Category Archives: oud

An Unexpected Reason Behind This Strategy’s Outperformance

One of the great anomalies of investing: the historical long-term outperformance of certain smart beta or factor-based strategies relative to the broader equity market (think choosing stocks based on their valuations, momentum, low volatility or quality metrics such as profitability). For example, according to data from MSCI, the MSCI USA Minimum Volatility (USD) index’s Sharpe ratio, a common way to measure risk-adjusted returns, was 0.61 for the last ten years, above the benchmark MSCI USA Index’s 0.44 ratio. The persistence of smart beta strategies’ outperformance relative to the broader market is surprising, because it doesn’t line up with the idea of an efficient market, one in which investors shouldn’t be able to simultaneously buy and sell securities for a profit without taking extra risk (the so-called “no arbitrage” principle ). In other words, in an efficient market, equity portfolios exhibiting low volatility, for instance, shouldn’t be able to earn comparable returns to their higher-risk counterparts. It’s no wonder, then, that numerous academic and financial industry research papers have been written on this topic, and there are various explanations for factor strategies’ outperformance. According to BlackRock’s smart beta experts, including my fellow Blog contributor Sara Shores, this outperformance can generally be attributed to a risk premium, structural impediment or behavioral anomaly. In other words, the outperformance is to compensate investors for taking on what’s actually a higher level of risk, a reflection of market supply-and-demand dynamics or the result of common decision-making biases. Personally, no shocker for my regular readers, I think explanations for this return performance anomaly rooted in behavioral finance add valuable insights to the discussion. In today’s highly connected world, where we can follow each other’s every move via social media, where we’re bombarded by data from every angle – including information on other investors’ positioning and trades – and where it can be hard to tune out the noise, human behavior may be a stronger performance driver than ever. Put another way, I believe investor behavior likely has a lot to do with the strategies’ outperformance. Behavioral explanations focus on investors’ cognitive biases, and the human tendency to use simple rules of thumb to make quick intuitive decisions, with individuals’ collective decision-making mistakes translating into security price distortions. Here’s a look at explanations for the outperformance of four commonly used equity factors. Value: Value stocks are ones that appear cheap in light of their sales, earnings and cash flow trends. Their returns, according to proponents of the efficient market hypothesis, have to do with investors rationally requiring extra compensation for investing in value firms, which tend to be procyclical, have high leverage and have uncertain cash flows. From a behavioral finance perspective, the outperformance of the value factor may have to do with a common decision-making mistake: people’s tendency to look at recent data trends and believe those trends will continue . If investors extrapolate past positive sales or earnings growth data into the future, they may overpay for growth stocks and underpay for value stocks. As a result, the prices of growth stocks may become too high relative to their fundamentals, predicting future reversal and the outperformance of value stocks. Alternatively, some researchers believe people’s tendency to strongly prefer avoiding losses over achieving gains (known as loss aversion) can help explain this anomaly . They hypothesize that loss-averse investors may perceive value stocks as riskier than they truly are, given the stocks’ recent underperformance, and may therefore require a higher future return from these investments. Momentum: This factor focuses on stocks that have strong price momentum , i.e., they have performed well over the past 6-12 months, and strong fundamental momentum, i.e. their earnings have recently been revised upward by security analysts. One explanation for this factor’s outperformance: Investors rationally demanding a higher return for investing in momentum stocks, which tend to be highly correlated and are perceived to perform poorly in times of distress. The behavioral finance explanation for this equity factor’s outperformance, on the other hand, has to do with analysts and investors putting too much weight on their prior beliefs at the expense of new information, leading to slow dissemination of firm-specific information , delayed price reactions to news and price continuation. For example, if investors like a stock and believe it has high earnings growth potential, they tend not to immediately adjust their beliefs sufficiently in light of new negative information – an investing mistake arising in behavioral finance from ” the anchoring-and-adjustment heuristic .” In other words, investors frequently drive price trends by