Author Archives: Scalper1

Portfolio Risk Contributions: Practical Examples

Portfolio risk contribution of an investment tends to differ from its portfolio weight. In some cases intuition may be misleading – a good example is the traditional 60/40 portfolio. It is paramount to assess the impact from each position in a portfolio. It is no secret that portfolio risk contribution of an individual security almost always differs substantially from its portfolio weight. However, investors frequently overlook this simple truth and tend to focus on notional dollar amounts invested. I have compiled a few examples that clearly illustrate why risk contributions matter. Let’s start with the traditional 60/40 portfolio, where SPDR S&P 500 ETF (NYSEARCA: SPY ) is used as a proxy for equities and iShares 20+ Year Treasury Bond ETF (NYSEARCA: TLT ) for bonds. Analyzing this portfolio on InvestSpy Calculator with 1 year historical data, we get the following results: The table above tells us that even though TLT had a slightly higher annualized volatility than SPY (which is an interesting fact in itself), its risk contribution to the total portfolio volatility was only 21.4% – way below TLT’s portfolio weight of 40%. And the difference would only get wider if we used shorter duration bonds for the fixed income component. So even though an investor may intuitively feel well diversified between stocks and bonds, almost 80% of portfolio risk comes from the equities component. Big discrepancies between portfolio weights and actual risk contributions can arise in equities-only portfolio as well. I came across the next example while writing a recent article about the ‘Fab Five’ stocks. Assuming a simple hypothetical portfolio where 50% is invested in SPY ETF and 50% in Google (NASDAQ: GOOG )(NASDAQ: GOOGL ), risk contributions from each position are far from even: This gap between risk contributions is primarily factored by the fact that GOOG is by far a more volatile security than SPY. The third example I would like to present is a portfolio that includes emerging market stocks. Investors are frequently reminded of a home country bias in their allocations and encouraged to include international stocks in their portfolio. So if a US investor allocates 20% to Vanguard FTSE Emerging Markets ETF (NYSEARCA: VWO ) with the remainder sitting in SPY, the risk profile of such a portfolio looks as follows: The risk contribution of the VWO position appears to be fairly close to its portfolio weight. Interestingly, the annualized volatility of the portfolio is only a tad higher than that of SPY’s in isolation despite the fact that VWO is significantly more volatile security. This is a direct result of the diversification effect. Therefore, the addition of emerging market stocks to diversify a portfolio of US stocks looks like a sensible decision. I hope the examples above give the readers a bit of a flavor how risk contributions work and why they are important. It is crucial to look beyond notional amounts invested in each position to assess if your portfolio is balanced the way it was intended. You will be surprised in some cases. Disclosure: I/we have no positions in any stocks mentioned, and no plans to initiate any positions within the next 72 hours. (More…) I wrote this article myself, and it expresses my own opinions. I am not receiving compensation for it (other than from Seeking Alpha). I have no business relationship with any company whose stock is mentioned in this article.

