Tag Archives: ideas

S&P 500: The Perfect Short

Summary Valuations at their highest levels in over a decade on a price/book, price/sales, and price/cash flow basis. Buy backs / M&A now representing 70% of all buying volume. Declining market breadth. The world is back to normal. The S&P (NYSEARCA: SPY ) is ~1% from its high, China is stabilizing, the U.S. is adding jobs, average hourly earnings are rising, and Dennis Gartman is ever so slightly long crude. This change in sentiment from the August lows led to the largest point rally in history, significantly weakening bear sentiment among individual investors, asset managers and the boys/girls with leverage, shown below. (click to enlarge) (click to enlarge) While the vicious upward move shook a lot of bears, including myself on the second leg, the concerns voiced during the sell-off are still present today, if not worse; however, the market seems to be operating under the assumption that everything is normal again given its recent price action, bringing me to one of my favorite graphics (note “return to normal.”) Yours truly, the S&P. (click to enlarge) So here we are, hovering around all-time highs with: Valuations at their highest levels in over a decade on a price/book, price/sales, and price/cash flow basis The largest amount of non-gaap adjustments as a % of total earnings since 2009 Buy backs / M&A now representing 70% of all buying volume The highest amount of corporate leverage in history Companies issuing debt to buyback record amounts of stock (’00, ’07) Two quarters of negative earnings growth 80% of IPOs with no earnings (last seen in 1999) A dollar that is breaking out 9.6 trillion of foreign debt denominated in dollars The highest sales/inventory levels since 2008 Declining market breadth Eerily similar price action to 2001 and 1937 And A Fed that “is definitely raising rates” in December With this as the backdrop, my view is that the path of least resistance is to the downside. I see an 8% chance that we break the previous highs. If that is that does manifest, a blow-off top may be in the cards. Valuations: I detailed in my previous post on gold (NYSEARCA: GLD ) that the current market multiples across a series of valuation metrics are the highest we have seen in 10+ years. This is by no means an indication that the market will go down, as something overvalued can become additionally overvalued, but should be used as an indication of how far the market could move under a perception change, which I believe we are currently undergoing given two quarters of negative earnings growth. As you can see below, the S&P currently trades at a price-to- EBITDA multiple of 10.4x, roughly in-line with the tech bubble. That turned out well. (click to enlarge) H/t @Jpcompson Buying Volume: In a recent interview , Ray Dalio sat down with Tom Keene and Michael McKee to talk all things markets. While the headline news was Ray calling for additional easing (QE4), his comments on buying volume were just as interesting. DALIO: American businesses right now are the number one thing is they’re flush with cash. And as a result, the biggest force in the stock market right now is the buy backs and mergers and acquisitions. So something like 70 percent of the buy, the buying in the stock market, is along those lines. So the largest buyers of stocks are corporations themselves. Think about this for a minute. 70% of the buying volume is coming from corporations not market participants. Companies typically buy back their stock for a few reasons: The stock is cheap, i.e. (NASDAQ: AAPL ) There is a lack of investment opportunity/uncertainty Artificially inflate EPS With that being the premise, let’s look at the current environment. Stocks are clearly not cheap, although value can still be found ($AAPL). The domestic economy according to many economists and pundits is doing “fine,” so there should be plenty of investment opportunities. So by process of elimination, companies are levering up to reduce shares out, in turn artificially inflating numbers and making their stocks look cheaper than reality. If companies are deploying capital to buy their stock at 16-17x non-gaap earnings (30+x gaap), the return over the following year would need to be 17% (30%+) to justify the investment. What we are witnessing is one of the most value destructive deployments of capital in history that will reemerge in future earnings, or the lack of. Corporate Leverage / Buy Backs / Cash Usage: The process of levering up to buy back stock is a direct effect of ZIRP and lack of corporate discipline, as companies allocate cash to please shareholders rather than invest in the future of their businesses. Goldman Sachs details this in the chart below. As you can see, buy backs as a percentage of total cash use has doubled since 2009 when