yield funds of 1.08%. Net Expense Ratio (%) FAGIX 0.72 LHYAX 0.94 OOSAX 0.97 GIFAX 1.04 Source: Morningstar Conclusion LHYAX is the best vehicle for executing on the investment thesis. However, a strong case can be made for long positions in either LHYAX or FAGIX. These two funds significantly outperformed OOSAX and GIFAX over the long term. LHYAX has the best comparison between actual yield and expected yield based on ratings distribution. Finally, LHYAX has the most exposure to high yield fixed income securities which is the heart of the investment thesis. FAGIX allocates a material portion of its assets to equities.