Author Archives: Scalper1

Dead-Cat Bounce Or Continued Bull Market? How To Invest If You’re Uncertain

Summary Financial pundits disagree, as usual. No one knows what the future holds. One way of dealing with uncertainty is to stay invested while protecting yourself against intolerable losses. We present a way for investors to do that while maximizing their potential returns. Before the market opened on Wednesday, Mark Hulbert offered a reason to be bullish in a post on Market Watch (“This Stock Market Gauge Predicts Double-Digit Gain For S&P 500″). The gauge Hulbert referred to was a combination of the market’s P/E ratio and the ” Misery Index “, which is the sum of the unemployment and inflation rates. According to Hulbert, the current level is associated with historic annualized stock returns of 13.2%, as indicated in the chart below, which Hulbert included in his column. (click to enlarge) After U.S. markets surged to ~4% gains on Wednesday, following six days of losses, John Auther of the Financial Times, in his video note (“Correction Foretold”) suggested the day’s market action was a “classic dead cat bounce”, and argued that a renewed bull market would depend on a renewal of earnings momentum, which has effectively run out of steam, as the chart he shared below indicates. (click to enlarge) Dealing With Uncertainty One way to deal with this sort of uncertainty is to invest in a handful of securities you think will do well, and hedge against the possiblity that you end up being wrong. That approach is systematized in the hedged portfolio method, which we detailed in a previous post (“Backtesting The Hedged Portfolio Method”). Below we’ll recap how you can built a hedged portfolio yourself, and present an example of a hedged portfolio created for an investor with $100,000 to invest who can’t tolerate a drawdown of more than 15%. Risk Tolerance, Hedging Cost, and Potential Return All else equal, with a hedged portfolio, the greater an investor’s risk tolerance — the greater the maximum drawdown he is willing to risk (his “threshold”) — the lower his hedging cost will be and the higher his expected return will be. In a previous post (“Keeping A Small Nest Egg From Cracking”), we created a hedged portfolio for a small investor who could tolerate a drawdown of as much as 20%. In this case, with an investor who can only tolerate a 15% drawdown, we would expect a lower potential return. Constructing A Hedged Portfolio The process, in broad strokes, is this: Find securities with high potential returns (we define potential return as a high-end, bullish estimate of how the security will perform). Find securities that are relatively inexpensive to hedge. Buy a handful of securities that score well on the first two criteria; in other words, buy a handful of securities with high potential returns net of their hedging costs (or, ones with high net potential returns). Hedge them. The potential benefits of this approach are twofold: If you are successful at the first step (finding securities with high potential returns), and you hold a concentrated portfolio of them, your portfolios should generate decent returns over time. If you are hedged, and your return estimates are completely wrong, on occasion — or the market moves against you — your downside will be strictly limited. How to Implement This Approach Finding securities with high potential returns. For this, you can use Seeking Alpha Pro , among other sources. Seeking Alpha articles often include price targets for long ideas, and you can convert these to percentage returns from current prices. But you’ll need to use the same time frame for each of your expected return calculations to facilitate comparisons of expected returns, hedging costs, and net expected returns. Our method starts with calculations of six-month potential returns. Finding securities that are relatively inexpensive to hedge. For this step, you’ll need to find hedges for the securities with high potential returns, and then calculate the hedging cost as a percentage of position value for each security. Whatever hedging method you use, for this example, you’d want to make sure that each security is hedged against a greater-than-15% decline over the time frame covered by your potential return calculations. Our method attempts to find optimal static hedges using collars as well as protective puts. Buying securities that score well on the first two criteria. In order to determine which securities these are, you may need to first adjust your potential return calculations by the time frame of your hedges. For example, although our method initially calculates six-month potential returns and aims to find hedges with six months to expiration, in some cases the closest hedge expiration may be five months out. In those cases, we will adjust our potential return calculation down accordingly, because we expect an investor will exit the position shortly before the hedge expires (in general, our method and calculations are based on the assumption that an investor will hold his shares for six months, until shortly before their hedges expire or until they are called away, whichever comes first). Next, you’ll need to subtract the hedging costs you calculated in the previous step from the potential returns you calculated for each position, and sort the securities by their potential returns net of hedging costs, or net potential returns. The securities that come to the top of that sort are the ones you’ll want to consider for your portfolio. Fine-tuning portfolio construction. You’ll want to stick with round lots (numbers of shares divisible by 100) to minimize hedging costs, so if you’re going to include a handful of securities from the sort in the previous step and you have a relatively small portfolio, you’ll need to take into account the share prices of the securities. Stocks such as Priceline.com (NASDAQ: PCLN ), trading at more than $1200 per share, wouldn’t work in a $100,000 hedged portfolio, because the investor wouldn’t be able to purchase one round lot. Another fine-tuning step is to minimize cash that’s leftover after you make your initial allocation to round lots of securities and their respective hedges. Because each security is hedged, you won’t need a large cash position to reduce risk. And since returns on cash are so low now, by minimizing cash you can potentially boost returns. In this step, our method searches for what we call a “cash substitute”: that’s a security collared with a tight cap (1% or the current yield on a leading money market fund, whichever is higher) in an attempt to capture a better-than-cash return