stocks were arguably the cheapest. The percentage of cash used for CAPEX is 30%, or 2% off the lowest level seen in the past 16 years. Cash used to invest in growth is also near the lowest levels seen since 1999, while cash returned to investors nears an all-time high. (click to enlarge) Due to the abundance of short-termism, corporate leverage, buy backs and debt issuance are at or near the highest levels we have seen in 25, shown below. This is in the face of back to back quarters of declining sales and earnings growth, according to FactSet. Excessive leverage is akin to running a marathon with a 100 pound weight on your back. That said, earnings growth in the face of a stronger dollar, global slowdown, wage inflation, corporate leverage, higher rates, and diminishing CAPEX leads me to believe the past two quarters of declines are just the beginning. (click to enlarge) Forward Estimates: Wall Street analysts currently see earnings growing substantially over the next year as FactSet highlights below. While this is completely possible, I’m not sold given the trends that we are seeing today. Friday’s jobs report showed the strongest average hourly earnings y/y growth since 2009, reinforcing corporate comments on wage inflation. Barbarian Capital had a great post recently highlighting restaurant wage pressure, which he views as a good proxy for the following reasons: “The US food service labor market is probably the deepest and most liquid labor market in the US. At the entry level, there are no entry barriers either in terms of credentials or task skills (people already make sandwiches and wash dishes at home).” “The labor force in the industry is big: 14 million people, or about 10% of the labor force” “Employee turnover is very high : it was 66% in 2014 and 81% in 2007 (chart at the bottom of the linked article). So at the entry level, 100%+ turnover is likely the norm. This means that employers, as a whole, pay the market rates: there is no lag or scheduled increases (ex of local min wages), unlike professional or unionized industries” “Publicly traded restaurant companies generally report direct labor costs in their filings, unlike retail establishments (another large liquid labor market). My impression is that this fosters labor discussions more often than in retail.” Here are a few of the many examples of wage inflation outlined on recent conference calls: Historically, SG&A has been ~17% of sales, COGS ~66% of sales, interest and taxes ~5% of sales, depreciation and other ~5%, leading to a 9% EBIT margin (note this is as of 2013.) Over this period, yields, the employment cost index, and effective corporate tax rates have all fallen, providing a tailwind to operating earnings. While the quality of gains in the jobs report are debatable, it is clear that the risk is to the upside on wage inflation, which will clearly have an adverse effect on operating income. And given the fact that Bernie Sanders is somehow in the presidential race, who knows where corporate tax rates will be. I am assuming that taxes remain around current levels and spreads widen (outlined below), which will further reduce the operating earnings. Below are the Wall Street margin assumptions that get you to $128 in earnings power for FY16. While the trend looks like it is about to roll over, people much smarter than I are forecasting continued expansion. I’ll take the other side. H/t @Callum_Thomas As I previously stated there is clearly some wage pressure being felt by corporations. At ~17% of sales (likely lower given additional items in SG&A), that alone puts material pressure on margin expansion, but price and COGS are the real levers here. Price – COGS (66%) = Gross Margin. I’m no economist, but when there is demand for goods, a seller is likely able to raise prices at a faster clip than the costs of those goods, in turn increasing margins. That being said, below is a chart of the personal consumption expenditures deflator showing that inflation is near post crisis lows and almost negative. H/t @Mktoutperform Core PCE is much stronger, but again minimal signs of inflation given its current downtrend. (click to enlarge) So as prices of goods and services continuously trend lower, how is it that margins will expand from here if Price – COGS = GM, especially given the recent dollar strength and a 70% chance of a hike in December. In addition, it will be very difficult to raise prices given current inventory levels. The inventory to sales ratio shown below was last seen during the financial crisis. Forced liquidations and falling orders is likely not good for margins. (click to enlarge) Corporate Leverage: To recap, we have the highest valuations in the past 10+ yrs, multiple factors are putting downward pressure on margins, and record amounts of corporate leverage