Category Archives: oud

Generating 15% Returns Using The Growth Rating System

Summary How the Growth Score is created. What Growth related ratios I focus on from a value viewpoint. Types of stocks produced from the Growth Score. The Growth Score Introduction The backtests for this Growth Score show that it’s another winner at 15.3%. Previously I showed the Quality Score generating 16.8% and the Value Score achieving 16.7% . Creating the Growth rating was harder than I thought as I don’t have much of a typical “growth” mindset. My interpretation and focus on growth has to do with the qualitative side. “Growth” questions I ask myself are things like; what other industries or creative ways is the company executing to grow? is the industry large enough to accommodate more growth by the company? is the industry also growing or shrinking? (sample questions you can add to your own checklist) I look for stocks that are solid fundamentally and in a position to grow. I don’t search for stocks based on how much revenue, earnings or other numbers have grown over the past years. Relative strength and other technical indicators are beyond me also. That’s the approach I took here as well. Rather than search for high flyers, what the Growth Rating really represents are stocks with positive growth who are growing by utilizing their assets well. I’m going to share the full details with you. Just don’t focus too much on the 15.3% returns. The 15.3% returns from the backtest is just theoretical proof that this works on paper. In other words, the strategy itself is a winner. But what I really want to show is how and why this works. Analyzing the Results First the numbers on a yearly basis. As I pointed out in the quality score, I focused on reducing drawdown as much as possible. Drawdowns are a huge problem with mechanical strategies and since you end up buying stocks you don’t know, it’s easy to give up. And since I create tests and strategies based on 1 year holding periods, the drawdowns are larger than trading systems where you buy and sell about 20 stocks a day. As much as I don’t like drawdowns, I also don’t believe in frequent trading as it eats away your portfolio with fees as you end up playing the same game as the traders. They will out trade you with their eyes closed. Now, there are really 3 bad years here where the Growth Rating seriously underperformed. 2007, 2008 and 2014 where 2008 was horrific with a -44% decline. That’s close to half of a portfolio being wiped out. 2009 more than made up for it, but 2008 is enough to make anyone puke. However, when coupled with Q and V, the final combined Action Score performed marvelously well in 2008. That’s the power of combining Q, V and G all together. But I’ll be talking about the Action Score in another post. How I Created the Growth Score I kept the max number of criteria to 4. The more filters a stock has to pass, the bigger the drop in performance. Just because stocks can pass a 8 point checklist, it doesn’t mean it’s a buy. It could be the total opposite where you are too strict and end up only allowing mediocre upside stocks to pass through. Here’s what I narrowed the Growth criteria to: TTM sales percentage change: greater than zero 5 year sales CAGR: greater than zero Gross Profit to Asset Ratio (GPA): greater than 1 Piotroski F Score: higher the better Here’s the initial backtest I performed that proved I was onto something. This is a 20 stock portfolio backtest. Growth Score Backtest – Full Universe Woah. Deep breath. Just theoretical returns. After eliminating OTC stocks, financials, energy, mining and utilities, the results continue the outperformance. Growth Score Backtest w/ no OTC, Financials, Energy, Mining or Utilities Based on this data, I’m really excited because the combination of metrics I’m using is validated and it’s not a borderline combination. The ugly spike in the first backtest is gone. Most likely from an OTC stock that exploded temporarily and crashed back down. Rationale for Each Criteria TTM Sales Percentage Change > 0 The goal here is to look for stocks that actually grew. I’m not interested in high flyers and wall street darlings. I’m really looking for growth stocks with a strong value flavor. 5 Year Sales CAGR > 0 Same thing as above. I don’t want companies that are perennial losers for 5 years or more. Gross Profit to Asset Ratio (GPA) This ratio deserves an article of its own. In this case though, it has the biggest positive effect on the results. Comparing gross profit to assets tells you whether or not the assets are profitable. In other words, GPA measures the growth of profitability. When I look for stocks with a GPA above 1, I’m saying that I want stocks that are generating more than a dollar for every $1 of asset. A GPA of 0.5 means the company is generating profits of $0.50 for every dollar of assets. You can see how this is also a great way to compare competitors within the same industry. Piotroski F Score I include the F score for quality and value. Best way to filter out horrific stocks so that it doesn’t cloud the results. A Rating System is NOT a Screener I have to repeat this because I get this question about the results often. Since my goal is building a rating system where every stock is scored and ranked, it’s very different to a screener. A screener is to simply get stocks that pass specific numbers. A rating system may have stocks at the top of the list that fail certain criteria. That’s why each variable is weighted in the final formula. Stocks outside of the ideal ranges are penalized. You’ll see what I mean in the list of 2015 stocks below. Top 20 Growth Stocks from 2015 If you look at the GPA column, only 4 stocks meet the criteria of being 1 or above. That’s what I meant by a rating system being different to a screener. If you bought these 20 stocks at the beginning of the year, you’d be looking at a price return of 1%. Sure I’d love to have shown you the growth stocks exploding and defying the struggles of 2015, but the final Action Score is so much better and you’ll be amazed at the results. Watch out the for the final part of how the OSV Ratings have been created. Disclosure: Long GILD