projecting past wins onto future investments, creating a ” herding effect .” Quality: Quality generally describes financially healthy firms with high return on equity, with stable earnings growth and low financial leverage. They can effectively be characterized as having less risk based on their fundamentals . Behaviorally, people may ignore these potentially profitable, yet also perhaps more boring, companies, and instead, veer toward potentially more exciting, yet also less stable, growth and lottery-like stocks (for example, because the more exciting stocks tend to be featured in colorful news stories). As a result, they may end up overpaying for the less-stable stocks, which quality strategies seek to avoid. This predicts future reversal and potential outperformance of quality stocks. Low volatility: The low, or minimum volatility, factor loads up on stocks with low volatility. Low volatility stocks’ excess returns may be rationally explained by leverage constraints. In the absence of access to leverage, investors may overpay for high-volatility stocks in an attempt to increase risk in their portfolios, potentially leading lower-volatility stocks to become more attractively valued and outperform in the future. From a behavioral perspective, these stocks’ outperformance may be due people’s tendency to overestimate small, and underestimate, large probabilities . The idea is that this tendency leads to a preference for lottery-like stocks with a small chance of a very high payoff, and this preference, in turn, drives up the prices of high-volatility stocks disproportionately, suggesting future underperformance. Further, overconfident individuals may veer toward riskier securities in expressing their outsized faith in their own investing and stock-picking abilities, exacerbating the anomaly. To be sure, while focusing on factor and smart beta strategies has historically, over longer periods of time, earned higher risk-adjusted returns relative to the broader market, there have been stretches, even long ones, when factor-based approaches underperformed (think value during the 1990s), according to data accessible via Bloomberg . Finally, while in an efficient market, these anomalies should diminish in size and ultimately disappear, a widespread belief in the factors’ outperformance may also become a self-fulfilling prophecy. This post originally appeared on the BlackRock Blog.

How High Is High? How Low Is Low?

How high is high? When asking this question it would also be wise to ponder the following, how low is low? Markets are capable of making extreme moves and we should remember trees don’t grow to the sky and markets don’t go up forever. As someone who has traded commodities for decades I would strongly recommend anyone considering jumping into the super high risk snake pit of commodity trading to steer clear of it. While I have had victories I have also gone through a slew of painful losses and been bludgeoned by markets and price swings that have defied all logic. Adding to a trader’s pain and woes is that when you are caught on the bad side of an ugly trade the speed that a vicious market can dish out its brutal assault is usually extremely underestimated. After over 30 years of trading commodities I will flat out state without any reservations that lies and manipulation run rampant. If you think anyone is looking out for the small independent trader in the stock market or commodity market you are wrong. A recent article caught my interest; it said: It is always darkest before the dawn. In other words, the energy market could see crude-oil prices tumble further in the coming days after closing near seven-year lows. January West Texas Intermediate crude tumbled $2.32, or 5.8%, to settle at $37.65 a barrel. At least one chart pattern followed by technical analysts is pointing to more pain for the WTI contract as oil tilted below $37 a barrel in early Tuesday’s trade. Talk has surfaced of 20 dollar oil at the same time some analyst said it is time for investors to jump in and “pick a bottom” pointing out energy stocks are now a bargain. History has shown that markets defy logic and our opinions are often wrong. Five years ago few market gurus predicted oil would trade at such low prices today. It is difficult to say where the price of oil will be next month. After asking the question of how high is high I must also ask, how low is low? Markets can make extreme or wild moves that charts often are unable to predict. This means it is both dangerous and difficult to pick a market top or bottom. Various technical trading systems while indicating an overbought or oversold market fail when asked to answer these two questions that would make us infallible and legendary investors. Today markets have added a couple new dimensions that will play an interesting role in just how violent and savage price swings are going forward. One of those is that computers now do a great deal of the trading and they are programmed to prey on the weaknesses of human trader using computing programs that exploit where stops are