Author Archives: Scalper1

Google Dodges Ad-Block Services While YouTube Soars

Google (GOOGL) got a price target boost and ratings upgrade late Thursday from investment bank Oppenheimer, which said the search leader’s newest ad products unveiled this week will let the company go head to head with rival Facebook ‘s (FB)existing ad offerings. And while ad-blocking worries ripple through the industry, Google’s control of both its Chrome Web browser and Android mobile phone operating system make it less vulnerable to having its

Investing With Russian ETFs

Summary With the majority of ETF options holding energy companies, the market has become a tradable opportunity for those looking to profit from volatility. The mid-term outlook remains bleak, as economic and political deficiencies have suppressed business growth in the country. For longer-term investors, the current market may provide an opportunity to build holdings in an emerging market portfolio. With the recent decline in Russian markets due to the drop in the price of oil, many interested investors have considered gaining exposure to the country. From a fundamental perspective, the nation’s abundance of resources provides a positive picture in the long term. However, the pertinent question is how investors can gain this exposure while also protecting themselves from unwanted paperwork related to direct investment in the Moscow Stock Exchange (MICEX). In the current environment, the best solution are the Russian ETFs available on the market. ETFs have become a popular tool in the past few years for diversifying portfolios and protecting investors from market volatility. For those considering exposure to the emerging markets, ETFs have become almost a necessity in the current decade, as global rates continue to decline and result in increased market volatility. Russian ETFs protect an investor’s portfolio from the large fluctuations in the MICEX while also offering a passive investment style which ensures even investment in all major Russian industry players. Many Russian ETFs have underperformed in the last year, due to continued pressure from a commodity price perspective. This period of pricing pressure provides an opportunity for investors to take on risk and bet on a recovery in the market as the price of oil recovers. Russian ETFs are not for everyone and while they offer reduced volatility compared to the MICEX, the outflow of funds from Russian ETFs in the past few months has reduced liquidity. In addition, a majority of the Russian ETFs are heavily invested in oil majors, a market that has taken hits due to sanctions related to the Ukraine crisis. For this reason, finding an ETF that offers exposure to oil while also targeting other industries is much more beneficial from a medium-term perspective. In the following article, I will cover three popular Russian ETFs to determine whether the current investment products available offer any opportunities for interested investors. Current market As many investors may already know, Russia is among the top oil producers in the world, ranking eighth in global proved reserves with 80 billion barrels of oil (BBL). That said, the Russian economy has been highly leveraged to the price of oil for several decades, as 60% of the country’s export balance comes from oil and gas, which also contribute 30% of its GDP. It is frightening to see how unsustainable the business model has been for the country, as it has leveraged itself highly to the primary industry and to commodity prices. From a productivity perspective , the average Russian worker contributes $25.90 to Russia’s GDP, while a US worker adds around $67.40. The gap in productivity relates back to the systemic deficiencies in the country as the political environment has weakened the country’s incentive to engage in international trade. The nationalistic behavior seen across the many Russian political groups has not only been limiting to the current generation, but will also create future deficiencies, as the current economy has set a precedent that the future generation is set to follow. Vladimir Putin looks to continue his reign in the country as propaganda from the Kremlin continues to support his 86% approval rating. The future looks bleak for the economy, and I suggest investors look at the country as a tradable opportunity rather than an investment , due to the constant volatility in the MICEX. For investors who would consider exposure to Russia, using the price of oil as a lead indicator is the ideal way to trade the nation’s currency and any other leveraged investment products. Possible Investment Opportunities For interested investors, the top three ETFs available are the Market Vector Russia ETF Trust (NYSEARCA: RSX ), SPDR S&P Russia ETF (NYSEARCA: RBL ), and the iShares MSCI Russia Capped ETF New (NYSEARCA: ERUS ). This begs the question: Which option should investors choose, and at what time should these ETFs be implemented into their portfolio? In the following analysis, I will take a quick look at the holdings and relative stability of each equity to help