is being used to purchase stocks at nose bleed valuations. This brings me to the leverage part of the equation. As shown below, the median debt-to-EBITDA ratio for both investment grade and high yield bonds is at the highest level since 2005, which is being accompanied by rising default rates. I am not an economist nor a credit analyst, but given the trends I’ve highlighted above I can make a pretty strong case for why this will likely deteriorate further. (click to enlarge) Rising spreads will have an adverse effect on earnings and make it increasingly difficult to refinance given that ~30% of the aggregate S&P debt matures in the next three years. (click to enlarge) As you can see below, junk bonds are rolling over again even as the market nears all-time highs. The same is true for investment grade corporates. I will put my money on bond market here. H/t @Callum_Thomas Breadth: Under the surface the S&P is losing steam, as the leadership of the market has narrowed substantially over the past few months. This has been evidenced by the difference between the S&P and the equally-weighted ETF, the RSP . As you can see the RSP:SPY ratio is breaking down to 2 year lows. Here is a chart from @NorthmanTrader that further illustrates the discrepancy. (click to enlarge) In addition, the number of stocks above their 200 day moving average and the current downtrend is indicating waning breadth. This further illustrates to me that the path of least resistance is to the downside. (click to enlarge) The Fed And The Dollar: The Fed’s recent commentary strengthened my view that their credibility, like the market’s breadth, is waning. From the press release: “household spending and business fixed investment have been increasing at solid rates in the recent months.” What are they looking at? Source: Zerohedge The committee then states the “pace of job gains has slowed,” and longer term inflation expectations remaining stable. This is clearly not the case as illustrated by the PCE deflator above. But fear not, the committee, “expects inflation to rise gradually toward 2% over the medium term as the labor market improves further” from its recent slowing. The illustration below from @NotJimCramer gives you an idea of the Fed’s talk and lack of action. (click to enlarge) The first thing that came to my mind was: www.youtube.com/watch?v=eKgPY1adc0A The Fed got their wish last Friday with a blowout jobs number, sending the Fed Fund futures probability of a December hike to 70% and moving the dollar up with it. In my opinion, the last thing the world needs right now is a stronger dollar. There is roughly 9.6 trillion of foreign debt denominated in dollars, 3 trillion of which has been added by emerging markets since Lehman. With global demand slowing, sovereigns are forced to devalue their currencies, in turn strengthening the dollar without the Fed’s move. It is my view, that there are currently multiple reflexive relationships that will force the Fed to hold off on hiking rates. Should the Fed hike, which the market and participants seem to believe is a foregone conclusion based on a jobs number that under the surface was not great, the dollar will: Hinder the repayment of emerging market debt Further reduce commodity prices, which will in turn hurt earnings and likely result in an abundance of defaults given the amount of debt tied to commodities Make U.S. goods less attractive, in turn further reducing sales and earnings That said, I am sticking with my view that the Fed is trapped in a corner and the next move will be to ease or cut rates, which has recently shown up in their verbiage. Price Similarities: In turning to history as a guide of the future I looked at 2001. The blue line is the S&P from 10/16/1998 to 12/20/2000 and the red line is the S&P from 10/10/2014 to present. As you can see the price action is almost identical. The next leg is clearly lower and should manifest over the next two weeks. Nautilus provides an additional analog comparing 1937 to today. Note the 93% correlation. Conclusion: Based on the evidence provided above, it seems the path of least resistance is to the downside. My thesis will be wrong should the following manifest: The dollar weakens significantly, aiding commodity prices, U.S. sales, and earnings Short-term: the market moves to all-time highs on increasing breadth Inflation increases significantly Wage pressures dissipate Spreads tighten Corporations halt buybacks and invest in the future at similar historical levels. (Although this would cut the current bid) The market fails to follow either analog sequence I am agnostic to the Fed in relation to my short thesis on the S&P. I believe a hike from them would be extremely detrimental to the macro economy, but the failure to hike can be as destructive. Feedback welcomed.

