Author Archives: Scalper1

Consumer Staples Momo ETF Is A Winning Smart Beta Selection In A Defensive Sector

Investors looking for an ETF that is both defensive and has the potential for out performance should review PowerShares DWA Consumer Staples Momentum ETF. FINRA recently chimed in on Smart Beta ETFs with a Caveat Emptor opinion. As long as the US Dollar remains strong, this ETF should continue to excel. As with many previous market downturns, money has been flowing into the “safer” sectors of utilities, consumer staples, and telecom. If one looks at the recent high of the SPDR S&P 500 Trust ETF (NYSEARCA: SPY ) at $213.50 on May 21, the markets have fallen -9.3% as of Sept 23. Popular ETFs for these sectors are the Utilities Select Sector SPDR ETF (NYSEARCA: XLU ), the Consumer Staples Select Sector SPDR ETF (NYSEARCA: XLP ) and the SPDR S&P Telecom ETF (NYSEARCA: XTL ). Since May 21, utility and consumer staples investors have been rewarded with better relative declines of -5.9% and -4.9%, respectively, while telecom lost about market average of -9.8%. However, if one looked at the declines of these sector ETFs from their most recent highs, the carnage is a bit worse. Utilities peaked on Jan 29 and has declined -15.1%, telecom peaked on June 18 and has fallen -11.9%. Consumer staples peaked on Aug 5 and has declined -7.2%. On a year to date base, SPY is down -2.9%, XLU -8.5%, XTL -3.3%, and XLP -1.2%. Within these popular defensive sectors, consumer staples would seem to be the best performer for relative performance against a backdrop of an overall market decline. There are 13 consumer staples ETFs listed on ETFdb.com . YTD performance ranges from 9.39% for the PowerShares DWA Consumer Staples Momentum Portfolio ETF (NYSEARCA: PSL ) to -46.1% for the Global X Brazil Consumer ETF (NYSEARCA: BRAQ ). The top three YTD US performers were: PSL, the PowerShares Dynamic Food & Beverage Portfolio ETF (NYSEARCA: PBJ ) at 5.3% and the Guggenheim S&P Equal Weight Consumer Staples ETF (NYSEARCA: RHS ) at 2.5%. On a 1-yr, 3-yr and 5-yr basis, PSL has outperformed both the SPY and XLP, with the majority of its relative strength clocking in since Oct 2014. Prior, PSL mirrored SPY and bested XLP and the recent outperformance has lifted overall returns. According to etfdb.com, during the past year, PSL has returned 18.5% vs 7.5% for XLP, on a 3-yr basis, PSL has returned 70.5% vs 41.9% for XLP, and on a 5-yr basis, PSL has returned 123.7% vs 93.9% for XLP. A 3-yr graph of PSL vs SPY and XLP is below. What is the investment strategy of PSL that creates the outperformance? As a “smart beta” ETF, the underlying portfolio shifts quarterly centered on individual stock’s technical performance relative to the sector. PSL is a PowerShares ETF offered by Invesco. From their website : “The PowerShares DWA Consumer Staples Momentum Portfolio ((Fund)) is based on the Dorsey Wright® Consumer Staples Technical Leaders Index (DWA Consumer Staples Technical Leaders Index). The Fund will normally invest at least 90% of its total assets in common stocks that comprise the Index. The Index is designed to identify companies that are showing relative strength (momentum), and is composed of at least 30 common stocks from the NASDAQ US Benchmark Index. The Fund and the Index are rebalanced and reconstituted quarterly.” Zack’s comments on PSL: “Consumer staples sector is on the rise as it is directly linked with improving economic fundamentals, in particular the spending power, which has increased owing to cheap fuel and rising income. As such, PSL has been able to withstand global worries, gaining 2.6% so far in the second half. The ETF provides exposure to 32 stocks having positive relative strength (momentum) characteristics by tracking the DWA Consumer Staples Technical Leaders Index. It has amassed $203.4 million in AUM and trades in lower volume of 56,000 shares a day on average. Expense ratio came in at 0.60%. The product is pretty spread out across securities, with each holding less than 4.9% of assets. It has a definite tilt toward mid cap stocks while the other two market cap levels take the remainder. Food products, beverages and household durables are the key industries in the ETF having double-digit exposure each.” Momentum investing, aka “momo”, is a strategy of buying stocks that have generated high returns over the past three to twelve months, and selling those that have experienced poor returns over the same period. The ETF seeks investment results that correspond to the price and yield of the DWA Consumer Staples Technical Leaders Index, which evaluates companies based on a variety of investment criteria, including fundamental growth, stock valuation, investment timeliness and risk, comparative to others in the sector. From DWA website concerning their relative strength and top-down approach: “Relative Strength: Relative Strength, the measurement of how one security performs in comparison to another, is a key concept within Dorsey Wright’s methodology. Before