investors determine how these investment product should be used. (click to enlarge) Table source: Author’s own work. Market Vectors Russia ETF Trust (click to enlarge) Source: Google Finance. Market Vectors Russia ETF Trust seeks to replicate as closely as possible the performance of the DAXglobal Russia Index (DXRPUS), a modified, market capitalization-weighted index consisting of publicly traded companies based in Russia. The product offers ideal exposure to the Russian market and should profit from an increase in the oil price as the economy sees a direct benefit from increased production. As previously stated, the oil and gas industries in Russia contribute 60% of the country’s export balance and make up 30% of the nation’s gross domestic product. With such an integral relationship between the commodity and economy, when comparing the ETF that follows the Russian economy, we can see that the decline in the price of oil has a significant effect on the performance of the equity. Therefore, for investors who would like to play oil volatility – or expect the price to recover to $100/barrel levels – the ETF should benefit greatly from the recovery and offer an easy way to profit from the recovery in the Russian economy, as output and trade increase relative to the price of oil. Looking at the respective ETF, the top three holdings are Magnit PJSC (8.14%), Surgutneftegas OJSC (7.89%), and LUKOIL PJSC (7.67%). Magnit is the leading food chain retailer in Russia with 10,728 stores as of June 30, 2015. The retailer’s infrastructure offers the company an expansive reach across the country. Twenty-nine specialized distribution centers allow the company to deliver to customers on a daily basis. Looking at the past year, the 30.3% increase in revenue signals how strong the company is in a recessionary environment. The company has shown incredible strength in the face of the recession, due to over 90% of products coming from domestic players — a strategy that protects the company from dangerous currency fluctuations seen in the past year. Currency translations have been a barrier that has limited the growth of many Russian-based multinationals. The fall of the Ruble, the nation’s currency, is primarily due to the drop in confidence related to the price of oil in addition to the fall in exports as sanctions continue to hit major trading partners. Surgutneftegas is an oil and gas producer with one of the largest refineries in Russia, Kirishinefteorgsintez. The company has not performed well in the last year, with net income declining by 3.93% as the price of oil continues to hit Russian producers hard. With costs declining, the company should be safe in the short to medium term, as the refinery business supports revenue. However, the price of oil needs to recover, as the company produces oil at around $60/barrel, an unprofitable level in the short term. Oil company LUKOIL is one of the largest oil and gas vertically integrated companies with the firm accounting for over 2% of global crude production and approximately 1% of proved global reserves. In the oil sector, the company is a behemoth, and should do incredibly well in the long term as it continues to monetize its large proved reserves throughout Russia. Looking at the domestic market, the company accounts for 16.4% of Russian crude production, while also contributing over 15.7% to total refined crude oil in the country. Unfortunately, with the decline in the price of oil and additional sanctions from several international economies, LUKOIL has been among the most affected, with revenues declining by 31% which translated to a 59% decrease in net income. In the current market, the company has attempted to hunker down and survive the downturn through reducing costs by 19% and increasing production by 5.2% to utilize well efficiency in the short term. While reserve efficiency and hedging strategies will protect the company temporarily, it is essential for the price of oil to recover in order to support enterprise profitability. Overall the company has not done well in the short term, and funds like RSX will need to wait a long time to recover capital losses. Looking at the Market Vector Russia ETF Trust, the equity offers an ideal way to play the Russian market with exposure to numerous large industry players. In my opinion, the company’s high exposure to Magnit will help the equity in the down-turn as the company is quite recession-proof from an earnings perspective. On the other hand, Surgutneftegas and LUKOIL offer exposure to the nation’s oil and gas industry which has underperformed. Anyone who is considering purchasing this ETF should be aware that the performance of oil is very important to show any strength, due to RSX’s 42.73% exposure to the energy industry. SPDR S&P Russia ETF (click to enlarge) Sourced: Google Finance. SPDR S&P Russia ETF seeks to provide investment results that correspond generally to the price and yield performance of the S&P Russia Capped BMI Index. The Index is a float-adjusted market cap index designed to define and measure the investable universe of