while keeping the investor’s downside limited according to his specifications. You could use a similar approach, or you could simply allocate leftover cash to one of the securities you selected in the previous step. Calculating An Expected Return. While net potential returns are bullish estimates of how well securities will perform, net of their hedging costs, expected returns, in our terminology, are the more likely returns net of hedging costs. In a series of 25,412 backtests over an 11 year time period, we determined two things about our method of calculating potential returns: it generates alpha, and it overstates actual returns. The average actual return over the next six months in those 25,412 tests was 0.3x the average potential return calculated ahead of time. So, we use that empirically derived relationship to calculate our expected returns. Example Hedged Portfolio Here is an example of a hedged portfolio created using the general process described above by the automated portfolio construction tool at Portfolio Armor . With that tool, you just enter the dollar amount you are looking to invest and the largest drawdown you are willing to risk (your “threshold” — in this case, 15%), and the tool does the rest. This portfolio was generated as of Wednesday’s close (results will vary at different times, depending on market conditions), and used as its inputs the parameters we mentioned for our hypothetical investor above: a $100,000 to invest, and a goal of maximizing potential return while limiting downside risk, in the worst-case scenario, to a drawdown of no more than 15%. Worst Case Scenario The “Max Drawdown” column in the portfolio level summary shows the worst case scenario for this hedged portfolio. If every security in it went to zero before the hedges expired, the portfolio would decline 14.28%. Negative Hedging Cost Although minimizing hedging cost was only the secondary goal here after maximizing potential return, note that, in this case, the total hedging cost for the portfolio was negative, -0.70%, meaning the investor would receive more income in total from selling the call legs of the collars on his positions than he spent buying the put legs. Best Case Scenario At the portfolio level, the net potential return is 11.76% (as predicted, it’s less than the potential return for the 20% threshold portfolio we alluded to above, which was 17.79%). This represents the best case scenario, if each underlying security in the portfolio meets or exceeds its potential return. A More Likely Scenario The portfolio level expected return of 4.30% represents a more conservative estimate, based on the historical relationship between our calculated potential returns and actual returns. Each Security Is Hedged Note that in the portfolio above, each of the five underlying securities – Foot Locker (NYSE: FL ), Hologic (NASDAQ: HOLX ), Netflix (NASDAQ: NFLX ), the ProShares UltraShort QQQ ETF (NYSEARCA: QID ), and Sketchers (NYSE: SKX ) is hedged. Hedging each security according to the investor’s risk tolerance obviates the need for broad diversification, and lets him concentrate his assets in a handful of securities with high potential returns net of their hedging costs. Here’s a closer look at the hedge for one of these positions, HOLX: As you can see in first part of the image above, HOLX is hedged with an optimal collar with its cap set at 17.44%, which was the potential return Portfolio Armor calculated for the stock: the idea is to capture the potential return while offsetting the cost of hedging by selling other investors the right to buy HOLX if it appreciates beyond that over the next six months.[i] The cost of the put leg of this collar was $1250, or 6.46% of position value, but, as you can see in the image below, the income from the short call leg was $425, or 2.2% as percentage of position value. Since the income from the call leg offset some of the cost of the put leg, the net cost of the optimal collar on HOLX was $825, or 4.26% of position value.[ii] Note that, although the cost of the hedge on this position was positive, the hedging cost of this portfolio as a whole was negative . Why These Particular Securities? Foot Locker, Hologic, Netflix, and Sketchers shares were included as primary securities in this portfolio because, as of Wednesday’s close, they were all among the top securities in Portfolio Armor’s universe when ranked by net potential return, and they had lower share prices than other securities similarly highly ranked. Recall from our discussion above about fine-tuning portfolio construction, that it can be difficult to fit round lots of securities with higher share prices in smaller portfolios. Regarding the inclusion of the inverse ETF QID as a cash substitute here, note that Portfolio Armor is agnostic about whether a security is a stock, ETF or inverse ETF when it ranks them by potential return and hedging cost. QID was included as a cash substitute because it had one of the highest net potential returns when hedged as a cash substitute. Possibly More Protection Than Promised In some cases, hedges such as the ones in the portfolio above can provide more protection than promised. For an example of that, see this recent instablog post on hedging Tesla (NASDAQ: TSLA ). Hedged Portfolios For Investors With Lower Risk Tolerance The hedged portfolio shown above was designed for a small investor who could tolerate a decline of as much as 15% over the next six months, but the same process can be used for investors who are more risk averse, willing to risk drawdowns of as little as 2%. Notes: [i] This hedge actually expires in a little more than 7 months, but the expected returns are based on the assumption that an investor will hold his positions for six months, until they are called away or until shortly before their hedges expire, whichever comes first. [ii] To be conservative, the net cost of the collar was calculated using the bid price of the calls and the ask price of the puts. In practice, an investor can often sell the calls for a higher price (some price between the bid and ask) and he can often buy the puts for less than the ask price (again, at some price between the bid and ask). So, in practice, the cost of this collar would likely have been lower. Disclosure: I/we have no positions in any stocks mentioned, and no plans to initiate any positions within the next 72 hours. (More…) I wrote this article myself, and it expresses my own opinions. I am not receiving compensation for it (other than from Seeking Alpha). I have no business relationship with any company whose stock is mentioned in this article.

