Exploring The Highest-Yielding, Dividend-Raising Utility
In a screen for the highest-yielding, dividend-raising utility I came across a Houston-based company with a 5%+ dividend yield. This company has provided solid investment results over the past decade. This article looks at what you might expect moving forward based on the company’s commentary. For dividend-oriented investors, David Fish’s list of Dividend Champions, Contenders and Challenges is the place to get your bearings. It’s nice because it provides you with a great subset of the types of securities you might be looking for: companies that have not only paid but also increased their dividend payments for at least 5, 10 and 25 years. Still, there are hundreds of names from which you can explore. As such, it can be helpful to whittle down the list to discover pockets of the investing world one by one. As an example, you might organize the list by utilities and then by “current” dividend yield. Naturally screens come with a bevy of limitations, but for exploration sake they work quite well. If you completed this exercise, you would notice that CenterPoint Energy (NYSE: CNP ) happened to be the highest-yielding, dividend-raising utility. Let’s explore. Tracing its roots back to 1866 , CenterPoint Energy began as the Houston Gas Light Company. Today the company has more than 7,400 employees serving more than 5 million customers. The business operates in four basic areas: natural gas distribution, electric transmission, natural gas sales and heating and cooling services. The largest segment is the Texas utility serving the Houston area, hence the utility category. However, the company also has a 55.4% limited partner interest in Enable Midstream Partners (NYSE: ENBL ), a natural gas and crude oil infrastructure pipeline. Incidentally, this also explains why CenterPoint has an above average yield – even when compared to other utilities. The payout ratio is well above average, and the share price has declined materially during the last year. Let’s take a look at the company’s history moving from 2005 through 2014: CNP Revenue Growth -0.6% Start Profit Margin 2.3% End Profit Margin 6.6% Earnings Growth 11.7% Yearly Share Count 3.7% EPS Growth 8.7% Start P/E 19 End P/E 17 Share Price Growth 6.9% % Of Divs Collected 54% Start Payout % 60% End Payout % 67% Dividend Growth 10.1% Total Return 10.0% The above table demonstrates an interesting story. On the top line the company actually had lower revenues in 2014 as compared to 2005. Yet this alone did not prevent the company from generating solid returns. The quality of those sales improved dramatically, resulting in total earnings growth of nearly 12% per year. Ordinarily this number is boosted by a reduction in share count. In the case of utilities, the opposite usually occurs. CenterPoint Energy has been no exception: increasing its common shares outstanding from about 310 million in 2005 to almost 430 million last year. As such, the earnings-per-share growth trailed total company profitability – leading to almost 9% average annual increases. Investors were willing to pay a lower valuation at the end of the period, resulting in 6.9% yearly capital appreciation. Moreover, investors saw a 3% starting dividend yield grow by 10% annually, resulting in total returns of about 10% per annum. In other words, despite the lack of revenue growth and P/E compression, shareholders still would have enjoyed a solid return. This was a direct result of strong underlying earnings growth and a solid and increasing dividend payment. Moving forward, looking at the investment with a similar lens can be helpful. Since the end of 2014, both the share price and expected earnings have declined materially as a result of the broader energy environment. For this fiscal year the company has provided full-year earnings guidance of $1.00 to $1.10 per diluted share – well below the $1.40 earned last year. Still, the company has indicated that it expects to keep the dividend at its current rate, resulting in a 90%+ payout ratio for the time being (this simultaneously equates to 60% to 70% utility operations payout ratio). Moreover, CenterPoint has indicated that it expects to grow its dividend in-line with EPS growth (forecasted at 4% to 6% annually) through 2018. This isn’t speculation on my part or a collection of analyst’s estimates. Instead, its what the company is telling you to expect. Granted they could certainly turn out to be incorrect, but it should be somewhat reassuring given their greater stakes, more to lose, higher company knowledge, etc. Here’s what the next three years of dividend payments could look like with 5% annual growth: 2016 = $1.04 2017 = $1.09 2018 = $1.15 In total an investor might expect to collect $3.28 in aggregate dividend payments, or roughly 18% of the recent share price. Without any capital appreciation whatsoever, this would equate to 5.6% annualized returns. With a future earnings multiple of say 17, this would equate to a total yearly gain of about 8.9% over the three-year period. This is how I’d begin to think about an investment in CenterPoint Energy. You might perform a similar screen and come across the company. Yet this alone does not mean that it’s a worthwhile opportunity. Just because a company has an above average yield doesn’t mean that it’s a great investment. There are other factors at play. However, it does mean that the “investing bar” is relatively lower. A higher starting dividend yield, especially when coupled with reasonable growth, means that a good portion of your return will be generated via cash received. In this case you could see 5% or 6% annual returns without any capital appreciation. From there, if capital appreciation does come along, your investment returns start to approach the double digits. Finally, it’s important to be prudent in these assumptions as the slower growing nature of the business creates an out-sized emphasis on the valuation paid. You could see years of slow or moderate growth outweighed by compression in the earnings multiple. As such, a cautious approach is likely most sensible: expecting to receive a solid and above average dividend yield without the simultaneous anticipation of wide price swings to the upside.