The MnM Portfolio Supplement – I Want To, But Can’t Purchase A Water Utility

Summary I outline my preference for water utilities. I review my analysis of the five water utilities listed as Dividend Champions on David Fish’s monthly publications. The current prices, yields, and historical dividend growth rates are unattractive as compared to other opportunities. A little background When I look over my MnM portfolio, last written about here , one of the key considerations I make is sector diversification. As I have built out the portfolio this year, it has come to my attention that I do not have any exposure to several sectors, including, but not limited to: utilities, telecoms, and financials (excluding REITs and insurers). I have been tempted to add positions in these sectors to round out the portfolio a little more. I hope to potentially do so in the coming year. That being said, I wanted to look a little bit deeper into utilities, as when I look at the overall utilities sector, represented by the Dow Jones Utility Average (^DJU), I see that it’s trailing the broader S&P 500 this year. (click to enlarge) Source: Yahoo Finance, 11 September 2015 It’s important to note that there are various types of utilities in the U.S. There are those that provide electricity, those that provide natural gas, those that provide water services, and some that provide a blend of these services, or others. A Quick summary of the regulated utility industry I am well versed with the regulated utilities environment, having grown up with a parent who worked in the industry, and spending some time in it myself. For those unfamiliar with how these companies work, a simple explanation is that utilities work with state and federal utility commissions to get rates approved to charge customers (end users of the electricity, gas, water, etc.) based upon a cost plus margin model. The utilities generally have to justify their capital expenditures to the commissions in seeking to be reimbursed for the costs (and consequently their margin). This model exists as utilities generally have a monopoly of service for their territories, meaning that other utilities are not able to offer up competing services. It’s too cost prohibitive. End users generally have only one provider option. As noted above, I do not currently hold any utility stocks, but if I were to purchase one down the road, my preference would be towards water utilities. Why do I have a preference for water utilities? When I take a step back from the fundamentals and technicals, I question whether in 25 years (or shorter) our current electric utilities will still operate in the same way. For example, if you were to tell me in 1995 that we would be seeing a huge shift away from coal within 20 years, I might have laughed at you. When I went to Germany back in 2012, to visit the country and experience Oktoberfest, I couldn’t help but notice that virtually every roof was covered in solar panels. As we speak we’re seeing a transformation in the US in terms of solar being increasingly cheaper, more available, and installed in a distributed (vs. centralized) manner, even as far north as where I live where we see weekly articles of the local utility Xcel Energy (NYSE: XEL ) fighting with solar providers over the size of solar gardens. Don’t get me wrong, I’m not calling for the death of utilities as we know it, but I do think that technological change will put pressure on the current distribution model, and could be a major challenge to growth (i.e. higher electricity sales). Now, there are obviously counters to these concerns, such as expanding populations and increasingly more powered devices (such as cars) across the US, but you cannot deny that things are changing. Some might argue that you could thank the EPA for that. To get back to my point, water is one thing provided by current utilities that I do not feel faces the same kind of technological threats to growth that the other utilities face. We will always need it, and it seems like climate change (whether you believe it or not) is negatively impacting the supply as well, as demonstrated by the droughts in California. Given all of this, water to me, is the most defensive, and thus the one resource I would most like to consider investing in. Why haven’t I bought in already? I looked through David Fish’s U.S. Dividend Champions list for Water Utilities and found there to be five within the dividend champions. Not a bad number. These include American States Water (NYSE: AWR ), California Water Service (NYSE: CWT ), Connecticut Water Service (NASDAQ: CTWS ), Middlesex Water Co. (NASDAQ: MSEX ), and SJW Corp (NYSE: SJW ), and they boast some impressive dividend streaks. (click to enlarge) Source: Price, P/E and Yield metrics courtesy of FASTgraphs.com, closing prices as of 10 September 2015. Dividend growth metrics courtesy of David Fish’s U.S. Dividend Champions spreadsheet updated 31 August 2015. When I took a look through their fundamentals, I have to stop my analysis right there. What disappoints me the most is that for the most part, the dividend increases have been barely above, or even less than the assumed 2% level of inflation, and not just over the last five years, but over the last ten years. American States Water, which has shown superior growth, is just too expensive to buy right now. Further, I personally have a mental “4% yield” requirement for both Utilities and REITs, meaning that is generally the minimum yield I want in order to enter into these securities. This is especially true as we enter a rising rate environment. None of them even come close right now. I would throw in a FASTgraph, but it doesn’t seem warranted. Conclusion I like water utilities in principle, and would love to have a more defensive play in my portfolio; but I just can’t justify owning one right now at their current multiples and stodgy dividend growth. The valuations on these stocks don’t seem to justify the lack of growth. I will keep tracking the securities, as I would like to own one at some point, but I need prices to come down and to see some more accelerated growth before I would jump in. Right now it seems that I could likely do much better with a telecom, such as Verizon (NYSE: VZ ), which is trading at a much lower multiple, pays a much higher distribution, and has grown dividends at a much higher clip. I have my eyes on Verizon, and hope to initiate a position in it at some point in the future. (click to enlarge) Source: FASTgraphs.com, closing price as of 10 September 2015 Disclosure: I/we have no positions in any stocks mentioned, and no plans to initiate any positions within the next 72 hours. (More…) I wrote this article myself, and it expresses my own opinions. I am not receiving compensation for it (other than from Seeking Alpha). I have no business relationship with any company whose stock is mentioned in this article.