investing in UPS, one should understand its recent performance relative to FedEx, or the S&P 500. The same logic can be applied to sector analysis, asset class evaluation, mutual funds, ETFs, commodities, fixed income, and even foreign countries. A relative strength matrix is like a massive tournament, where a huge quantity of investment options can be compared to one another – and we see who is strongest. Relative strength is the basis for virtually all of our managed products, where we select the best investment options from within a large universe of options. Top-Down Approach: We use primary market indicators to get a measure of overall risk, and then analyze broad industry sectors to determine which are in favor. We want to invest in sectors that are controlled by demand. We then select investments that have positive relative strength and have a good probability of outperforming the market. We do not feel compelled to be fully invested in stocks when an alternative investment (cash reserves) offers a more attractive opportunity. In fact, it is our belief that avoiding severe losses is extremely important in achieving strong market performance over the course of an entire market cycle.” PSL is one of 14 momentum driven ETFs utilizing various Dorsey Wright Technical Leaders Indexes and a list of other Indexes is found here . DWA offers an in-depth White Paper on the Dorsey Wright Strategy titled ” Relative Strength and Portfolio Management ” pdf. PSL was rebalanced on June 30 and the most recent list of stocks is below: (click to enlarge) Due to its focus on owning the top momentum stocks with quarterly rebalancing, investors should not be surprised at a high 83% Annual Turnover Rate. According to Morningstar, of the companies listed above, one was purchased in 2012, three in 2013, nineteen in 2014 and nine in 2015. The ETF’s industry allocation is broad based within the consumer staples sector and is reported by Invesco as follow: As the strategy includes NASDAQ stocks, PSL’s portfolio will have higher exposure to mid-caps and small-caps than its large cap S&P ETF brethren. Not only are smaller companies known for higher earnings potential, but usually are focused on domestic US markets rather than an extensive international network. Recently, the strength of the US Dollar has weighted on revenue growth and exchange rates for large cap companies, and this concern is usually less with smaller companies. The strength in domestic markets and reduced currency risk exposure may be a factor in these specific company’s current individual outperformance. The outperformance of PSL compared to XLP coincides with the meteorically rise in the US Dollar starting in Aug 2014. The average market cap in the portfolio is $14.5 billion and 72% of the portfolio are mid-caps or smaller. Below is a table offered by Morningstar of PSL valuation and growth matrix compared to the Benchmark of S&P 1500 Consumer Staples and the Category of Morningstar Defensive. While the comparison indicates PSL is trading at a higher valuation than the Benchmark and Category, its growth profile is also quite a bit higher. With Cash-Flow Growth 25% above the benchmark and Book-Value Growth more than double the Benchmark, a higher valuation would seem appropriate. This week, FINRA issued an Investor Alert titled, “Smart Beta-What You Need to Know”. The bottom line of the alert is the old adage: Know what you are buying and what the strategy is of the specific ETF. There are about 840 products that fall into a smart beta category, representing almost half of all the exchange-traded products listed in the U.S. and investors should understand that any strategy that aims to beat the market carries its own risks. “Recently, there has been significant growth in the number of financial products, primarily ETFs, which are linked to and seek to track the performance of alternatively weighted indices. These indices are commonly referred to as “smart beta” indices. They are constructed using methodologies that rely on, for example, equal weighting of underlying component stocks, or measures such as volatility or earnings, rather than market-cap weighting. Investors need to understand there is no free lunch here. Any time you are deviating from the market, you’re taking some kind of tilt. Understand what is the fund doing that is different than the market. That is a risk.” Investors looking for an ETF that is both defensive and has the potential for outperformance should review PSL to evaluate how it may fit into their current portfolio construction. As long as the US dollar stays strong and the international economies remain in question, this ETF should continue to reward long term investors. However, FINRA is correct: Caveat Emptor. Author’s Note 1: NASDAQ OXM (NASDAQ: NDAQ ) agreed to acquire privately-held Dorsey Wright Associates in Jan for $225 million. This will push NASDAQ into the smart beta ETF market in an aggressive manner. Author’s Note 2: Please review disclosure in Author’s profile.