3 Of Apple’s Best Podcasts

Summary What are the best podcasts for investors on Apple iTunes? Here are some of my favorites based on my experiences on air. Additionally, here is one of the newest: our Rangeley podcast. As the name indicates, Apple (NASDAQ: AAPL ) iTunes is primarily for music; however, it is also growing as a home to value investing podcasts. For investors in search of an edge, what are the best podcasts with an investment focus? Three of my favorites are Micro Cap Investing , Investor in the Family , and our new Rangeley Capital Weekly Podcasts . So when you see someone enjoying iTunes, they may well be learning about investing… It’s not given to human beings to have such talent that they can just know everything about everything all the time. But it is given to human beings who work hard at it – who look and sift the world for a misplaced bet – that they can occasionally find one. – Charlie Munger Micro Cap Investing Fred Rockwell Nate Tobik This podcast is hosted by Fred Rockwell and Nate Tobik . I admire both men and have learned a lot from them through the years. Fred runs Tarsier Capital and Nate founded CompleteBankData.com . They also host the MicroCap Conference which I recently attended. I was a recent guest on this podcast. The questions were great and we had fun discussing ideas with fellow value investors. There are no bad assets, just bad prices. – James Grant Investor in the Family This podcast is hosted by Brian Bain who also writes for Seeking Alpha. He focuses on solar, technology, and natural gas. I enjoyed our conversation about investing and hope that you might too. Life, and everything in it, is based on arbitrage opportunities and their exploitation. – Paul Wilmott Are Diamonds BS? Before you listen to this podcast, be forewarned that this is for entertainment purposes only. Nothing you hear is an offer or a solicitation to buy or sell any investment. So, if you think you are being entertained: you are correct. If you think you are being offered investing advice: you are so wrong. Each week, Rangeley Capital’s portfolio managers host a weekly fifteen-minute podcast. If you missed last week’s episode, then please check out Is Nothing Sacred? Rangeley Podcast #2 . We discussed a fund that goes anywhere and does anything. This week, we discuss Diamonds Are BS and debate the merits of blowing one’s savings on highly compressed coal. Then we debate whether something can have value if you can’t subsequently buy or sell it with ease. This week’s topic is not just a discussion subject, it is an intervention. This is a subject near to my heart. I hope that listeners enjoy it and I hope that you find it convincing. You will be able to seriously impress people with the force of your logic by not buying them diamonds. Value investing is at its core the marriage of a contrarian streak and a calculator. – Seth Klarman The podcast is hosted by Andrew Walker and Chris DeMuth Jr., two Rangeley Capital portfolio managers. You can follow us on Twitter (NYSE: TWTR ) ( Andrew and Chris ). You can subscribe to the podcast on iTunes here or on Soundcloud here . What are your favorite investing-themed podcasts on Apple’s iTunes? Please offer suggestions for others in the comment section below. We would appreciate the chance to hear from you. Take the probability of loss times the amount of possible loss from the probability of gain times the amount of possible gain. That is what we’re trying to do. It’s imperfect, but that’s what it’s all about. – Warren Buffett ( BRK.A / BRK.B )

Wisconsin Energy- Let’s Look At It After The Acquisition Of Integrys

Summary Half a year a go I wrote an article about WEC as a dividend growth investor. The latest Q3 report will allow me to understand whether the growth prospects are present. If the acquisition is successful, WEC will have plenty of room to grow. The post merger WEC might offer a 3.5% yield, 6% EPS and dividend growth, and all that in a business that is a regulated monopoly. Introduction Six months ago I wrote an article about Wisconsin Energy (NYSE: WEC ) as a dividend growth stock. At the time, the company was just before the acquisition of Integrys (NYSE: TEG ). Another great article in June also gave investors information about the sealed deal to acquire Integrys. On November 4th, WEC published its Q3 results. The results were great as WEC has beaten the EPS consensus by 3.5% and revenue consensus by 15%. This report and the information given by the company allow me to take a first glance at the new Wisconsin Energy company. Many dividend growth investors such a myself, divide their portfolio by sectors. I don’t like the utilities sector too much, but I am willing to allocate 2.5% of my portfolio to it. In addition, dividend investors also divide the portfolio by “types” of dividend growth stocks. We have stocks with low yields with high growth, medium yield and medium growth and high yield with low growth. It shouldn’t surprise fellow investors that as a 25 years old investor, I prefer the first and second group. However, I also buy shares from the third group for current income as well as diversification. I think that Wisconsin Energy has the potential to be a great investment, as it might offer great starting yield with robust growth especially for a utility company. All that comes as WEC is a regulated company with ROE of over 12%. The outcome of the merger The new Wisconsin Energy is the leading electric and natural gas utility in the Midwest. It has acquired a new growth platform, and it will allow it to access many more clients in the Midwest. Currently, it serves 4.4 million customers which get electricity and gas from the company. It also owns gas and electric