Author Archives: Scalper1

Building A Bulletproof Portfolio Of A+ Growth Stocks

Summary An investor can “bullet-proof” his portfolio while maximizing his expected return using the hedged portfolio method. When creating a hedged portfolio, you can start from scratch or start with a list of stock picks. We explore the second method here. The stock picks we start with are ones rated “A+” by S&P Capital IQ for growth and stability of earnings and dividends. We provide a sample hedged portfolio of “A+” stocks designed for an investor unwilling to risk a drawdown of more than 14%. Growth Investing versus Value Investing The idea of buying a stock for less than its ” intrinsic value ” has an innate appeal to value investors, but, as leading buy-and-hold investing blogger Eddy Efenbein suggested in a recent quip, not everyone is cut out for it: Give a man a value stock and he’s invested for a day, but teach a man value investing and he’ll be in anxiety-ridden mess for life. – Eddy Elfenbein (@EddyElfenbein) September 24, 2015 Unlike bargain-shopping value investors, growth investors are willing to pay more for a stock, in return for the prospect of higher future earnings growth. But that doesn’t necessarily eliminate anxiety. As with any style of stock investing, with growth investing, you face two kinds of risks: idiosyncratic risk , the risk of something bad happening to one of the companies you own, and market risk , the risk of your investments suffering due to a decline of the market as a whole. Two Ways of Limiting Stock-Specific Risk One way to limit stock-specific risk is via hedging; another way is via diversification. In a previous article (“How to Limit Your Market Risk”), we discussed ways to limit market risk for a diversified portfolio. In this post, we’ll look at how to “bulletproof” a concentrated portfolio of growth stocks using the hedged portfolio method . In that method, you limit both stock-specific and market risk via hedging. First, we’ll need a list of growth stocks to start with. For that, we’ll use a screen devised by the research firm S&P Capital IQ . A+ Stocks with High Projected Growth The goal of this screen is to find stocks likely to extend their superior historical earnings and dividend growth records. It uses two criteria: Forward annual earnings growth estimates of 12% or better over the next 3-5 years. An S&P Capital IQ Earnings and Dividend Rank of A+, which means a 10-year history of high growth and stability of earnings and dividends. On Wednesday, Fidelity’s screener identified seven stocks meeting those S&P Capital IQ criteria: Advance Auto Parts (NYSE: AAP ) CVS Health (NYSE: CVS ) Echolab (NYSE: ECL ) Ross Stores (NASDAQ: ROST ) Tupperware Brands (NYSE: TUP ) UnitedHealth Group (NYSE: UNH ) Walt Disney Co. (NYSE: DIS ) We’ll use those stocks as a starting point to construct a “bulletproof”, or hedged portfolio for an investor who is unwilling to risk a drawdown of more than 14%, and has $500,000 that he wants to invest. First, though, let’s address the issue of risk tolerance, and how it affects potential return. Risk Tolerance and Potential Return All else equal, with a hedged portfolio, the greater an investor’s risk tolerance — the greater the maximum drawdown he is willing to risk (his “threshold”, in our terminology) – the higher his potential return will be. So, we should expect that an investor who is willing to risk a 24% decline will have a chance at higher potential returns than one who is only willing to risk a 14% drawdown. Constructing A Hedged Portfolio We’ll outline the process here briefly, and then explain how you can implement it yourself. Finally, we’ll present an example of a hedged portfolio that was constructed this way with an automated tool. The process, in broad strokes, is this: Find securities with high potential returns (we define potential return as a high-end, bullish estimate of how the security will perform). Find securities that are relatively inexpensive to hedge. Buy a handful of securities that score well on the first two criteria; in other words, buy a handful of securities with high potential returns net of their hedging costs (or, ones with high net potential returns). Hedge them. The potential benefits of this approach are twofold: If you are successful at the first step (finding securities with high potential returns), and you hold a concentrated portfolio of them, your portfolios should generate decent returns over time. If you are hedged, and your return estimates are completely wrong, on occasion — or the market moves against you — your downside will be strictly limited. How to Implement This Approach Finding promising stocks In this case, we’re going to start with the stocks generated by the A+ high growth screen. To quantify potential returns for these stocks, you can, for example, use analysts’ price targets for them and then convert these to percentage returns from current prices. In general, though, you’ll need to use the same time frame for each of your