Comparing 6 Of The Top International Equity Options

Summary This group of 6 ETFs offers 3 options from Schwab and 3 options from Vanguard. The ETFs that were selected each have a fairly similar match from the other ETF provider. I’m using modern portfolio theory to assess the impact on portfolio risk. The data favors Schwab at first, but after adding a bond ETF investors can get very similar levels of exposure through either option. My favorite two ETF combinations for international equity are combining either SCHC and SCHF or VSS and VEA. I would base the decision on free trading for frequent rebalancing. As I’ve been working through a comparison of low fee ETFs, it seemed prudent to do a comparison on a batch of ETFs between two of the lost cost leaders in the industry. Vanguard has a very long and proud track record of offering investors excellent diversification with extremely low fees. Schwab decided to compete in that arena and introduced a very respectable group of ETFs that also have very low expense ratios. In this piece I’m running a comparison on the international ETF options for Schwab and Vanguard. In an attempt to keep the comparison reasonable, I’ve selected the Schwab International Small-Cap Equity ETF (NYSEARCA: SCHC ), the Schwab Emerging Markets ETF (NYSEARCA: SCHE ), and the Schwab International Equity ETF (NYSEARCA: SCHF ) for Schwab and the Vanguard FTSE All-World ex-US Small-Cap ETF (NYSEARCA: VSS ), the Vanguard FTSE Emerging Markets ETF (NYSEARCA: VWO ), and the Vanguard FTSE Developed Markets ETF (NYSEARCA: VEA ) for Vanguard. SCHC and VSS invest in international small-cap companies. SCHE and VWO invest in emerging markets. SCHF and VEA invest in developed markets. The Core of the Portfolio To form the core I am using heavy allocations to SCHB and VTI. These two funds represent Schwab’s Broad Market ETF and Vanguards Total Market Index ETF. Each broad market ETF is being allocated 35% of the portfolio value and each international ETF is being allocated 5% of the portfolio value. A quick check for volatility can then be performed in the context of the portfolio by looking at which investments are adding the most risk to the portfolio. The similarity of returns can also be assessed by checking if each pair of international ETFs that I believe to be similar are actually showing high similarity in their returns so far this decade. The chart below shows the results for the sample portfolio. (click to enlarge) The highest annualized volatility measures go to VWO, VEA, and SCHE, but the more important factor is the risk contribution since volatility that is not correlated to the domestic stock market is substantially less relevant in determining how volatile the portfolio will be as a whole. When we look at the “Risk Contribution” column or the “Beta” column we can get a quick feel for which international ETFs are adding more risk than others. As it happens, VWO, VEA, and SCHE are again the three highest in each category. When I run these comparisons with portfolios that include more asset classes there is often a disconnect between the annualized volatility of the individual funds and their contribution to the overall risk profile. Quick Interpretation The notable differences are that VEA seems to be offering more volatility than SCHF and VWO seems to be more volatile than SCHE. When it comes to SCHC or VSS, the volatility has been almost precisely the same. The differences in the amount of volatility are not huge and may be within a reasonable margin of error. If investors were to compare historical returns to simply see how the funds have done, it is clear that SCHC outperformed VSS, but in the other two cases the vanguard funds with more volatility also had better returns. When We Add Bonds I ran the simulation again but this time I added in a 20% allocation to a very high duration bond fund, the PIMCO 25+ Year Zero Coupon U.S. Treasury Index ETF (NYSEARCA: ZROZ ). Using ZROZ gives the portfolio a large dose of negative beta and provides a portfolio that when considered in the aggregate is substantially less risky than the portfolio with no bond exposure. The goal is to see how the risk contribution changes when we start pushing the portfolio to be closer to the efficient frontier by reducing volatility. To keep the comparison focused on the international ETFs, I simply dropped SCHB and VTI by 10% each. (click to enlarge) Now that the portfolio contains ZROZ, we see that SCHE is contributing more risk than VWO, though the other relationships remain unchanged. The portfolio as a whole, despite using the same time frame, has reduced the annualized volatility from 16.8% to 11.7%, The difference here is fairly dramatic as the portfolio went from being more volatile than the S&P 500 to being substantially less volatile. In this portfolio with bonds it appears that we have one fund for Vanguard winning in the risk comparison, VWO, one fund for Schwab winning, SCHF, and a tie between SCHC and VSS remains. What Does It All Mean? For investors that have free trading on either the Schwab or Vanguard funds, it looks like the