publicly traded companies based in Russia. The Index component securities are a subset, based on region, of component securities included in the S&P Global BMI Equity Index. The ETF has declined by 34.39% YOY, primarily due to its high exposure to the energy market (49.39%), as the price of oil and gas have consistently underperformed in the past year. Looking at the ETF’s top three holdings, Public Joint-Stock Company Gazprom (15.44%), Oil company LUKOIL PJSC (13.41%), and Sberbank Russia OJSC (7.41%) make up the top exposure to the Russian economy. Looking at the ETF’s exposure from a sector-specific perspective, Energy (49.39%), Basic Materials (14.37%), and Financials (12.09%) make up majority of the fund. With such high exposure to the price of oil and the related positions of the fund’s portfolio, large amounts of capital has left the fund as its current market cap of $24.44 million USD signals the illiquid environment the product is facing. Compared to the Market Vector ETF, which has over $1.72 billion USD in the fund, the SPDR S&P Russia has been badly bruised in the current Russian downturn. While the fund will recover, the timeline is unknown at the moment, and I would use the current environment as a case to judge the strength of the fund. Significant money flows out of the SPDR ETF has shown that investors do not favor the equity as their first choice to gain exposure to the nation. Therefore, while I am sure that as oil prices recover in the following 3 years, liquidity will be injected into the fund and help fuel returns, the current downturn has illustrated how weak the fund is compared to other available options on the market. When investing in an ETF, the liquidity and size of the fund is extremely important to protect holdings. In addition, the fees that investors pay on a smaller fund versus a larger fund results in compensation for the portfolio manager to be higher, which attracts more experienced and successful investors. Looking at the price movement of the fund, the product has seen more volatility due to the fact that liquidity is much lower and any institutional buyers will move the price much more. Thus, I recommend that investors look for another option to gain exposure to the Russian market as this ETF has been severely weakened by the current downturn in the market and does not provide an option to avoid market volatility. iShares MSCI Russia Capped ETF (click to enlarge) Source: Google Finance. iShares MSCI Russia Capped ETF is a much newer product available for investors as it was released in early January of 2015. The equity was introduced in order for investors to play the Russian decline as the Ruble, the nation’s currency, continued to fall on the FX markets. As economic output declined and prices continued to drop in regards to the decline in oil, the ETF has taken a position in major industry players at fundamentally undervalued price points. For this reason when looking at the equity’s exposure from a sector perspective, the top three sectors are: Energy (53.75%), Basic Materials (14.28%), and Financials (14.01%). Looking at the overall objective and investment strategy, with a relatively stable fund size of $208.43 million USD, the equity has taken large positions in undervalued sector leaders in order to take advantage of the current downturn in Russia. Looking at the overall performance of the equity, the iShares MSCI Russia Capped ETF is the only one in its product class that has shown positive returns; YOY, the equity has increased by 8.88%. Looking at the ETF’s portfolio, the top three holdings are public joint-stock company Gazprom (17.50%), oil company LUKOIL PJSC (12.74%), and Magnit PJSC (7.42%). Magnit and LUKOIL were previously covered, so I will skip over these two companies and focus on the ETF’s top holding, Gazprom. The public joint-stock company is a globally recognized energy player with major business lines in exploration, production, transportation, storage processing, and sales of gas, oil, heat and electric power. The company holds the world’s largest natural gas reserves in addition to being the largest producer and exporter of liquefied natural gas in Russia. With such a strong position, the company’s domestic market share has reached 72% in the last year while global market share in the natural gas sector was around 12%. The size of the company illustrates the sheer strength and presence it has on the global natural gas sector, with reserves estimated at 36 trillion cubic meters, while oil and condensate reserves reached 3.3 billion tons. In addition to strong reserves, the company has the world’s largest gas transmission system capable of sending production over 170,000 kilometers. The strength of this network was seen in early 2015 when Ukraine were unable to pay Gazprom for its natural gas due to its limited cash reserves . The country and majority of Eastern Europe have become dependent on the company’s production which provides an ideal market position for Gazprom as operations continue to expand in the oil and natural gas sector. Looking at the YOY performance