potential return calculations to facilitate comparisons of potential returns, hedging costs, and net potential returns. Our method starts with calculations of six-month potential returns. Finding inexpensive ways to hedge these securities Whatever hedging method you use, for this example, you’d want to make sure that each security is hedged against a greater-than-14% decline over the time frame covered by your potential return calculations (our method attempts to find optimal static hedges using collars as well as protective puts going out approximately six months). And you’ll need to calculate your cost of hedging as a percentage of position value. Selecting the securities with highest net potential returns In order to determine which securities these are, out of the list above, you may need to first adjust your potential return calculations by the time frame of your hedges. For example, although our method initially calculates six-month potential returns and aims to find hedges with six months to expiration, in some cases the closest hedge expiration may be five months out. In those cases, we will adjust our potential return calculation down accordingly, because we expect an investor will exit the position shortly before the hedge expires (in general, our method and calculations are based on the assumption that an investor will hold his shares for six months, until shortly before their hedges expire or until they are called away, whichever comes first). Next, you’ll need to subtract the hedging costs you calculated in the previous step from the potential returns you calculated for each position, and exclude any security that has a negative potential return net of hedging costs. Fine-tuning portfolio construction You’ll want to stick with round lots (numbers of shares divisible by 100) to minimize hedging costs, so if you’re going to include a handful of securities from the sort in the previous step and you have a relatively small portfolio, you’ll need to take into account the share prices of the securities. Another fine-tuning step is to minimize cash that’s left over after you make your initial allocation to round lots of securities and their respective hedges. Because each security is hedged, you won’t need a large cash position to reduce risk. And since returns on cash are so low now, by minimizing cash you can potentially boost returns. In this step, our method searches for what we call a “cash substitute”: that’s a security collared with a tight cap (1% or the current yield on a leading money market fund, whichever is higher) in an attempt to capture a better-than-cash return while keeping the investor’s downside limited according to his specifications. You could use a similar approach, or you could simply allocate left over cash to one of the securities you selected in the previous step. Calculating Expected Returns While net potential returns are bullish estimates of how well securities will perform, net of their hedging costs, expected returns, in our terminology, are the more likely returns net of hedging costs. In a series of 25,412 backtests over an 11-year time period, we determined two things about our method of calculating potential returns: it generates alpha, and it overstates actual returns. The average actual return over the next six months in those 25,412 tests was 0.3x the average potential return calculated ahead of time. So, we use that empirically derived relationship to calculate our expected returns. An Automated Approach Here we’ll show an example of creating a hedged portfolio starting with S&P Capital IQ’s A+ growth stocks using the general process described above, facilitated by the automated hedged portfolio construction tool at Portfolio Armor . In the first step, we enter the ticker symbols in the “Tickers” field, the dollar amount of our investor’s portfolio (500000), and in the third field, the maximum decline he’s willing to risk in percentage terms (14). In the second step, we are given the option of entering our own return estimates for each of these securities. Instead, in this case, we’ll let the site supply its own potential returns. A couple minutes after clicking the “Create” button, we were presented with the hedged portfolio below. The data here is as of Wednesday’s close. Why These Particular Securities? The site included all of the entered securities for which it calculated a positive potential return, net of hedging costs. In this case, that turned out to be all of them except TUP. In its fine-tuning step, Portfolio Armor added Facebook (NASDAQ: FB ) as a cash substitute. Let’s turn our attention now to the portfolio level summary. Worst-Case Scenario The “Max Drawdown” column in the portfolio level summary shows the worst-case scenario for this hedged portfolio. If every underlying security in it went to zero before their hedges expired, the portfolio would decline 13.8%. Negative Hedging Cost Note that, in this case, the total hedging cost for the portfolio was negative, -1.98%, meaning the investor