The Trouble With Momentum – And What To Do About It

Summary Growth stocks have outperformed value stocks in recent years, which is shining a spotlight on momentum. Unlike other investment factors, the momentum premium has been persistent since it was identified by financial academics in the 1990s. We believe that combining momentum with value and other factors within a multi-factor framework is a compelling way to address the challenge of tapping momentum profitably in a growth portfolio. It’s no secret that growth stocks have outperformed value stocks in recent years. For example, in the two years from September 1, 2013 to August 31, 2015, large cap growth stocks (as measured by the Russell 1000 Growth Index) returned 14.7% annualized vs. 9.6% annualized for value stocks (Russell 1000 Value Index). This pattern of outperformance has shone a spotlight on momentum , an investment factor that works particularly well in growth-stock investing. But making money by identifying growth stocks with momentum characteristics isn’t as easy as it sounds. In this column, I will explain why and briefly describe how Gerstein Fisher addresses some of the problems inherent in tilting a growth stock portfolio to momentum. Momentum: a Persistent Investment Factor First, let’s define what we mean by momentum. Momentum is the tendency for winning stocks (that is, stocks that have outperformed the market over the past three to 12 months) to keep winning and losing stocks to keep losing. First identified in papers co-authored in the early 1990s by Sheridan Titman, one of our Academic Partners, the momentum factor would seem to refute the weak form of the Efficient Market Hypothesis, which asserts that stock prices reflect all available information and that past price movements should be unrelated to future average returns. Momentum suggests that prior movements in price are in fact related to expected stock returns – that security prices essentially have memory, which students of statistics will recognize as serial correlation. Since those landmark studies in the 1990s, a number of other academic papers have established that a momentum strategy works not only in equity markets around the world (with the notable exception of Japan’s) but also in several other asset classes, including currencies and commodities. At Gerstein Fisher, we find that a momentum tilt works at least as well in our multi-factor real estate investment trust (aka REIT) portfolio as in our US and international growth equity strategies. Exhibit 1 shows the compound annualized returns from 1927 to 2014 for 10 portfolios formed on momentum (defined here as the one-year return skipping the most recent month). Investing in the highest past one-year return (i.e., highest-momentum) stocks generated a 16.9% annualized return, while the lowest decile of momentum lost 1.5% per year. Note the steady improvement in performance as momentum increases. (click to enlarge) Moreover, unlike some other investment factors identified by financial academics, momentum has remained remarkably robust and persistent. For instance, since the size premium for small cap stocks was identified in the early 1980s, it has shrunk dramatically (see my recent column for more on this phenomenon: ” Is the Small Cap Stock Premium Disappearing? “); similarly, the value premium has also sharply declined since Fama and French published their pioneering paper on it in 1992. Quite possibly, once seminal research is available in the public domain, quantitative investors target and thereby reduce the available premiums, although they still exist. But momentum seems to be different: our research shows that the strategy has remained profitable, generating a momentum premium of five to seven percentage points* even years after Prof. Titman’s groundbreaking papers in the 1990s. The Challenge for Momentum So if all of this academic and empirical evidence for momentum is present, then what’s the problem? For one thing, momentum stocks are also subject to short-term reversals, the tendency for stocks that have risen relative to the rest of the market in the last month to underperform those that have fallen relative to the rest of the market (for more on this topic, see our recently posted paper: ” Do past returns predict future returns? Evidence from Momentum and Short – Term Reversals “). In addition, the discipline and emotion-free decisions required to hold high-momentum winners and cut low-momentum losers every month are behaviorally difficult for many individual investors to make. Most importantly, there is a very large issue with turnover and transaction costs (and tax liabilities, if held in a taxable account) with a momentum growth stock portfolio. In short, without rules for controlling portfolio turnover, transaction costs will quickly devour a premium from a tilt to momentum (a monthly rebalanced, long-only momentum strategy may have a turnover of about 300%, implying a holding period of around four months). We believe that an effective approach to addressing the problem of excess turnover is by combining momentum, a so-called fast-moving factor, with value (which we may define, for instance, as a tilt to higher book-to-market stocks than the Russell 3000 Growth Index), a slow-moving factor. Combining these two negatively correlated factors in one portfolio provides factor diversification, which is a good thing since there are pronounced and different cycles to different factors. But we also find that by combining the signals of value and momentum, we can slow down portfolio trading dramatically and improve risk-adjusted performance, both relative to the index and compared to the sum of standalone value and momentum strategies-a typical advantage of a multi-factor strategy in one portfolio. We will soon publish our research on the optimum way to combine momentum and value in an academic journal. In the meantime, I invite you to read our working paper: ” Combining Value and Momentum “. Conclusion Growth stocks – and momentum – have been the source of strong performance in the stock market. The momentum premium is palpable but difficult to tap profitably in a growth portfolio. We believe that combining momentum with value and other factors within a multi-factor framework is a compelling way to address this challenge. *The momentum premium is defined as the returns of the highest 30% of large cap US stocks rated by momentum less the return of the lowest 30% of stocks rated by momentum. Data on momentum decile portfolios are taken from Ken French’s website. Disclosure: I/we have no positions in any stocks mentioned, and no plans to initiate any positions within the next 72 hours. (More…) I wrote this article myself, and it expresses my own opinions. I am not receiving compensation for it. I have no business relationship with any company whose stock is mentioned in this article.