How Many Stocks Should You Own? Remember Warren Buffett’s Advice

Summary Diversification is trumpeted as a key point of proper portfolio design. Warren Buffett disagrees with diversification, with a single caveat. The return spread among stocks suggest that every new holding you add is more likely to be a loser than a winner. If you asked SeekingAlpha readers why investors should own more than one stock, the overwhelming response would easily be diversification. The idea is simple: the more holdings you have, the less exposure you have to unsystematic risk (risk associated with a particular company or industry). Now, if you asked a follow-up question, “How many stock holdings you should have?”, you would end up with a hotly debated topic. On page 129 of my copy of The Intelligent Investor , legendary money manager Benjamin Graham advocates holding 10 to 30 positions. Modern portfolio theory supported this advice, and many continue to follow its preachings religiously. According to this theory, if you own 20 well-diversified companies, each held in equal amounts, you’ve eliminated 70% of risk (as measured by standard deviation) and reduced volatility. Can’t argue with the math (or can you?), and diversification has been harped on by many as the foundation of any properly constructed portfolio. It is likely that anyone that has had a financial advisor or even discussed finances with a family friend has heard this advice before. Always spread your capital across multiple sectors and markets is in that person’s best interest. Makes sense right? Who doesn’t want less volatility and risk? Warren Buffett apparently. “Diversification is protection against ignorance. It makes very little sense for those who know what they’re doing.” – The Oracle of Omaha Himself So, Do You Know What You’re Doing? Of course, modern portfolio theory and its offshoots were theorized between the ’50s and ’70s. Volatility is up since then, and stocks have become increasingly uncorrelated with the underlying market. To more clearly illustrate this point, stocks increasingly don’t follow a normal distribution pattern: * Source: Investopedia The results of the above image have been repeated over and over in recent market studies. The key takeaway for an individual investor is that the odds of a stock you own outperforming the stock market is actually worse than 50/50 , contrary to what many investors might think off hand. The reason for this is because overall market returns have been boosted by just a handful of “superstar” stocks, like Apple (NASDAQ: AAPL ) or Microsoft (NASDAQ: MSFT ). If you don’t own something like the next Apple or Microsoft in your portfolio (roughly 1 in 16 odds), then well, you’re likely doomed to underperform. So if you have a portfolio of 16 stocks, what are the odds you have that one in sixteen superstar company included based on random chance? Just 38%. Let us say you get lucky and manage to stumble upon a superstar. Now the question is whether you will continue to hold it as it multiplies. Enter the disposition effect . Retail investors have a tendency to sell winners (realizing gains too early) and hold onto losers, following the thought process that today’s losers are tomorrow’s winners. How many investors held on to Apple from $7.00/share in the early 2000’s all the way up to more than $700.00/share (split-adjusted) today? The answer is likely very few. Retail investors took the profit from the double or triple (if they even held that long) and likely didn’t reinvest back in because they had sold in the past. None of this changes the fact that the more companies you own, the more you will inevitably track the index of the positions you hold. In order to generate alpha (abnormal return adjusted for risk), it is a fact that the more stocks you own, the less likely you will be able to generate that alpha. The more holdings you have, the more likely you will have just tracked the index that your holdings are a part of, but in an inefficient way. For all your trouble, you are out both your free time and likely higher trading costs. The question then is why bother with all the headaches of investing in numerous individual companies you buy individually, if you could simply just buy the index and take it easy? If you take a look at major hedge fund and money manager holdings, it is clear that concentrated holdings are used to drive alpha. Visiting the Oracle of Omaha’s portfolio, the man clearly practices what he says. The top five holdings of Berkshire Hathaway (NYSE: BRK.A ) (NYSE: BRK.B )[Wells Fargo (NYSE: WFC ), Kraft Heinz (NASDAQ: KHC ), Coca Cola (NYSE: KO ), IBM (NYSE: IBM ), and American Express (NYSE: AXP )] constituted 67% of his portfolio as of September 30, 2015. 43 scattered holdings constituted the remaining 33%. As for diversifying across sectors versus buying what you know and understand, 37% of Buffett’s holdings fall in the Consumer Staples sector and 35% in Financials. The man clearly doesn’t buy utilities just because portfolio theory tells him he should in order to reduce his risk. Conclusion Thousands of people will read this article. Are you smarter than two thirds of them? If you don’t believe that, buy ETFs, sit back, and be content with market returns. If you think you’re smarter than two thirds of readers of this article (I suspect 95% of you believe that), then the takeaway is slightly different. Diversification, for the sake of diversification, is stupid. Buy what you know, can understand, and believe in the long-term potential of. Don’t understand bank stocks? Reading their SEC filings even gives me headaches, and I work at one. If you don’t understand the company, chances are you aren’t going to pick a winner other than by dumb luck. You shouldn’t lose sleep at night for not having exposure to an industry you can’t adequately review, and it is likely your portfolio returns will thank you for it. As far as how many positions to have, hold as few positions as you are comfortable with when it comes to risk and volatility in order to increase alpha on your high conviction positions. For most investors, that sweet spot still likely falls within modern portfolio theory guidance, around 15 to 25.