would receive more income in total from selling the call legs of the collars on his positions than he spent buying the puts. Best-Case Scenario At the portfolio level, the net potential return is 5.76% over the next six months. This represents the best-case scenario, if each underlying security in the portfolio meets or exceeds its potential return. A More Likely Scenario The portfolio level expected return of 2.02% represents a conservative estimate, based on the historical relationship between our calculated potential returns and backtested actual returns. How to Get a Higher Expected Return The site calculates potential returns using an analysis of price history and options sentiment, and, according to those metrics, didn’t consider the stocks we entered “A+”. If you disagree with the site’s potential returns for these stocks, you can enter your own estimates for them. Alternatively, you could decide not to enter any ticker symbols, and let the site pick its own securities. If you had done that on Wednesday using the same dollar amount ($500,000) and decline threshold (14%), the hedged portfolio generated would have had a net potential return (best case scenario) of 16%, and an expected return (more likely scenario) of 4.8%. Each Security Is Hedged Note that each of the above securities is hedged. Facebook, the cash substitute, is hedged with an optimal collar with its cap set at 1%, and the remaining securities are hedged with optimal collars with their caps set at each underlying security’s potential return. Here is a closer look at the hedge for UnitedHealth: UnitedHealth is capped here at 4.62%, because that’s the potential return Portfolio Armor calculated for it over the next several months. As you can at the bottom of the image above, the cost of the put protection in this collar is $1,600, or 2.6% of position value. But if you look at the image below, you’ll see the income generated from selling the calls is $2,700, or 4.38% of position value. So, the net cost of this optimal collar is negative.[i] Possibly More Protection Than Promised In some cases, hedges such as the ones in the portfolio above can provide more protection than promised. For an example of that, see this instablog post on hedging the iPath S&P 500 VIX ST Futures ETN (NYSEARCA: VXX ). [i]To be conservative, this optimal collar shows the puts being purchased at their ask price, and the calls being sold at their bid price. In practice, an investor can often buy the puts for less (i.e., at some point between the bid and ask prices) and sell the calls for more (again, at some point between the bid and ask). So the actual cost of opening this collar would have likely been less (i.e., an investor would have likely collected more than $1,100 when opening this hedge).

Eversource Energy Prepares For Earnings Growth By Alleviating The Northeast’s Energy Shortages

Summary Northeast electric and natural gas utility Eversource Energy reported Q2 earnings that beat on both lines by keeping its costs low even as revenue increased. The company is preparing the groundwork for long-term future earnings growth via multiple large capex projects to import additional electricity and natural gas to ease the region’s supply constraints. Its short-term outlook has been hampered by the development of strong El Nino conditions, which will likely cause Q4 and Q1 temperatures in its service area to be warmer than normal. The company’s shares are trading at low valuations, however, and they will be attractively valued if the price falls below 15x future earnings in response to a warm winter. Northeast electric and natural gas utility Eversource Energy (NYSE: ES ) reported Q2 earnings at the end of July that beat on both lines , as the company’s three major segments all reported strong YoY increases to income. Eversource occupies a unique position as a major utility in the U.S. Northeast, which suffers from a lack of natural gas supply infrastructure following the conversion of many of the region’s coal-fired power plants to natural gas. This shortfall causes the price of natural gas, which is finding increasing use in heating applications as well, to experience substantial volatility during the winter as supply is insufficient to meet both heating and electric generation demand. The utility has been undertaking large-scale transmission projects to minimize this volatility while simultaneously selling unattractive generation assets, both of which will support its planned earnings growth. Its share price has fallen YTD despite these moves, however (see figure). This article evaluates Eversource Energy as a potential long investment opportunity. ES data by YCharts Eversource Energy at a glance Formerly known as Northeast Utilities, Eversource Energy took on its current name and ticker symbol in February 2015. The changes followed the utility’s merger with Massachusetts utility NSTAR in April 2012. Headquartered in Hartford, CT, Eversource Energy provides electric and natural gas utility services