SJNK: Boosting Yields With Debt That Moves With Equity

Summary The fund follows through on “high yields” by offering investors greater than 5% yield from a junk bond portfolio. The allocations are primarily allocated to the 3-5 year range. The sector allocation is substantially higher for the industrial segment which should encourage investors to avoid buying equity exposure to the same sector. Despite being a debt instrument, the ETF has a negative correlation with treasuries. If investors are using SJNK to boost portfolio yields, it should replace part of the equity portfolio rather than part of the debt portfolio. The SPDR Barclays Capital Short Term High Yield Bond ETF (NYSEARCA: SJNK ) should be an interesting option for investors for one reason; it offers a fairly solid yield. When investors are looking for ways to enhance the income on their portfolio, a small allocation to junk bonds is one solid way to get the job done. I put together some analysis looking at both the holdings of SJNK and how it performs within a portfolio. Expense Ratio The expense ratio on SJNK is .40%, which is definitely higher than I want to see. Junk bonds can be a tricky part of the market because passive investing can be more difficult. Since it is more difficult to do passive investing, the expense ratios for the sector should be a bit higher. Quality I grabbed a chart to break down the credit ratings of the bonds in the portfolio: This certainly qualifies as a junk bond portfolio without being absurdly low ratings. Most of the securities are still BB or B, having over 17% of the portfolio below that rating shouldn’t go unnoticed. This is a very credit sensitive portfolio and as such investors should consider it as a mix of equity and debt since there will be some material correlation with the stock market. When markets are selling off, investors may also flee this credit sensitive debt. Maturities While the portfolio is certainly subject to credit risk, it is not subject to very much duration risk. The portfolio is heavily concentrated on the 3-5 year part of the yield curve, but there are some shorter allocations as well. It looks like the fund is selling off bonds as they get closer to maturity in favor of buying new longer dated securities that bring more risk and higher yields. Sector Allocation The fund appears to be very heavily invested in industrial debt. The logic here should be fairly simple. Since this credit sensitive debt will have positive correlations with equity and negative correlations with treasury debt, investors need to be wary of the sector. If they are going to buy into SJNK, they should not buy into any index funds that are heavily focused on industrial allocations. Doing so would result in having a higher concentration of risk. There just isn’t any reason to risk going heavily long on both the equity and the credit sensitive debt of a single sector. Building the Portfolio This hypothetical portfolio has a moderately aggressive allocation for the middle aged investor. Only 25% of the total portfolio value is placed in bonds and a fifth of that bond allocation is given to high yield bonds. If the investor wants to treat an investment in an mREIT index as an investment in the underlying bonds that the individual mREITs hold, then the total bond allocation would be 35%. Given how substantially mREITs can deviate from book value, I’d rather consider the allocation as an equity position designed to create a very high yield. This portfolio is probably taking on more risk than would be appropriate for many retiring investors since a major recession could still hit this pretty hard. If the investor wanted to modify the portfolio to be more appropriate for retirement, the first place to start would be increasing the bond exposure at the cost of equity. However, the diversification within the portfolio is fairly solid. Long term treasuries work nicely with major market indexes and I’ve designed this hypothetical portfolio without putting in the allocation I normally would for equity REITs. An allocation is created for the mortgage REITs, which can offer some fairly nice diversification relative to the rest of the portfolio and they are a major source of yield in this hypothetical portfolio. The portfolio assumes frequent rebalancing which would be a problem for short term trading outside of tax advantaged accounts unless the investor was going to rebalance by adding to their positions on a regular basis and allocating the majority of the capital towards whichever portions of the portfolio had been underperforming recently. Because a substantial portion of the yield from this portfolio comes from REITs and interest, I would favor this portfolio as a tax exempt strategy even if the investor was frequently rebalancing by adding new capital. The portfolio allocations can be seen below along with the dividend yields from each investment. Name Ticker Portfolio Weight Yield SPDR S&P 500 Trust ETF SPY 35.00% 2.06% Consumer Discretionary Select Sector SPDR ETF XLY 10.00% 1.36% First Trust Consumer Staples AlphaDEX ETF FXG 10.00% 1.60% Vanguard FTSE Emerging Markets ETF VWO 5.00% 3.17% First Trust Utilities AlphaDEX ETF FXU 5.00% 3.77% SPDR Barclays Capital Short Term High Yield Bond ETF SJNK 5.00% 5.45% PowerShares 1-30 Laddered Treasury Portfolio ETF PLW 20.00% 2.22% iShares Mortgage Real Estate