New Valuation Approach – PTR: PTR-Based Fund Delivers Over 63% Annual Returns In Big Data Simulations

A new approach to stock valuation looks at the relationship of the stock price to the value of the patent technology owned by the firm. Simulations indicate that stocks with low price-to-technology ratios outperform the market. Investors may wish to include PTR valuations as part of a stock-screening exercise. A former student approached me with a new model for stock valuation that appears to have great promise. Wisdomain.com has a database with comprehensive information on patents which has been used by intellectual property professionals to manage technology. Recently, the company figured out a Price/Technology ratio that appears to be a powerful tool for screening technology investments. PTR challenges the conventional principles of long-term value investing. It takes a completely objective approach to valuation through the mining of intellectual property big data and combining it with financial big data. It is an investment indicator that provides insights into the future performance of investments by identifying undervalued companies that possess patented technologies. Because patent valuation is technology valuation, PTR uses a proprietary algorithm based on technology valuation and total market capitalization data to identify undervalued technology companies. PTR = Market Capitalization Σ (Total Value of Patents) Σ (Total Value of Patents) = Total Technology Asset Value Technology assets play a key role in facilitating the competitiveness of a company in most industries. Since the sum of the value of all of the patents owned by a company is a good proxy for the value of the technology assets owned, it can be considered to be tied to the future potential profitability of the company. Although the formula is similar to the P/E ratio in that the companies with relatively lower PTR values are considered to be the undervalued companies, it is also completely different. Historical simulations of a PTR index formed by PTR funds comprised of the top 20 lowest PTR stocks exceed the NASDAQ’s average returns by 46.4% in the 1st year and 71.9% in the 2nd year. Similarly, the simulations show that the low PTR funds outperform the S&P 500 by 5.8% in the 1st month and 78.8% by the 2nd year. The PTR Index outperforms the market 100% of the time during the simulation period, and funds held over longer periods result in higher returns relative to the market. (click to enlarge) Simulation period = 2010-2015; PTR, NASDAQ, and S&P 500 values have been normalized to 1,000; Funds purchased on a daily basis over the course of the simulation period to minimize the effect of daily variations in stock prices and obtain the average performance values of the funds over the investment periods within the simulation period. The PTR investment model shown above is based on long-term investments into funds comprised of 20 low PTR companies. There were individual cases among the 20 lowest PTR stocks where the stock demonstrated negative returns; however, funds created by combining the 20 lowest PTR stocks have been shown to deliver positive returns. Although investments into individual stocks with the lowest PTR values do not guarantee positive returns, the PTR as a stand-alone indicator has proven to be quite successful. The top 15 companies with the lowest PTR values that are currently traded on the NASDAQ and NYSE are as follows. DMRC , ESIO , CKP , RIGL , IMMU , SNMX , UIS , ROVI , SGI , ARRY , OCLR , AMD , IMI , XNPT and HTCH . (click to enlarge) Although the simulations above demonstrate that the PTR is a breakthrough investment indicator for technology-driven companies, analysts are still in the early stages of developing the methodologies to maximize profitability through the application of the PTR. Some interesting findings to date have shown that the PTR stocks in the smaller market capitalization categories demonstrate better performance relative to PTR stocks in the larger market capitalization categories. With this level of performance, it will be interesting to see what else the PTR has in store for us.