to a total of 3.6 million customers in Connecticut, New Hampshire, and Massachusetts via multiple regulated subsidiaries (all of which now share the Eversource name). The company’s operations are broadly divided into three segments: electric transmission, electric generation and distribution, and natural gas distribution. Its transmission segment includes 4,270 miles of lines in all three of the states located within its service area. Likewise, its generation and distribution segment, which includes 72,000 miles of distribution lines, also operates in all three states. Finally, the natural gas segment, which includes 6,459 miles of pipeline, operates in Massachusetts and Connecticut. Massachusetts became the largest state by population in the company’s service area following the merger and it now provides for 1.4 million electric customers and 283,000 natural gas customers. Connecticut is close behind with 1.2 million electric customers and 222,000 natural gas customers. New Hampshire, on the other hand, only has 510,000 electric customers. The latter’s small number led Eversource to announce in March 2015 that it intends to sell 1,058 MW of electric generating capacity in the state. The majority of the capacity is coal- and oil-fired and the company determined that, given the relatively small customer base in the state, pending environmental regulations on power plants made their continued ownership by it unattractive. New Hampshire’s governor signed off on the divestiture agreement in July. That said, it remains to be seen whether potential buyers will find the agreement’s terms, which includes requiring the buyer to honor the existing collective bargaining agreement and keep the plants open for 18 months post-acquisition, to be too onerous. Even as it is reducing its exposure to generation (Eversource Energy will continue to distribute purchased electricity to its New Hampshire customers), the company is expanding its natural gas and electric transmission segments. Natural gas and heating oil prices moved in opposite directions following the advent of shale gas extraction, with the former falling to a fraction of the latter’s price. While the recent fall in the price of crude has offset the advantage of natural gas to a large degree, customers in the Northeast have been switching from heating oil to gas in large numbers. Eversource, for example, is targeting 16,000 new natural gas customers annually through 2023 via such conversions. This shift has coincided with a broader move by power plants to abandon coal in favor of natural gas, first due to the latter’s low price and more recently to comply with expanding federal regulations on power plant emissions. Natural gas distribution capacity in the Northeast has not managed to keep up with the combined demand effects of this increased consumption. While sufficient supply is achieved in the summer when heaters aren’t running, natural gas shortages and consequent price volatility have been frequent occurrences in the Northeast during the winter months, especially during the type of exceptionally cold winters seen in 2014-15, for example. In an effort to offset increased demand for natural gas by its customers, Eversource Energy is building the high-voltage Northern Pass Transmission [NPT] line that will connect its service area’s electric grid to the Quebec province by way of New Hampshire. The $1.4 billion will construct 187 miles of new transmission lines that will run the length of New Hampshire and, in the process, connect the service area to 1,200 MW of Canadian hydroelectric capacity. The project is still several years away from completion, with the company stating that it doesn’t expect it to be in service until the first half of 2019, assuming that construction begins by the end of 2016. Complementing the Northern Pass project is a natural gas pipeline that Eversource announced late last year in partnership with Spectra Energy (NYSE: SE ). The $3 billion project is actually an expansion of pre-existing pipelines in the Northeast that supply natural gas to 60% of the region’s natural gas-fired power plants. When completed, the Access Northeast project will supply 5,000 MW of gas-fired electric generation capacity with natural gas from the Utica and Marcellus Shale regions, further helping to alleviate the Northeast’s natural gas shortages in the winter. The full expansion is expected to be in service as early as November 2018. Q2 earnings report Eversource Energy reported Q2 revenue of $1.8 billion, up by 8.3% YoY (see table) and beating the consensus estimate by $70 million. The increase came despite lower retail sales across its segments, with electric distribution sales down 0.1% YoY and natural gas sales down 1.2% YoY. Total operating income rose to $412 million from $294 million YoY as operating expenses failed to increase by the same amount as revenue. The company’s O&M costs fell as well, helping to offset an increase to purchased power costs over the same period. Eversource