placed, this improves their ability to wash the weak out of their positions. Another factor is many people have grown far to complacent. The “buy the dip” mentality and the idea that the central banks coupled with the too big to fail financial institutions will keep these distorted markets elevated has become entrenched in the minds of many investors. This has lessened the importance of economic fundamentals and the question of how sustainable this market is. It has also put on the back-burner the question and issue of, how high is high. I have seen and heard far too many comments by those bullish on higher equity prices and ever higher markets basing their strategy on a policy of “don’t fight the Fed” and “buy the dips.” While this has worked since 2009 it is no guarantee that it will continue to produce positive results in the future. The “buy the dip mantra” will prove very costly when a real drop in the market does occur. A saying often used cautions traders they should never try to catch a falling knife. One problem we face in the current stock market is a lack of traders holding short positions. Several of the stocks that were recently on strong uptrends appear at heart to be fundamentally unstable and may have been driven higher by bears capitulating and buying back their positions rather than market fundamentals. We have witnessed massive moves in several speculative stocks like Amazon (NASDAQ: AMZN ), Tesla (NASDAQ: TSLA ), and Netflix (NASDAQ: NFLX ) that are hard to defend by any other reasoning than shorts being squeezed out of the market. It is logical to think the higher a market goes the more vulnerable it becomes to a major violent decline or sudden savage downward price moves. A lack of short positions will bode poorly for the market if it falls rapidly because in such a situation as shorts take profit and buy back their positions they act as a floor under the market giving it support. The floor under this market is questionable and with contagion a growing concern it is understandable that junk bonds have begun to take a beating. The point of this post is to remind all of us the world of investing is a dangerous place and that much of how people react to events depends on how things are set up or how the cards are stacked when things happen, develop, and unfold. We often see that market reaction has more to do with timing and perception rather than being driven by reality. The economy tends to develop loops that feed back upon themselves, to this market driver we must add cross border money flows, central bank intervention, currency manipulation, and derivatives. This is only part of the list of pitfalls we face when we develop expectations that drive prices. To top things off we should recognize that at any time an unexpected black swan crisis is always lurking in the wings. This reinforces the idea that we should remain humble in trying to answer the questions of, how high is high, and how low is low. I have learned some valuable lessons over the years: markets don’t go in just one direction, values constantly shift, and after you lose your money it is to late.

Is The Calpine Dip An Opportunity?

Summary Calpine one of the largest power generators in the U.S. and Canada, with ~27,000 megawatts of generation capacity. It’s our belief that this best-in-class operator is being unduly punished by the decline in oil & gas prices. We find the shares to be incredibly attractive at current levels, with an FCF yield of 17.33% (low-end adj. FCF 2016) and EV/EBIT of 13.51. The low commodity prices in natural gas have generate negative sentiment around Calpine (NYSE: CPN ). The company has ~27,000 megawatts of generation capacity, with 97% being natural gas-fired. Normally, you’d think this would be a good thing for the company and its customers, but the market doesn’t see it that way. Anything natural gas-related is being sold, regardless of the underlying fundamentals. The continued drop in oil & gas prices dictates that electricity will remain low. Calpine is still able to generate excess free cash in a low electricity price environment; however, it gets better margins on high prices. With that said, we don’t expect oil & natural gas prices to remain at these depressed levels forever. So, is the dip in Calpine an opportunity to back up the truck in this best-in-class utility operator? The largest provider of electricity from natural gas and geothermal Calpine was founded in 1984, and is one of the largest power generators in the U.S. The company has ~27,000 megawatts of generation capacity from 83 power plants in 19 states and Canada. It has a formidable presence in the increasingly competitive wholesale power markets in the northeastern U.S., California, and Texas. In addition, it owns natural gas and geothermal power plants across North America. (click to enlarge) Essentially, the company’s power generation portfolio consists of natural gas combustion turbines and renewable geothermal conventional steam turbines. (1) Calpine is one of the largest owners of cogeneration plants and industrial