of the company, while sales have declined by 2%, the increased profitability of the company’s pipeline network in addition to positive currency translation as volumes in Europe increased resulted in a 29% jump in net income. In addition, the company has been focused on reducing its leverage in the past year as net debt has declined by 12% due to natural gas and oil operations continuing to expand. I believe that both Gazprom and LUKOIL will do well in the long run, as the fundamental stability of their proved reserves and established network across Eastern Europe should help the companies. For this reason ,when looking at the iShares MSCI Russia Capped ETF, I am confident that the current downturn will be beneficial for the new product, as positions have been opened at the bottom of the down cycle and should help the fund increase as the recovery begins. Looking at the overall ETF, while the 53.75% exposure to the energy sector remains quite worrisome in the current market, due to the product coming onto the market at the bottom of the investment cycle, I am confident that these new positions in major oil and gas leaders should increase profitability in the medium term. In Conclusion (click to enlarge) Source: Author’s own work. After analyzing these investment holdings and determining how each ETF could be used in an investment strategy, I would like to provide a final comparison in order to help first time investors choose the safest investment product. In the current market, the recent decline in the price of oil has rocked the Russian economy and increased recessionary pressures in a nation that produces over 30% of GDP from the oil industry. When approaching a nation like Russia, having a defensive strategy is extremely important in order to ensure that holdings can survive a volatile downturn like the one seen in the past year. The investment approach should not be shaped in avoiding a loss but rather surviving one. Compared to many other emerging markets, Russia has leveraged itself to the commodity trade greatly and this leads to a cyclical investment experience where long-term investors will add to positions in the downturn and profit off any increases in the price of oil or gas. Looking at the longer-term projection for oil, the following decade should see a recovery to the $100/barrel as demand should continue to increase in the long-term. The question investors should ask themselves is not if there will be a recovery, but when . Therefore, with that mentality, when selecting a Russian ETF, keeping in mind the longevity and downside protection of major positions in the fund is essential to choosing the right product. Taking a look at the overall performance in the past 6 months, all products performed relatively the same, with returns in the 4% to 6% decline range. Thus, investors should not base their assumptions on the short-term performance of each product. The products have been designed to diversify holdings while reducing risk against volatility through the timing of established positions, an investment goal that is achieved in the long term. (click to enlarge) Source: Author’s own work. After taking into account the short-term performance of all three products, and understanding the overall investment strategy adopted by these ETFs, I believe that the iShares MSCI Russia Capped ETF New offers the best opportunity for investors to gain exposure to the Russian market in the long-term. While the other products have been available to the market for a longer period of time, and have allowed investors to better judge their historical performance, the timing of the iShares product means that majority of the positions initiated in the fund have been at the bottom of the downturn. With the price of oil continuing to decline into the New Year, the start of 2015 marked one of the lowest points in the past four years in regards to the price of oil. This decline had triggered the collapse of the Ruble and eventual recession in the Russian economy as the equity and FX markets saw large outflows of money. That said, the iShares product came onto the market at this exact time, and looking at the type of holdings in the product’s portfolio, the ETF has over 53.75% exposure to the energy sector through beaten-down industry leaders. I expect that in the following decade, as the price recovers, while all three products have holdings in these major industry players, due to iShares’s timing on the market, I expect the recovery to be much more profitable for the product and its investors. Overall, while my suggestion may provide the safest and most profitable option among the three products listed, the current market is a time to build holdings in an emerging market portfolio. Whether a Russian ETF product is the way to go depends on the investor and his/her risk tolerance. In my opinion, with the political and economic uncertainty, implementing a Russian ETF into your investment strategy is a very tactical decision that ensures protection against further volatility in the market while also profiting from increased money flow.