Energy financials (non-adjusted) Q2 2015 Q1 2015 Q4 2014 Q3 2014 Q2 2014 Revenue ($MM) 1,817.1 2,513.4 1,881.1 1,892.5 1,677.6 Gross income ($MM) 1,131.9 1,351.4 1,538.8 1,057.2 950.7 Net income ($MM) 207.5 253.3 221.6 234.6 127.4 Diluted EPS ($) 0.65 0.80 0.70 0.74 0.40 EBITDA ($MM) 588.6 667.0 594.3 606.0 451.7 Source: Morningstar (2015). Net income rose to $209.5 million from $129.2 million YoY, resulting in a diluted EPS of $0.65 versus $0.40 over the same period and beating the consensus estimate by $0.09. The strong earnings result was due to a number of factors related to both the company’s core operations and regulatory changes. Its electric generation and distribution segment fared best, reporting earnings of $121.6 million compared to $83.4 million in the previous year. The gain, which the company attributed to rising revenue and lower O&M expenses, occurred across all of the segment’s subsidiary entities. The electric transmission segment generated earnings of $80.4 million, up from $43.9 million YoY. The gain was almost entirely due to a FERC charge that was accounted for in the company’s Q2 2014 earnings report and was not repeated in the most recent quarter. Finally, the natural gas distribution segment had a slow quarter due to seasonal issues, although its earnings more than doubled from $2 million to $5.3 million YoY as a result of cold weather early in the quarter that resulted in a larger number of heating degree-days. Of Eversource’s total $0.25 YoY gain to diluted EPS, $0.11 was due to the previous year’s FERC charge and $0.10 was due to higher revenues in the most recent quarter. The Q2 earnings were in line with management’s earnings expectations and the company reaffirmed its estimated FY 2015 EPS range of $2.75 to $2.90 during the Q2 earnings call . The company also increased its quarterly dividend by 7.7% YoY to $0.42, resulting in a forward yield of 3.6%. Outlook Eversource Energy’s outlook has been dampened over the last year due to adverse regulatory decisions. The first of these was a decision by Connecticut state regulators to limit the company’s ROE to 9.17% , with 50/50 earnings sharing for the 100 basis points over that amount. This ROE was less than the company had expected and relatively low compared to those permitted for its industry peers. Second, federal regulators recently reduced the company’s transmission ROE from 11.14% to 10.57% . This latter decision in particular is a negative for Eversource given its large investment in new transmission assets. I am also concerned about the weather outlook for the company’s service area over the next six months. This year’s El Nino event is now expected to be one of the strongest on record even if it doesn’t actually set a new record. Previous El Ninos of similar strengths have been characterized by warmer-than-normal winter weather across the northern half of the U.S. that, as far as the eastern seaboard is concerned, pushes as far south as Washington D.C. This year’s event is expected to last into the spring, meaning that Eversource Energy’s service area is likely to experience fewer heating degree-days than normal (and certainly fewer than last year’s bitter winter) during its traditional high-earnings quarters of Q4 and Q1. It should be noted that El Nino’s impacts are not as severe on the eastern seaboard as on the western seaboard and, just as importantly, the forecast is still quite uncertain. That said, investors should not be surprised if the company reports YoY declines for the period from October to March. Eversource Energy’s longer-term outlook is improved by its heavy planned capital expenditures, especially on natural gas pipelines and electric transmission lines. In addition to providing a basis for future rate case increases, the capex is also intended to serve a more fundamental purpose by reducing the Northeast’s notorious natural gas price volatility, particularly in the winter months. As discussed earlier, the widespread replacement of coal in power plants and heating oil in homes by natural gas leads to shortages when temperatures turn colder, resulting in wide price swings in states such as Massachusetts that aren’t reflected by the Henry Hub price (see figure). In addition to being onerous for consumers who find their heating and, more recently, electric bills spiking each autumn and winter, this volatility threatens long-term consumption trends by encouraging consumers to find alternatives. Massachusetts Natural Gas Citygate Price data by YCharts While Eversource’s proposed capex is intended to lay the groundwork for long-term earnings growth via both rate and volume growth, potential investors should be aware that, as a regulated entity, many of these plans are dependent on the support of multiple regulated entities. The Northern Pass project has encountered numerous instances of NIMBYism in sparsely-populated New Hampshire that have driven up its costs by requiring some of the line to be buried, for example, and despite its relatively