best strategy is to use the group of ETFs that the investor can trade without commissions. Neither group is outperforming the other by enough to warrant paying the commissions. Rebalancing Because the annualized volatility on these international investments is so high, an investor should take care to consider a strategy for rebalancing their portfolio regularly to increase their allocations to whichever investments are out of favor with the market. Within Each Group When I’m looking at a comparison between VSS, VWO, and VEA, I’m seeing VSS as a very desirable option. VSS has an expense ratio of .19% which is slightly higher than I want to see on international investments, but it also has 3369 individual holdings within the portfolio and only 3.2% of the total assets are invested in the top 10 holdings. The internal diversification is exceptional. In my opinion, VSS is a world class option for including in diversified portfolios. Within the Schwab fund I’ve shown a slightly preference for SCHF in picking the ETFs for my own holdings, but I’m also attracted to using some SCHC and I’ve got a buy-limit order placed on SCHC to pick it if it falls far enough. With the market being so volatile right now, my cash is simply covering limit orders on a few of the ETFs that I have identified as desirable. That batch currently includes the Schwab U.S. Dividend Equity ETF (NYSEARCA: SCHD ) and SCHF. I already own some of the first two ETFs, but don’t have any SCHC yet. I have not decided if I like SCHC as much as SCHF, but I do appreciate a little bit of extra diversification that can come from using both. If I had free trading on VSS, I would be tempted to use it also. Ideal Allocations The highest total international equity allocation that I would be comfortable holding is around 20% of the portfolio value. I think my ideal allocation level may be closer to 10% to 15% though. One factor that will influence me is the simplicity of rebalancing. When rebalancing is easier, I’m willing to use slightly higher international allocations because the higher volatility can be dealt with more effectively. Current Influences I’ve been a pretty huge bear on China and was calling for some major corrections in that market. On the other hand, while the domestic market felt a little frothy, I wasn’t expecting the drawdown we have seen in August. Because of my views on the performance of China and the correlation of markets during times of stress, I’m inclined to focus my international allocations on developed markets rather than emerging markets. That causes me to see SCHC, SCHF, VSS, and VEA as the more desirable options. On the other hand, if China has a very solid crash and emerging market funds fall hard, then I’d be comfortable working a small emerging markets position into the portfolio. I’m not convinced that those prices will fall far enough for me to decide that I want to add more emerging markets rather than developed markets. If investors want to use emerging markets rather than developed markets for the international portion of the portfolio, I would suggest using a lower limit than 20%. The emerging markets have more inherent risk and a heavy allocation to the sector simply produces too much risk. To find the optimal exposure level, I think investors can use any two of the international ETFs except for combining SCHE and VWO. Going all emerging markets with no developed markets simply does not make sense for risk adjusted returns on a portfolio. Disclosure: I am/we are long SCHF, SCHB, VTI. (More…) I wrote this article myself, and it expresses my own opinions. I am not receiving compensation for it (other than from Seeking Alpha). I have no business relationship with any company whose stock is mentioned in this article. Additional disclosure: Information in this article represents the opinion of the analyst. All statements are represented as opinions, rather than facts, and should not be construed as advice to buy or sell a security. Ratings of “outperform” and “underperform” reflect the analyst’s estimation of a divergence between the market value for a security and the price that would be appropriate given the potential for risks and returns relative to other securities. The analyst does not know your particular objectives for returns or constraints upon investing. All investors are encouraged to do their own research before making any investment decision. Information is regularly obtained from Yahoo Finance, Google Finance, and SEC Database. If Yahoo, Google, or the SEC database contained faulty or old information it could be incorporated into my analysis.

Workday Stock Gains As Investors Digest Earnings

Workday (WDAY) stock managed to climb in early trading on Thursday despite a drastic drop in shares during off-hours sessions, after investors had a chance to digest the company’s guidance on future billing numbers. Though a slew of analysts lowered their price target on the company, Workday stock was trading up more than 3% from its Wednesday close, near 75 in early-afternoon trades. Workday, a maker of cloud-based enterprise software designed to