gas turbines. (2) It also has one of the largest geothermal power portfolios in the U.S. with its Geyser assets in northern California. The company generates ~15% of renewable energy in California. (click to enlarge) Calpine has strong competitive advantages from its scale, low-cost status, and geographic presence. The natural gas shale revolution has certainly driven down the price of natural gas with the glut in supply. In turn, this has helped the company to generate low-cost electricity from its gas-fired generators. An abundant supply of natural gas and the displacement of older or obsolete power technologies has positioned Calpine to deliver low-cost electricity well into the future. The company’s geothermal power plants position it well against environmental liabilities. (click to enlarge) Calpine’s status as a low-cost provider in the power generation space gives it a big competitive advantage versus competition. The company is well positioned for stricter federal and state environmental regulation, as it has substantially less greenhouse gas emissions than its peers. Competition is increasing in this commodity business As natural gas prices continue to make new lows on a weekly basis, Calpine benefits dramatically. It relies on natural gas to fire its plants. But what happens if there is a dramatic increase in prices for a sustained period of time? We wish we had the answer. Certainly, it represents a risk if natural gas continues increasing in price over the long term. Our view is oil & gas prices in the U.S are likely to be capped for the foreseeable future due to the glut of supply in the market. Alternative energy and solar companies are another threat. This threat is likely to be subdued in a low commodity environment, which makes many of the alternative energy sources more expensive. However, over the long term, renewable energy sources could dramatically hurt Calpine’s business if they gain traction and compete on a cost basis. Main competitors include Atlantic Power (NYSE: AT ), Talen Energy (NYSE: TLN ), Ormat (NYSE: ORA ), NRG Energy (NYSE: NRG ), and Duke Energy (NYSE: DUK ). Long wave of growth potential As we have mentioned before, Calpine’s gas-fired plants should benefit from the ample supply of natural gas in the U.S. over the long term. More importantly, the power industry is one of the largest industries in the U.S. We are all impacted by the generative capabilities of utilities. The deregulation of the power industry presented uncertainty in the markets for a period of time. Wholesale power producers increased competition dramatically and decreased Calpine’s geographic advantages. However, utilities bring with them incredibly high barriers to entry. The secular trends of abundant, affordable natural gas, increased environmental regulations, focus on grid reliability and pay-for-performance, and the need for capacity to help intermittent renewable should pave the way for outsized growth in the future. Management is shareholder-friendly and competent The company generates excess free cash in the amount of ~$700-800 million per year. This leaves plenty of excess capital for share buybacks and dividends in the future. Management has a strong track record of capital allocation that is accretive to shareholders. Since 2010, management has bought companies at an average of ~6x EBITDA, while it has sold companies ~14x EBITDA. It continues to monetize non-core assets through sales or contracts, and is firmly committed to returning capital to shareholders with the excess free cash that the company is generating. (click to enlarge) Bottom Line It’s our belief that this best-in-class operator is being unduly punished by the decline in oil & gas prices. The entire sector continues to get beaten up, while Calpine continues to generate excess free cash. The secular trends of abundant, affordable natural gas, increased environmental regulations, focus on grid reliability and pay-for-performance, and the need for capacity to help intermittent renewable should pave the way for outsized growth in the future. In addition, the company has $6.9 billion in NOLs that still need to be worked through. The market appears to be pricing Calpine for dead, as it trades at a substantial discount to its replacement cost. We find the shares to be incredibly attractive at current levels, with an FCF yield of 17.33% (low-end adj. FCF 2016) and EV/EBIT of 13.51. Future dividends and buybacks should prove to be additional catalysts for this heavily undervalued company. While we are not huge fans of the power generation business, Calpine should do very well for investors over time. Notable Shareholders: Bill Miller | Altalis Capital | Rivulet Capital | Addison Clark Please share your thoughts in the comments section below as I learn just as much from you as you do from me. It can be a timely endeavor, but I answer all of your comments and questions myself. Your patience and understanding is greatly appreciated. I will get to your comments as soon as possible. 🙂 (Source of the above figures: Company Presentation )