advanced stage, the company doesn’t expect final permits to be received until the end of 2016. Likewise, while the Access Northeast pipeline has political support due to the history of natural gas shortages in the region, there is always the potential for a combination of NIMBYism and environmental concerns to cause delays and additional expenses. Valuation The consensus analyst estimates for Eversource Energy’s diluted EPS in FY 2015 and FY 2016 have remained relatively flat over the last 90 days as its Q1 and Q2 earnings have largely met expectations. The FY 2015 estimate has increased from $2.85 to $2.87, near the top of management’s expected range, while the FY 2016 estimate has remained flat at $3.04. Based on a share price at the time of writing of $47.47, the company’s shares are trading at a trailing P/E ratio of 16.5x and forward ratios of 16.5x and 15.6x for FY 2015 and FY 2016, respectively. All three of the ratios are near, but not quite at, the bottom of their historical respective ranges since the beginning of 2012, having fallen substantially since the beginning of the year (see figure). ES PE Ratio (TTM) data by YCharts Conclusion Electric and natural gas utility Eversource Energy reported Q2 earnings earlier in the summer that beat on both lines, as its cost-saving efforts offset slight declines to retail volumes. The company is in the midst of a strategic shift following its recent merger that will see it move from electric generation and distribution to electric transmission and natural gas distribution. This is a forward-looking move that, in addition to providing the company with years of large capex to support future rate cases, is aimed at mitigating the natural gas shortages that affect its service area on an annual basis. Furthermore, unlike some logistics projects (the Keystone XL pipeline being the most visible example), neither the Northern Pass nor the Access Northeast projects are likely to be especially offensive to the environmentally-conscious residents of the region, with the former in particular connecting the company’s service area to zero-emission electricity. NIMBYism and opposition to natural gas do create some regulatory uncertainty regarding both projects’ futures, of course, but these are more likely to increase their costs rather than result in their cancellations. The company’s share price is trading at low valuations in terms of both trailing and future earnings. The only thing that prevents me from buying its shares today is the presence of an especially strong El Nino, which increases the likelihood that the company’s service area will experience warmer-than-normal temperatures in Q4 and Q1 2016, especially on a YoY basis. Disappointing earnings results in one or both quarters could cause the company’s shares to fall a bit further, especially if such an announcement follows on the heels of an expected interest rate increase by the Federal Reserve at the end of 2015. It has been more than three years since Eversource Energy’s share price has remained below 15x future earnings for a lengthy period of time, however, and I consider its shares to be an attractive long investment opportunity in the event that they decline below $45.60, or 15x FY 2016 earnings at the time of writing.

AmeriGas Partners: Proceed Cautiously

Summary 8.5% yield is enticing for income investors, but has risks. Heritage Propane acquisition just isn’t working well; leverage up, earnings per share are down. Propane faces stiff competition from continued natural gas expansion and increasing market supply. AmeriGas Partners (NYSE: APU ) is a nation-wide propane distributor operating as a MLP. The company’s primary business model is to supply propane to rural areas where natural gas is not run due to the costs involved. To operate as a business that serves these small communities, AmeriGas has had to develop significant transportation and distribution infrastructure, helping give the company the current market advantage it holds. Propane is a multi-faceted commodity. The fuel source is plentiful, easily separated from crude oil during refining and also extracted as a byproduct from oil/natural gas wells. The resurgence of fracking in the United States has unlocked a major supply source for the fuel that is unlikely to go away anytime soon – the Marcellus and Bakken shale plays are expected to produce billions of gallons of propane annually by 2020. However, propane is less energy efficient than other sources of power generation like gasoline and natural gas. This relative energy inefficiency will continue to have propane play second fiddle to more efficient fuels. Over the past decade as energy markets have evolved, propane prices have collapsed in comparison to alternatives like gasoline and home heating oil. Toughening the market for AmeriGas, residential consumer propane use has shrunk as well, outside of years with exceptionally cold weather. The future of the fuel primarily relies on commercial uses such as use in internal