infrastructure in several states. The merger has increased the long term debt of the company significantly over the past year. The debt was issued in order to pay for the cash part of the acquisition. However, WEC prioritize to minimize the effects of the additional debt and interest on its free cash flow. It has bought TEG for a relatively low premium when compared to others, and the additional debt didn’t decrease its credit rating. The merger allowed the 8% dividend increase in June, and raised the EPS growth guidance. At the same time, credit rating is intact and the company is managing its debt wisely. The synergies between the companies will allow additional cost savings and higher profit margins. The chairman and the CEO is very happy with the merger result: Since the close of the acquisition at the end of the second quarter, we have made significant progress in focusing our six operating utilities on world-class reliability, customer satisfaction, and financial discipline. I’m very pleased with our post-acquisition work, and we remain highly confident that the merger will deliver tangible benefits to our customers, to the communities we serve, and to the stockholders who count on us to create value. The great management is confident with the merger, and the metrics support their confidence. Revenue, EPS and dividend are up, and margins are regulated by the regulator, but still reach double digits. All this happens in a large utility company that doesn’t receive enough credit from investors. Fundamentals I have discussed the historical fundamentals lengthy in my previous article. I will briefly write the main metrics, and then show the future fundamentals estimates that make me so comfortable with Wisconsin Energy. Revenue growth is irrelevant due to the huge acquisition that resulted in massive growth of the revenue and the amount of shares outstanding. EPS grew over the past decade at a CAGR of over 7%, while dividend grew at a CAGR of over 14%, both figures are impressive. The dividend and EPS are forecasted to grow at around 7% in 2016, and 6% late on. The company is willing to maintain its 67% payout ratio, and is sure in its ability to grow EPS at a CAGR of 6% for the long run. The management is committed to its dividend which is great, and it know it has to manage the debt. Currently, the company enjoys good credit rating. The company has now many more shares due to the merger, and I believe that after some deleveraging, it will use some of its excess FCF to repurchase its shares. Buyback is not something that WEC hasn’t tried already. It used $300 million to buyback its own shares back in 2014. Opportunities Wisconsin Energy is spread across several states and therefore have exposure to several regulators. Indeed, it has the largest exposure to Wisconsin’s legislatures, but the larger spread is an advantage. Moreover, the regulator is acting in stable and fair way towards the company. It allows fair ROE, and doesn’t require too many harsh and expensive measures. The declining price of natural gas is a great opportunity. Wisconsin Energy is pretty green company that uses mostly natural gas and not coal. The whole electric infrastructure is going now towards natural gas which is much cleaner. The lower price will help the company to save money, and the fact that it uses natural gas already will reduce capex that related to transforming coal power plants to gas power plants. On top of that, Wisconsin Energy is a monopoly that enjoys a promises stream of revenues. Indeed, there is tight regulation that comes with it, but still, the company proved that they know how to deal with the regulation and show high ROE and growing revenue, EPS and dividends. Risk The larger amount of debt that the company carries is a risk. Especially now after the probability for raising interest rates is higher. In a higher interest rate environment, the interest expenses will be higher. Yet, the management is aware of that, and is willing to manage the debt carefully until they lower the debt levels. Moreover, the regulation is favorable toward Wisconsin Energy now, but it might change in the future. Expensive laws can forced upon the company, and tighter regulation might demand lower ROE from Wisconsin Energy. Both these measures can harm EPS substantially. Another important point is the lower return on equity. Since the acquisition the return on equity is lower than it used to be. This is due to the acquisition itself, and management will have to take care of it as soon as possible as the decline was pretty sharp. Valuation Valuation may seem a little bit high to some investors, but I disagree. The valuation is fair, and after today’s 4% decline in the stock price it is even more fair. I find the price today reasonable for initiating a new position. WEC PE Ratio (NYSE: TTM ) data by YCharts The forward P/E on this year is 18.15 and for next year it is less than 17. I find it to be reasonable, because you actually buy value with your money. I always like to buy value for cheap, but I don’t mind paying fair price for value as well. Conclusion I will start with a quote and a graph from the latest presentation: WEC is the only company in the S&P Electric Index, S&P Utilities Index, Philadelphia Utility Index and Dow Jones Utilities Average that has grown earnings per share and dividends per share every year for the past 12 years. If you buy Wisconsin Energy now, you buy some real value especially for a utility company. You buy 3.7% dividend yield that will grow at around 6% every year for the medium term, and you get it from a monopoly that knows how to deal with the regulation, deliver good product and satisfy both its customers and its shareholders.