Upgrade Your Investment Approach And Put Some Fears To Rest

Despite the pleas of many consultants and wealth managers for investors to ignore tumult in the markets, the fact is that oftentimes such fears are warranted. Although long term investors should not impulsively react to small market moves, they should be alert to signs that things are “not right”. The mean-variance approach to investing is a very common one, but time has revealed a great number of weaknesses that unnecessarily expose its adherents to risk. The Kelly criterion is a very useful approach to investing that also corresponds more closely to the way markets actually work. The investment services industry as a whole has been slow to disseminate improvements in investment theory and practice. We are born with some pretty good warning mechanisms and most people are pretty good at sensing when things are not right. Martin J. Dougherty makes exactly this point in his book Special Forces Unarmed Combat Guide : “Victims of assault often say afterwards that they could see it coming.” He continues, “The problem, then, is not being able to spot danger but being willing to act on this information and avoid it.” While this is just one manifestation of our defense network, it does highlight our natural ability to “spot danger”. It also highlights the imperative of being able to act on useful warnings. Given that volatility and risk are endemic to the exercise of investing, there is no particular reason why most market behavior should cause undue duress for a well-informed investor. And yet times of unsettled markets and high volatility can keep a lot of investors awake at night, including seasoned investment professionals. Oftentimes, concerns revolve around a sense of uncertainty – a sense that something isn’t quite right or that something is being missed. Sometimes it comes from an uneasy feeling that a prescribed course just doesn’t seem right. Indeed, it may just be that one’s approach to investing is the source of discomfort as much or more than market moves. Two common approaches to investing vary substantially in their assumptions and in the logic of how they aim to get you from point A to point B. If you are feeling uneasy, it may be a good time to make sure that your investment approach will allow you act so as to avoid danger. One approach focuses on the importance of diversification and uses statistical analysis to design portfolios that maximize returns for a given level of risk. It is well entrenched in investment theory and practice. This approach is characterized by graphs that show the upper and lower bounds of growth in assets and gives assurance that if you just stick to the plan, you will have an extremely high chance of meeting your investment goals. It makes a lot of sense and is hard to refute. Another approach is described by William Poundstone in Fortune’s Formula as being one that “offers the highest compound return consistent with no risk of going broke.” It is well recognized in investment theory, though probably less so in practice. It can certainly be characterized by wide swings, but gives the assurance that if you just stick to the plan, you will maximize your wealth over your investment horizon. It makes a lot of sense and is hard to refute. This juxtaposition of strategies highlights a common investment challenge: how can you tell which one is better and/or which one is more appropriate for you? Do you know which one your financial planner or wealth manager or consultant uses? These are exactly the types of fundamental questions that are so critical to long term investment success but are so rarely discussed thoroughly. The fact is that both approaches have merit to them, but both also rely on important assumptions. The first approach is referred to as the mean-variance framework and is a part of a body of thinking called “modern portfolio theory”. While the mean-variance approach correctly highlights the importance of diversification, it does so at the expense of some serious structural shortcomings (For an excellent, though technical discussion, see Michael Mauboussin’s interview with the physicist Ole Peters here ) . One of the flaws of the approach is that it models returns using only mean and variance. Unfortunately, the reality is that return distributions have other dimensions that are extremely important to investors. Considering only mean and variance is akin to describing a three dimensional object with only two dimensions. The description will be at best incomplete and at worst, wholly unrepresentative. The implication is that all of those great graphs of wealth accumulation are at best possibilities and at worst complete fantasy. Another important flaw of the mean-variance framework is that it relies on expectation values. In theory, according to Ole Peters, expectation values represent an “ensemble of imagined parallel universes” and can potentially serve as the “basis for sensible behavior”. In practice, however, most firms simply apply averages from the past, but these past actualities fall well short of representing all imaginable future possibilities. In other words, since (arguably) most firms do not populate the model with the right information, one cannot expect it to produce useful results. Garbage in, garbage out. This common deficiency almost completely undermines the case for using mean-variance as an investment strategy. The