combustion engines. However, commercial users have more options than residential buyers who have little to no access to alternative sources of heat production. Any sustained growth in propane prices compared to alternatives will be met by falling demand by end-users. Overall, given my views on natural gas pricing remaining low despite strong demand from utilities and chemical companies, my views on propane fall in the same category. I’m in the camp that propane prices will remain lower for longer. To offset losses, the company has to rely on continued expansion in propane cooking and water heating. This will likely at best offset the downtrend in residential heating markets. This doesn’t mean that AmeriGas is doomed, but the company does face headwinds given the environment it is currently competing in. Whatever your opinion on propane’s future, there isn’t any denying that the North American energy market, propane included, is in the middle of significant and profound change. Mixed Bag Of Operating Results *numbers in millions CAGR 2015 (est) 2014 2013 2012 2011 Total Revenue 3.76% 2942 3713 3167 2922 2538 Cost of Revenue -3.44% 1395 2121 1660 1720 1605 Operations & Maintenance 11.21% 950 964 944 889 621 Depreciation & Amortization 19.39% 193 197 203 169 95 Total Operating Expenses 2.67% 2592 3250 2774 2764 2333 OpEx as % of Total Revenue -1.06% 88.10% 87.53% 87.59% 94.59% 91.92% Investors should note that the above are fiscal year results – AmeriGas’ fiscal year ends 9/30 which means only one quarter needed my estimation. As investors can see, 2015 total revenue is set to fall over 20% primarily due to a more mild winter season compared to prior years. On the plus side, gross and operating margins have improved and operating income expanded. It might surprise investors to find out that 2011 was the more profitable year. Why? The acquisition of Heritage Propane in 2012 was incredibly expensive, paid for by nearly $1.5B in cash that had to be raised in the debt markets, along with a $1.1B dilutive stock issuance that diluted shareholders nearly 40%. Total debt now stands at $2.2B, compared to $929M in 2011 and AmeriGas now pays $100M more in interest expense annually than it used to, even in a falling interest rate environment that has improved. Debt used to finance the purchase wasn’t cheap – the majority ($1B due 2022) carries a burdensome 7% rate that cannot be refinanced due to covenants until 2017. I have yet to see much value in this purchase. While operating income has nearly doubled, shareholders haven’t seen any reward as earnings per share has moved nowhere. The estimated $2.38/share AmeriGas will earn in 2015 is less than the $2.93/share the company earned in 2011. *numbers in millions CAGR 2015 (est) 2014 2013 2012 2011 Cash From Operations 30.07% 521 480 356 344 189 Capital Expenditures 7.54% 111 114 111 103 77 Dividends Paid 20.45% 362 347 327 272 172 Resulting Free Cash – 48 19 -82 -31 -60 Additionally, when evaluating utilities I like to see how the cash is used. When looking at a utility, there are two main uses for cash from operations: capital expenditures and dividend payments. If investors in their research see continued years of negative free cash after these two items are paid, eyebrows should be raised. Utilities with healthy leftovers have cash balances they can use for acquisitions, debt retirement, share repurchases, or just setting aside cash for a rainy day. This is an area that has seen improvement for AmeriGas, although I would like to see more improvement than what I’ve seen. As another critique, historically, approximately 60% of capital expenditures have been “maintenance” capital expenditures, or capital expenditures that are done simply to maintain the current asset base. So from a growth perspective, only 40% of 2015’s capital expenditures, or $45M, is used to build new plants, storage devices, or purchase new equipment. Future growth may be curtailed if this investment remain slow. Conclusion Investors were skeptical back in late 2011/2012 over whether the Heritage Propane acquisition was a good deal. Several ratings agencies downgraded the company’s debt on questions whether the cost (11x EBITDA) and risk of failed execution high. This is part of the reason why AmeriGas’ debt issued to fund the acquisition carried such unfavorable rates. Looking back from today, it appears those fears were largely founded. Investors who are likely salivating at the current 8.5% yield should question whether that yield may remain stagnant in the years to come. Management wants to target 5% annual targets but free cash flow currently cannot support much further growth. I can see expansion if we have a string of cold years in 2016 and 2017 while interest rates remain low. Strong operating results before a debt refinance option opens up could free up some cash flow to support some future dividend raises. Beyond 2018, the source of tens of millions in additional free cashflow to fuel 5% dividend increases each year becomes murky.