Summary Karoon is a depressed stock trading 20% below cash backing due to a low oil price, and several major shareholders exiting the stock. A major selloff has resulted in Karoon being significantly undervalued. Provides fantastic long term exposure to a rising oil price with 85 mmbbls of 2C reserves from 2 recent oil discoveries. Karoon Gas is currently in the process of buying back up to 10% of stock on issue. Overview Karoon Gas (ASX: KAR, OTCPK:KRNGF , OTC:KRNGY ) is an Australia-headquartered oil and gas company with exploration opportunities focused in North-West Australia, Peru, and Brazil. With a set of great oil prospects, and no major gas prospects, they should consider changing their name to Karoon Oil. Of all the sell-offs in the oil and gas sector, this one has intrigued me the most. On a market cap of AU$450 (US$319) Million at the current share price, they sit on cash of AU$550 (US$390) Million. This cash came from their recent sale of their Browse Basin permits to Origin for the following: An upfront payment of US$600 Million (Received) A deferred cash payment of US$75 Million payable on FID A deferred cash payment of US$75 Million payable on first production A deferred cash payment of US$5 Million for every 100 BCFe of independently certified 2P reserves exceeding 3.25 TCFe Reimbursement of the costs associated with drilling its 40% held Pharos-1 well. (Received) So why are they trading so low? Apart from the oil price, I think it is primarily due to these 3 factors: Several major investors have exited the stock over the last year. IOOF Holdings, Future Fund Board of Guardians, and Paradise Investment Management all ceased to be substantial holders, selling out a major portion of the stock. The company has some corporate governance issues. There are concerns that family members of the chairman Bob Hosking are appointed on key positions at the company, as pointed out by the activist hedge fund manager Pegasus. The majority of shareholders may or may not agree with this, and I myself have questions regarding it, but none of the three candidates that Pegasus put up for election were voted in. A lot of Australian companies have corporate governance issues, and activist investment is much lower than in the US. Like any market risk, this is a risk that must be weighed against the benefits. Speculators pushed the price up to obscene levels, and then pushed the price back down in fear Despite these issues, Karoon has a great track record of increasing the long-term value of shareholders when you normalize for the boom and bust cycle. Past speculation during the boom had driven the share price as high as $12.10 – it currently sits at $1.81 at the time of writing. Karoon is, at present, up over 950% from 2004 and has managed to unlock plenty of cash for the exploration and appraisal of their major Brazil operation in the Santos Basin. (click to enlarge) ( Google Finance ) Offshore Brazil (Two Significant Oil Discoveries) The map below shows the Kangaroo and Echidna resource as well as the Bilby oil discovery dating back to 2014. (click to enlarge) ( Source – Karoon Annual Report 2015) Kangaroo went through further appraisal in 2014, production testing at rates that signaled a single vertical well could flow 6,000-8,000 bopd from a net pay of 135 meters ( Source ). It needs to be noted that Kangaroo 2 also had two side tracks as part of the appraisal that indicate that this may be a complex reservoir which would enhance the cost and difficulty of production. Despite the complexity, it remains a significant find that has a great chance of commerciality. Echidna followed up the Kangaroo discovery with a 103 meter net oil column and a facility constrained flow test 4650 bopd, further enhancing the chance of a commercial discovery for the region. (click to enlarge) ( Source ) From an operational perspective , Karoon is looking at a variety of options for producing the Echidna and Kangaroo discoveries that are less than 50km apart. The lowest capital cost method includes a Floating Production Storage and Offloading Vessel (FPSO) producing roughly 20,000 barrels of oil per day (bopd), then expanding that to 50,000 – 70,000 bopd once the field has been proven. Discussions for the development of Kangaroo have also involved Petrobras for an integrated oil hub in the region, which could be economic as low as $43/bbl according to Citigroup ( Source ). The same article also denotes the drop in costs which could make the project economic at even lower prices “Because it’s a distressed market now worldwide, we are looking at redeployed assets, for example, a redeployed FPSO [floating production storage and offloading vessel]. The labor market is getting cheaper, the labor is getting cheaper; we see there’s a lot of cost savings for us.” One of the primary reasons for investing in Karoon is that there is almost no value attributed to the Kangaroo and Echidna discoveries. After writing off Karoon’s AU$105 (US$76) million tax liability against its cash reserves, the 2C reserves equate to a value of AU$0.41 (US$0.29) /bbl. However, investors must keep in mind that production isn’t likely oncoming until 2018 at the earliest while Karoon moves through engineering and approvals, and this may hold the share price back for the medium term. Offshore Peru and Offshore Australia After all this, Karoon still has more to offer. A possibility of more major discoveries exists offshore Peru and Australia. Nearly 27000 square kilometers of permits sit on the acreage outside of Brazil, with significant long-term potential for Karoon. They have a habit of bringing in joint venture partners to free carry them through the initial drilling stages to minimize the capital outlay from Karoon. These are likely to sit for several years during the current supply glut, however, they provide some great upside for an oil recovery. (click to enlarge) (Karoon Annual Report 2015) Share Buyback One of my favorite things to see a company do is an all-cash share buyback – specifically when their share price is trading at an all-time low. Karoon has bought back 9.4 million shares at $3.27 over the last 12 months as well as announcing plans to buy back a further 25 million shares. That comprises up to 10% of the company’s ordinary shares on issue and will further expose investors to the upside of an oil price recovery in 2-3 years. On top of all that, Karoon has a significant amount of built up exploration expense of $AU485 Million that can be written off against future cash flows. Risks and Uncertainties Karoon is in the early stages of several significant oil discoveries. There are plenty of issues that need to be sorted out, and a significant amount of cash that needs to be spent to bring these oil fields into production. Production is not likely to begin for several years, and the oil price currently sits at levels that would make these projects uneconomic. Most investors would agree that the current supply glut will not extend out to 2018, however, it is possible and poses a significant risk as Karoon spends more on the appraisal process. Karoon also has no source of cash flow, and Origins deferred payments are unlikely in the current environment. Conclusion Having several major investors exit the stock over the last 18 months has left the share price in the doldrums. While Citigroup has calculated a combined development for Kangaroo and Echidna would be economic as low as $43, I would not expect the project to go ahead unless oil moved well into the 60’s – unless the resource is found to be much larger than current estimates. There is plenty of unrealized value in this stock with hardly any value attributed to the Kangaroo and Echidna discoveries, and no value to the significant amount of exploration expense that Karoon can write off against future cash flow. Karoon’s cash reserves can be used to develop these discoveries and increase shareholder value at the same time the share buyback is increasing investors oil exposure per share. As for the remaining Australian/Peruvian blocks, Karoon will likely delay drilling as much as possible to preserve cash for the Kangaroo and Echidna discoveries. Overall, there is a significant amount of risk around Karoon going forward. They are in the early stages of appraising these reservoirs while the oil price has crashed. However, a crashed oil price means cheaper drilling, completions, procurement, and construction. Karoon would not be likely to produce oil until 2018 at the earliest, and there is plenty of time for the oil price to recover in that time period. As the Financial Review quoted from an RBC Capital Markets report “Whilst high risk, this is a freebie and success would open a significant new oil play.” I love Karoon as an asymmetric bet on an oil recovery, and I can confidently see an upside of well over 100% in the next 3-5 years in the event that the oil price recovers. Editor’s Note: This article discusses one or more securities that do not trade on a major U.S. exchange. Please be aware of the risks associated with these stocks.