Capped ETF REM 10.00% 14.45% Portfolio 100.00% 3.53% The next chart shows the annualized volatility and beta of the portfolio since April of 2012. (click to enlarge) A quick rundown of the portfolio Using SJNK offers investors better yields from using short term exposure to credit sensitive debt. The yield on this is fairly nice and due to the short duration of the securities the volatility isn’t too bad. PLW on the other hand does have some material volatility, but a negative correlation to other investments allows it to reduce the total risk of the portfolio. FXG is used to make the portfolio overweight on consumer staples with a goal of providing more stability to the equity portion of the portfolio. FXU is used to create a small utility allocation for the portfolio to give it a higher dividend yield and help it produce more income. I find the utility sector often has some desirable risk characteristics that make it worth at least considering for an overweight representation in a portfolio. VWO is simply there to provide more diversification from being an international equity portfolio. While giving investors exposure to emerging markets, it is also offering a very solid dividend yield that enhances the overall income level from the portfolio. XLY offers investors higher expected returns in a solid economy at the cost of higher risk. Using it as more than a small weighting would result in too much risk for the portfolio, but as a small weighting the diversification it offers relative to the core holding of SPY is eliminating most of the additional risk. REM is primarily there to offer a substantial increase in the dividend yield which is otherwise not very strong. The mREIT sector can be subject to some pretty harsh movements and dividends from mREITs should not be the core source of income for an investor. However, they can be used to enhance the level of dividend income while investors wait for their other equity investments to increase dividends over the coming decades. If you want a really quick version to refer back to, I put together the following chart that really simplifies the role of each investment: Name Ticker Role in Portfolio SPDR S&P 500 Trust ETF SPY Core of Portfolio Consumer Discretionary Select Sector SPDR ETF XLY Enhance Expected Returned First Trust Consumer Staples AlphaDEX ETF FXG Reduce Beta of Portfolio Vanguard FTSE Emerging Markets ETF VWO Exposure to Foreign Markets First Trust Utilities AlphaDEX ETF FXU Enhance Dividends, Lower Portfolio Risk SPDR Barclays Capital Short Term High Yield Bond ETF SJNK Low Volatility with over 5% Yield PowerShares 1-30 Laddered Treasury Portfolio ETF PLW Negative Beta Reduces Portfolio Risk iShares Mortgage Real Estate Capped ETF REM Enhance Current Income Risk Contribution The risk contribution category demonstrates the amount of the portfolio’s volatility that can be attributed to that position. Despite TLT being fairly volatile and tying SPY for the second highest volatility in the portfolio, it actually produces a negative risk contribution because it has a negative correlation with most of the portfolio. It is important to recognize that the “risk” on an investment needs to be considered in the context of the entire portfolio. To make it easier to analyze how risky each holding would be in the context of the portfolio, I have most of these holdings weighted at a simple 10%. Because of TLT’s heavy negative correlation, it receives a weighting of 20% and as the core of the portfolio SPY was weighted as 50%. Correlation The chart below shows the correlation of each ETF with each other ETF in the portfolio. Blue boxes indicate positive correlations and tan box indicate negative correlations. Generally speaking lower levels of correlation are highly desirable and high levels of correlation substantially reduce the benefits from diversification. (click to enlarge) Conclusion SJNK offers investors a very attractive yield that can help their portfolio produce a higher level of income if they are in need of immediate income. Despite that benefit, the fund has some substantial correlation with the major equity indexes and should be treated as a bit of a mix of debt and equity due to the risk factors. Despite being a debt instrument, the correlation with PLW is negative. In an interesting twist, we see that SJNK is actually showing more of a negative correlation with treasuries than FXU, the utility ETF in this scenario. Since SJNK is so credit sensitive, investors using it in their portfolio to enhance income should consider it as a replacement for part of their equity allocation rather than using it to replace treasuries in an a bid to generate more current income from their portfolio. It is fine to use junk bonds to enhance income, just don’t pretend that they will offer the same negative correlation benefits that treasury bonds offer.

Leading Industry Groups Come Under Fire As Market Weakens

Leading industry groups in the market are starting to show signs of wear and tear. That’s not surprising as selling pressure continues to build in the major averages. The top-ranked group in IBD’s database, Finance-Mortgage & Related Services, fell around 4% Thursday. During the week ended Aug. 21, it plunged 8.5%. LendingTree (TREE), a former big leader in the group, plunged below its 50-day moving average Thursday in heavy volume. Another former