second approach is referred to as the Kelly criterion and gained notoriety as a betting system. Michael Mauboussin gives a nice overview in “Size Matters” here : “Based on information theory, the Kelly Criterion says an investor should choose the investment(s) with the highest geometric mean return. This strategy is distinct from those based on mean/variance efficiency.” In general, Mauboussin continues, “The Kelly Criterion works well when you parlay your bets, face repeated opportunities, and know what the underlying distribution looks like.” Poundstone adds, “The Kelly criterion is meaningful only when gambling profits are reinvested. A practical theory of investment must largely be a theory of reinvestment.” This is a key point: most people do think of and act on investments as discrete opportunities that change over time and not as a singular procedure that operates like a reliable machine. In this way, the Kelly approach seems to correspond with the way many people actually invest. According to Poundstone, “They [most people] buy stocks and bonds and hang on to them until they have a strong reason to sell. Market bets ride by default.” It is also natural to recognize the importance of reinvestment: One good investment does not a retirement make. You need to keep it up. Poundstone clarifies the strategy: “The Kelly formula says that you should wager this fraction of your bankroll on a favorable bet: edge/odds. The edge is how much you expect to win, on the average, assuming you could make this wager over and over with the same probabilities. It is a fraction because the profit is always in proportion to how much you wager.” As Mauboussin puts it, “As an investor, maximizing wealth over time requires you to do two things: find situations where you have an analytical edge; and allocate the appropriate amount of capital when you do have an edge.” An important condition for the Kelly approach is that the system only works as long as the investor “stays in the game long enough for the law of large numbers to work.” Further, it is also natural to think of calibrating the magnitude of investments according to their attractiveness. While the Kelly approach does require one to have an edge in order to make an investment, it doesn’t require one to invest when no edge exists. This all makes common sense – which ought to make it easier to adhere to even in tough times. Conversely, investors may have trouble adhering to a mean-variance approach because it isn’t that hard to perceive problems with its assumptions and logical consistency. For one, it’s not an inherently bad idea to look to past returns for an indication of what future returns might be, but why should that be the only input? Other things matter a lot such as valuations and your starting point. Likewise with assessing diversification benefits. It’s not bad to look at past cross correlations for starters, but why not also consider the potential for increased global interconnectedness to increase correlations and reduce diversification benefits in the future? Arguably the biggest issue with the mean-variance approach, however, is that it understates risk. It would make sense that unprecedented levels of central bank intervention the last seven years is a factor that ought to be incorporated into one’s investment approach, and yet mean-variance ignores it. It is also true that sometimes bad things do happen and it makes sense to try to avoid them. The mean-variance approach is very weak at adapting to change: it essentially says that since the vast majority of the time you don’t get attacked in dark alleys, you shouldn’t worry about dark alleys. Thus, although this approach is an industry standard and used by countless wealth managers, financial planners, consultants, and other industry participants, it actually serves as a very weak foundation upon which to base one’s investments. It treats the market as a utility, reliably cranking out returns, but that isn’t how the market actually works – as anyone who follows it knows all too well. As a result, it may well be that much of the anxiety investors feel in regards to unsettled markets has a lot to do with the discord that they feel in regards to the mean-variance approach. To be fair, it is not like the mean-variance framework is an obviously bad idea that never should have taken hold. The theory is over fifty years old though and a great deal has been learned during that time to improve and refine investment approaches. As one example among many, advances in behavioral economics have been a major development. Indeed it is one of the weaknesses of the investment services industry that it has been slow to disseminate many of the useful advances in investment theory and practice nearly as quickly as markets have evolved. The Kelly approach isn’t the end of the line either, but it does represent progress. Just like walking alone down a dark alley at night can intuitively seem like a bad idea, so can navigating through markets with an investment strategy that you don’t really trust. Neither may seem incredibly risky at the time and you might even be able to get by unscathed a few times. Don’t let anyone convince you that such actions are a good idea though. People are usually pretty good at spotting danger; make sure you are just as good at responding to it. If you don’t have a good idea of where to go, ask for help. (click to enlarge)